Please select your home edition
Edition
Vaikobi 2019AUG - Leaderboard 3

Monopoly? What Monopoly?

by Robert Deaves 28 May 2019 13:58 PDT
Finn Open European Championship 2019 © Robert Deaves

The Finn class has a long history and has been witness to many changes in the sailing world. It originates from a, perhaps, more simpler time, when many of today's problems did not exist.

The original intention of the design, to allow people to build their own boats and compete in friendly international competition, led to a robust set of Class Rules, that have been developed and fine tuned to cope with changes in technology and safety, but while leaving the basic shape and structure untouched.

Today the class is strong because of the consistency and commercial competitiveness brought about by these Class Rules. They created an open market, where anyone could build a Finn, but also such that builders could make equipment commercially available in competition with other builders. Each boat is tested for dimensions, for weight and most importantly, for weight distribution. There are no super Finns and no way to create a super Finn; there are only the Class Rules.

Over time various builders have found favour with the sailors and it is not uncommon for one builder to create fast boats that everyone wants: Tormentor, Raudaschl, Taylor, Vanguard, and today Devoti.

That Devoti Sailing is the most common builder in recent years led World Sailing President Kim Andersen to incorrectly state in an interview with Sail-World, published 24 October 2024, "In the Rio Olympics, the Finn class is probably the biggest monopoly. Because there are 23 boats, 22 of those came from the same manufacturer."

Whether by intent or implication, this message was previously stated by World Sailing CEO, Andy Hunt. In a letter to World Sailing members, dated October 15, he wrote, "One common argument for measurement controlled one design is that anybody can produce everywhere in the world - the facts are far from this... For instance, for the Finn... 22 out of 23 boats in Rio... from one single manufacturer. So despite even in a free to build market, the potential for exclusivity remains."

However these statements distort the truth. Notwithstanding that hulls all came from the same builder, there were three mast manufacturers, four boom manufacturers, six foil manufacturers and three sail manufacturers represented within the Finn fleet at the Rio 2016 Olympics. That is certainly no monopoly.

Furthermore, at the 2018 Sailing World Championships in Aarhus there were four mast manufacturers, nine boom manufacturers, eight foil manufacturers and five sail manufacturers represented within the Finn fleet.

Even though the top sailors tend to control perceived differences by herding towards one hull builder, competitive hulls are freely available from at least four or five major builders, and all are capable of winning at the highest level. Herd mentality is prevalent in any fleet and in many sports. But it doesn't create a monopoly. It is still all about customer choice and market forces, the principles on which World Sailing's FRAND (Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory) strategy is based.

Indeed, the World Sailing Olympic Equipment Strategy, agreed by Council in November 2018, contradicts the former statements when it states that the Finn "already provide[s] access to the market in FRAND terms."

In fact, of all the current and proposed Olympic classes, the Finn is the most FRAND of all.

For the Finn, no license has, or has ever been, required. It is all down to choice, and that is a fundamental concept of FRAND principles. Anyone is entitled to build a Finn to the freely available class rules. As a measurement controlled class, it is not open to illegal modifications, or 'allowable' building tolerances. It is either a Finn or it is not a Finn. There is no middle ground. There is no scandal waiting to be exposed. It is a safe, and proven option.

This rigorous and carefully controlled measurement process is one of the reasons the Finn has created a solid reputation for reliability and quality. It is a completely open market. Market forces are king and the sailors will always migrate to the builders they think will provide the best quality, the greatest reliability and the best chance of winning. History proves this to be the case.

The close controls of measurement such as accurate templates and the Lamboley swing test to control weight distribution as well as quality controlled production means that Finns are more similar to each other than virtually than any SMOD (Single Manufacturer One Design) class.

The Finn class has at least 10 hull builders across four continents, and countless manufacturers of equipment and parts. The Finn has been eminently suitable for Olympic competition for 68 years and nothing has changed in that regard. In fact the boats are better quality, more reliable and more accessible than ever before. The boat is fun, fast and appeals to a huge range of sailors across the world.

Hulls are built to the most exacting and repeatable standards, with strict controls to ensure quality and reliability. The hull requires refined and skilful handling and rewards those who train hardest. It is the perfect epitome of Olympic sailing ideals and the perfect bridge between youth classes and a career at the top of the sport such as the America's Cup and The Ocean Race.

At a time when FRAND and contractual obligations are becoming a distraction to maintain or create virtually all other Olympic classes, the Finn remains steadfast and open to all sailors and builders, as it has always been.

Related Articles

Happy Hour with Mateusz Kusznierewicz
Stretch & Stirfry chat with the Olympic champion and Star Sailors League pioneer Becoming an Olympic Champion at 21yrs old, a brief Polish history lesson, the Star Sailors League and Stirfry's language skills all come under close scrutiny as the lads chat with Mateusz Kusznierewicz. Posted today at 9:00 am
Some days you're lucky. Others you're blessed.
Thanks to the AST, and the Coffs Harbour YC, we are delighted to bring you these images. With many, many thanks to the Australian Sailing Team, and the delightful members of the Coffs Harbour Yacht Club, we are delighted to bring you these images. Posted on 4 Jul
Olympic and world champions set for Kiel Week 2020
Top ten at the Laser Radial Worlds all to compete Within only nine days the participant lists in eight classes were closed and the organizers had to readjust the maximum number of starter places in the classes. The international sailing world is counting on the postponed Kieler Woche. Posted on 24 Jun
US Sailing updates Tokyo 2020 selection procedures
Revisions focus on three classes for the 2020 U.S. Olympic Sailing Team As a result of the postponement of the Olympic Games Tokyo 2020, US Sailing has updated the Athlete Selection Procedures for the 2020 U.S. Olympic Sailing Team in accordance with Guiding Principles from the U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee (USOPC). Posted on 24 Jun
Caleb Paine steps away from Tokyo 2020 Campaign
Turning his focus to other areas of the sport After a long, successful career competing for the US Sailing Team in the Finn class, Caleb Paine (San Diego, Calif.) has decided to end his campaign for the Tokyo 2020 Olympics and turn his focus to other areas of the sport. Posted on 23 Jun
Celebrating 50 years of the Finn Masters
This week should have been the 2020 event in The Netherlands This week should have been the 2020 Finn World Masters in Port Zelanda, in The Netherlands. Entries were approaching 250 when the decision was made to cancel back in March, with more than 300 Finns expected to turn up. Posted on 1 Jun
The next stage of return to training
British Sailing Team prepares following the latest Government guidance for elite sport The British Sailing Team is preparing to move to the next phase of its return to training following the latest Government guidance for elite sport. Posted on 29 May
2021 Finn World Masters will be in Medemblik
Planning well underway and it should be a great party The International Finn Masters Committee is delighted to announce that the 2021 Finn World Masters will be held in Medemblik, The Netherlands. Posted on 15 May
Watch the Finn on Finn TV
Today was the day that the 2020 Finn Gold Cup was scheduled to start in Palma Many things are being remembered today, but for Finn sailors it is particularly poignant as today was the day that the 2020 Finn Gold Cup was scheduled to start in Palma, Mallorca. Posted on 8 May
Digging into the Finn Class archive
1000s of photos, with some dating back to the 1950s During this time of waiting and restrictions we have been digging deep into the Finn Class archives. These date back to the 1950s and contain thousands of prints and slides, and tens of thousands of digital images. Posted on 3 May
Melges IC37 2019 FooterUpffront 2020 Foredeck Club SW FOOTERVaikobi 2019AUG - Footer 3