Please select your home edition
Edition
Cyclops Marine 2023 November - LEADERBOARD

America's Cup: America's Cup Class Rule agreed to be a legitimate event cost

by Richard Gladwell Sail-World NZ 22 Dec 2020 14:45 AEDT 22 December 2020
Emirates Team New Zealand's base in Auckland's Viaduct Harbour © Richard Gladwell

The long standing and at time bitter public wrangle over the AC75 class rule cost has been resolved, and America's Cup Event Ltd and its CEO and Directors, Grant Dalton, Tina Symmans and Greg Horton have been exonerated.

A media release issued Tuesday afternoon confirms the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Economic Development (MBIE), Emirates Team New Zealand (ETNZ) and America's Cup Event Ltd (ACE) have met today in a mediation setting to resolve issues regarding whether the creation of the Class Rule for the America’s Cup was an Event Cost under the Host Venue Agreement.

We regret the manner in which this issue has played out in the public arena and the detrimental reputational impact of the process on ETNZ and ACE, its directors and the teams.

The parties have all agreed that there was reasonable basis for the differing views held to date. The contractual dispute arose during the course of an independent audit initiated by MBIE as a result of allegations of financial impropriety and misappropriation of funds, which were subsequently investigated and found to be wrong.

In the course of the mediation regarding the dispute, ETNZ and ACE have provided MBIE with information and independent advice that supports their view. MBIE, ETNZ and ACE have now agreed that there was a reasonable and legitimate basis for ETNZ and ACE to consider that the Class Rule costs were within the scope of Event Costs in the Host Venue Agreement. MBIE accepts that expenditure incurred to date under the HVA has been incurred in good faith.

MBIE is satisfied that event investment in relation to the Crown’s contribution has been or will be properly incurred by ACE.

In light of the above, the dispute has now been resolved.

We look forward to a successful America’s Cup, the statement said in conclusion.

Legal action taken by ETNZ and ACE in regard to actions, comments and allegations made by various parties, in regard to the matter are confirmed to be continuing.

On November 11, 2020 the Directors of ETNZ and ACE released several documents and letters several documents and letters into the public domain accompanied by a statement.

"In the face of further defamatory and baseless allegations again being levelled at ETNZ/ACE and its Directors we feel that we must now set the record straight having tried to respect a due process in this saga all year.

"We have wanted to avoid such a public condemnation of MBIE but given their moves to conceal their totally inappropriate behaviour through this protracted contractual process, we now feel obliged to release a suite of letters addressed to MBIE and Ministers which call MBIE to account for their actions.

"These letters paint quite a different story than that currently being presented.

"As we state in these letters we would welcome the intervention of the Ombudsman or Public Services Commission to look at MBIE’s actions through this protracted process."

Emirates Team NZ and ACE were exonerated by an MBIE commissioned audit. ETNZ and ACE were also successful in obtaining firstly an ex parte Injunction preventing the publication of leaked and confidential content by news media. The Injunction was later confirmed after a High Court Hearing. The Audit Report was released publicly with redactions as to competitive and confidential information.

The audit conducted by specialist forensic accounting firm Beattie Varley, whose principals are all former Serious Fraud Office employees with 10-15 years experience in that role, said in its summary conclusion. "We have not seen any evidence that ACE/ETNZ misapplied the Event [NZ40million] Investment."

The matter of the charging of $3million as part of the AC75 Class Rule development by ETNZ to ACE and against the Hosting Fee, was a dispute that should have been resolved by mediation as prescribed by the Host Venue Agreement, rather than being acted out in public.

The terms of the mediation was believed to have been extended to include MBIE's role in the affair, however the statement is not explicit in that regard.

Related Articles

America's Cup entries open on Sunday
A Cup in turmoil - has Grant Dalton dodged a bullet with the new Cup organisation? America's Cup gets underway in Rome with Round 2 of the official welcoming ceremonies on Wednesday in Naples. Emirates Team NZ CEO Grant Dalton apprears to have dodged a bullet with the formation of of new AC organising body. Posted on 26 May
Italian PM welcomes America's Cup in Rome
Prime Minister Meloni set out a bold vision for the regeneration planned around AC38 The magnificent setting of the Casino del Bel Respiro, commissioned by Pope Innocent X in 1644, in the grounds of Villa Pamphilj, was the outstanding and historic setting for the formal presentation of the Louis Vuitton 38th America's Cup. Posted on 26 May
America's Cup: Big changes in crew line-up
Women and Youth crews to sail in AC75 in the next Cup - Final Draft of AC38 Protocol Historic changes are proposed in the Final Draft of the Protocol released by the America's Cup Defender. For the first time a Female and Youth crew members will be part of the six-crew lineup on board the all-electric AC75s. Posted on 23 May
America's Cup: The Blitz of Statements
Various parties associated with the America's Cup released statements calling for more transparency Various parties associated with the America's Cup released statements calling for more transparency in the America's Cup. Emirates Team New Zealand responded by releasing what is tagged as the Final Draft of the Protocol. Posted on 23 May
America's Cup: Emirates Team NZ respond
Emirates Team New Zealand has responded to the statements sent overnight (NZT) Emirates Team New Zealand has responded to the statements sent overnight by two Challenger teams calling for more transparency in the negotiations over the Protocol and venue for the 38th Match. Posted on 22 May
NYYC American Magic team statement
Concerns over transparency and cooperation necessary to secure a fair Protocol Over the past seven years, we've competed with pride, purpose, and perseverance in two editions of the America's Cup. It has been an honor to represent the New York Yacht Club and the United States on the global stage. Posted on 22 May
Athena Racing concerned over 38th AC transparency
Around the recent announcement of a Host City for the Cup in 2027 Athena Racing, representing Royal Yacht Squadron Ltd. as Challenger of Record for the 38th America's Cup, is concerned by the ongoing lack of transparency around the recent announcement of a Host City for the Cup in 2027. Posted on 22 May
America's Cup: Part 2 - No Excuse to Lose
The last race of the (63+254i) America's Cup has begun where tension deepens and strategy sharpens The last race of the (63+254i)th America's Cup has begun. Earth's syndicate, led by the New York Yacht Club, faces off against the Thalassocratic League of Deniau in a final match — winner takes all. Posted on 18 May
Dalton claims Alinghi are still recruiting
Emirates Team NZ CEO claims the Swiss America's Cup team Alinghi are still actively recruiting. In the course of a TV interview following the announcement of the venue for the 38th America's Cup, Emirates Team New Zealand CEO claimed that the Swiss America's Cup team Alinghi, were still actively recruiting, despite being in an "orderly wind-down". Posted on 17 May
Naples to host 2027 America's Cup
The fight for the Auld Mug will take place under the watchful shadow of Mt Vesuvius The Government of Italy, in conjunction with Team New Zealand and the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron, are pleased to announce Italy as the Host Country and Naples as the Host City for the Louis Vuitton 38th America's Cup to be held in 2027. Posted on 15 May
Switch One DesignBoat Books Australia FOOTERNavico AUS Zeus3S FOOTER