Please select your home edition
Edition
SW newsletters (top)

IOC Exec Com member slams latest WS Board Proposal

by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com/nz 29 Oct 2018 13:58 PDT 30 October 2018
World Sailing's Olympic Sub-Committee meets in Sarasota, Florida, USA is hosting the Annual Conference from 27 October to 4 November. © Daniel Smith

Former World Sailing Vice President Ng Ser Miang (SIN) has hit back at the last minute Submission introduced yesterday by the Board of World Sailing.

Ser Miang is now an Executive Committee member of the International Olympic Committee.

This lifts the mis-management and misinformation of the 2024 Sailing Olympic Events and Equipment to a new and very serious level, as it clearly has a level of visibility within the IOC which had not previously been confirmed.

As previously reported the World Sailing Submission proposed a Mixed Gender Doublehanded Keelboat, non-foiling and 6-10metres long to be sailed in an event format yet to be defined and in a class which it was hoped to get sponsored.

Ser Miang writes on his Facebook page click here

During the midyear meeting in May this year, the World Sailing Council received more than 60 submissions on the 2024 Olympic events, 13 of them were debated on and after prolong process and 7 rounds of voting it took a decision. Now, barely 5 months later the World Sailing Board decided that one of the event cannot work and is proposing to change that. What sort of process is this? lack of leadership? cherry picking? commercial interests manipulation?

A mixed two person keelboat offshore event that will go on for 48 hours? a liberal interpretation of Regulation 23? the reasons given in this submission paper are pretty strange.

1) That the mixed one person dinghy event is not workable, then why was it put forward in the midyear meeting and approved after due process?
2) keelboat has a long history in the Olympic programme, but not offshore!!

3) 50% of sailors in the world compete in offshore keelboats ?! fake data?! 49 countries in the world are landlocked, many non landlock countries do not have offshore racing. the huge costs and logistic of offshore racing is not comparable to dinghy racing. the maritime traffic in many parts of the world do not make offshore racing easy.
4) the reasonable costs of supplied equipment is pretty humorous. will the boat manufacturing be prepared to supply free keelboats for participating MNAs to train and qualified their sailors???

5) my understanding from broadcasters is that the event will be complex and expensive to cover. I do not think it is necessary to go into other "reasons" in the paper. In a note dated 15 Oct sent by Andy Hunt, CEO of World Sailing, he warned of expensive litigations should anyone try to change the Nov decision on Olympic equipment. I find this very strange as in the same breath, the Board is trying to change decision of the Council made in May?!

Further, even if the Board will manage to make the Council change its May decision, how will the Council decide on which offshore keelboat at this Annual Meeting? unless someone has already decide which keelboat will be designated? if this is not the case and like all Olympic equipment that has to be well tested and universally accepted then the decision has to be deferred. should the same not apply to all other untested equipment proposed?

The Olympic Games is not a testing ground for new experiment. The complexity of our sport cannot be an excuse for not following principles and protecting the integrity of our sport and most importantly our sailors. In most of the Olympic IFs, the National Federations form the supreme body of their sport. Sailing is no different, classes and equipment manufacturers are important partners, but they are not National Federations. It is time for the MNAs to be involved and to take charge.

As delegates and observers gather for the Annual Conference of World Sailing, leading US sailing website Sailing Illustrated is running a special show at 2000UTC today, Monday featuring former World sailing President Paul Henderson who has been a leading critic of World Sailing's proposals.

The show can be seen at Sailing Illustrated

In a further development overnight, Sail-World understands that an invitation only briefing is being held for Council members and others ahead of the formal meetings. It is not known what is being disclosed or why World Sailing, if reported correctly are seeing fit to only invite some Council members.

Related Articles

So how do you get to the Olympics?
Early in 2019, the Australian Sailing Team completed the task of defining the path Early in 2019, the Australian Sailing Team (AST) completed the task of defining the path to the Olympics. Posted on 25 Feb
Gladwell's Line: What do we really know?
A look at the use of prototype or test boats, alternate strategies and the nuances of a dry tack A look at the use of prototype or test boats in this America's Cup cycle, and the alternative strategies teams could be using as they keep their Cup developments running. Plus a look at dry tacks and gybing in the AC75. Posted on 24 Feb
Sail-World NZ news : Feb 24 - The Week that Was
Read the latest newsletter from Sail-World NZ, with the top stories covering of the week Read the latest newsletter from Sail-World New Zealand, with the top stories covering the America's Cup action from New Zealand and around the world, and the Harken International Youth Match Racing Posted on 24 Feb
Time for Fresh Oil
It's a new year and a new season of SailGP, so it's definitely a great time for some fresh oil. It's a new year and a new season of SailGP, so it's definitely a great time for some fresh oil. As we know, this is really important for the best shallow or deep fry, and for Season Two the gas has been turned up somewhat with the seven F50s. Posted on 23 Feb
Gladwell's Line: Four Olympic nominations sorted?
Centre stage in the first couple of week in February has been the four Olympic class worlds Centre stage in the first couple of weeks in February has been the four Olympic class world championships being sailed in Australia. Posted on 20 Feb
Sail-World NZ news : Feb 16 - Olympic class Worlds
Top stories covering the America's Cup latest from NZ and around the world, and Top stories covering the America's Cup action from New Zealand and around the world, and the Olympic class Worlds from Geelong and Melbourne Posted on 18 Feb
Olympic moments abound
The Summer of Sailing around Port Phillip has been quite the big deal The Summer of Sailing around Melbourne's Port Phillip has been quite the big deal. How cool would it be to have Australia represented in the 470M, Laser, 470W, Finn, 49er, FX, Nacra, and also Laser Radial Posted on 16 Feb
Sail-World: Feb 16: Burling & Tuke win sixth
Welcome to Sail-World.com's New Zealand e-magazine for February 16, 2020 Welcome to Sail-World.com's New Zealand e-magazine for February 16, 2020 Posted on 15 Feb
Welcome sign, not toll booth, nor boom gate
The question of participation is the proverbial whipping boy of yachting Quite possibly, and even more so than keels of Unobtanium and constantly dynamic sail membranes filled with Helium, the question of participation in our sport is the proverbial whipping boy of yachting. Posted on 9 Feb
Gladwell's Line: SailGP rings changes for Season 2
SailGP was very much at the forefront of the sailing stage this week SailGP was very much at the forefront of the sailing stage, this week - and not for what happened on the water. Great Britain SailGP announced a crew line up stacked with members of the INEOS Team UK America's Cup team and a minority investor signed on. Posted on 9 Feb
MBW newsletters (top)