Please select your home edition
Edition
Allen 2018 US A4866XB 728x90

Sail-World.com USA Newsletter: Vestas 11th Hour Racing report, warm-water racing

06/03/2018


Vestas 11th Hour Racing’s tragic accident, Caribbean and Florida racing

Zhik 2018 Yacht 728x90

North Sails 3Di 60 - 728x90

Vestas 11th Hour Racing - Leg 4, Volvo Ocean Race Melbourne to Hong Kong - photo © Vestas 11th Hour Racing/Volvo Ocean race


Dear [recipient name]

While sailboat racing isn't a danger sport, per se, the simple fact remains that accidents do happen and people do occasionally get hurt. Still, much like hopping into our cars for the drive down the freeway to the marina or YC, most of us accept this risk while using our skills, training and years of experience to best mitigate risk and danger for ourselves and for our friends and fellow competitors. But what if the person who got hurt or killed isn't part of sailing's fraternity and didn't accept the same risk profile as sailors hopping onto a highly strung raceboat that was designed to ply the world's ocean? Such was the case on the early morning of January 20, 2018, just after 0100 hours (Hong Kong time), when Vestas 11th Hour Racing hit a fishing boat some 30 miles off of Hong Kong while sailing in roughly 20 knots of air as they were finishing Leg 4 of the Volvo Ocean Race (Melbourne, Australia to Hong Kong), knocking the fishermen into the water and tragically claiming one life.

While the sailors were unharmed, living with the real-world consequences of this reality is no easy weight to bear, especially for the team's afterguard.

 
RS Sailing - Zest Seat 300x250   J111 Worlds 2018 Retina MPU
 

Given that a human life was lost in this tragic collision, Vestas 11th Hour Racing has been tight-lipped about what transpired, both out of respect for the lost fisherman's family and so that the investigation can run its due course sans any inkling of influence or obstruction.

Last week, the team announced that they have been told by investigators that authorities in Hong Kong and China are close to wrapping up their investigations and that "no further action will be taken". As a result, Mark Towill, the team's number two who was acting as skipper on Leg 4 (due to a medical emergency in skipper Charlie Enright's family), went on the record in a Q&A with his team that was sent out as a press release to offer clarification on what transpired that dark morning.

Mark Towill, Vestas 11th Hour Racing - photo © Vestas 11th Hour Racing/Volvo Ocean race
Mark Towill, Vestas 11th Hour Racing - photo © Vestas 11th Hour Racing/Volvo Ocean race

"It was a dark and cloudy night, with a breeze of around 20 knots and a moderate sea state," said Towill in the official team interview. "As we approached the fishing vessel that we had identified on AIS, the on-deck crew confirmed visual contact – the fishing vessel was well lit – and we headed up to starboard to keep clear. I was watching AIS and communicating the range and bearing to the crew. The crew confirmed we were crossing the fishing vessel when, before the anticipated cross, there was an unexpected collision."

 
Zhik 2018 Dongfeng 300x250   Allen IQP 300x250
 

Here, the team first had to ensure the health and well-being of all sailors, work to stabilize water ingress aboard their own vessel, and issue a Mayday call before they could render assistance.

"It took roughly 20 minutes to get our boat under control, and then we headed back towards the location of the collision," said Towill. "Upon arrival, several people on a fishing vessel nearby were shining lights to a point on the water. Our first thought was that they could be looking for someone, so we immediately started a search and rescue. After some time searching, we eventually spotted a person in the water."

Vestas 11th Hour Racing was involved in a collision just 30nm from the finish of VOR leg 4 (Hong Kong) and has retired. - photo © Suzy Rayment
Vestas 11th Hour Racing was involved in a collision just 30nm from the finish of VOR leg 4 (Hong Kong) and has retired. - photo © Suzy Rayment

While the team was on station and assisting in the rescue operations, the scene was anything but simple and straightforward. Towill again: "Communication was difficult. The sheer volume of traffic on the radio meant it was hard to communicate to the people we needed to. Not many people on the VHF were speaking English, but we found a way to relay messages through a cable laying vessel, and they were able to send their guard boat to aid in the search and rescue."

Given that Hong Kong is one of the world's busiest ports, it's not surprising that there were a lot of lights on the water, but this certainly didn't make things easier for Towill and company, who were dealing with a massive hole in their port bow that made maneuvering difficult (the team also swung their keel to starboard and kept their sail stack on that board in order to help roll their damaged port bow clear of the brine), in addition to wending their way through a populated piece of water.

"Difficult conditions and limited maneuverability hampered our initial efforts to retrieve the casualty," continued Towill. "The guard boat from the cable layer provided assistance and every effort was made from all parties involved in the search and rescue. We were finally able to successfully recover the casualty after several attempts. When we got him aboard, our medics started CPR. We alerted Hong Kong Marine Rescue Coordination Centre that we had the casualty aboard and they confirmed air support was on its way. He was transferred to a helicopter and taken to a Hong Kong hospital where medical staff where unable to revive him."

Vestas 11th Hour Racing unloaded and waiting to start the trip to Auckland for repair ahead of the start of Leg 7 of the Volvo Ocean Race on March 18, 2018 - photo © Facebook.com
Vestas 11th Hour Racing unloaded and waiting to start the trip to Auckland for repair ahead of the start of Leg 7 of the Volvo Ocean Race on March 18, 2018 - photo © Facebook.com

While there's no question that none of the sailors who set off from Melbourne aboard Vestas 11th Hour Racing will ever be quite the same again, there's also no question that a human life was lost and that the lost fisherman's family will be dealing with grief and the butterfly effect of this unexpected disaster for years, if not decades.

The fact that Hong Kong and Chinese investigators are close to wrapping up their inquiry and that no further action will be taken likely comes as a relief for Towill, Enright and the Vestas 11th Hour Racing team, who are now in New Zealand preparing for Leg 7, which will take the fleet from Auckland to Itajai, Brazil. However there's no escaping the fact that the race organizers knew darn right well that the entrance to Hong Kong harbour is littered with marine traffic. Moreover, race organizers also knew that plenty of this traffic doesn't carry AIS (or even proper navigation lights, let alone radar reflectors), and they know the speeds that Volvo Ocean 65s sail at under full racing conditions.

All of this begs the question: If races like the Volvo Ocean Race are going to visit ports as choked with commercial and fishing-boat traffic as Hong Kong, wouldn't race officials be wiser to finish the boats maybe 40 miles offshore and then allow them to arrive at the dock in the same order in which they finished racing?

Leg 4 from Melbourne to Hong Kong. Vestas 11th Hour Racing against the Hong Kong backdrop. 20 January,. - photo © Ainhoa Sanchez / Volvo Ocean Race
Leg 4 from Melbourne to Hong Kong. Vestas 11th Hour Racing against the Hong Kong backdrop. 20 January,. - photo © Ainhoa Sanchez / Volvo Ocean Race

True, this doesn't provide the same spectator thrill as watching boats finish under full sail within sight of their cheering fans, but if this allows the race to safely visit ports that otherwise might be questionable to enter at (ballpark) 20 knots of boat speed, this seems like a worthy trade-off, especially when human life is concerned.

Fortunately, the Volvo Ocean Race has already commissioned an independent report on the dangers of racing into crowded areas at night that will be chaired by Rear Admiral Chris Oxenbould AO RAN (Rtd) and assisted by Stan Honey and Chuck Hawley. Hopefully a safe and viable solution will come from this report.

Charlie Enright, Vestas 11th Hour Racing - photo © Vestas 11th Hour Racing/Volvo Ocean race
Charlie Enright, Vestas 11th Hour Racing - photo © Vestas 11th Hour Racing/Volvo Ocean race

Sail-World.com offers our deepest condolences to the family of the lost fisherman, and we also extend our thoughts to Vestas 11th Hour Racing's crew and afterguard as they deal with the ghosts of Leg 4, and as they prepare to engage the mammoth Leg 7, which will take the fleet around Cape Horn.

Meanwhile, on a brighter note, this past weekend also marked the J/24 Midwinter Championship (March 2-4) and the start of the Star class racing at the 2018 Bacardi Cup Invitational Regatta (March 4-10; J/70 class racing begins later this week), as well as the start of Miami Sailing Week (March 5-11), where teams are competing in Melges 24, Flying Tigers 7.5, A-Cat and M32 classes.

38th St. Maarten Heineken Regatta 2018 - Final day - photo © Laurens Morel / www.saltycolours.com
38th St. Maarten Heineken Regatta 2018 - Final day - photo © Laurens Morel / www.saltycolours.com

Finally, racing wrapped up on Sunday at the 38th annual St. Maarten Heineken Regatta (March 1-4), and the winners were crowned in 16 classes. According to reports, Sunday offered breeze-on conditions that allowed the Race Committee to send the maxi and ocean-racing classes around the island (counterclockwise), while the other classes raced off windward-leeward courses off of Simpson Bay.

May the four winds blow you safely home,

David Schmidt, Sail-World.com North American Editor

 
Selden CX & GX Furling Systems 600x500   Gul Winter Drysuits 300x250 1
 


Record attendance at CCA Seminar equates to increased interest in Safety-at-Sea Training
The Cruising Club of America (CCA), one of the principal organizers of the biennial 635-mile Newport Bermuda Race, has announced that its upcoming Safety At Sea Seminar has reached the maximum number of sailors it can train during the hands-on sessions

Bacardi Cup Invitational Regatta - Day 1
The 91st Bacardi Cup is taking place and features the cream of world sailing talent, who are looking to maximize their performance across the six races for the Star fleet and nine races for the J/70 fleet.

RS:X and Techno Windsurfing South American Championships
The RS:X Windsurfing and Techno South American Championships concluded on Sunday with four days of amazing sailing in near perfect conditions.

 
Rooster Sailing North America Find a Stockist   Barton Marine 300x250
 
2018 18ft Skiff JJ Giltinan Trophy - Race 3
The Australians fought back after previous domination by the New Zealand teams when Finport Trade Finance took out Race 3 of the Winning Group JJ Giltinan 18ft Skiff Championship on Sydney Harbour today.

Turn on the Turbo: Seldén Code Zero and Asymmetric Spinnaker Furling Systems
New technology, as with high fashion, is usually introduced at the top end of the market and initially adopted by trailblazers before elements gradually filter down to the mass market. The is true for the introduction of products in the marine industry.

Four months to the start of the Golden Globe Race
Don McIntyre, founder of the 2108 Golden Globe race, is proud to announce the appointment of Patrice Carpentier, the well-known French sailor, author and editor of Course au Large Magazine as Race Director.

 
Fever-Tree 300x250   North Sails 3Di 60 300x250
 
Puerto Vallarta Race: Monday at the 50 Yard Line
In San Diego Yacht Club's Puerto Vallarta Race last night, a good portion of the fleet passed the metaphorical 50 yard line… or the "500 miles to go" mark.

America's Cup: Further delays expected to planning deadlines
There could be a further delay to decisions on how to build an America's Cup village in Auckland. Minister David Parker will be out of the country for the rest of the week, with an already-extended part of the planning process due to close in eight days.

Designer Spotlight: Juan Garay & Juan Meseguer
For the past decade, both Juan Garay and Juan Meseguer have been sought after by the most competitive inshore Grand Prix teams because they combine sailing experience and sail design expertise.

 
Mars Keel -  Manufactured Keel Systems 250   Nebo 300x250 1
 
Melges, Ankers and Thielman take podium at the Melges 14 Midwinter Championship
Taking his grandfather's advice, Harry Melges IV started first and increased his lead — and ultimately won the Melges 14 Midwinter Championship.

JJ Giltinan 18ft Skiff Championship - Knight Frank does a sternboard
Knight Frank, performed a spectacular sternboard, as the 25 strong fleet battled 20-25 kt winds in Race 2 of the JJ Giltinans. Jono Witty of Aeromedia.com.au captured this sequence from the drone camera which is being used for coverage of the event.

Clipper Round the World Yacht Race 8 Day 1 - Light wind lottery creates early winners and losers
The light wind lottery that got Race 8: The Sailing City Qingdao Cup, underway yesterday from Sanya, has continued overnight, with the teams out east taking the early jackpot as they do their best to escape north

 
Hyde Sails 2017 March 300x250   Sperry Charleston Race Week 2018 MPU v2
 
Ian Proctor : The Man Who Designed Racehorses
We turn our attention to the life, times, boats and innovations of Ian Proctor, as we celebrate his centenary in 2018. Jack Holt and Ian Proctor almost dominated small boat sailing, both in the UK and internationally, for nearly a quarter of a century.

SuperFoiler speeds things up in Sydney with Expr3ss!
The stunning series climax to the inaugural SuperFoiler Grand Prix will be delivered thanks to a new broadcast and event location partner Expr3ss!

Winners take to the stage in the 38th St. Maarten Heineken Regatta
A burst of breeze from the west made for a spectacular grand finale of racing at the 38th St. Maarten Heineken Regatta, and with lead positions still up for grabs in several classes, many teams were eager to make their final claims on class victories.

 
KZRaceFurlers   Mackay 250
 
J/24 Midwinter Championship - Overall
All eight scheduled races were completed in gorgeous Miami, FL conditions at the J/24 Midwinter Championship, but Will Welles' Bogus only needed seven of them to tie up the victory.

Gladwell's Line: America's Cup Auckland - will history repeat?
A week ago the submission deadline for Panuku Developments' America's Cup base proposal was extended for reasons that are not exactly clear. Now time, more so than money is the most vital commodity. Richard Gladwell writes.

RC44 Calero Marinas Cup - Overall
Nico Poons' Charisma clung on to her lead from yesterday to win the RC44 Calero Marinas Cup, opening event of the 2018 RC44 championship.

 
Insun - AC - Promo   Predictwind - Iridium
 
SuperFoiler - Locals Light Up Busselton Leg to Ignite Championship Challenge
Two West Australian skippers have steered their teams to the podium in their home regatta with Perth's Luke Parkinson (tech2) and Steve Thomas (Pavement) climbing onto the Busselton dais alongside Kleenmaid.

X-Yachts is pleased to announce the launch of the new X46 – the latest addition to the X range
In January 2018, the X49 was presented for the first time to the press at the world's largest boat show, Boot Düsseldorf. As expected, everyone was thrilled to finally board the boat and to dream about and plan for the coming sailing seasons.

America's Cup: Cyclor turns Grinder
The cyclist who turned Team New Zealand sailors into cyclors is fighting his way back into the crew - which means learning how to sail. Suzanne McFadden reports.

 
Naiad NZ250   Protector - 300x250
 
Clipper Round the World Yacht Race starts all China race from Sanya to Qingdao
Sanya, which made its debut on the Clipper 2017-18 Race route and also has a team entry, lived up to its reputation for putting on a spectacular show with a final departure ceremony for the Clipper Race fleet

Puerto Vallarta Race : Everyone is on the race course
Everyone is on the race course... and judging from 0600 comments from the boat, most are having a classic race to Mexico. Winds are generally from aft of the shrouds, sea states are moderate and 'pushy', and the temperature is rising.

51st Newport Bermuda Race - Preview
When as many as 200 sailing yachts head southeast in June, they'll be competing in several races within the race.

 
C-Tech 250   Southern Spars Recruitment 300x250
 
North U Seminars
North U Seminars provide classroom training with a roster of top instructors, the latest in interactive multimedia training.

British Optimist Association sending a team for US Nationals in Florida
Great Britain's National Optimist Dinghy Association, IOCA UK, is excited to announce that following Selections in May, this year's Development Team will be heading to the 2018 USODA US Nationals in Pensacola, Florida from 13 - 22 July 2018.

Inaugural Monaco Swan One Design Regatta less than a month away
Hot on the heels of October's successful and inaugural Nations Trophy, Nautor's Swan is set to deliver an ever-increasing programme of one-design events dedicated to select models of this iconic yacht brand.

2018 18ft Skiff JJ Giltinan Trophy - Race 2
New Zealand's domination of the 2018 Winning Group 2018 JJ Giltinan 18ft Skiff Championship continued on Sydney Harbour today when Honda Marine proved too good for the 25-boat fleet of the world's best 18 Footer teams.

Registration open for 2018 California Offshore Race Week
Welcome to the 2018 California Offshore Race Week! Encinal Yacht Club, San Francisco Yacht Club, Monterey Peninsula Yacht Club, Santa Barbara Yacht Club and San Diego Yacht Club are joining forces and races to provide you, your crew and your family

The countdown to 2018 Antigua Sailing Week starts now
Antigua Sailing Week's 51st edition begins in exactly 2 months on April 28th. We already have 75 entries hailing from over 15 countries and we can't help but say it is shaping up to be a fantastic regatta!

2018 18ft Skiff JJ Giltinan Trophy - Race 1
The young New Zealand Maersk Line team of Josh Porebski, Jack Simpson and Dave Hazard was a shock, but well-deserved winner of Race 1 of The Winning Group JJ Giltinan International 18ft Skiff Championship on Sydney Harbour today.

Puerto Vallarta Race First Start: Downwind sailing under a full moon
For the first roll call of San Diego Yacht Club's 2018 Puerto Vallarta Race, it was clear that Peter Isler's weather briefing the morning before had been spot on.

Barcelona World Race: Cape Horn may be tougher
The rounding of Cape Horn is one of the most delicate and meteorologically complex stages of the Barcelona World Race.

RS Sailing BOTTOM

Fever-Tree 660x82

This email was sent to the.recipients@email.address by YY Online Services Ltd.
The George Business Centre, Christchurch Road, New Milton, BH25 6QJ
Registered in England No. 7895890

Our records show that you signed up to receive news from us on 1 January 1900

Please do not reply to this message as we cannot receive replies.

You can unsubscribe at any time or email us here if you encounter any difficulties
RS Sailing BOTTOMWindBot-COACH-660x82Naiad 660x82px_Tourist