Please select your home edition
Edition
X-Yachts Leaderboard 2024 1

America's Cup- Mitchell fires new salvo at ISAF Jury Officials

by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com NZL on 5 Feb 2015
18 months after the conclusion of the 34th America’’s Cup legal action continues to embroil some of the individuals involved and Jury Guilain Grenier Oracle Team USA http://www.oracleteamusamedia.com/
Matthew Mitchell, previously a member of Oracle Team USA, has issued a media release advising that he has filed complaints of Gross Misconduct against all five Americas Cup jury members with the sport's International governing body (ISAF).

This action follows on from his recent claims about the actions of another team member Simeon Tienpont, now with Challenger Luna Rossa.

Mitchell's claims focus on the International Jury not taking action against Tienpont, who admitted being involved in instances where boat weight was added to three AC45 catamarans used in the America's Cup World Series leading up to the 34th America's Cup.

Five members of the Oracle Team USA were named by the Int Jury. A sixth had his name and details suppressed. One of the five was let off with no further action by the Jury. The other four were suspended from the regatta and subjected to further consideration by the International Sailing Federation.

The World body suspended one of the five for a period, since reduced by the Court for Arbitration for Sport to 18 months, which was due to complete in February 2015.

In his statement Mitchell claims the 'Jury members were selectively negligent and that he was unwittingly used as a pawn in OTUSA’s quest to defend the Cup against ETNZ.'

'The disruption to Mitchell’s family, and himself, has been monumental', the statement says.

He notes that ISAF recently ruled a close to his case, due partially to the fact that the suspension set by CAS in a related Hearing was set at 2 years, and that any suspension levied on Mitchell would be less than this period and therefore already passed.

In a report commissioned by Mitchell's own national sailing authority, Yachting New Zealand’s in April of last year, YNZ recommended no action and queried some of the actions of the International Jury.

Mitchell's latest statement says he is 'now embarking on an indefatigable quest to bring the real perpetrators to account.'

'I have at all times told the truth during this episode and placed my reliance in the ISAF and ACIJ process to establish the facts. As competitors we are faced with no alternative but to trust in the administrators of our sport to adjudicate without bias' Mitchell says. In this regard the ACIJ failed completely,' he concludes.

Copies of the individual complaints against the five Jury members were also appended to the statement and these are claimed to have been filed with the International Sailing Federation for investigation and action.

No comment has been made by the ISAF, however the issue is expected to be discussed at its Executive Committee meeting in the next week or two.

Henri-Lloyd Dynamic RangeRS Sailing 2021 - FOOTERNorth Sails Loft 57 Podcast

Related Articles

British Dragon South West Championship
A spectacular warm-up for the 2025 Edinburgh Cup Torquay delivered a spectacular warm-up for the 2025 Edinburgh Cup, as 13 Dragon teams took to the waters of Tor Bay for the South West Championship, a two-day regatta packed with shifting breezes, tactical gambles, and top-class racing.
Posted today at 8:59 am
West System Six10 Epoxy cartridges are back!
Pre-thickened, gap filling epoxy back after a disruption to supply for an extended time ATL Composites is very happy to announce that WEST SYSTEM Six10 Epoxy Cartridge Packs are now available again to the Australian and Asian markets.
Posted today at 8:34 am
Foiling Sport Congress gathers global players
To shape the Future of Foiling Last week, Malcesine hosted the first-ever Foiling Sport Congress — a by-invitation event organised to foster an in-depth discussion on the current state and future developments of foiling across all disciplines.
Posted today at 5:59 am
OK Dinghy Europeans at Warnemünde day 2
Charlie Cumbley leads at the half-way stage Britain's Charlie Cumbley holds a two-point lead at the half-way stage of the 2025 OK Dinghy European Championship in Warnemünde, Germany, after two more races were held on Monday.
Posted today at 4:14 am
Gran Canaria Gloria Windsurf World Cup Day 3
The best female wave sailors in the world showcase their skills on the global stage After the men had taken centre stage for the opening two days of the 2025 Gran Canaria Gloria Windsurf World Cup, today was the day for the best female wave sailors in the world to showcase their skills on the global stage.
Posted today at 4:11 am
Transpac Onboard Episode 4
Anything Can Happen at Sea All Transpac 2025 competitors are now at sea and actively racing to Hawaii. We take a look at the Pasha Live Race Tracker and talk about the significant wind hole confronting a contingent of competitors.
Posted today at 3:06 am
Stops & re-starts in first two legs of AEGEAN 600
A tough first night and early morning spent fighting zephyrs getting through the Cyclades After a beautiful breezy start yesterday, but a tough first night and early morning spent fighting zephyrs getting through the Cyclades, at the end of today's daylight the AEGEAN 600 fleet is back on the move.
Posted on 7 Jul
British Classic Week Day 1
Northerly winds gusting 22 knots make for a brisk start Day one at British Classic Week in Cowes saw fast-paced racing around the cans sponsored by Spirit Yachts for over 50 classic and modern classic yachts.
Posted on 7 Jul
International Moth Worlds Opening Ceremony
137 sailors from 25 nations have gathered, featuring some of the biggest names in sailing After weeks of preparation and an intense lead-up, the 2025 Moth World Championship is ready to get under way. Official racing begins tomorrow, 8 July, on the waters of Lake Garda, with the event hosted by Fraglia Vela Malcesine.
Posted on 7 Jul
iQFOiL Worlds a Aarhus day 2
No racing, but spirits stay high in Aarhus Day 2 of the iQFOiL World Championship in Aarhus tested the patience of sailors, coaches, and the Race Committee alike, as the wind refused to settle across the bay.
Posted on 7 Jul