Please select your home edition
Barton Marine 2019 728x90

Supreme confidence or a big mistake? It's a fine line…

by Mark Jardine 11 Mar 2021 21:27 PST 10-17 March 2021
America's Cup match day 2 - Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli lee-bow tack ahead of Emirates Team New Zealand to take control of race 3 © ACE / Studio Borlenghi

If the momentum wasn't already with Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli after their race win to level the score after day one, it certainly is after race three, but things could have been very different.

After a very even start with Emirates Team New Zealand to leeward, the Italians took control with a lee-bow tack near the left boundary to squeeze the Kiwis into a high mode that they clearly weren't comfortable with on their small foils in the lighter winds. Being stuck in dirty air in any boat is bad, but the AC75 is exponential in many ways, including the size and distance of the wind shadow created.

What could have been the key moment of the race was when the Italian team decided not to tack and cover the home team midway up the first upwind leg. The slightest puff or shift in these light conditions could have turned a lead into a deficit, but both Francesco Bruni and Jimmy Spithill had confidence in their call, reducing the number of tacks needed to round the windward mark, and they were away.

With the narrow course, confined by the side boundaries, passing lanes are few and Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli stretched their lead to take a comfortable 37 second win.

Francesco Bruni summed it up beautifully when he said, "I think we just sailed a clean race... We took the opportunity for a little stretch at the top mark... From being strong to being weak is the split of a second."

Despite Emirates Team New Zealand being faster both upwind and downwind they sailed nearly 1.5km further during the race. Part of this will have been due to sailing in dirty air, and it's never easy to take the right shifts when you're the boat behind, but it did feel like Luna Rossa has a better 'high mode' upwind, sailing closer to the wind, especially in the light stuff.

The question of who has the faster boat certainly hasn't been answered yet and as Peter Burling said after race three: "It's going to be won by whoever sails the best".

The wind was becoming increasingly patchy for race four and Emirates Team New Zealand briefly fell off the foils in the pre-start jostling. Jimmy Spithill on Luna Rossa contemplated going for the hook, rounding behind the Kiwis and luffing, but decided against it and it was proved to be the right with the New Zealand boat lifting straight back up a moment later. Burling and Ashby stuck to their guns with the leeward position on the line, but this time were much closer, forcing the Italians to tack off.

With clear air Emirates Team New Zealand took control of the race, winning by over a minute to level up the score at 2-2.

It's been another day of steep learning for us as viewers and the teams themselves. Today reminded us of some key match racing facts, with the biggest being that you must win the start. The much-hyped boatspeed differences simply aren't there and Peter Burling was spot on with his comment that this America's Cup is going to be won by whoever sails the best.

In any sport momentum is a powerful thing, and the pendulum has just swung back to Emirates Team New Zealand.

Related Articles

Just a second
Hull 1 of the Farr X2 has lost its keel offshore - the remains have washed up Hull #1 of the Farr X2 has lost its keel offshore, and the remains have washed up on a beach on the South Coast of NSW. Mercifully, the two sailors on board are alive, and subsequently had a wee sojourn in hospital to ensure all is well. Posted on 3 Jul
14s Forever
Nothing lasts forever.... unless you're an International 14 The International 14 would bring the giants of 'between the wars' dinghy design, Morgan-Giles, Thornycroft and Fox, to the fore whilst at the same time laying the foundations of sailing competition on the international stage. Posted on 1 Jul
Understanding safety onboard
With Ocean Safety Ambassador Dee Caffari MBE and Ocean Safety MD Alistair Hackett's Mark Jardine talks to Ocean Safety Ambassador Dee Caffari MBE and Ocean Safety MD Alistair Hackett to get a better understanding of the safety features needed onboard yachts. Posted on 29 Jun
The utterly brilliant Foiling SuMoth Challenge
Promoting sustainable practices by challenging young naval architecture and engineering students The Foiling SuMoth Challenge is a competition inspired by the need of a more sustainable and efficient sailboat designs and manufacturing methods. Posted on 28 Jun
What do you get...
...when you cross The Jacksons, Milli Vanilli, and Engelbert Humperdinck? An unreal Centre Console! What do you get when you cross The Jacksons, Milli Vanilli, and Engelbert Humperdinck all together? Honestly, I have no idea, and it could get amazingly weird, but I do know we have the 60s, 70s, 80s, and 90s all covered in that lot. Posted on 23 Jun
A Fine Line
Dinghy historian Dougal Henshall looks at race officers and start lines As the world around us reblooms after the constraints of lockdown, there is plenty of food for thought surrounding the debate as to something of a reset for dinghy racing. Older sailors talk in nostalgic terms of the delights of the 'golden era'. Posted on 22 Jun
R2AK, Newport Bermuda Race, Mac Solo Challenges
R2AK update, Newport Bermuda Race, Mac Solo Challenges The past week has been a big one for North American sailing, with the start of the Race to Alaska, the Newport Bermuda Race, and the Great Lakes Singlehanded Society's Mac Solo Challenges. Posted on 20 Jun
Not just another...
…case of miscellaneous ramblings. You might say that, but you could well have missed the point. …case of miscellaneous ramblings. I mean, yes, you might say that, but you could well have missed the point right there. Posted on 20 Jun
Vortex Pod Racer: fly me to the moon
Or: how the Asia Editor went foiling! “I want to go foiling, so I'm designing a gentleman's foiler..." and he drew it on the back of a fag packet (actually, it was a napkin). Posted on 17 Jun
France SailGP's sustainability and diversity work
Bruno Dubois on the France SailGP Team's sustainability and diversity efforts I checked in with Bruno Dubois, team manager of the France SailGP Team, via email, to learn more about their Season 3 sustainability and diversity efforts. Posted on 15 Jun
Vaikobi 2021 Boots - FOOTERLloyd Stevenson Catalyst 45 728x90px3 BOTTOMMarine Resources 2022 - FOOTER