Please select your home edition
Edition
Sea Sure 2020 - SHOCK-WBV - LEADERBOARD

America's Cup: Two team designers analyse AC75 hull shapes - Tip & Shaft

by Tip & Shaft 30 Nov 2020 23:36 PST 1 December 2020
Forming an end plate between the rig and water surface - INEOS Team UK - Waitemata Harbour - November 2020, - 36th America's Cup © Richard Gladwell / Sail-World.com

On Thursday 19th November Emirates Team New Zealand were the last team to launch their second AC75, the boat on which the Kiwis will defend the 36th America's Cup over the period March 6 to 21, 2021. Three weeks before the start of the America's Cup World Series in Auckland, Tip & Shaft interviewed Martin Fischer Martin Fischer co-design coordinator at Luna Rossa Challenge, and Benjamin Muyl chief designer for the INEOS Team UK challengers, to understand design differences between the new, second boats of the four teams.

Did you have enough time to learn much from the first AC75s to carry forwards to the design of the second boats which were launched about a year later?

Martin Fischer: Between the launch of the first boat and the freezing of the design of the second, we actually had have very little time. So we saw some things, but we didn't really get a lot of experience out of it. On the other hand we learned a lot about the build, the experience of the first boat allowed us to see where we could gain or add weight. In terms of the shape of the hull, we stayed quite close, because we were convinced this is the way to go. And I think that we were right, because the Americans and the English have followed.

Benjamin Muyl: Our second boat is very different from the first so obviously our choices were not the same. What we can say is that after seeing all the first boats, with on one side the challenger of record and the defender, and on the other American Magic and we have revised our ideas, at least in terms of the hull adding what is being called a bustle under the hull.

These were already seen on the first AC75s of Luna Rossa and of Team New Zealand, what is the bustle for?

M.F.: First of all, it is used for take-off itself: we realized that when we started to take off quite quickly at a certain boatspeed, say 10-12 knots, because the foil is already lifting but after that its was getting difficult. We therefore designed this catamaran type hull so that once the boat has reached this fairly critical speed, it compensates for the deficit between the lift of the foil and the weight of the boat. The aim is to have the behaviour of a multihull, that is to say to accelerate more easily. And it is important for touchdown phases (see below).

What differences do you see between the hulls shapes of the different AC75s?

B.M: We can see that there are two families: Luna Rossa, Team New Zealand and us on the one hand, who went narrow and American Magic on the other hand which has a very V-shaped hull at the front with a lot of volume. Now they have removed some from the back to be able, on take-off, to turn the hull with the bow in the air by putting angle in their foils. We, on the other hand, we take off almost flat, a little down on the nose itself, to clear the back of the hull.

M.F: There are also differences in the volume of the bustle. The Americans seem to have very little volume, the English some more, while we and New Zealanders are somewhere in the middle. There where Team New Zealand is a little different, is that, much like the Brits, they completely separated this 'thin hull' from the rest of the boat, we really see a break between the two, as if it has been stuck underneath. We did it in a less extreme way. They have also tried to increase the freeboard of theirs so that it really needs to sink deep into the water before the rest of the boat really touches the water, especially at the front.

"The lower you fly, the quicker you are" What are the advantages and drawbacks of having a greater or smaller volume in the bustle?

M.F.: If you have a greater volume, it takes less lift from the foil to take off, while with less volume, the acceleration phase at low speed is a bit harder. But the advantage with less volume is that when you touch the water in a touchdown, you are close to the extra wetted surface, so you can afford to touch down more and take more risks flying lower. The lower you fly, the quicker you are. Ideally, the hull is practically touching the water.

B.M.: The other things at stake with the bustle are linked to aerodynamics. The aim is to close the hull under the boat to act like a plate and limit the air circulation. We did it with a square shape, very vertical sides offering more volume than the others. Luna Rossa adopted a much rounder shape. The choices depend on how you see taking off and touching down. It's not completely objective, and you need to imagine things.

M.F.: It is all a matter of compromise: you work out how much a gap of one centimetre more between the hull and the water costs and then the opposite, how much one centimetre less will increase the likelihood of touching a wave. Based on that, you decide the measurements of the bustle.

The plate effect seems to have played a role too in the choice concerning the deck?

M.F.: Yes and here too, we can see differences: the Brits and Americans have a boom that you can see well above the deck, while our mainsail goes right down to the deck [like the Kiwis, editor's note]. There is a structure underneath to take the strain. It's no longer really a boom. I can't give you all the details about what it is exactly. It means we can create a hollow shape at the bottom of the mainsail and increase the plate effect. I think we have an advantage with that, because with a boom, you can't develop that hollow effect at the bottom.

For the rest of this story click here

Related Articles

Prada Cup: Day 4: Course C - Sudden death
For Day 4 of the Prada Cup, racing will revert to the expanded Course C area. For Day 4 of the Prada Cup, racing will revert to the expanded Course C area. Today one race in Round Robin 3 will be sailed. Posted on 22 Jan
Prada Cup: Capsize triggers changes to Cup
Regatta Director Iain Murray has made several changes to the conduct of the Prada and America's Cups Regatta Director Iain Murray has made several changes to the conduct of the Prada and America's Cups, following a review with all involved parties including the competitors. Posted on 21 Jan
America's Cup Rialto: Jan 17 - Saving of Patriot
Here's our perspective from on the water with exclusive images of the near sinking No two days are ever the same in the America's Cup. The final race of Round Robin 2 was no exception. Here's on the water impression, with exclusive images of a day that brought out the best in the America's Cup teams to save a fellow competitor's boat. Posted on 20 Jan
Prada Cup: Hutchinson confirms raceboat rebuild
American Magic confirmed that the team will remain in the Prada Cup American Magic Executive Director Terry Hutchinson has confirmed that the team will remain in the Prada Cup, after nearly sinking their raceboat Patriot yesterday evening in Auckland. Posted on 18 Jan
Prada Cup: Day 3: Course A - off Barker's place
For Day 3 of the Prada Cup, racing will shift to a new course area off Milford Beach For Day 3 of the Prada Cup, racing will shift to a new course area, in an unusual response to the predicted wind. For the first time in the Prada Cup, Course A off Auckland's East Coast Bays, and North Shore suburbs, will be used. Posted on 16 Jan
America's Cup Rialto: Jan 16 - A day of surprises
Day 2 of the Qualifiers for the Challenger Selection Series, in the 36th America's Cup had as many s Day 2 of the Qualifiers for the Challenger Selection Series, in the 36th America's Cup had as many surprises as the first day of the event. Posted on 16 Jan
Prada Cup: INEOS Team UK scores a hat-trick
Day 2 of the Prada Cup continued to turn the challenger form book inside out. Day 2 of the Prada Cup continued to turn the challenger form book inside out. American Magic from the New York Yacht Club, was widely expected to emerge as top challenger from the Round Robin phase of the Challenger Selection Series. Posted on 16 Jan
Prada Cup: Day 2: Course C - D options
Regatta Director Iain Murray has advised that racing will be held on either Course C of D race areas Regatta Director Iain Murray has advised that racing will be held on either Course C of D race areas today. The breeze is expected to come in later than the 3.12pm start schedule and will be from an average of 230 degrees - or SSW. Posted on 15 Jan
America's Cup Rialto: Jan 15 - Arise, Sir Ben
INEOS Team UK today surprised everyone, perhaps including themselves, with two wins from two races INEOS Team UK today surprised everyone, perhaps including themselves, with two wins from two races on the opening day of the Prada Cup in Auckland. Even more telling the British extended their margin on 11 of the 12 legs sailed. Posted on 15 Jan
Prada Cup Day 1 belongs to British
Team INEOS UK put their stamp on the Prada Cup with two wins on Day 1. Team INEOS UK put their stamp on the Prada Cup with two wins on Day 1. Here's the action as it happened: Shining sun and southerly sea breeze is the theme for Day 1 of the 2021 Prada Cup as the three challengers line up for the first official racing. Posted on 15 Jan
Doyle Sails 2020 - Pure Brilliance 728x90 BOTTOMETNZShop-SAILRACING-728X90 HR BottomOfficial-Collection-Navy 728x90 BOTTOM