Please select your home edition
Savvy Navvy 2021 SW LEADERBOARD v2

America's Cup: Emirates Team NZ wins Arb Panel confidentiality complaint

by Richard Gladwell/ 9 Mar 2020 13:50 PDT 10 March 2020
Te Aihe in a higher flight mode - again the degree of immersion of the rudder wing foil can be deduced by comparing the 'Steinlager' writing with the water level and referencing that back to the launch photo at the top of this story © Richard Gladwell /

Emirates Team New Zealand has been exonerated following a complaint that the Kiwi team had breached confidentiality restrictions surrounding the Match Conditions for the 36th America's Cup.

The complaint was lodged by the Challenger of Record, Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli after it became known that there was a dispute between the Italian team and the Defender Emirates Team New Zealand - who are the two parties who negotiate the rules and conditions for the America's Cup Regattas.

The final sticking point was over the negotiations of the Match Conditions and specifically the wind limits that would apply. The media were tipped off that there was an issue when it became plain that a deadline of December 20, 2019 would not be met for publication.

It emerged that the two parties could not agree on wind limits that should apply when the deadline was missed. Sail-World broke the story on December 22, carrying a quotation from Emirates Team New Zealand's long time and highly experienced rules adviser Russell Green.

It soon emerged that despite a requirement in the Protocol for the Challenger of Record (the first to lodge a Letter of Challenge required under the 19th century Deed of Gift which governs the conduct of the America's Cup) to "represent all Challengers" had not been met in its wider sense when the New York Yacht Club's American Magic stated in an interview with Associated Press that Luna Rossa had not consulted them as to their views on the wind limits that should apply.

That news surprised Emirates Team New Zealand who had apparently assumed that the other three Challengers would be consulted n this vital issue.

On January 9, 2020 (NZT) the New Zealanders issued a statement on their website expressing the view "Under the AC 36 Protocol, the Challenger of Record has the responsibility to represent all Challengers and that responsibility involves consulting with other Challengers before taking a position with the Defender on issues such as race conditions."

That put the Challenger of Record in the same position of Artemis Racing in the 2013 America's Cup who frequently pushed their own views as a Challenger of Record and were opposed in Hearings by the majority of the Challengers - ETNZ and Luna Rossa. The Italians have been on the receiving end of some very unfair actions, and at times disgraceful actions, by the Challenger of Record, and it was surprising to hear they had acted without consultation.

The Italian response was to go to the Arbitration Panel complaining that ETNZ was in breach of the Protocol and the Rules of Procedure established by the Arbitration Panel, which is binding on all parties.

The Arb Panel noted that the provisions of the Racing Rules of Sailing (America's Cup version) are not relevant to the case as the Challenger of Record/Defender has not adopted them.

To the surprise of no-one, there is no "Dalton Clause" in the current Protocol. The clause, effectively a gagging order, was a feature of the last America's Cup Protocol and stopped teams expressing a view that was at variance with the dictates of the Defender or the Event. "The [curent] Protocol does not contain a general obligation of confidentiality," said the three-man Arbitration Panel in its Decision.

The Panel further noted that under its Rules of Procedure proceedings "will be transparent and not confidential between the Parties" unless a confidentiality order was explicitly made by the Panel "in exceptional circumstances". No such order was made before January 10.

According to the Decision issued by the Arbitration Panel, Luna Rossa also tried to claim that the "friendly competition between foreign countries" phrase in the Deed of Gift was a defacto confidentiality order. That view is quite a stretch given that the only two disputes that have gone before the New York Supreme Court have been decided within the "four corners of the Deed". If it were to be upheld, Luna Rossa's claim would have required NYSC to have determined the intent of the donor - which is an area that has not been necessary to support a previous ruling by the Court.

The Arbitration Panel found there were no grounds to uphold any aspect of the Complain, and it was summarily dismissed.

"Confidentiality did not apply until such time as the Sole Mediator issued its confidentiality order under Art. 7.2 of the RoP by way of its Directions 02 dated January 10 2020," the Arbitration Panel wrote in its Decision. "The media statements that the Applicant complained of in its Application (i.e. the 1st Stuff Article and the Media Statement) both occurred before such confidentiality order was made. As a consequence, the Respondent did not breach its obligations under the Deed of Gift, the Protocol, the RoP, The Mercury Bay decision or its fiduciary duties."

Submissions on costs were to be made by March 5, and a decision on the amount and liability for those has yet to be announced by the Arbitration Panel.

Related Articles

America's Cup: Defender rebuffs NYYC overtures
The America's Cup Defenders and Challenger of Record have rebuffed NYYC's Challenge Unsurprisingly, the America's Cup Defenders, along with the Challenger of Record, have rebuffed the surprise Challenge lodged by the New York Yacht Club, on May 6, and announced earlier today. Posted on 9 May
Gladwell's Line: Pressing ignition on pro-sailing
The sail racing world is spluttering back into life after over 12 months of being hostage by COVID The sail racing world is spluttering back into life after over 12 months of being hostage to the COVID pandemic - here's a look at how SailGP and the America's Cup coped, plus the 2024 Olympic event quandary. Posted on 6 May
American Magic ready to sail with 7-8 days notice
American Magic's Terry Hutchinson says they are all ready to go sailing at 7-8 days notice American Magic's Terry Hutchinson says the AC36 Challenger are all packed and ready to go sailing at 7-8 days notice, if the next venue is Auckland, otherwise they will head back to the USA. Posted on 3 May
SailGP Bermuda: Dramatic onboard collision video
Dramatic video footage shot from on-board Japan SailGP as their courses intersected with USA SailGP Dramatic video footage shot from on-board Japan SailGP as their courses intersected with USA SailGP on Leg 3 of Race 4 of Day 2 of SailGP Bermuda. Nathan Outteridge describes how it unfolded. Posted on 26 Apr
ACHof: Induction of Peter Montgomery and Ed Baird
America's Cup Hall of Fame: Induction of Peter Montgomery and Ed Baird On March 19, 2021, just a couple of days after the Emirates Team New Zealand successfully defended the America's Cup, the America's Cup Hall of Fame held an Induction Ceremony to welcome broadcaster PJ Montgomery and America's Cup winner Ed Baird Posted on 22 Apr
America's Cup: Luna Rossa's control systems outed
AC36 Challenger Luna Rossa explain how their systems work and the rules that govern their use Handling a boat like the AC75 requires the use of sophisticated management and control systems actioning a compact network of valves and pistons. Here Luna Rossa explain how their systems work and the rules that govern their use Posted on 14 Apr
Coutts more confident of SailGP Bermuda proceeding
SailGP needs COVID dispensations for Bermuda event to proceed on schedule Russell Coutts, CEO of SailGP has told Bermuda Tonight that he is more confident of the first regatta in the 2021 circuit getting underway as scheduled, despite there being only 10 days left until the scheduled start on April 24. Posted on 14 Apr
SailGP: Bermuda goes into seven day lockdown
Bermuda will enter a "shelter at home" policy, ending after the start of SailGP Round 2 It has been announced in Bermuda that the island will enter a "shelter at home" policy for the next seven days at least. The Premier says no exceptions will be made for SailGP for training or racing. Posted on 12 Apr
36th America's Cup put under the microscope
The international broadcast team for 36AC give their take on the breakpoints of regatta Key moments and analysis on the 36th America's Cup. This includes several interviews with key team members on their recollections of some of the more spectacular incidents, which were glossed over at the time due to the pace of the event. Posted on 10 Apr
America's Cup: Gulf Wars - your record of 36AC
A souvenir record of the regattas of the 36th America's Cup is now on sale across all regions A souvenir record of the regattas of the 36th America's Cup is now on sale in New Zealand, and available internationally published just over a week after racing concluded in the 36th America's Cup. Posted on 31 Mar
Sea Sure 2021 - RED - FOOTERZhik 2021 New Season FOOTERSOUTHERN-SPARS-AGLAIA-SPARS_728X90 Bottom