Please select your home edition
Melges 14 2019 Leaderboard

America's Cup: Raft of Protocol changes as more Challengers emerge

by Richard Gladwell, 13 Sep 2018 02:08 PDT 13 September 2018
Hologram - America's Cup Overture © Carlo Borlenghi

Emirates Team New Zealand say they are "dealing with five further possible challengers and although we cannot say with any certainty how many of them will proceed".

The comment came in Evidence lodged with the Environment Court, by Emirates Team New Zealand in response to calls for the number of bases to be reduced. Only three Challenges had been received at the time of the Resource Consent Application Hearing seeking to get the go-ahead for the America's Cup base construction in Auckland.

The spokesman for the team added: "I am confident RNZYS will be receiving a formal challenge from the first of those teams in the coming weeks. This team has advised ETNZ it intends building two race yachts and may yet be seeking to be allocated a double base for their operation."

The comment was more definitive than earlier Evidence given by the team which indicated that they were dealing with five challengers and qualified their remarks by saying: "We are not expecting all of them to proceed and I cannot say with any certainty how many will."

The addition of one new Challenger will mean that the Semi-Final for the Prada Cup will become a four-boat affair meaning that two teams instead of just one will be eliminated.

The entry of a second new Challenger will put a real edge into the Round Robin phase of the Prada Cup - with one team being eliminated at the end of the first round, and there are no carry over points from the America's Cup World Series to distort the Prada Cup points totals.

If what is being said regarding entries by Emirates Team NZ actually comes to fruition the argument about compressing the plans for Amerivca's Cup 36 bases, looks more than a little flawed. And, if Team New Zealand does follow the statistical trend and defend successfully, then space on Wynyard Point will be need to be extended to accommodate more than five Challenging teams.

Design strategies affected by Protocol Change

In late August, the Defender and Challenger of Record for the 36th America's Cup published a raft of Protocol Changes.

Covering eight pages the most significant change is the allowance of alterations to the hull surface of both AC75's owned by a team, while previously teams were allowed to change the surface of one hull only.

The way that would have worked would have meant that teams building two boats would have been expected to use the first as a true development boat, made any alterations required to that and then built their second boat incorporating the design changes

Under the previous version of the Protocol, hull alteration of the one boat only was restricted to 25% of the hull surface area, now that has been downsized to 12.5% but on each boat.

With only three Challengers confirmed - all the so-called "Super Teams" - it is not surprising that the rules have been changed to suit the entered teams, who are expected to build two AC75's each plus the usual fleet of smaller boats which outwardly look to be useful, but in retrospect were only a distraction.

The problem with the former rule restricting alteration on the surface of just one hull would have affected the design development cycle.

The issue with the rule as it stood, is that the hull surface of the second boat (able to be launched 10.5 months after the first) could not be altered once she had been splashed, assuming the team had modified the hull surface of the first launched in some way.

While the design cut-off dates under the old rule, would have varied from team to team, the effect would have been similar in that the teams would have had to lock off their development and design for the external hull shape of the second boat, about 5-6 months after the launch of the first boat.

The difficulty with the old rule which allowed changes only to one boat, is that it became a game of pitching launch dates and design and build timelines which could have become very complicated.

The effect of the new rule is to relieve that pressure, and the teams can now do what ever development they like to either hull whenever they like, right up to the start of the regatta.

With the revamped timelines the Defender, Emirates Team New Zealand probably gives up some advantage.

The Defender does not have to be ready to race until the beginning of March, three months later than the start of the Prada Cup for Challengers, normally the home team would have the advantage of an extra three months of development.

Now, the gain for the Defender, and to some extent the Challengers, is that if they spot a breakthrough development on another boat they can copy it onto one boat and test.

The sting in the new rule that the teams are limited to altering just 12.5% of the surface area of the hull, which prohibits wholesale rebuilds.

In the first version of the Protocol issued last September, the teams are also still limited to sailing one boat at a time - and the long days of working through a daily two-boat test schedule are also gone. The Defender was always allowed to start two-boat racing and testing but only once the Prada Cup gets underway.

The rest of the rule changes appear to be housekeeping which is to be expected once the Arbitration Panel has been appointed, and after input has been received from the entered teams.

Several of the rule changes relate to liability and indemnity of organisers and officials, including stating that the responsibility for the reliability of supplied parts, such as the rigging package and foil canting mechanism, remains with the Team and not the supplier.

A key date for teams comes in just over two weeks at the end of September, when the Performance Bond of USD$1million must be deposited.

A second key date has just passed being September 1 the counting of the 380 days for residency of non-nationals of a team began and must be complete by August 31, 2020.

Late entries close on November 30, 2018, however Emirates Team New Zealand have said that even this date will be extended if necessary by the Defender and Challenger making a suitable amendment to the Protocol.

Related Articles

America's Cup: Luna Rossa's AC75 foiling - Video
First video released by Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli of their AC75 foiling in Cagliari, Sardinia First video released by Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli of their AC75 foiling in Cagliari, Sardinia. Posted on 15 Nov
America's Cup: The Agony and Ecstacy
Like all professional sports, race results in the America's Cup mean more than just bragging rights “A little bit of boat speed makes you famous” once said an America's Cup skipper. The unsaid flip side is that a lack of it, will relegate you to obscurity. Posted on 15 Nov
Burling and Tuke announce new ocean ambition
Olympic champions Peter Burling and Blair Tuke have announced the establishment of Live Ocean Olympic champions Peter Burling and Blair Tuke have announced the establishment of Live Ocean, a registered New Zealand charity with a focus on ocean conservation. Burling and Tuke say they're excited about what may be their biggest challenge of all. Posted on 10 Nov
America's Cup: Two AC75s line up in NZ and UK
Two videos that show some of the similarities and differences between the Brits and Kiwi's AC75s America's Cup teams sailing against each other, other than at sanctioned events is illegal under the Protocol for the next America's Cup. Here is the next best thing - two videos that show the similarities and differences between the AC75 designs Posted on 8 Nov
America's Cup: Te Aihe nosedives at high speed
Spectacular high speed AC75 nosedive caught on camera Emirates Team New Zealand's AC75 had a high speed nosedive while sailing upwind in moderate to fresh winds on the Hauraki Gulf today. The sequence was caught on camera, at long distance, by Sail-World NZ. Posted on 7 Nov
America's Cup: A closer look at Te Aihe
America's Cup: A closer look at ETNZ's AC75 Te Aihe, as she waited for the wind earlier in the week Light winds earlier in the week in Auckland probably didn't do much for Emirates Team NZ's America's Cup workup, but it did allow a closer look at their AC75 Te Aihe, as she waited and waited for the breeze to arrive. Posted on 7 Nov
America's Cup: Putting the Spark into Te Aihe
Real-time data from race boat to chase boat – Spark announces the next step with Emirates Team New Z Spark New Zealand has announced that it is trialling a 5G service on the water for Emirates Team NZ The trial 5G service covers parts of Auckland Harbour, off Milford and Takapuna, where Emirates Team New Zealand do some of their test sailing. Posted on 4 Nov
America's Cup: Te Aihe warms up on the Waitemata
An image gallery of Te Aihe (the Dolphin) at play Monday morning under North Head. Te Aihe, Emirates Team NZ's first AC75 got out of the boatshed for another training session, this morning as the Southern Hemisphere moves into late spring. Here's an image gallery of Te Aihe (the Dolphin) at play under North Head. Posted on 4 Nov
America's Cup: Agreement signed after CEO spat
CoR/D and World Sailing have reached agreement for the next edition of the America's Cup. Three weeks after Emirates Team NZ issued a statement accusing then World Sailing's CEO, Andy Hunt of "attempting to circumvent the [negotiation ] process by contacting the New Zealand Government" the parties have announced the signing a formal agreement Posted on 31 Oct
America's Cup: Images of INEOS Team UK
John Green captures the the sea trialling of Britannia, UK's latest America's Cup challenger. Isle of Wight based photographer, John Green, is fortunate to be living in the epicentre of world sailing, and the birthplace of the America's Cup. Here he captures the sea trialling of Britannia, UK's latest America's Cup challenger. Posted on 30 Oct
Mackay BoatsVaikobi 2019AUG - Footer 1Marine Resources 2019 - Footer