Please select your home edition
Edition
X-Yachts X4.3

Gladwell's Line- A rough week for the Cup at 60 Centre Street

by Richard Gladwell on 28 Oct 2009
"ALINGHI 5" training on Lake Geneva Thierry Martinez http://www.thmartinez.com
Justice Shirley Kornreich's decisions, handed down from the Bench of the New York Supreme Court at 60 Centre Street, New York, should have surprised no-one.

Like the other Decisions that have emanated from the Bench of that Court, all are consistent with the literal meaning of the words contained within the Four Corners of the of the Deed of Gift, for what was the premier trophy in sailing.

The words 'America's Cup' have now become a general byline for long run litigation in sport, that benefits no-one.

How long will it take the parties to realise that continued obstinacy is an exercise in self-destruction?

The Auld Mug has had a colourful history. But the events of this week with the lodging of an action for Breach of Fiduciary Duty against the current Trustee of the America's Cup, Societe Nautique de Geneve plus Kornreich's Decision today on the Venue, represent a new low point in Cup annals.

For its part, the sailing world has reacted with muted shock and bewilderment at this week's turn of events.

The Decisions from Centre Street are consistent with the thinking of anyone who has a modicum of understanding of sailing administration, sailing rules, how sailing regattas are put together.

Such practical knowledge is essential to grasp what can and can't be done in terms of the Deed of Gift, as it was drafted by sailors and is a simple document describing how the Matches for the America's Cup should be run.

In the late 19th century, as now, the intent of donors was clear - that the America's Cup should be a regatta staged between yacht clubs of different nations on terms agreed between the Defender, the current holder of the Cup, and the first Challenger who met the requirements of the Deed of Gift.

Such a Club should have an annual regatta on the open sea, and if it won the Match would be able to Defend the America's Cup on its home waters, ten months after receiving the next Challenge.

If the two Clubs couldn't agree on the conditions for the Match, then the Deed of Gift specifies a basic regatta of three races, and states the courses to be used.

The Match is so simple in its format that the course could be laid with just a single Committee Boat, three marks, and two mark laying boats.

Most club racing conducted around the world in thousands of clubs every weekend, is way more complex than this.

Measurement is equally basic, needing just a plumbline, a marker pen, and a 90ft measuring tape.

So far, so good.

Now get the egos, visionaries and lawyers involved.

One of the problems with visionaries is that sometimes they can see too much. Their other problem is that they need to be able to lead and take people with them, not prescribe. It's about leadership.

At some stage before July 2007, all sailing logic and race management process seems to have flown out the door. The meaning of words in a 122 year old, two page document, were bent every which way, so that some new interpretation of how things could be done emerged.

Quite why it was necessary to change what was essentially a successful format, in a good venue has never been explained. And, why it was necessary for the Defender to assume many of the rights of the Challenger is still a mystery.

For many years there has been the catch-cry that the Deed of Gift needs reform to run what used to be one of the most prestigious competitions in sailing. Always the answer was the same 'if you want to change it, first win the America's Cup.'

None of those who have been vociferous in the call for reform have ever won the America's Cup, and have had the opportunity to put their fine thoughts into reality. And so the Cup has stayed the same.

By and large, the game doesn't need to change - provided organisers have a basic understanding of the Deed of Gift, and run a regatta that is consistent with the Deed of Gift. No tricks, no distortions and with constrained vision.

The flaw in the Deed of Gift for the America's Cup has alway been in its transition process between Cups. To work effectively this requires a competitive relationship between the Challenger and the Defender not a conniving one.

The transition process worked reasonably well, in its various forms (save for the 1988 Mismatch, bred out of the frustration with the Defender trying to maximise the game) until the America's Cup was won by Societe Nautique de Geneve, a landlocked club which did not conduct its regular racing on the sea.

At that point the phrase 'bidding the venue', of necessity, re-entered the America's Cup lexicon, and the current issues were perhaps inevitable.

Before the 32nd America's Cup there is no way that a Club who won the America's Cup would have been allowed by its membership, or country, to hold a Defence away from its home or national waters.

As with the Olympics, bidding the venue invites money and egos to come into play and inevitably the power games, and behind the scenes action begin. With Valencia some delicate footsteps on thin political ice were enough to carry the day for a great regatta. Ras al-Khaimah proved to be an Emirate too far.

Where to from here?

It's time to back up the truck. Accept the America's Cup for the simple, basic game it can be, and run it that way.

Accept Valencia as the venue. Take the date of 8 February 2010 that has been set.

If the regatta can't be financed by a combination of sponsorship, TV rights and modest event fees, then charge the competitors an entry fee that does cover the costs of the competition - the same as happens in every other regatta in the world. The time for brinkmanship has long gone. Everyone is tired of it.

Accept the ISAF appointed International Jury and Race Officials. Give them the power to act, independently, and trust them to get on and do what they do best.

Forget the blamestorming. Right now, a bit of forgiveness will go a long way.

And give the sailing world the Match they deserve - between two great teams, sailing two of the most spectacular, most powerful and technologically advanced yachts in history.

It won't fix the damage that has been done, but it might ease some of the pain.

Now is the time to move on.

RS Sailing 2021 - FOOTERCyclops Marine 2023 November - FOOTERPantaenius Sail 2025 AUS Footer

Related Articles

24th Argentario Sailing Week day 0
Historic boats from 9 nations have gathered in Porto Santo Stefano Historic boats have gathered in Porto Santo Stefano to take on the 24th edition of the prestigious Argentario Sailing Week, organised by the Yacht Club Santo Stefano with the tangible support of the Monte Argentario Municipal Council.
Posted today at 4:58 pm
29th Superyacht Cup Palma fleet is ready to go
Crews are now able to size-up the competition in their respective classes The owners, captains and crews of the spectacular array of yachts gathered for the 29th edition of the Superyacht Cup Palma are making their final preparations ahead of the start of racing next Thursday.
Posted today at 3:42 pm
Swan One Design Worlds kicks off
Practice race and opening ceremony in Costa Smeralda The crystal waters of the Costa Smeralda once again set the stage for one of the most anticipated events in the international racing calendar: the 2025 Swan One Design Worlds, hosted by Yacht Club Costa Smeralda in collaboration with ClubSwan Racing.
Posted today at 10:09 am
Class40 top guns enter Rolex Fastnet Race
One of the most successful genre of offshore race boat ever Now 20+ years old, the Class40 has proved itself one of the most successful genre of offshore race boat ever.
Posted today at 6:45 am
Finn World Masters in Medemblik Day 2
Pieter-Jan Postma leads after the second day of racing in The Netherlands Pieter-Jan Postma, from The Netherlands, is leading the fleet of 307 Finns from 27 countries after everyone sailed two more races at the 2025 Finn World Masters in Medemblik. France's Laurent Hay is second with Germany's Fabian Lemmel in third.
Posted on 17 Jun
World Sailing launches the World Sailing Academy
A new online learning platform for the global sailing community World Sailing officially launched the World Sailing Academy, an innovative new online learning platform designed to provide comprehensive educational resources and training to sailors, coaches, officials, administrators, and the global sailing community.
Posted on 17 Jun
Sailing and the summer solstice
Celebrating sailing and the longest day of the year If you love long evenings and early mornings, this is one of the best times of the whole year, as the summer solstice (Friday, June 20) and the entire rich expanse of summer are about to burst into bloom.
Posted on 17 Jun
New Caledonia Groupama Race update
Rushour crew safely back in Noumea after capsize The boat was located and it was identified as capsized. All crew members were accounted for. Crew were transferred in the larger aircraft at Koumac and arrived back at Noumea at about 4pm local time.
Posted on 17 Jun
Video Review: The Amazing Cure 55
Composite Construction meets Cruising Convenience It was two years ago at the Sanctuary Cove International Boat Show that I talked to Dave Biggar about his ideas and plans for the Cure 55. At the 2025 show I got to step on board the yacht and see how his ideas became reality.
Posted on 17 Jun
ASBA launches Touring Trophy Series
The new leadership team brings experience, enthusiasm, and strong focus on inclusivity and planning The Australian Sports Boat Association (ASBA) has announced a dynamic new initiative to enhance participation and connectivity within the sports boat community - the ASBA Touring Trophy series.
Posted on 16 Jun