Please select your home edition
Edition
Mackay Boats 728x90 TOP

Gladwell's Line- ISAF Events Committee falls into its Heffalump Trap

by Richard Gladwell on 11 Nov 2010
"Mr Foiling Moth" Rohan Veal flying with at the 2009 Int Moth Worlds - but the Finns get the automatic tick as the second Olympic singlehander Sean Trew (Pacific Fog) http://www.pacificfog.net/

By design or default, ISAF's Events Committee seems to have fallen into its own Heffalump Trap after conducting two key votes at the International Sailing Federations Annual Conference in Athens.

The trap was set inadvertently by the ISAF's own Executive Committee in the form of two submissions which required that two votes to be undertaken, first by the Events Committee and then by the ISAF Council. The submissions came on the back of the ISAF's Olympic Commission Reports, in May and November calling for some very substantial changes in the way the Olympic Regatta and other feeder events are run.

Issues raised by the Olympic Commission have been covered extensively in Sail-World.com http://www.sail-world.com/NZ/Gladwells-Line:-Olympic-Decision---will-ISAF-get-caught-by-a-Yorker?/75967!click_here and http://www.sail-world.com/USA/Gladwells-Line:-Olympic-Commission-report-a-thunderbolt-for-the-sport/69444!click_here

In the first mentioned story we covered the trap that the ISAF has created for itself, with the submissions 096-10 and 097-10. To recap the Executive Committee prescribed that events would be changed at a minimum of six years notice. Then in Submission 097-10 set out two votes for Core Events which established a slate of six Core Events to be decided in Vote 1, and then in a second and third vote, a selection of four events made from a selection of six stated.

So far so good - remembering that (a) this a transition process ie it might not be 100% right first time - so there should be no problem deferring to May 2011 for a tidy up if required and (b) that the thrust is to determine the Events not link these with classes or Equipment in this round.

Having made excellent ground leading up to the current meeting, the trap became truly set when the passing of Submission 096-10 got interpreted as meaning that no new Events could be introduced in May 2011, because that would be inside the six year window for change set by 096-10. (Our apologies for the convoluted logic that seems to be de rigueur in ISAF circles.)

The effect of this process being that unless the Multihull or Boardsailing or any other of the several 'new' events were not passed in 2010, then they were forced out until 2020 Olympics at the earliest.

Sorry guys, but this fine-point needlework is not what the sport needs at this stage. The key is to get the basics right, not be driven by some intricacy of the process. No-one will remember this logic, even in just 12 months time, but the decision bred from it will remain for many years.

Changing the thinking

Part of the issue with the implementation of any change, is to change the attitudes.

In its May report the Olympic Commission got the right shoes on the right feet by talking about Events - which should be decided first, and then the Equipment selected and matched to those Events. All of which we have covered before.

The attitudinal change required was to get those present NOT to think in terms of their beloved Classes, but in terms of Events.

The Executive Committee failed in this regard with their submission (097-10) which set out the Events and then put Classes against some of those options. In others, they had specified Evaluation trials to be held, as was done to selected the best equipment for the Twohanded High Performance Skiff (49er being selected) and the Womens Keelboat (Elliott 6 Metre), and going further back, the Trials which produced the Tornado, Contender, Soling and Tempest - three of which eventually made it to the Olympic regatta.


The logical approach in November 2010, would have been to select the Events, and then propose Evaluation Trials for those Events, and select the best Equipment option in 2011. In other worlds the submissions should have been silent on the Equipment - then we would have had a debate on whether a second single hander was needed, or whether a Mixed Keelboat would have been better in the overall mix. Out of a potential Events slate of say 20 Events options, 10 would have been selected at the November 2010 meeting.

The Olympic Commission correctly recommended the conduct of Evaluation Trials to select some of the Equipment (aka Classes). While some may claim that is an expensive process, the simple point is that ISAF has to be seen to be fair to all classes.

Further, the state of the sport is such that the costs of conducting proper trials (which could be a paper based evaluation, based on known classes or options or a full blown sailing trials) are relatively minor compared to the costs to the sport of being asked to leave the Olympic family.

Do the Events Committee seriously expect the sailing world to believe that the best Mens Singlehanded class (if that is chosen as a second singlehanded Event) is the Finn???

And that by definition, a one man skiff, of which there are several good classes, a foiling Moth or any number of other options which grab the attention of the so-called Facebook generation don't really do the job required for the sailing Olympics???

The claim is that a class suitable for heavier males is required - if that is so - then factor that into the Evaluation Trial mix, and select accordingly.


Do the Events Committee seriously expect the sailing world to believe that the best option for a second Twohanded Dinghy with spinnaker is a Mixed 470????

In its reports, the Olympic Commission noted that a 'improved' 470 was required, which was less technical, for the better adoption for the new style Olympics. That gives a class within a class, which is always a lemon.

And taking that a step further, is a simplified 470 is what is required - then surely it is logical for these to be supplied boats - and which of the licenced builder's mould would be used to produce these? And what happens at Sailing World Cup events - are these sailed in regular 470's or the 'Olympic' 470?

Further the 470 is currently sailed as a Mens and Womens Event. For men it is a class for highly skilled lightweight sailors, and for women equally technically skilled sailors closer to the average female physiques. While these weights may be more suitable for Asian nations, the fact is that in 2008 Olympics only four Asian countries were represented in the 29 strong Mens fleet and three in the 19 strong Womens fleet.

As an aside, only one race has ever been won at Olympic level by a Mixed crew at Olympic level when the 470 was an Open class. (1984 - GBR's Kathy Foster and Peter Newlands).

Again, if a second doublehander is required then why not be consistent with two other Events, in the second vote, and choose that Equipment by by evaluation rather than specification??

While the Events Committee have been forced into the trap set inadvertently for them by their Executive Committee, the ISAF Council which is the final arbiter has a recent history of ignoring the votes of the Events Committee.

Hopefully this trend will continue and a consistent approach to the Equipment for Events will be adopted.

While the lobbying will be frantic ahead of the ISAF Council deliberations and vote, the simple point is that this is not about who is the best lobbyist, who runs the best PR campaign, produces the best DVD or YouTube clip, or who is the most politically astute. It is about the people who aren't there, particularly the young sailors who they need classes they aspire to sail, and which will make them want to stay in sailing.

And that is not in boats that are beloved by the older generation.

PostScript: By our calculations, and assuming that the Mixed classes will both be helmed by female sailors (being less weight in the stern of the boat) then of a 16 strong team in all events, there will be a total of nine female place and seven male places. Of the helming positions there will be six women helming places and four male helming places.


The official release from the International Sailing Federation reads:

It was the most packed session we have had this week to hear the Events Committee’s recommendation on the provisional Olympic events and equipment for 2016.

This is how the voting went.

The Events Committee recommends:

Board or kite-board for men and women – equipment evaluation

One person dinghy men – Laser Standard

One person dinghy women – Laser Radial

Two person dinghy (skiff) men – 49er

Two person dinghy (skiff) women – equipment evaluation

Second one person dinghy men – Finn

Two person mixed multihull – equipment evaluation

Two person mixed dinghy with spinnaker – 470

Women’s keelboat – Elliott 6m

In so doing the committee’s voting recommends taking out the men’s keelboat. The second one person dinghy for women was the other option not to be selected.

The Committee’s recommendations are of course just that. They will go to the ISAF Council for consideration this weekend. After Council vote they are then subject to confirmation at the ISAF Mid-Year meeting in May 2011

Boatseekr_LeaderBoard_122 - BOTTOMSydney Boat Show 2025 - Apply to ExhibitV-DRY-X

Related Articles

Who made the right call to get to the breeze?
And how technology is changing the Transpac Race to Hawaii Boats racing in the 2025 Transpac continue to reel in the offshore miles toward the finish line off Honolulu, Hawaii, in the 53rd edition of this historic 2,225-nautical-mile race.
Posted today at 12:54 am
Collinson FX: July 9: Immunity builds
The constant threats and moving goalposts, are becoming tiresome and markets are building immunity. Markets absorbed the ever-changing dates, rules and margins, of US trade and tariff policy. The constant threats and moving goalposts, are becoming tiresome and markets are building immunity.
Posted on 8 Jul
British Classic Week Day 2
An early start for Classes 1-3 as they prepared to race around the Isle of Wight It was an early start for the British Classic Week fleet on day two, as Classes 1-3 prepared to race around the Isle of Wight.
Posted on 8 Jul
iQFOiL Worlds a Aarhus day 3
The leaderboard tightens at the halfway mark after today's racing in a building breeze After a frustrating day of waiting ashore on Monday, Day 3 brought back the action in Aarhus Bay with spectacular foiling conditions and a full day of intense racing.
Posted on 8 Jul
Fleet advances to the last half of the AEGEAN 600
In contrast to yesterday's slow pace, the rate of progress has been much improved Most of the fleet of 59 Monohulls and Multihulls who are sailing in this year's AEGEAN 600 have either already entered the second half of the race at the island of Rhodes or are well on their way to reaching this important milestone.
Posted on 8 Jul
Mediterranean Regatta season in full swing
A+T instruments seen all over Europe delivering high-level performance for racing fleets As regatta season gathers speed, A+T instruments were seen all over Europe delivering high-level performance for the racing fleets.
Posted on 8 Jul
International Moth Worlds at Lake Garda Day 1
Storm cells circling Lake Garda lead to atypical and tricky conditions The 137 sailors representing 25 nations faced the first day of racing in conditions that were anything but typical for Malcesine, with unstable weather creating a complex, yet exciting, opening.
Posted on 8 Jul
NYYC International Women's Championship update
Teammates and Competitors Join Forces The strength of bonds forged in competition is a common theme among the second group of skippers and teams invited to compete in the 2026 New York Yacht Club International Women's Championship.
Posted on 8 Jul
The Ocean Race Europe Video Preview
We speak to Phil Lawrence, Peter Rusch & Pip Hare to find out more The Ocean Race Europe will take place between 10 August & 21 September, following a debut event in the summer of 2021. The racing is in IMOCA yachts, the same as the Vendée Globe, but this time with 4 crew and an OBR who will document the action on board.
Posted on 8 Jul
Sailing's Glitterati prepare for the Admiral's Cup
The depth and quality of talent is truly breathtaking. The 2025 Admiral's Cup is shaping up to be one of the most compelling editions in the event's storied history, featuring a glittering constellation of the sport's elite.
Posted on 8 Jul