Please select your home edition
Edition
J Composites 2022 - J45 LEADERBOARD

World Sailing – Don’t rock the boat, whatever you do

by Rob Kothe and the Sail-World team on 5 Dec 2015
Capsize coming up - abandon ship Frank Quealey
In October 2014 Sail-World was in Palma, Mallorca to watch and listen to the deliberations of the International Sailing Federation (ISAF), the world governing body for the sport of sailing. Annual General Meeting council.

We were frankly appalled at the time management of the critical last two days of the event, of the major meeting when the Council met and deliberated on a large number of submissions from MNAs around the world.

It was easy to see why the group could have made the kind of stupid decision-making errors that will go down in history such as the famous removal of the Tornado multihull from the 2012 Olympics.

For the last two years, Sail-World has been attempting to find a copy of the overall plan. The master plan. The core mission statement of ISAF - without success. (Does anyone have a copy they can forward to us?).

We've asked numbers of people in ISAF. They say they will get back to us, but all we hear is the sound of crickets.

It is therefore not surprising that the delegates and the MNA's could produce submissions that in fact may have gone in the opposite direction to the unpublished philosophy and aims of the organisation.

Just as the decision to cut the Tornado, for purely political reasons, went in the opposite direction to the ISAF submission to the IOC, which had said our aim is to have faster, more exciting boats. That historic vote removed the fastest and most exciting boat from the Olympic suite.



At the 2014 AGM, there was a lot of work to be done and very important decisions to be made and then what struck us was the amount of time that was nothing more than entertainment and the background education for an expensively assembled group.

We estimate that at least a third of the time of the last critical two days' critical decision making of the meeting was spent on education, running of videos, briefings, speeches, etc.

All this information could have been presented to the delegates on a DVD two or three weeks before the event, letting people spend five or six hours of their time watching this content.

That would have allowed them to come to the Council meeting up to speed and ready to engage in constructive debate and informed decision making.

Large numbers of submissions were put to the council with no cross reference between any unpublished overall council policy and the direction of the actual submission.

With precious time already consumed, the deliberations of the group was cut short because of a crammed list of items, many of them nonsensical that required formal decisions.

There were, in fact, rare glimpses of actual intelligent debate and conversation amongst the delegates.

The whole event was deeply depressing.

After the weekend, I commented to one of the ISAF old hands among the delegates, how appalling the time management and decision making had been at the meeting, and he said to me, ‘I guess that was your first ISAF AGM meeting? ‘I nodded, and he said ‘I thought so. ‘It was so much better than in the olden days!!'

The reality is that had that procedure been followed in a commercial environment heads would have rolled.

This was the environment that still existed in early July 2015 when Sail-World interviewed, on his third day in the office, Peter Sowrey the man in the hot seat in Southampton.



Sowrey had a strong corporate background in large organisations where decision making was a premium, and this decision making was fact based.

At the time, we asked Sowrey just how he felt he could handle the politics of a very political organisation ISAF. He said,’ I am not interested in politics, I let the facts speak for themselves’.

Sowrey’s optimism on his ability to engender change within the peak sailing body without worrying about politics seemed to us overly optimistic, and so it is proven.

Now the highly credentialed and experienced corporate reformer is gone. (See the ISAF Press release)

Did he jump or was he pushed?

Don't assume a press release is a fact, but was there a culture clash?

Although he was an enthusiastic sailor Sowrey had not been involved in the machinations of ISAF and not been present at any ISAF Annual Conferences or Mid-Year conferences.

Looking at the background of the conversation that came out of Sanya, China, at the Annual General Meeting, that is pretty plain to see. The speed at which the CEO wanted to move, and the speed at the which the ISAF executive has traditionally moved seems to be poles apart.

One commentator said to us upon hearing of Sowrey’s departure is that perhaps the problem is that our representatives at ISAF are displeased with interruptions when they are drinking champagne, and they certainly don't like their opinions being questioned.

The previous CEO Jerome Pels had been in the organisation for some years before he took on the CEO role and it’s clear given the sorry state of the organisation he left after 17 years, sadly it seems he did not rock the boat.

Going forward it would appear that the selection of a new CEO for ISAF is going to be even more difficult - if the most recent CEO found that his position was unacceptable after less than six months.

Now it seems ISAF is unlikely to appoint a reformist CEO going forward. Probably one won't present anyway. Where now do you find a reformer out there who believes he can find his way through the ISAF politics.

Regardless when the ISAF Executive next sits down together, one hopes they don’t smugly congratulate each other for seeing off someone who was questioning their lack of direction and leadership, but rather hang their heads in shame at failing to rise to the reformist challenge.

Which do you think they will do?

McConaghy 2022 - MC63p & MC75 FOOTERSelden 2020 - FOOTERVetus-Maxwell 2021 v2 FOOTER

Related Articles

Return to paradise
OK Dinghy Europeans open in Bandol Once again, the beach at Bandol, France, has filled up with OK Dinghies from all over Europe ahead of the 2022 European Championship, which was opened on Tuesday at the Société Nautique de Bandol.
Posted today at 6:53 pm
Hobie 16 Worlds in Spain day 13
Another long day but the semis are in the books. Who made the cut? Similar to yesterday, racing for the final day of the semi-finals got under way shortly after 11:00 AM in the offshore breeze. The early race started off in 12 knots of breeze but, it didn't hold. As the wind got lighter during the race it became shifty.
Posted today at 6:46 pm
Royal Cup 52 Super Series Scarlino Day 1
Quantum Racing are back on form in Scarlino After two races in winds which topped 27kts in the gusts Quantum Racing lead the Royal Cup Scarlino 52 SUPER SERIES regatta.
Posted today at 6:38 pm
New arrival in the Zhik range - Flight Jacket
A crew/shore jacket with a cosy recycled fleece lining Zhik's new ergonomically styled Flight Jacket crosses between street, dockside and the water. With a cosy 240gsm recycled fleece lining, this versatile jacket is made with a recycled, breathable and showerproof outer fabric.
Posted today at 4:00 pm
SailGP Update and look at Tasar Worlds 2022
Sail-World's David Schmidt looks at the racing scene across North America The last two months have been full-on for the nine teams that are competing in SailGP's third season, with four events taking place over this time period. This translates to an event roughly every other weekend for this two-month period.
Posted today at 3:00 pm
Setting vibe for Lepanto Formula Kite Europeans
Australia is represented by four male and two female riders From September 25th to October 2nd the Greek town of Nafpaktos will host the International Kite Association (IKA) European Championships for the first time.
Posted today at 7:51 am
Shirley Robertson talks with John Bertrand
Shirley Robertson talks with John Bertrand about conquering the Everest of sailing The fourth Series of Shirley Robertson's Sailing Podcast starts in emphatic fashion as double Olympic gold medallist Robertson sits down with the skipper of the America's Cup's first ever successful Challenger, Australian John Bertrand.
Posted today at 5:21 am
Cup Critiqued: A significant week in AC37
It has been one of the more significant weeks in the now 18-month-old 37th America's Cup cycle. It has been one of the more significant weeks in the now 18-month-old 37th America's Cup cycle. Sail-World NZ's Editor, Richard Gladwell looks What's happening with the teams in Auckland, Barcelona, China and Cadiz.
Posted today at 5:11 am
Iain Murray and Richard Slater in AC37 key roles
As Independent Regatta Director and Chief Umpire In a double announcement by America's Cup Events Limited it is confirmed today that Iain Murray has been appointed as Independent Regatta Director for the 37th America's Cup in Barcelona alongside Richard Slater who continues in the role as Chief Umpire.
Posted today at 4:52 am
Planet Sail reviews SailGP Cadiz
Video reports from the heart of the action in Spain The tide has turned in SailGP as the leader board gets shaken. The previously dominant Aussies are finding it increasingly hard to hold onto the top spot as the fleet learns how to sail fast.
Posted on 26 Sep