Please select your home edition
Edition
C-Tech 2020 Tubes 728x90 TOP

America's Cup- Challenger of Record pulls pin in unprecedented move

by Richard Gladwell on 12 May 2011
As USA crosses the finish Line, GGYC accept the Club Nautico di Roma as challenger of Record , l. to r. : Melinda Erkelens (GGYC) - Norbert Barjurin (GGYC) - Marcus Young (GGYC) - Alessandra Pandarese (Club Nautico di Roma)- Vincenzo Onorato (Club Nautico di Roma)***14/02/2010 - Valencia (ESP) - 33rd America’s Cup - BMW ORACLE Racing - Race 2 - - As USA crosses the finish Line, GGYC accept the Club Nautico di Roma BMW Oracle Racing Photo Gilles Martin-Raget http://www.bmworacleracing.com

The Challenger of Record for the 34th America's Cup, Mascalzone Latino has just announced that they will not compete in the 34th America's Cup.

No announcement has yet been made by the America's Cup organisers as to what will happen next, in this unprecedented move, which had been tipped for some time.

The team headed by Italian shipping magnate Vincenzo Onorato cites an inability to raise sufficient sponsorship as the reason behind the withdrawal.

The team was also one of those believed to have missed the posting of the first performance bond on 30 April 2011.

There was some surprise in Cup circles, when Mascalzone Latino did not take up on of the first AC45's instead it was claimed they had 'chartered' that boat to Oracle Racing, who sailed two boats.

In the end Onorato remained true to his word, when a few weeks ago he commented 'If in a few months I don't find the economic support to be competitive, the I'll quit'.

Clearly he had reached, or passed, the point of no return.

Curiously at the time of the venue from the 34th Defence of the America's Cup being subject to an intense bidding war, the Italian club of Mascalzone Latino was widely reported as being the European venue for the event, and had offered a massive venue fee for the hosting the event.

The announcement drops the clubs entered in the 34th America's Cup down to 13 teams, including the defender Oracle Racing.

The move by Mascalzone Latino will create some uncertainty in Cup circles. It is certainly unprecedented in America's Cup history. While some may expect the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron, as a Cup Trustee to step into the breach, the role is regarded as a poison chalice by many in New Zealand, as no Challenger of Record has ever gone on to win the most prestigious trophy in sailing.

While some would point to three years (1970, 1992 and 1995) when there was no challenger of record, in 1970 the New York Yacht Club asked the Australian challenger to run a selection series with the winner being confirmed by the International Sailing Federation. In 1992, the initial Challenger was Yacht club de Sete (FRA) who dropped out early in the piece, and the Challengers' affairs were run a by a Challenger of Record Committee headed by West Australian, Ernie Tyalor. The same arrangement continued in 1995.

The reason for needing a Challenger of Record is to negotiate the terms of the Protocol for the Match and events leading to it. Protocols, as a means of controlling the conditions under which an America's Cup was run, first came into existence in the 1992 America's Cup.

Under the current Protocol the only advantage of being a Challenger of Record, is that the club as the right of veto over some conditions sought be to imposed by the Defender.

The most likely replacement, if a club is to be accepted is the first time Swedish challenger, Artemis Racing. Sail-World understands that the Swedish team were also the second Challenger. Under the 19th century Deed of Gift, they have the right to Challenge before others can be engaged, and that club would need to accept the terms of the Challenge made by Club Nautico di Roma.

Another option is to run the event under a Challenger of Record Committee as was done in 1992 and 1995.

The statement from the team boss, Vincenzo Onorato reads:

With deep sorrow I have to announce my decision to withdraw my team from the 34th America’s Cup.

Since the very beginning of our role as Challenger of Record, I have been working on this project focused to bring the Cup in our Country.

Larry deeply loves Italy and he was excited about this idea. The Cup in Italy would have been the greatest worldwide promotion for our beautiful coasts. There have been some very high level and important meetings that made us believing in this dream, but the things went in a different way.


As Challenger of Record, we have worked with humility next to Oracle and I am satisfied of the result we have reached: a new Cup, spectacular, with new boats, the catamarans, that will launch on the international scene a new generation of sailors.

With Russell we have discussed for long time on the most difficult challenge that the next Cup must face: an international situation with big economic crisis and therefore huge difficulties to find sponsor. This is the only, true, real enemy of the next Cup. We have then thought of the idea to create the class AC45, a concrete way to make lot of teams get involved in the event reducing costs, at least in the delicate period of the start-up.

On our side, I must thank the two Italian sponsors that believed and confirmed us their trust. We are not able, however, to reach a budget that allows us to be a competitive team.

In our sport, men in blazer have overcome by now those in oilskins, I'm a man in oilskin and when I go in the sea, I want to win. I’m not interested in a hopeless challenge, I would lie to the sponsors, to our fans and last but not least also to myself.

I would like to thank our friends from Club Nautico di Roma. I am sure that we will have new exciting adventures together.

The sailing adventure of Mascalzone Latino doesn’t end anyway with the Cup, but it continues with the sailing school in Naples, free of charge, for those children coming from the most difficult areas of this town. A daily challenge, and, who knows, maybe someday we will see a new America’s Cup champion coming out from one of them.

Fair wind to all of you.

Henri-Lloyd Dynamic RangeRooster 2025Allen Dynamic 40 Footer

Related Articles

2025 Dutch Water Week day 2
Some fleets are testing new race formats and scoring systems Day two of Dutch Water Week once again delivered classic Dutch autumn conditions: strong gusty winds, grey skies and occasional rain showers.
Posted today at 7:28 am
Women's Match Racing Worlds in Chicago Day 2
Teams battle challenging conditions As racing runs into sunset in Chicago The second day of racing at the 2025 World Sailing Women's Match Racing World Championship on Lake Michigan presented challenging conditions for the twelve competing teams as a gradual easterly breeze created a sloppy short swell on the course.
Posted today at 5:27 am
Womens America's Cup opportunities expand
the pathway for female athletes has never been stronger than in the Louis Vuitton 38th America's Cup 2024 and the inaugural Puig Women's America's Cup was announced following the publication of the Protocol for the Louis Vuitton 37th America's Cup in Barcelona. It was a moment not only for women's sport and equality but showed that the America's Cup was
Posted today at 1:30 am
48 hours in light airs on the cards
15th Défi Azimut Lorient Agglomération begins The two-handed Défi Azimut - Lorient Agglomération 48 Hours race set sail from the IMOCA headquarters at Lorient on 18th September, promising a tricky light airs contest for the 12 crews taking part.
Posted on 18 Sep
OK Dinghy Worlds at Lake Garda Day 4
Andrew Mills within reach of title Two more race wins from Britain's Andrew Mills places him within one race of clinching the 2025 OK Dinghy world title on Friday. He took two more emphatic race wins on Thursday on Lake Garda in the windiest conditions so far.
Posted on 18 Sep
J/105 North American Championship day 2
California Dreamin' - two San Francisco boats are dominating in lighter breeze Although they are accustomed to heavy air and hiking, two San Francisco boats are dominating in lighter breeze after five races at the J/105 North American Championship in Toronto.
Posted on 18 Sep
Big colour displays
Which would you prefer? A+T Instruments will be at the Monaco Boat Show and at the Les voiles de Saint-Tropez. Hugh will be navigating on SY Sealen B, and Pete will be navigating on SY Mariella.
Posted on 18 Sep
Exceptional Line-Up for Les Voiles de Saint-Tropez
Over 240 remarkable yachts will take to the waters of the Gulf of Saint-Tropez Over 240 remarkable yachts will take to the waters of the Gulf of Saint-Tropez from September 27 to October 5, carried by the lively winds of late September that extend the Tropezian summer with its golden light.
Posted on 18 Sep
2025 Dutch Water Week day 1
The format with ten participants and new race formats is being tested and evaluated From Wednesday 17 to Sunday 21 September, Almere is hosting the fourth edition of Dutch Water Week. This edition serves as a pilot for the Sailing Grand Slam Final (SGS).
Posted on 18 Sep
IMOCA Speed Runs in Lorient
15th Défi Azimut Lorient Agglomération kicks off Une Battle commenced in the 15th Défi Azimut Lorient Agglomération with a spectacle guaranteed from the get-go. Speed runs left, right and centre in the Courreaux de Groix, followed by a grand parade by an 11-strong fleet of IMOCAs to delight the crowds.
Posted on 18 Sep