Please select your home edition
Melges 14 2018 Leaderboard

False killer whales in the main Hawaiian Islands

by NOAA Fisheries 15 Sep 07:39 PDT
A false killer whale spy hops © NOAA Fisheries / Adam Ü

To help protect and recover endangered wildlife populations, we need to monitor them over time. By definition, however, endangered populations are at risk of extinction, which usually means they are small in size.

As a result, studying them can be difficult, especially if we rarely encounter them because they have unpredictable behavior or live in areas we cannot easily access. So, what do we do when our best research efforts result in limited data?

We are guided by law or mandate to move forward using the "best available science," or more specifically the "best available data," although it is not always clear what data qualifies as best or how to use them appropriately. Because the best available data on endangered populations are probably limited, we need to take special care in how we use these data. That is, we must account for bias in the data and acknowledge the limits of our conclusions.

False killer whales are broadly distributed in tropical and warm temperate waters, but are naturally rare throughout their range. The insular population of false killer whales in the main Hawaiian Islands is one of three populations of false killer whales in Hawaiian waters. This population is listed as endangered under the U.S. Endangered Species Act and is considered strategic under the U.S. Marine Mammal Protection Act. These designations involve specific management actions that require certain information about the population, including its abundance (or size).

Researchers have studied false killer whales in the main Hawaiian Islands since 2000 by taking photographs of the dorsal fins of individual whales, a method known as photo-identification. We used this long-term photo-identification dataset to estimate the abundance of the population.

The nonprofit Cascadia Research Collective collected most of the data during small-boat surveys from 2000 to 2015, but a large number of ocean users and research groups, including NOAA's Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, contributed photographs to the dataset. Prior to this effort, we did not have reliable estimates of abundance for this population.

Two characteristics of the small-boat data collection (or sampling) resulted in the potential for bias in our abundance estimates. First, research priorities, funding support, and logistical constraints caused the sampling to vary annually, seasonally, and spatially. Second, the sampling was limited to areas with calm sea conditions, which were primarily the leeward (west) sides of the islands. However, we know that false killer whales spend much of their time on the windward (east) sides of the islands from the movements of whales Cascadia researchers tagged with satellite transmitters.

Given the possible biases in the dataset, how did we reliably estimate the abundance of false killer whales in the main Hawaiian Islands? To begin with, we used an analytical method called mark-recapture. This method allows us to calculate the size of a population based on the rates that we "mark" (identify a whale in a photo) and "recapture" (identify the same whale in another photo) individuals over time.

Once we had mark-recapture abundance estimates in each year from 2000 to 2015, we performed additional analyses to see how sensitive the estimates were to bias from the sampling variability. Each analysis estimated abundance from a data subset that had some form of reduced bias, including overall, annual, seasonal, and spatial variability. These analyses did not show major departures from the abundance estimation based on the full dataset. We were happy to learn that the estimates from the full dataset were not sensitive to these forms of bias!

There is a limit on the conclusions we can make from these abundance estimates. Because of the limited spatial sampling of the range of this population, the estimates apply only to the portion of the population using the sampled area and may underestimate the true population size in each year. Still, the resulting estimates and other supporting evidence (like the low rate at which new whales are photo-identified over time) indicate the main Hawaiian Islands false killer whale population is small. For example, fewer than 200 whales were estimated to have been in the sampled area in 2015.

We do not think our estimates greatly underestimate the true size of the population because satellite tag data show that the whales move in and out of the sampled areas. We are actively trying to quantify any underestimation as part of an ongoing follow-up study.

In the meantime, we have a framework for using photo-identification data that have been regularly collected each year by many contributors to estimate the abundance of main Hawaiian Island false killer whales. These estimates will better inform management and, ultimately, the protection and recovery of this endangered population.

Read more about this collaborative study in "Abundance estimates for management of endangered false killer whales in the main Hawaiian Islands" (published in Endangered Species Research).

Related Articles

New Zhik ECO Wetsuits achieve Special Mention
Dame Awards recognise Zhik's innovations for third year in a row The new Zhik ECO Wetsuit received a Special Mention today at the METS DAME awards, recognising Zhik's innovations in technical sailing apparel for the third year in a row. Posted today at 7:07 pm
Golden Globe Race day 135
Mark Slats has closed the gap on the leader by 500 miles this week Jean-Luc Van Den Heede may have to earn his passage around Cape Horn. The embattled French leader nursing a damaged mast after the yacht was pitchpoled in a storm a week ago, has the prospect of having another Southern Ocean buster. Posted today at 6:57 pm
Interview with Steve Cockerill and Kate Sargent
Rooster Sailing win DAME award for the Rooster Exofleece We talked to Steve Cockerill and Kate Sargent at the METS marine trade fair in Amsterdam, where Rooster Sailing have just won a DAME award in the clothing category for the Rooster Exofleece. Posted today at 3:00 pm
Phil Robertson to skipper China SailGP
SailGP today unveiled the fifth team in its new global racing league – the China SailGP Team SailGP today unveiled the fifth team in its new global racing league – the China SailGP Team – with a bold ambition to drive the growth of high-performance sailing in China. The China SailGP Team takes to the water in February 2019 Posted today at 7:55 am
18ft Skiff Spring Champs - Races 5 and 6
Spring Championship 2018 Race 5 and 6 - Chris Webb Memorial Trophy - 3 Buoys There were two races sailed on Sunday in the Spring Championship for the Chris Webb Memorial Trophy. Sailing in 13-16kts ENE both races were dominated by end to end winners - Asko in Race 5 and Finport Finance in Race 6. Posted today at 7:31 am
49th Star Class South American Championship
Robert Scheidt and Arthur Lopes win in Rio Robert Scheidt and Arthur Lopes (BRA) are the 2018 South American champions of the Star class. The two-time Olympic champion won the first race on Sunday, last day of the event, at the Yacht Club in Rio de Janeiro, and finished second in the last. Posted on 12 Nov
Route du Rhum-Destination Guadeloupe day 9
François Gabart says he's happy with his second-placed finish At the moment, François Gabart says he's happy with his finish at Pointe-à-Pitre and to have been able to battle to the end, even though Francis Joyon stole the victory by taking the lead at the finishing line, just seven minutes ahead of him. Posted on 12 Nov
Emirates Team NZ are first team in Cup Village
Long the Cinderella of America's Cup teams, Emirates Team NZ have now made it to the glass palace After years of being cooped up in a grimy, gritty base, America's Cup victors Emirates Team New Zealand finally have a sparkling new home on Auckland's waterfront. Suzanne McFadden takes a look inside Posted on 12 Nov
Joyon sets course record in the Route du Rhum
Joyon sets course record in the Route du Rhum–Destination Guadeloupe France's Francis Joyon (62), sailing aboard IDEC Sport, crossed the Route du Rhum–Destination Guadeloupe's finishing line seven minutes and eight seconds ahead of Francois Gabart (FRA; 35), to set a new course record. Posted on 12 Nov
Optimist Asian/Oceanian Championship practice day
Teams arrive in Myanmar Yesterday marked the opening day of the 2018 Optimist Asian and Oceanian Championship, hosted by the Ngwe Saung Yacht Club and Resort with the support of the Myanmar Yachting Federation. Posted on 12 Nov
P&B Autumn Sale 2018 - FooterMelges 14 2018 FooterWindBot-COACH-660x82