Please select your home edition
Edition
X-Yachts Leaderboard 2024 2

Compare and contrast - Sail-World.com Australia newsletter

18/09/2023


Compare and contrast

Pantaenius 2022 - SAIL LEADERBOARD AUS

Rolly Tasker Sails 2023 LEADERBOARD

Emirates Team NZ struggle to get foiling - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 - Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media


Dear Recipient Name

"Pretty painful yachting," was how Emirates Team New Zealand's Glen Ashby described the Match Race Grand Final at the first Preliminary Regatta of the 37th America's Cup in Vilanova i La Geltrú, Spain.

Thankfully the pain was short-lived, as what little breeze there was petered out completely, so NYYC American Magic and Emirates Team New Zealand's race was abandoned with neither team making the windward mark inside the 10-minute time limit.

Both boats struggle at the start of the Final - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 -  Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media
Both boats struggle at the start of the Final - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 - Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media

 
ALT Composities 2020 West System 3 - 300x250   Webasto AUS 2020 MPU 4
 

The Vilanova Preliminary Regatta was the first proper regatta for the AC40s, so there was much anticipation beforehand as to what the racing would be like. The first day was a washout, in the literal sense of the word, with torrential rain, thunder and lightning. Not the start they were looking for.

Day two was right on the edge of foiling with the wind hovering around the 6-knot mark. The teams use tow-ins to get up on the foils pre-start, and then try to keep foiling using apparent wind.

Luna Rossa leads Orient Express - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 -  Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media
Luna Rossa leads Orient Express - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 - Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media

The French Orient Express Racing Team, even though they'd only had 15 days practice on the AC40 before the event, pulled off a masterful victory in the first race, while the others wallowed in lowriding mode.

In the second race Emirates Team New Zealand then did what was seemingly impossible, transitioning from lowriding mode to foiling during the race in the lightest of gusts, chasing down the early leader Alinghi Red Bull Racing, to take victory.

Alinghi Red Bull Racing - Race Day 2 -  AC40 - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Vilanova - September 16, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media
Alinghi Red Bull Racing - Race Day 2 - AC40 - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Vilanova - September 16, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media

 
X-Yachts 2022 AUS SAIL X4.3 MK II MPU 1   Race Yachts 2023 v3
 

It was hard watching at times, but strangely addictive to see some teams at 24 knots, and others at 2.4 knots, sometimes side-by-side. Whether you class that as good racing is another matter.

Lack of wind at events, as well as too much of it at others, has been a major talking point of 2023, so it was no surprise to see yet another event blighted by the weather. My mind went back to June and the Moth Worlds in Weymouth, UK, which ended up being a non-event due to the windless conditions.

Richard Didham, USA 5, on day 5 of the Wetsuit Outlet and Zhik International Moth World Championship 2023 - photo © Mark Jardine / IMCAUK
Richard Didham, USA 5, on day 5 of the Wetsuit Outlet and Zhik International Moth World Championship 2023 - photo © Mark Jardine / IMCAUK

Staying on the foils through the light stuff is an art form, and there are definitely masters of it. The USA's Richard Didham is one of those Moth sailors who has the kind of smooth boat handling, eye for the breeze and plan for their course. He nailed a third place in one of the few races at the event in really marginal conditions, even though he picked up weed on his main foil on the first upwind leg. Making a calm decision about the problem saved his race as he described:

"I had to round the windward gate without clearing it, because the breeze was pretty light there. Then I sailed to the right of the course and actually did a tack, on the downwind, to clear the weed. There's never a good place to do it, but I figured since there was more breeze on the right side of the course, I could clear it and get back up in a puff quickly. I think that was the right call, based on the circumstances."

 
Flagstaff 2021AUG - Excess 11 - MPU   Ensign 2023 Bavaria SR41 HT
 

Emirates Team NZ in a foil-fall - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 -  Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media
Emirates Team NZ in a foil-fall - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 - Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media

It was no different in the AC40s over the weekend. Those who looked ahead to spot the puffs of breeze to tack and gybe in were the ones who stayed on the foils, while those who were less picky ended up splashing down. To add to the complication there was a tricky swell on the racecourse which was always lurking to trip up even the best, as Emirates Team New Zealand found out to their cost. There's no doubt Lady Luck also played her part at times.

The final day saw enough breeze to hold three decent races and highlighted the potential of these boats to provide a great racing spectacle. Having the AC40s in One Design mode means it was all down to how teams sailed, and there was clearly a lot of learning-on-the-job going on. Expect the fleet to tighten up as the fast modes are found in the different wind conditions, and especially if racing is held in a couple of knots more breeze.

Start- America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 -  Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © Franck Socha
Start- America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Day 3 - Vilanova - September 17, 2023 - photo © Franck Socha

 
MIA 2021 DEC MPU   Marine Auctions 2019 600x500
 

Comparing and contrasting this regatta with SailGP, it was great to see 'standard' windward-leeward racing, an upwind start, and the boat speed shown in knots. We've had a couple of years to get used to SailGP insisting on showing boat speed in kilometres per hour, but I've found I now simply ignore this figure, and look at where the boats are, rather than the telemetry. It's all very well trying to chase new audiences, as SailGP is undoubtedly trying to do, but please remember who your core audience is.

The 20-minute target race time is also far more palatable and gives you time to understand what is going on. A SailGP race often feels like watching a stock car race, when you're on the lookout for a big incident, rather than who is where.

Canada SailGP Team helmed by Phil Robertson nearly capsize as France SailGP Team helmed by Quentin Delapierre sail closely past during the second race on Race Day 1 of the Range Rover France Sail Grand Prix in Saint Tropez, France - photo © Bob Martin for SailGP
Canada SailGP Team helmed by Phil Robertson nearly capsize as France SailGP Team helmed by Quentin Delapierre sail closely past during the second race on Race Day 1 of the Range Rover France Sail Grand Prix in Saint Tropez, France - photo © Bob Martin for SailGP

 
Navico AUS Zeus3S MPU   Vaikobi 2023 Gloves - MPU
 

Just as we saw with Luna Rossa in the 36th America's Cup, the AC40 is sailed with separate port and starboard helmsmen. It was very noticeable that the top two teams, NYYC American Magic and Emirates Team New Zealand, had four International Moth World Champions on the wheels in the form of Tom Slingsby, Paul Goodison, Peter Burling and Nathan Outteridge. Sailors with a strong foiling background seem to fit right in to AC40 racing.

Race Day 2 -  AC40 - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Vilanova - September 16, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media
Race Day 2 - AC40 - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Vilanova - September 16, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media

Compare and contrast this with INEOS Britannia, who have the two Finn legends Ben Ainslie and Giles Scott on the wheels. Race results of 6,4,6,6,5 wasn't pretty for the team. Their starting was off the ball, they were too often in low-riding mode, and seeing them limp in to finish race 5, well behind the others, summed up their event. There are going to be some pretty glum sailors after their weekend, but at the end of the day does it matter?

The AC75 which the 37th America's Cup is going to be raced in might look similar, but it's a very different beast. Bragging rights aside, these Preliminary Regattas carry very little weight, but do raise interest in the Auld Mug as we build towards the main event between August and October 2024.

 
Nautilus Marine 2023 - SAIL MPU   Rolly Tasker Sails 2023 MPU
 

Emirates Great Britain SailGP Team helmed by Ben Ainslie cross the finish line as they sail past the bell tower and old town of Saint-Tropez on Race Day 2 of the France Sail Grand Prix in Saint-Tropez, France - photo © Ricardo Pinto for SailGP
Emirates Great Britain SailGP Team helmed by Ben Ainslie cross the finish line as they sail past the bell tower and old town of Saint-Tropez on Race Day 2 of the France Sail Grand Prix in Saint-Tropez, France - photo © Ricardo Pinto for SailGP

Sir Ben certainly hasn't suddenly turned into a bad sailor. Memories may be short in the TikTok age, but don't forget it was only a week ago that he won the SailGP France Sail Grand Prix in Saint Tropez. He and Giles will put more time into the AC40 and come back strong.

Race Day 1 -  AC40 - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Vilanova - September 15, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media
Race Day 1 - AC40 - America's Cup Preliminary Regatta - Vilanova - September 15, 2023 - photo © America's Cup Media

Overall, it was a weekend of marked contrasts. The biblical rain of Friday, the sunshine and light airs of Saturday and Sunday, the sublime speed and performance of the AC40s at times, and the painful splashdowns at others. Comparing the AC40s and F50s is inevitable for anyone who watches both, and it's clear each have their advantages and disadvantages. Right now, my preference goes with the AC40 due to its hoisting sails and that fact that's a monohull... of sorts. I also definitely preferred watching windward-leeward racing. Others will have different views, but as I keep saying, the beauty of our sport is its diversity.

Mark Jardine
Sail-World.com and YachtsandYachting.com Managing Editor

 
Windcraft 2022 July - Dehler 46SQ - MPU   J Composites 2022 - J99 MPU
 


Edouard de Keyser starts Global Solo Challenge
Yesterday, Sunday, September 17th, marked the departure of Edouard de Keyser, the only Belgian skipper entered in the Global Solo Challenge.

Cup Spy Sept 17: Day 3 - American Magic win first event of the 2024 America's Cup
After being the first team to exit the 2021 America's Cup in Auckland, the New York Yacht Club's American Magic won the first Preliminary Regatta of the 2024 America's Cup.

Only 99 days to go until 2023 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race
A strong fleet featuring former winners, diverse international entries and a highly competitive two-handed division is already building for the 2023 RSHYR, with just 99 days to go until the 78th edition of the historic race on Boxing Day.

 
38 South / Jeanneau AUS SF30 OD - MPU   Boat Books Australia
 
America's Cup: American Magic defies the odds to win AC37 Preliminary Event in Vilanova
Having come into the final day of the first Preliminary Regatta of the 37th America's Cup sitting in fifth place, it was an outside bet at best that NYYC American Magic could climb the leaderboard and challenge for a spot in the Match Race Grand Final.

McIntyre OGR entrant “Triana” diverting with injured crew
At 14:00 UTC, skipper of yacht Triana FR (66), Jean d'Arthuys, informed McIntyre Ocean Globe race control of an incident onboard. Crew member Stéphane Raguenes had fallen on deck, resulting in a serious open wound on the back of his leg

America's Cup: Race Reports - Day 3 - a look at how American Magic was able to come back from 5th
With NYYC American topping the final series standings after a simply stunning day where they took their chances, front-ran like demons and sailed incredibly smoothly, it was all-on for the Match race Grand Final.

 
Pantaenius 2022 - SAIL & POWER 1 MPU AUS   Vetus-Maxwell 2020
 
A Class Catamaran World Championship at Yacht Club de Toulon - Overall
In 1986 at Brenzone, Italy, a 32 year old Aussie sailor and Olympic medallist, won the A-Cat Worlds. 37 years later he does it again in Toulon. John Scott Anderson is living proof of the saying 'There is still life in the old dog yet!'.

Australia's top sailors in Sydney for America's Cup Youth and Women's Squad Selection Camp
Some of Australia's top performing sailors have undergone a two and a half day training camp in Sydney this week for selectors, led by John Bertrand AO, to finalise a youth and women's squad for Australia's America's Cup campaign in 2024.

J/24 World Championship at Nautical Club of Thessaloniki, Greece - Overall
Keith Whittemore's Furio of the USA, with team Willem van Waay, Marianne Schoke, Brian Thomas and Melanie Edwards, have been crowned 2023 J/24 World Champions.

 
Selden 2023 CXe   Allen 2022 - PSH Cam Cleat MPU
 
America's Cup Preliminary Regatta 1 in Vilanova i La Geltrú - Day 2
The first day of the Preliminary Regatta of the 37th America's Cup was a day of mixed fortunes, drama, desperation, nail-biting excitement, exquisite light-airs technique and tension untold with a new name on the podium and brilliance shining through.

Cup Spy Sept 16: Day 2 - Light air foiling prowess determines outcome of first day of racing.
[Updated] It was the Day of the Underdog in Race 1, with the newest entry Orient Express Racing Team taking the first race win of the 2024 America's Cup Preliminary Regatta. The Kiwis staged a comeback to win Race 2. Luna Rossa reinstated into Race 1.

eDNA data collection in The Ocean Race could provide crucial insights on ocean biodiversity
Environmental DNA, known as eDNA, one of the most cutting-edge ways to measure ocean health and biodiversity, was collected during The Ocean Race 2022-23 in a world first for racing boats.

 
Upffront 2020 Foredeck Club SW MPU   Henri-Lloyd 2023 Freo Jacket - SW MPU
 
Clipper Race fleet embarks on transatlantic race from Spain to Punta del Este
The Clipper Race fleet has departed for Punta del Este as the second race in the circumnavigation left from Puerto Sherry, Spain yesterday, which was the first stopover destination following an electric Race Start from Portsmouth, UK.

Rolex New York Yacht Club Invitational Cup Overall
Needing simply to not shoot themselves in the foot to ensure victory in the Rolex NYYC Invitational Cup, the San Diego Yacht Club dominated the windy final race to stamp their authority on the eighth edition of the world's premiere Corinthian regatta.

Yanmar Dragon Gold Cup 2023 at the Royal Torbay Yacht Club - Overall
A spectacular fifth race in warm sunshine and a light east-south-easterly concluded the 2023 Yanmar Dragon Gold Cup in Torquay.

 
MPU July August September   Cyclops 2023 August MPU
 
SailGP: Kiwi team out of action for second successive event - won't sail at Taranto
SailGP has announced today (Sept 16) that it will not be possible to transport and fit out the replacement wing sail for the New Zealand SailGP Team in time for the next event in Taranto, Italy.

Racing in style: Queensland French Yacht Owners Association announces their upcoming two-day regatta
After 17 successful years of organising the Beneteau Cup and 10 years of holding the French Cup Challenge, the QFYOA is proudly presenting its upcoming regatta, promising a showcase of top-class vessels and exciting racing experiences.

America's Cup Preliminary Regatta 1 in Vilanova i La Geltrú - Day 1
The picturesque, stunning Mediterranean conditions of yesterday were replaced briefly today by conditions that multiple America's Cup winner Glenn Ashby described as "downright atrocious," from the commentary booth.

 
Rooster 2023 - MPU   RS Sailing 2021 - MPU
 
Cup Spy Sept 15,- Day 1: The Rain in Spain didn't 'stay mainly the plain,' but came to Vilanova
After being delayed from the scheduled start time of 1530hrs CET (1330hrs UTC) Race Director Iain Murray decided to pull the pin for the day at around 1610hrs CET (1410hrs UTC) after heavy rain and thunder storms approached Vilanova.

Michel Marie: IMOCA must be ambitious as it moves towards a greener future
Impose a carbon cap on IMOCA boat builds, reduce the use of carbon fibre in production molds, simplify the IMOCA box rule and drive forward to more green solutions in the Class with a clear sense of purpose.

OK Dinghy European Championship on Lake Garda Overall
Charlie Cumbley, from Britain has won the 2023 OK Dinghy European Championship on Lake Garda, hosted by Circolo Vela Arco. He led a British clean sweep with Nick Craig in second and Matt Howard in third.

 
Barton Marine 2019 600x500   North Sails Performance 2023 - MPU
 
Seamless Crew Rotation: Get New Personnel Up To Speed In No Time
We've all been there... you're going brilliantly one week, moving up the fleet, winning races, the entire operation ticking like precision machinery... then something disrupts that flow - someone gets ill, injured, or is unavailable.

Holcim-PRB welcomes Nicolas Lunven for Vendée Globe 2024 & Rosalin Kuiper for The Ocean Race Europe
Following the second-place finish in the last edition of The Ocean Race, Team Holcim-PRB welcomes new skipper and French offshore racing expert Nicolas Lunven and his co-skipper the talented Dutch sailor Rosalin Kuiper.

Star Worlds at Yacht Club Isole di Toscana - Preview
A hundred Stars ready to shine in the Maremma Tuscany waters for one of the highlights of the extraordinary racing season of Yacht Club Isole di Toscana.

 
SOUTHERNSPARS_MAST-&-BOOMS_SW_300X250-MISSY   PredictWind - Offshore App 300x250
 
New J/99 Elegance Line launch
What if you could experience the speed of the J/99 while enjoying the comfort of a cruising boat? This new version of the J/99 offers fast cruising enthusiasts, an easy, comfortable and high-performance sailboat, without compromise.

Seventh heaven for Corentin Horeau (Banque Populaire) as he realises childhood dream
"I am not very good at maths but to be better than second there is only one step." Corentin Horeau told the French sailing media when he returned to La Solitaire du Figaro in 2021.

Aussies set to fly at Kite Euros
A strong Aussie contingent has landed in the UK to prepare for their assault on the 2023 Formula Kite European Championships, which are set to launch from Eastney Beach in Portsmouth with racing from the 19th to 24th of September.

 
C-Tech 2021 America's Cup 300x250   Mirabaud Yacht Racing Image 2023
 
Corentin Horeau wins 2023 La Solitaire du Figaro Paprec title
Crossing the finish line of the third and final stage in sixth place at 03:44:27hrs (local time) this morning off Piriac-sur-Mer, Corentin Horeau (Banque Populaire) is the overall winner of the 54th La Solitaire du Figaro Paprec (subject to jury).

Antigua Classic Yacht Regatta 2024 - Registration is now open
The Antigua Classic Yacht Regatta committee is pleased to announce that registration is now open for the 35th edition of our regatta.

Provezza versus Platoon in 52 Super Series 2023 title shoot out in Puerto Portals next week
Next week the Bay of Palma will be the scene for one of the most exciting title showdowns in the history of the 52 Super Series, the world's leading grand prix monohull circuit.

 
Doyle Sails 2020 - By Sailors For Sailors 300x250   HALLSPARS_MAST-&-BOOMS_SW_300X250 cnb66
 
SailGP and Mubadala bring world's most exciting racing on water to UAE's capital for the first time
Abu Dhabi will host the world's most exciting racing on water as it gears up for the inaugural Abu Dhabi Sail Grand Prix.

Driving the J/70, with Josie Gliddon
Josie Gliddon was one of a number of women racing at the J/70 Europeans, although she really doesn't like the gender question. "Everyone who knows me knows that I sail as a sailor," says Gliddon who was steering Brutus II owned by Charlie Thompson.

Perseverance crowned Clipper Race 2023-2024 race 1 winners at Puerto Sherry Prizegiving Ceremony
The first Prizegiving ceremony of the 2023-24 edition took place at the Puerto Sherry Marina, with a stunning Spanish sunset and plenty of the local aperitifs to celebrate the achievements of Race 1.

 
Hellamarine-Apelo-A3-@2x_600x300   T Clewring One Design - 2
 
FlyingNikka wins the Maxi Class Line Honours Trophy
Winning the three coastal races held during the week, FlyingNikka won the Maxi Class Line Honours Trophy, awarded to the absolute fastest yacht among the 50 or so Maxis competing in the 33th edition of the Maxi Yacht Rolex Cup in Porto Cervo.

Bartercard Sail Paradise - Aramex steps up!
Team 'Aramex,' the 2022 Sail Paradise Champions, are gearing up for another thrilling competition. Owners Steve Curtis and Kerry Noyes, and their passionate crew are eager to take on this year's fleet with full force.

Jump aboard Nautilus Marine Insurance Sydney Short Ocean Racing Championship now!
Entries are now being accepted for the 2023 Nautilus Marine Insurance Sydney Short Ocean Racing Championship (SSORC), with the entry form online at the official website where the Notice of Race can also be found.

 
Armstrong-FG-3 300x250   Lloyd Stevenson - Artnautica60 300x250px
 
The new Zhik Seaboot that feels like a superlight running shoe
Zhik's new Seaboot 700 is extremely lightweight and flexible, giving the agility, feel and comfort of a modern trainer around the deck. Making clumpy boots a thing of the past, the boots weigh just 500g per boot.

Great Britain and The Netherlands lead Olympic qualifiers after Allianz Sailing World Championships
World Sailing has confirmed the first 107 boats and boards qualified for the Paris 2024 Olympic Games following the 2023 Allianz Sailing World Championships, The Hague.

Marine Auctions September 2023 Online Auction
Details of the Vessels & Marina Berths, Marine Auctions will be offering in our September Online Auction, together with Vessels we have for Private Sale.

Adventures down under sailing the J/45
We hope you enjoy this entertaining story from the owners of the new J/45 #3 SASSAFRAS- James and Sally.

Sail into 2024: The 2024 Tasar Worlds at Sandringham Yacht Club await!
Set sail for an extraordinary adventure in the world of sailing! The 2024 Tasar World Championship is just around the corner, and it promises to be a sailing spectacle like no other. But the clock is ticking!

Poole claims victory at Oakcliff and Grand Slam title
World number 1 ranked match racer, Chris Poole and his Riptide Racing defeated New Zealand's Gavin Brady and his True Blue Racing team this weekend to claim victory at the Oakcliff International, stage 12 of the 2023 World Match Racing Tour.

38 South / Jeanneau AUS SF30 OD - FOOTER

J Composites 2022 - J45 v4 FOOTER

This email was sent to the.recipients@email.address by YY Online Services Ltd.
Towngate House, 2-8 Parkstone Road, Poole, BH15 2PW
Registered in England No. 7895890

Our records show that you signed up to receive news from us on 1 January 2000

Please do not reply to this message as this address cannot receive replies.

You can unsubscribe at any time or email us here if you encounter any difficulties
J Composites J/45SOUTHERN-SPARS-MISSY-FURLING-BOOMS-728-X-90 BottomMackay Boats 728x90 BOTTOM