Please select your home edition
Edition
Upffront 2020 Foredeck Club SW LEADERBOARD

Sailboat Composite Standing Rigging - Material Options

by Phil Anniss 5 Nov 2020 01:00 PST
Composite rigging benefits © Future Fibres

Having established the significant advantages of reducing rigging weight, next we would like to look at the composite rigging options available on the market. However, before we get to that point, we need to take a little diversion into basic material properties to provide some background context.

Physical material properties are a technical subject and numbers vary considerably depending on manufacturer, test procedures and samples used. The table below represents a correlation of data across multiple sources and reflects the relative characteristics of a range of different materials. N.B. These are theoretical numbers for the material itself and finished products (cables, rods, wires) will have their own unique properties which will generally be lower than theoretical.

FibreYoungs Modulus (GPa)Density (kg/m3)Strength (Mpa)Elongation at Break (%)Source
T800 Carbon294180058802Toray T800
PBO275156055002.5Toyobo Zylon Datasheet
N50 Steel193780069035Matweb
316 Stainless193800058060Matweb
Dyneema SK991309804100100DSM Dyneema Datasheet
Dyneema SK751169803300100DSM Dyneema Datasheet
Aramid K49112144030002.4Matweb
Hemp321490300 Matweb
Polyester131390784 Matweb
Cotton81540225 Matweb
Nylon41140616 Matweb

Terminology

  • Youngs Modulus - this is a measure of the stiffness of the material. The bigger the GPa number - the stiffer the material.
  • Density - provides an indication of relative weight for the given strength/stiffness
  • Ultimate Strength - is the amount of load to failure
  • Elongation at Break - this is the % increase in length to failure point (of a lab sample)

Discussion

Nylon/Cotton/Polyester/Hemp are shown for interest. Hemp and Cotton were traditional sailing ship materials for standing rigging and sailcloth and show just how far things have moved forward.

Steel wire replaced Hemp standing rigging from the mid 1800s and is still the default material for boats sailing around today. Wire is 6x stiffer than Hemp and double the strength, but this does come at a significant weight penalty. Durability, reliability, ease of use and mass production techniques led to wire's domination. However, in pure strength-weight terms, Hemp was not a bad material!

The performance metallic standing rigging option is Nitronic 50 rod. Nitronic is a nitrogen-strengthened steel alloy and was developed in the 1960s. The basic material properties are stronger and lighter than stainless wire plus the fact that it is a solid rod, rather than a twisted wire, leads to a significant diameter reduction for equivalent stiffness, which reduces windage.

The synthetic rigging revolution started quite slowly with the introduction of Aramid fibres in the early 1980s. A Kevlar 49 cable, built to the same stiffness, would be approx. 70% lighter and 7x stronger than Nitronic 50. The other major development was the extremely low elongation at break (2,4%) which means that the fibre will sit under high load and not deform / lengthen until it breaks. This is very important for standing rigging in terms of maintaining rig tune. The one downside with Kevlar is that it takes a lot of fibre to achieve the same stiffness, which adds significant diameter compared to rod.

PBO (Zylon) arrived on the sailing scene in the early 1990s with carbon rigging products coming in the early 2000s. These two materials have very similar properties and are approx. 45% stiffer, 80% lighter and 8 times stronger than Nitronic rod. There are challenges in manufacturing these materials into standing rigging cables but, for a stiffness equivalent cable, they are comparable in diameter to wire/rod, whilst providing major weight and strength gains.

For the last 20 years therefore, Carbon, PBO and Kevlar have established themselves as options for lightweight, high strength standing rigging cables. Whilst it is possible to build lateral rigging from Kevlar, it is relatively uncommon due to its diameter. For example, a Nitronic Dash 17 rod has a diameter of 8,4mm - in PBO the stretch equivalent cable would be approx. 9,5mm but Kevlar would be more like 14mm. Kevlar is mainly limited to backstays on larger yachts where it can still deliver a 70% weight saving over wire/rod.

Dyneema®, which is a household brand name for an Ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene (UHMWPE), was developed around the same time as Aramid fibre. It is a bit stiffer than Kevlar (depending on the type), similar in strength but extremely light. However, UHMWPE has not been widely used in standing rigging, to date, due to one weakness - it creeps. At 30 degrees under constant load (10% of break load) it physically grows (SK75 - 0,02%/day, SK78 - 0,006%). On a 15m cable that equates to approx. 8% / 1.1m in 365 days for SK75, and 2.2% / 330mm for SK78.

Having said that - Dyneema is a cost effective and incredibly reliable / durable fibre and, on smaller boats (under 45ft), there is a growing community of sailors who are adapting and finding ways to manage these challenges. This can be done by using long lashings for terminations, so that creep can be taken up, and also by over-building the cable, which reduces the rate of creep. On larger boats it becomes physically impossible / impractical to develop the required rig tension using a lashing.

Summary

For performance sailors and larger yachts - PBO and Carbon are the primary material choices available for standing rigging. For sportsboats and smaller yachts these materials/products can become cost prohibitive and there is an increasing trend towards DIY Dyneema® rigging solutions.

If you would like to explore the options for a retrofit to composite rigging on your boat, please use the Composite Rigging enquiry form or contact us at

Related Articles

Ronstan SHOCK Blocks
Simple efficient low friction rings The name of the Ronstan SHOCK Block is derived from SHeaveless blOCK and reflects the growing trend for replacing ball bearing blocks, with "low friction rings", in a whole range of sailing system applications. Posted on 22 Jan
Ronstan Cam Cleats
Lighter, stronger and kinder to ropes Simple, reliable and extremely versatile, Cam Cleats are a staple on boats of all sizes, either as the primary rope holding solution on dinghies, or as part of a purchase system on larger boats and yachts. Posted on 15 Jan
Harken Small Boat Furler range
From 14ft dinghy to 30ft sportsboat there's a model for you Harken have a dedicated range of furlers for dinghies and keelboats up to 30ft (3mm, 5mm and 6mm diameter forestays). These are what upffront.com would term "structural furlers", in that they are an integral part of the main forestay. Posted on 1 Jan
Harken Radial versus Performa Winches
Phil Anniss from upffront.com talks about the differences Harken have an extensive range of winches which are split into two primary ranges: Radial and Performa. In this blog we help you understand the key differences between these ranges and guide you to the right choice for you and your boat's needs. Posted on 23 Dec 2020
New product launch - Karver V3 Furlers
A major redesign of the entire KF continuous line furler range Karver have just released details of a major redesign of their entire KF continuous line furler range. Almost 20 years of end user feedback and manufacturing experience have been brought together in this extensive upgrade. Posted on 18 Dec 2020
Improve your Race Starts
Velocitek V2 ProStart is the distillation of more than a decade of experience The new Velocitek V2 ProStart is the distillation of more than a decade of experience and customer feedback building stand-alone, GPS-based, distance-to-line starting aids. It's all about time and distance. Posted on 10 Dec 2020
How Long is my Furling Line?
Guide to estimating when you can't measure It's a simple question but if you are buying a new furler or need to organise a replacement furling line and do not have access to measure it....... how long should it be!? Posted on 3 Dec 2020
Continuous versus Discontinuous Standing Rigging
Looking at the differences, and pros/cons of both types Regardless of material choice (wire, rod or composite), there are two main types of lateral rigging configurations, referred to as Discontinuous or Continuous rigging. Posted on 26 Nov 2020
Celebrating curves with the LOOP Flexi Stick-on
These padeyes can stick to a curved surface, and take a lot of weight You would probably agree that there are very few flat surfaces on a sailing yacht, whereas most hardware bases are flat. Using modern materials and construction methods, the innovative LOOP Flexi Stick-on padeye offers some interesting possibilities. Posted on 19 Nov 2020
Straight Talking
Mast and standing rigging terminology from upffront.com Upffront.com is all about performance sailing hardware and rigging systems. The heart, and driving force, of any sailing yacht is its mast and standing rigging which support the sails. In this article we outline the key terminology. Posted on 12 Nov 2020
Upffront 2020 Foredeck Club SW FOOTER