Please select your home edition
Edition
Trofeo Princesa Sofía Mallorca 2025

Why weren't Luna Rossa penalised in the Race 4 pre-start incident?

by Mark Jardine 29 Sep 2024 09:50 PDT 29 September 2024
Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli vs. INEOS Britannia on Louis Vuitton Cup Final Race Day 3 - September 29, 2024 © Ricardo Pinto / America's Cup

Race 4 between Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli and INEOS Britannia in the Louis Vuitton Cup Final was full of drama, but one moment had had sailors asking questions on social media groups more than any other, and clearly riled Ben Ainslie and Dylan Fletcher on the British boat.

To British fans it looked like a clear windward-leeward situation. To Italian fans it looked like Luna Rossa was clear ahead. The reality lies elsewhere, and the key is in the Racing Rules of Sailing, and a particular Appendix C (Match Racing) rule that doesn't apply in the America's Cup.

Rule 13.2 'After the foot of the mainsail of a boat sailing downwind crosses the centreline she shall keep clear of other boats until her mainsail has filled or she is no longer sailing downwind.' has been removed for the America's Cup, and instead a boat just needs to be beyond the angle of the wind direction to have gybed, which meant that Luna Rossa had actually gybed far earlier than appears on screen, as we were all looking at the sails, not the angle of the boats to the wind, which isn't at all obvious on TV.

So, if the diamonds which surround the boats had intersected when INEOS Britannia protested, it may have been the British team penalised, or Italy, depending on whether Luna Rossa were judged to have given the Brits enough room to keep clear.

We, as everyday sailors, were looking at things from our own experience, and the rules we use. The America's Cup rules though are slightly different, which they need to be to accommodate racing these extraordinary machines.

When these kinds of situation arise, we'll try and make things clearer.

Rewatch the whole race in full: (the incident in question starts at 2 minutes in)

Mozzy's analysis of the call here:

Related Articles

Going to publish the 'F' word – Again!
Clearly, there are lots of young sailors out there looking to add a load of fun to their sailing Now we published the first one back in June last year. It did really well, thank you. Very much appreciated. Clearly, there are lots of young sailors out there looking to add a load of fun to their sailing, and are keen to get into the foiling world. Posted on 23 Mar
SailGP news, J/22 Midwinters, SP80 update
Rolex Los Angeles Sail Grand Prix, J/22 Midwinters, SP80's speed record attempt While 2025 hasn't been kind to the City of Angels, sailing fans turned out to celebrate the Rolex Los Angeles Sail Grand Prix event this past weekend, which saw 12 SailGP teams engaging in racecourse fisticuffs on the waters off the Port of Los Angeles. Posted on 18 Mar
Is it the science of silence?
A sensibility and inner peace that only real Zen can deliver. Yes. This is Silent Yachts. Distinctly more than just moments in love? You'd have to think so. A serene theme for life. A futuristic take on it all. New Romantic collides with Renaissance. Abstract meets impressionism. A sensibility and inner peace that only real Zen can deliver. Posted on 17 Mar
No more excuses
2025 is all about the club sailors, the weekend warriors, the open meeting stalwarts I was wondering if things were going to slow down in sailing after the huge events of 2024, namely the Olympics, America's Cup and Vendée Globe but, if anything, they've speeded up. Posted on 17 Mar
The oldest video footage of sailing in Ireland
A look back into our video archive, from 1926 to 1980 As we prepare for St Patrick's Day tomorrow, let us direct our exploration of the video archive towards anything Irish. We have discovered several videos from Ireland, starting as early as the 1920s! Posted on 16 Mar
A windy Possession Point Race
Some thoughts on the 2025 Possession Point Race Mea Culpa: I didn't take any pictures on Saturday's Possession Point Race. That's because both of my hands were either busy either dealing with foredeck duties or holding on tight to the lifelines of Jonathan and Libby McKee's Riptide 44, Dark Star. Posted on 11 Mar
Two boats. Same Direction.
You know the deal… It means there's a race on. You know the deal… It means there's a race on. So, the second South Pacific Superyacht Rendezvous is set for August 26 to 29, 2025. If it is even half as much fun and interesting as the first one, then it will bolster its burgeoning reputation. Posted on 9 Mar
The 600 Sweet Spot
The world of offshore racing is booming around the world The world of offshore racing is booming around the world. Record entries, some of the world's fastest yachts and highest profile campaigns, and a plethora of Corinthian teams have the 'classics' on their bucket list. Posted on 4 Mar
Foggy sailing on Puget Sound
East Coast fog and West Coast whales The biennial Marblehead to Halifax Race, which celebrates its 40th edition this summer, is a 361 nautical mile race that's often characterized by light upwind sailing in fog. Last Saturday on Puget Sound felt like a return to these storied waters. Posted on 4 Mar
Inaugural Fast Women's Switch Training Camp
Some of the best sailors in the world gathered in Thailand The first ever Fast Women's Switch Training Camp took place at the Royal Varuna Yacht Club in Thailand, attracting some of the best sailors in the world, fresh from competing in the Australia Sail Grand Prix. Posted on 4 Mar
Hyde Sails 2024 - One DesignMaritimo 2023 M600 FOOTERLloyd Stevenson - Catalyst GT 1456x180px BOTTOM