Please select your home edition
Edition
RS Sailing 2021 - LEADERBOARD

America's Cup: Emirates Team NZ wins Arb Panel confidentiality complaint

by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz 9 Mar 2020 13:50 PDT 10 March 2020
Te Aihe in a higher flight mode - again the degree of immersion of the rudder wing foil can be deduced by comparing the 'Steinlager' writing with the water level and referencing that back to the launch photo at the top of this story © Richard Gladwell / Sail-World.com

Emirates Team New Zealand has been exonerated following a complaint that the Kiwi team had breached confidentiality restrictions surrounding the Match Conditions for the 36th America's Cup.

The complaint was lodged by the Challenger of Record, Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli after it became known that there was a dispute between the Italian team and the Defender Emirates Team New Zealand - who are the two parties who negotiate the rules and conditions for the America's Cup Regattas.

The final sticking point was over the negotiations of the Match Conditions and specifically the wind limits that would apply. The media were tipped off that there was an issue when it became plain that a deadline of December 20, 2019 would not be met for publication.

It emerged that the two parties could not agree on wind limits that should apply when the deadline was missed. Sail-World broke the story on December 22, carrying a quotation from Emirates Team New Zealand's long time and highly experienced rules adviser Russell Green.

It soon emerged that despite a requirement in the Protocol for the Challenger of Record (the first to lodge a Letter of Challenge required under the 19th century Deed of Gift which governs the conduct of the America's Cup) to "represent all Challengers" had not been met in its wider sense when the New York Yacht Club's American Magic stated in an interview with Associated Press that Luna Rossa had not consulted them as to their views on the wind limits that should apply.

That news surprised Emirates Team New Zealand who had apparently assumed that the other three Challengers would be consulted n this vital issue.

On January 9, 2020 (NZT) the New Zealanders issued a statement on their EmiratesTeamNZ.com website expressing the view "Under the AC 36 Protocol, the Challenger of Record has the responsibility to represent all Challengers and that responsibility involves consulting with other Challengers before taking a position with the Defender on issues such as race conditions."

That put the Challenger of Record in the same position of Artemis Racing in the 2013 America's Cup who frequently pushed their own views as a Challenger of Record and were opposed in Hearings by the majority of the Challengers - ETNZ and Luna Rossa. The Italians have been on the receiving end of some very unfair actions, and at times disgraceful actions, by the Challenger of Record, and it was surprising to hear they had acted without consultation.

The Italian response was to go to the Arbitration Panel complaining that ETNZ was in breach of the Protocol and the Rules of Procedure established by the Arbitration Panel, which is binding on all parties.

The Arb Panel noted that the provisions of the Racing Rules of Sailing (America's Cup version) are not relevant to the case as the Challenger of Record/Defender has not adopted them.

To the surprise of no-one, there is no "Dalton Clause" in the current Protocol. The clause, effectively a gagging order, was a feature of the last America's Cup Protocol and stopped teams expressing a view that was at variance with the dictates of the Defender or the Event. "The [curent] Protocol does not contain a general obligation of confidentiality," said the three-man Arbitration Panel in its Decision.

The Panel further noted that under its Rules of Procedure proceedings "will be transparent and not confidential between the Parties" unless a confidentiality order was explicitly made by the Panel "in exceptional circumstances". No such order was made before January 10.

According to the Decision issued by the Arbitration Panel, Luna Rossa also tried to claim that the "friendly competition between foreign countries" phrase in the Deed of Gift was a defacto confidentiality order. That view is quite a stretch given that the only two disputes that have gone before the New York Supreme Court have been decided within the "four corners of the Deed". If it were to be upheld, Luna Rossa's claim would have required NYSC to have determined the intent of the donor - which is an area that has not been necessary to support a previous ruling by the Court.

The Arbitration Panel found there were no grounds to uphold any aspect of the Complain, and it was summarily dismissed.

"Confidentiality did not apply until such time as the Sole Mediator issued its confidentiality order under Art. 7.2 of the RoP by way of its Directions 02 dated January 10 2020," the Arbitration Panel wrote in its Decision. "The media statements that the Applicant complained of in its Application (i.e. the 1st Stuff Article and the Media Statement) both occurred before such confidentiality order was made. As a consequence, the Respondent did not breach its obligations under the Deed of Gift, the Protocol, the RoP, The Mercury Bay decision or its fiduciary duties."

Submissions on costs were to be made by March 5, and a decision on the amount and liability for those has yet to be announced by the Arbitration Panel.

Related Articles

America's Cup: Luna Rossa's Challenge accepted
According to local media the Italian team, Luna Rossa has had its Challenge accepted by the Kiwis. Leading America's Cup journalist, Fabio Pozzo, reports that the Italian team, Luna Rossa has had its Challenge accepted for the 2027 Cup in Naples. Posted on 12 Sep
America's Cup: ETNZ's design boss on new AC75 Rule
Kiwi design chief, Dan Bernasconi on recycled AC75 hulls, electric power and other rule changes. Kiwi design chief, Dan Bernasconi on the use of recycled AC75 hulls, the switch to full electric power, and other changes. He claims there is plenty of performance gain left in the AC75 for the designer teams. Posted on 12 Sep
America's Cup: Class Rule and Tech Regs out
The America's Cup Class Rule and Technical Regulations for the Naples Match have been published With the clock ticking down to the start of the Louis Vuitton 38th America's Cup in Naples in 2027, the AC75 Class Rules and Technical Regulations have been issued to all teams and published with a focus on cost containment. Posted on 11 Sep
America's Cup: Running silent and deep, again.
A look at the flotsam that has surfaced as the Cup teams again go into deep and silent negotiation. A look at the state of the Cup - given the three weeks of silence since the hasty final Protocol signing. Previously a long deep dive by the teams has indicated that a lot of negotiation is underway. Here's what we've seen floating on the surface. Posted on 10 Sep
From The Other Side - The State of the Sport
The editors of Sail-World New Zealand and Inside Great Lakes Sailing discuss the state of sailing. The Editors of Inside Great Lakes Sailing and Sail-World New Zealand got together last week to shoot the breeze in an unscripted video discussion, without any pre-arranged "talking points" about various aspects of the sport. Posted on 5 Sep
Youth America's Cup set to continue in Naples
The Youth America's Cup is a sign-post to the future direction of the America's Cup itself. Since its inaugural event in 2013, the Youth America's Cup, designed as a competition for sailors under the age of 25, has always been the most remarkable sign-post to the future direction of the America's Cup itself. Posted on 4 Sep
America's Cup: Carlo's insights 1983-2024
Leading Italian lensman Carlo Borlenghi has been shooting the America's Cups for 41 years Carlo Borlenghi is the go-to photographer for many of the world's top sailing events and has covered every America's Cup since 1983 when he was assigned to the Azzurra team for Italy's first challenge. Posted on 30 Aug
America's Cup: A seismic shift for sailing
For the first time in its 174-year history, female sailors will be mandated onboard AC75s This week's announcement from the America's Cup felt momentous. For the first time in its 174-year history, female sailors will be mandated onboard AC75s at the pinnacle of our sport. Posted on 15 Aug
America's Cup: The Brave, New Protocol
The just announced Protocol for the America's Cup has many innovations and a few fish hooks The just announced Protocol for the America's Cup has many innovations, and maybe a few unintended consequences around the mandatory re-use of 2024 vintage AC75 hulls. Updated with a look at how the new Cup structure could work. Posted on 12 Aug
America's Cup: A "ground breaking" partnership
An innovative Protocol for the 2027 America's Cup has been agreed between RNZYS and RYS An innovative 11th hour Protocol for the 2027 America's Cup has been agreed between the Challenger of Record and the Defender. It creates a commercial framework for the current and future Cups, eases nationality rules, and has a quota for female sailors. Posted on 12 Aug
Rooster 2025North Sails Loft 57 PodcastC-Tech 2021 (Spars-QFX Racer) 728x90 BOTTOM