America's Cup: RNZYS Committee calls for reality check on NZ based AC37 Match
by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com 22 Nov 2021 15:35 AEDT
22 November 2021
The America's Cup on display in the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron, flanked by the two Challenger trophies won by Emirates Team New Zealand in the 2013 and 2017 America's Cup regattas © Richard Gladwell / Sail-World.com
The Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron General Committee have set Thursday December 9, as the date for the Special General Meeting to consider a motion to hold the 37th America's Cup, and all others defended by the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron's America's Cup team.
However a second motion has been submitted by the General Committee (labelled "Alternative Two"), is diluted version of the first.
The General Committee says "it does not believe that it would be helpful that either motion is passed".
In a blunt statement to the membership the outgoing General Committee says: "There needs to be a reality check in respect to a New Zealand based AC37 Match. ETNZ needs to secure funding, with local and central Government support, to hold this event in Auckland.
"Unless this happens, we need to consider offshore venues. The consequences of not doing so are potentially dire – no cup defence at all, and giving the America’s Cup back having been unable to stage a defence and meet our obligations under the Deed of Gift.
"This means the loss of the America’s Cup, the loss of our Team New Zealand, and the potential loss of future America’s Cup challenges from the RNZYS, and most likely New Zealand.
"So, while we understand and support the sentiment of the petition and their desire to “have the event in New Zealand”, the answer is not that simple."
The Special General Meeting will be held after the Squadron's Annual General Meeting set for December 9, 2021 at 6.00pm (NZDT)
Both meetings will be held under New Zealand's "Traffic Light" system of segregation using COVID-19 vaccination certificates. Under the so-called Protection Framework, the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron's clubrooms will be a red-light zone, with gatherings restricted to 100 people, all of who must show vaccination certificates to enter. Once in the club rooms they must observe social distancing and be 1 metre apart. Royal NZ Yacht Squadron has 3,500 members.
The motion put by the group of members (minimum of 25) who requisitioned the Special General Meeting reads: "The members of the Squadron deem it necessary and expedient under both the terms of the Deed of Gift and for the welfare and development of the Squadron under rule 1.2 (objects) that the America’s Cup shall always be defended in the waters adjacent to the City of Auckland."
The second motion proposed by the outgoing General Committee, which believe the first motion would be "ineffective" under RNZYS Rules reads: "The members of the Squadron confirm that the purposes of the Squadron include holding America’s Cup regattas in Auckland and that it is their desire that they are held in Auckland."
Emirates Team New Zealand and the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron's Flag Officers and General Committee have made it very clear in the past that the selection of an America's Cup Defence venue is one for the team to take, in order to undertake a successful Defence.
The two Motions with comments are:
Alternative One:
"The members of the Squadron deem it necessary and expedient under both the terms of the Deed of Gift and for
the welfare and development of the Squadron under rule 1.2 (objects) that the America’s Cup shall always be
defended in the waters adjacent to the City of Auckland."
Explanation provided by the proposers of the motion (Alternative One):
Funds for a local defence for the America’s Cup are now available.
Given:
- It is in the best interest of “friendly competition between foreign countries” for the America’s
Cup;
- The Deed of Gift makes clear the America’s Cup is a yacht club trophy;
- The overwhelming history and tradition of the America’s Cup is for defences to be held in a
defender’s home waters;
- Longstanding support and investment in the America’s Cup by members of the Squadron since
1984;
- The very significant investment and support made by City of Auckland ratepayers in the America’s
Cup;
- The investment and support of New Zealand taxpayers in the America’s Cup;
- The longstanding and repeated promise that success in the America’s Cup would result in defences
being held in New Zealand; and
- A need to return the past support of the people of the City of Auckland and of New Zealand, after
they have suffered and will continue to suffer a trying and difficult economic recovery period
resulting from a global pandemic.
The venue for the defences of the America’s Cup should be on the waters of the ‘City of Sails’, in Auckland,
New Zealand, upon which the Squadron conducts its regattas.
Alternative Two:
The General Committee are of the view that the motion Alternative One, if passed, would be an ineffective motion under the rules of the RNZYS. In our view, the following motion (Alternative Two) would be effective:
The members of the Squadron confirm that the purposes of the Squadron include holding America’s Cup regattas in
Auckland and that it is their desire that they are held in Auckland.
RNZYS [General Committee's] reasons for opposing the motion:
We have taken care to clarify with members the respective roles and obligations of RNZYS and ETNZ based on our contractual and working relationship of over 25 years.
ETNZ has responsibility for conducting the 37th America’s Cup defence, with all aspects of AC37 organisation, management, and fundraising, resting with them. In return, the Club is not required to make any financial contribution to AC37 activities, and RNZYS are fully indemnified from any liability, financial or otherwise. It is through these arrangements that we are in the privileged position of Trustee of the Cup for a fourth America’s Cup cycle.
We have said all along that it is RNZYS’s preference for AC37 to be held in New Zealand, however it needs to be viable to do so. What we and ETNZ have allowed ourselves is time to do everything possible for this to happen. It is very important to us that ETNZ remains viable, that we keep the Team together, and we honour our commitments and undertakings with our Challenger of Record, RYS and INEOS Britannia.
Over the last few months ETNZ have kept RNZYS up to date daily with developments, and RNZYS has acted when necessary as Trustee. A Trustee according to Hamish Ross “cannot at law make a
determination for the future before that determination is required to be made”.
There needs to be a reality check in respect to a New Zealand based AC37 Match. ETNZ needs to secure funding, with local and central Government support, to hold this event in Auckland. Unless this happens, we need to consider offshore venues. The consequences of not doing so are potentially dire – no cup defence at all, and giving the America’s Cup back having been unable to stage a defence and meet our obligations under the Deed of Gift. This means the loss of the America’s Cup, the loss of our Team New Zealand, and the potential loss of future America’s Cup challenges from the RNZYS, and most likely New Zealand.
So, while we understand and support the sentiment of the petition and their desire to “have the event in New Zealand”, the answer is not that simple.
The General Committee have been active, not only around America’s Cup matters, but in ensuring the club remains viable and prosperous for future years. This in itself will not be a small feat given the significant financial and operational impact of lockdown, with Club doors closed for four months. The General Committee meets monthly and considers significant matters to ensure the Club is run prudently, within its means, and fulfils its constitutional, contractual and membership obligations.
Legal threats and misinformation do not help leadership at RNZYS (or ETNZ) work towards what we are all here for – “the encouragement of Corinthian yachting generally and such other purposes connected with aquatics….”.
To encourage Corinthian yachting, the club should be striving to (again) win the oldest trophy in international sport. The General Committee will continue to work on behalf of members, to do just that.