Please select your home edition
Edition
sMRT AIS Man Overboard Beacons AUS / NZ

Would George Schuyler have accepted RNZYS in the America's Cup?

by Richard Gladwell on 25 Sep 2007
Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron, established in 1859 and a six time competitor in the America’s Cup over a 20 year period. Sail-World.com/NZ

Parties associated with the Defence of the 33rd America’s Cup, continue to push out claims that the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron was not a bona fide challenger, for the period of its three Challenges from 1987 to 1995, and two Defences for the America’s Cup.

So far, the Squadron’s legitimacy as a Challenger and Defender has been called into question by the Societe Nautique de Geneve, the Arbitration Panel for the 33rd America’s Cup, and in an affidavit sworn by Alinghi General Counsel, Hamish Ross, who is also a member of RNZYS.

The latest claim is contained in a paragraph of the affidavit filed by Ross in support of submission by Societe Nautique de Geneve to the New York Supreme Court. This affidavit is part of its response to the motions filed by Golden Gate Yacht Club querying the legitimacy of the present Challenger of Record, Club Nautique Espanol de Vela.

In his affidavit, Ross asserts at paragraph 45:

'RNZYS first challenged for the 1987 Cup and its challenge was accepted by the then trustee Royal Perth Yacht Club of Western Australia Incorporated. RNZYS challenged twice more, for the 1992 America’s Cup and the 1995 America’s Cup, and its challenges were accepted by the then trustee San Diego Yacht Club, despite not ever being incorporated.

'Attached hereto (as Ex. V) is a copy of the Certificate of Incorporation for RNZYS, dated February 28, 2003, and obtained from the Registrar of Companies New Zealand. RNZYS won the America’s Cup in 1995 and was the Defender/trustee in 2000 and in 2003. It was not 'incorporated, patented, or licensed by the legislature, admiralty, or other executive department,' as required by the Deed, until after it had lost the America’s Cup to SNG and ceased to be the trustee.'

Ross is referring to the fact that from the period of its inception in 1859 until 2003, the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron was not registered in New Zealand under the Incorporated Societies Act (1908). However under the constitution of Yachting New Zealand, such incorporation is specifically not required for yacht clubs of the Squadron’s vintage.

The argument being advanced by the parties associated with Defender and the Arbitration Panel is designed give credence to the action of Societe Nautique de Geneve in accepting the Challenge of Club Nautico Espanol de Vela, which parties associated with the Golden Gate Yacht Club have claimed to be illegitimate in terms of the Deed of Gift of the America’s Cup.

The legitimacy of the Club Nautico Espanol de Vela is at the heart of the arguments made to the New York Supreme Court by Golden Gate YC. The argument being made in response is that there is precedence, and effectively that two wrongs make a right.

The RNZYS first responded, in an earlier story in Sail-World, to the claims, made in an interview by Hamish Ross. RNZYS Commodore John Crawford responded to the comments:

'Under New Zealand law, becoming 'incorporated' is simply a means of limiting individual Club Members’ liability. The Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron has operated as a legal entity since 1859 and has had H.R.H. The Duke of Edinburgh as its Patron since 1986.

'The Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron was granted a warrant to fly the Blue Ensign by the British Admiralty in 1902 and has subsequently been awarded a warrant to fly the New Zealand Blue Ensign by H.R.H Queen Elizabeth.'


It subsequently transpired that Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron was not listed on the New Zealand Register of Incorporated Societies until 2003. However this is not unusual as many clubs had been in existence prior to the 1908 Act, and took a long time to realise the benefit of limited liability conferred by the Act. It is still not compulsory, in New Zealand to be an Incorporated Society - to operate as a yacht, or any other, club.

The Oxford Dictionary of Law gives a definition of Incorporation which is more applicable internationally to yacht clubs, where it defines Incorporation as 'The formation of an association that has corporate personality ie a personality distinct from those of its members.'

It also follows that regulations and legal process covering incorporation will vary from country to country, and what is the practice in Spain, will be different in New Zealand.

Research by Sail-World has revealed that while many New Zealand organisations are registered under the Incorporated Societies Act, it is not compulsory. Given that the Yacht Squadron has been successfully operating for 50 years, before the Act was introduced, there was obviously no pressing need voluntarily register and undertake the compliance requirements, since the organisation had been operating quite successfully without it.

As Crawford pointed out the main advantage of incorporation is to limit the liability of members, if this limitation is not in place then all members are liable for the actions the Squadron, and in many eyes this is a stronger level of commercial backing.

The statement that 'RNZYS was not 'incorporated, patented, or licensed by the legislature, admiralty, or other executive department,' as required by the Deed' contained in the affidavit, but also a consistent theme in submissions made by parties associated with the Defender and Arbitration Panel, is not correct.

Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron clearly was incorporated in terms of the Oxford Dictionary definition of Incorporation from its inception in 1859. It also fits with the definition of a Club by the same authority which is 'An association regulated by rules that bind its members according to the laws of contract.'


Further RNZYS is a long standing member of Yachting New Zealand, and is the largest club within that federation of NZ clubs. As the New Zealand national authority affiliated to the International Sailing Federation (ISAF), YNZ is the only body entitled to 'licence', by affiliation, yacht clubs in New Zealand for the purposes of yacht racing and organisation of sailing regattas and events that may use the ISAF Racing Rules of Sailing.

Writing in the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron club magazine 'Breeze' in September/October 1999, Hamish Ross commented that RNZYS was one of 32 yacht clubs in the United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand having a warrant for members to fly a Blue Ensign. 'The Admiralty practice of issuing warrants to yacht clubs arose early in the nineteenth century shortly after the first yacht clubs were formed to encourage sailing' says Ross in the Breeze article.

Ross notes that the right was given by the British Admiralty to the Squadron’s members in 1902. The warrants, of which Ross has one, are signed by the Second Sea Lord of the British Admiralty.

Although there is no formal means of licencing yacht clubs by the British Admiralty, the nearest document seems to be 'The Navy List' which is published by the Royal Navy, which does list the yacht clubs entitled to fly the White, Blue and defaced Blue and Red Ensign. RNZYS is listed in that document, along with two other New Zealand Clubs and former Cup holder Royal Perth Yacht Club, and current Challenger, Royal Thames YC.

The granting of the Royal Warrant in 1902 enabled the Squadron to change its name from the New Zealand Yacht Squadron to the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron. The ability of the Flag Officers to fly the White Ensign and the Members to fly the Blue Ensign was a byproduct of the granting of the Warrant.


In its decision of 7 September 2007, the Arbitration Panel, appointed by America’s Cup Management on behalf of Societe Nautique de Geneve, repeated Ross’s assertion to support its confirmation of Club Nautico Espanol de Vela at paragraph 108:

'RNZYS challenged for the America’s Cup for the 26th Match held in 198

Maritimo 2023 M600 FOOTERVetus-Maxwell 2021 v2 FOOTERVaikobi 2024 December

Related Articles

2025 Santa Maria Cup in Annapolis, USA Day 2
Final four skippers emerge from a competitive qualifying double-round robin stage A thrilling second day of racing at the 2025 Santa Maria Cup saw the final four skippers emerge from a competitive qualifying double-round robin stage.
Posted today at 4:47 am
Scandinavian Gold Cup at Sopot, Poland Day 1
A slow start with very little wind The Scandinavian Gold Cup opened Thursday in Sopot, Poland, with seven 5.5 Metres competing for this historic and iconic trophy that dates back to 1922. Unfortunately, there was not enough wind to even complete one race.
Posted on 5 Jun
49er, 49erFX and Nacra 17 Europeans Day 3
A six-hour bake on the water Veteran and multi-Olympic race officer Sulis was clear at the morning briefing, "Our priority is to get three races for the 49er so they can progress to the gold fleet."
Posted on 5 Jun
Galicia 52 Super Series Royal Cup Day 3
Platoon Aviation turn up the heat but don't dent American Magic Quantum Racing's lead After a disappointing first regatta of the season when they finished in an uncharacteristic last position in Saint-Tropez, the fortunes of the German flagged 2023 52 SUPER SERIES overall champions Platoon Aviation seem to have turned for the better.
Posted on 5 Jun
Diverse international fleet for 5th AEGEAN 600
The race start is a little over 1 month away In a sign that this newest of the world's 600-mile classic offshore races has reached maturity, organizers from the Hellenic Offshore Racing Club are pleased to announce yet another large international fleet will be assembled for the 2025 AEGEAN 600.
Posted on 5 Jun
America's Cup: Another sponsor signs for Italians
Luna Rossa has announced that Unipol has renewed its trust in the team Luna Rossa has announced that Unipol has renewed its trust in the team and will accompany it as an official sponsor for the duration of the 38th America's Cup.
Posted on 5 Jun
SailGP: Media Conference concludes in New York
The media conference ahead of the Mubadala New York Sail Grand Prix has concluded, without any speci The media conference ahead of the Mubadala New York Sail Grand Prix has concluded, without any special points being revealed, save for Brazil lending a crew member to Germany.
Posted on 5 Jun
A decade of pushing the boundaries at A+T
Celebrating 10 years of the world's best yacht instruments 2025 marks a decade of pushing the boundaries of quality and customer service in the global yachting industry for A+T Instruments.
Posted on 5 Jun
Hugh Jackman and Ryan Reynolds Take the Helm
As Co-Owners of the 'BONDS Flying Roos' Australia's SailGP Team Today Australia's three-time SailGP champions have unveiled a new identity as well as two new co-owners - Hugh Jackman and Ryan Reynolds - who join Driver and CEO Tom Slingsby in leading the freshly rebranded BONDS Flying Roos SailGP Team.
Posted on 5 Jun
Should SailGP ditch the wings?
As SailGP resumes in New York this weekend, we ask the question As SailGP resumes in New York this weekend, we ask the question of whether the F50's solid wingsails should be ditched and replaced instead with twin-skin mainsails, in a similar way to what is used on the AC75 and AC40 of the America's Cup.
Posted on 5 Jun