Please select your home edition
Edition
Rooster GETSEASMART 728x90

Paris 2024: World Sailing Committee recommends RS Aero

by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz 18 May 21:33 PDT 19 May 2019
RS Aero topped the Olympic Equipment Trials © RS Sailing

The Equipment Committee of World Sailing has voted to recommend the RS Aero to the body's Council for confirmation at its meeting tomorrow (Sunday).

The RS Aero was supported by nine members of the Committee, with only three supporting the Laser. The other two options, the D-Zero and Melges 15 received no votes. The voting was the same for the Mens and Womens Equipment (class).

The Laser has been an Olympic class first sailed in the 1996 Games, and numbers 215,000 boats worldwide, with 50,000 active sailors and 14,000 members of the international class association. In response to a question from a member of the Committee it was stated that the RS Aero had 1850 boats worldwide at the time of the Evaluation Trials in Valencia, Spain in mid-March, 2019. The Laser was sailed in 85 countries in the Qualification process for the 2016 Olympic Regatta, and was the largest class in terms of universality. The Laser Radial was the second largest with 69 countries participating in the Qualification Events for Rio 2016.

The price of the RS Aero is stated by the Evaluation panel to be £6041 the price of the Laser is in the range £4973 to £5516. The Panel claims the RS Aero is suitable for a Male weight range of 85-91kg and Female range 68-73kg.

During the Evaluation process the International Laser Association decided to cancel the building licence of its biggest builder Laser Performance (LP) which constructed over 70% of the annual production of Lasers, as it claimed that LP had refused factory inspections by ILCA for an extended period of time.

The Evaluation Committee recommended that both the Laser and RS Aero could be selected by the Equipment Committee rather than just selecting a single boat from the Evaluation Trial.

The recommendation from the Equipment Committee will be forwarded to the Council of World Sailing for confirmation when it meets tomorrow, Sunday on the final day of the Mid Year meeting.

Windsurfer trial sought

In a further recommendation, the Equipment Committee voted not to support the Board's recommendation to Council to retain the RS:X Windsurfer for the 2024 Olympics. After calling for tenders for the Windsurfer, the Board decided that the RS:X had fitted the specification it published previously, and bypassed the expert Equipment Committee, by making a recommendation directly to the Council.

The position of the Equipment Committee has long been that the Windsurfer Equipment should go through an evaluation process similar to that of the Laser/Laser Radial for the One Person Dinghy. The Equipment Committee voted, after lengthy discussion, "To reject the Board recommendation and recommend that the Board selects New Equipment and conduct sea trials against an updated set of criteria".

It would seem from the discussion that the Equipment Committee would like to see Windfoilers tested against displacement windsurfers.

The vote was a resounding vote to Reject by 0 votes for, 11 against and two abstentions.

More devil in the detail for Mixed Two-Person Offshore

The Equipment Committee spent a considerable period of time wordsmithing a changed Submission M01-19 from the Board of World Sailing, which altered once again the process to select the Mixed Two-Person Offshore Keelboat, for the 2024 Olympics.

"We have to approve this but it's flawed" commented Stan Honey who is both a member of the Equipment Committee. His view was that the current proposal was completely unworkable and the latest amendment was an improvement in that it is capable of further amendment.

The change stretched the date for World Sailing to publish the so-called "long list" of boats believed to be suitable for countries to use if they were wishing to enter the Mixed Two Person Offshore keelboat. Instead of being published by December 2019, it will now be done by December 2020. The proposal for the selection of the actual supplied Equipment to be used at the 2024 Olympics still remains at "no later than 31 December 2023".

The flaws raised in the course of the discussion included a preference for World Sailing just to publish a list of criteria for the "long list" and then leave sailors and Member National Authorities and regions to sort out their preferred option.

It was pointed out that December 2023 was too late for the French builder of the supplied equipment to actually produce the boats required for the new and controversial 2024 Olympic event.

Another questioned whether the boat selected for 2024 would also be used for 2028. There was the alternate view expressed that the intention of this event was not to have it centred around a boat, and that a new boat would be selected for 2028.

That then begged the question as to whether sailors/MNA's should be asked to buy a boat or two at €200,000 each for training heading into the 2024 Olympics, in the knowledge that boat would only have a life just for the 2024 Olympics, and that another boat would be used for 2028 - if the event remained in the Olympics..

In subsequent discussion three issues were aired:

1. Whether there should be a list of boats or the less prescriptive list of criteria required of the boats.

2. Whether the concept of the class is one that gets selected is long standing, like other Olympic classes. Or, if a set of criteria is published around which the organising body for an Olympic Regatta would work with local builders to produce a boat.

3. Whether the event should be highly technical where all technology should be allowed that is is permitted in other major offshore events, and the race becomes an exercise in intense analysis, as well as sailing. Or, if the event is more about Man against Nature and technology use should be highly restricted - "no data in, only data out", referring to the acceptance that there would be onboard cameras and audio running 24x7.

The Committee accepted that there was little that could be done to control cost, and that MNA's would spend as much or as little as they liked. All that could be done was to structure the class and event on the basis of diminishing returns for higher levels of expenditure.

There were differing views on the types of autopilot allowed - one based on inertia technology; or one that would just sail a compass course; or whether they should be banned all together and hand-steering or a pinned helm permitted.

Similarly with engines, whether there would be fossil fuel engines permitted, or if they would electric only - and presumably solar panel charged.

Given that the fleet will be escorted and monitored by the French Navy, whether liferafts would be required to be carried.

The last two points touched on the sufficiency aspect of offshore racing and also safety in a man overboard situation - as to whether the remaining crew member would be required to attempt to recover a crew member who was overboard, or if an America's Cup style chase boat would swoop in and return the crew-member to his/her boat and they kept racing with a set time/suspension of racing penalty.

The discussions will continue amongst a joint Working Party of the Equipment Committee and the Oceanic and Offshore Committee.

Related Articles

Paris 2024: Has Windfoiling's time arrived?
Sometime next Thursday in Bermuda, World Sailing's Events Committee will decide on its Recommendatio Sometime next Thursday in Bermuda, World Sailing's Events Committee will decide on its Recommendation for the Windsurfing Equipment for the 2024 Olympic Regatta in Marseille. Posted on 29 Oct
Paris 2024: (Un)Intended consequences in Marseille
Events Committee member and CEO of Yachting New Zealand on the Mixed Offshore Event in Marseille "I think the argument that the Offshore Committee have around not having an Arms Race is going to have the opposite effect completely and will create a fast track for one nation, probably France to get an advantage over everyone else." Posted on 28 Sep
Ainslie says Olympics need radical overhaul
Winner of five Olympic medals disappointed at dropping of Finn: 'What do guys over 85kg sail?' Sir Ben Ainslie, winner of five Olympic medals, four of them Gold, believes the Olympic Sailing Regatta needs a radical overhaul - he wants a reduction in classes and sailors and to improve quality of racing Posted on 13 Jul
Paris 2024: Laser Performance hits out at ILCA
The testy relationship between ILCA and Laser Performance has just 10.5 weeks to be remedied Laser Performance the predominant builder of the Laser dinghy, until they had their building licence revoked last March, have hit out at the International Laser Class Association (ILCA), after the class was provisionally confirmed for the 2024 Olympics Posted on 20 May
Laser voted in for 2024 Paris Olympic Sailing
Laser/ILCA was voted as the One Person Dinghy for the 2024 Olympic Sailing Regatta Laser/ILCA was voted as the One Person Dinghy for the 2024 Olympic Sailing Regatta, by a landslide in the Council Meeting. The RS:X was rejected and the Windsurfers will have an Evaluation Trial - which will include Windfoilers Posted on 19 May
Olympic champion unhappy with RS:X recommendation
Current World and Olympic Champion not happy with decision to retain RS:X windsurfer With the Olympic Equipment fires burning on several fronts, the current World and Olympic Champion has hit out over the World Sailing's recommendation to retain the RS:X Windsurfer, provided a new deal is struck with the licence holder. Posted on 15 May
Finn Champ resigned to Olympic exit after 2020
The defending Olympic Champion in Finn class says Tokyo 2020 is likely to be his last Olympics The defending Olympic Champion in the one man Finn class says Tokyo 2020 is likely to be his last Olympics. There will be no place for heavier men in Paris 2024, due to the rigid application of a gender equality policy by World Sailing. Posted on 12 May
Controversy dogs World Sailing Mid Year Meeting
World Sailing Mid Year will take place against a backdrop of controversy The Mid-Year Meeting of World Sailing is set to take place at the end of next week in the Chelsea Football Club, London. The Meeting will take place against a backdrop of controversy over the Olympic classes and events for the 2024 Olympics in Paris. Posted on 10 May
World Sailing wants to stop 'Arms Race'
World Sailing tries to stem "Arms Race" in new Olympic Offshore Keelboat event World Sailing's Board has made another "Urgent" submission to be considered at the Mid-Year Council meeting to facilitate the inclusion of the new Mixed Two Person Offshore Keelboat - Updated Posted on 28 Apr
Big reductions in the 2024 Olympic fleets ahead?
The 2024 Olympic decisions taken by World Sailing over the past five months have been very divisive. The 2024 Olympic decisions taken by World Sailing over the past six months have been greeted with a mix of angst, derision and elation. Apologies for the length of this story which includes sailing specific comment from the International Olympic Committee Posted on 21 Nov 2018
Melges 14 2019 FooterFestival of Sails 2020 GIF - FOOTERPandB 2019 Autumn Sale - Footer