Please select your home edition
Edition
Zhik - New Gear Has Arrived

America's Cup - ISAF and Cup Jury summonsed by California Court

by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World .com on 9 Sep 2015
David Tillett second from right, with the other members of the 34th America’s Cup Jury (from left John Doerr, Graham McKenzie, Josje Hofland, and Bryan Willis) ACEA /Gilles Martin-Raget
The International Sailing Federation, the controlling body for world sailing, and the five individuals who made up the International Jury for the 34th America's Cup have been served with a Summons by a San Francisco Court.

The action has been brought by Matthew Mitchell (NZL) a former Oracle Team USA crewman who was one of five to be penalised by the International Jury after conducting an investigation and Hearings into allegations of boat tampering in the America's Cup World Series.

The papers were filed with the San Francisco Court last Friday.

The taking of civil court legal action against the ISAF and a Jury, is unprecedented, and could have deep ramifications in the sport - where ISAF certified and approved officials are involved in all forms of adjudication, on a voluntary basis, and usually without any insurance.

While disputes are common-place over Jury decisions, they have not been previously subject to civil court litigation of this nature.

The Summons lodged on September 4, with the US District Court for the Northern District of California based in San Francisco, names the International Sailing Federation, and five International Jury members, chairman David Tillett (AUS), Graham McKenzie (NZL), Josje Hofland (NED), John Doerr (GBR) and Bryan Willis (GBR/MAS). Four of the Jurors are the most experienced in the ISAF stable, having served at Olympic Games and America's Cup level going back into the late 1980's. All but McKenzie (a former partner of a leading NZ legal firm) are International Judges certified by the ISAF.

The claim centres around the premise that the Jury is a panel of five Arbitrators and seeks to have the Arbitration Award vacated.

It is also claimed that the Jury had ignored the law of scienter, which requires that an offending party must have knowledge of the 'wrongness' of an act or event prior to committing it.

Mitchell claims that he did not know that the changes to Kingposts and other modifications were illegal. He assumed because they were on a support team work-list, that they had been approved by the team's rules adviser and were, therefore, legal. The boats involved were AC45 wingsailed catamarans and were strict one-designs, and could not deviate from the class rules in any way.

The Jury decision in the measurement tampering, across four regattas, was announced only a few days before the start of the Match for the 34th America's Cup between Oracle Team USA and Emirates Team New Zealand.

Hearings were conducted, after an investigation by two Jury members, under the provisions of Racing Rule 69 Allegations of Gross Misconduct.

Two Oracle Team USA crew were suspended from racing. Wingsail trimmer Dirk de Ridder (NED) was excluded for the entire match. Mitchell (NZL)received a four-race exclusion. However, he was on the water in a chase boat. Oracle Team USA were fined $250,000 by the Int Jury.

De Ridder received an 18-month suspension from the sport after an Appeal to the Court for Arbitration for Sport. No further action was taken against Mitchell or any of the other crew by their national authorities who have post-event jurisdiction in such cases.


In February 2015, Mitchell issued a media release saying that he had filed complaints with the ISAF because the International Jury had not taken action against another former OTUSA crew member, Simeon Tienpont (NED) for his part in the boat tampering incidents.

A second OTUSA team member Joe Spooner has also taken action in the same Court over a claim relating to his termination from the team, when he claimed he had a signed contract running through to the 35th America's Cup in Bermuda.

Several sets of exhibits were filed with the Summons - several have previously been in the Court domain. However, a confidential contract between the International Sailing Federation and America's Cup Regatta Management was also included.

The contract reveals that the ISAF charged ACRM 800,000Euros for Jury services covering the America's Cup Match and its preliminaries, including the nine regattas that made up the America's Cup World Series.

In addition to their payment from the ISAF, the Jurors received a premium economy airfare to each regatta, accommodation and 30Euro as a per diem allowance - the travel and accommodation expenses are similar to the standard for all ISAF Jury members working on regattas from Optimists upwards. They were required to be available for eight days for each ACWS regatta (plus travel time) - anticipated to be 16 in number, and then be based in San Francisco from July to September 2013. The time requirements are such that it would be highly disruptive to most business/regular income and the Jurors were compensated for this loss of income, over the three year period.

Air travel costs were estimated at 145,000Euro over the three-year period.

America's Cup Regatta Management, a company, registered in St Helier, Jersey in the Channel Islands was also required to provide Professional Indemnity Insurance Cover of 10,000,000Euro for the International Jury.

There is no mention in the Summons of Matthew Mitchell seeking to make a claim under this policy if his case were successful, however if this were the outcome it would be expected that some financial compensation would be paid.

The ISAF and individual Jury members have 21 days to respond to the Summons.

A Hearing is scheduled for early December 2015, but may be settled with some form of Mediation beforehand.

North Sails Loft 57 PodcastExcess CatamaransRolly Tasker Sails 2023 FOOTER

Related Articles

Allocation of entries for the 29er Worlds in Kiel
All countries will be allocated a minimum of three entries The 29er Class has not restricted entries for the World or European Championships in the past but due to the expected popularity of the Worlds in 2026 in Kiel we feel it is necessary to do an Entry Allocation. This is very difficult to do fairly.
Posted today at 4:45 pm
Exiting new product for METS
A+T Instruments is proud to be supplying instruments for some of the most advanced yachts The marine world gathers at METS in Amsterdam. A+T is proud to be supplying instruments for some of the most advanced new-build yachts. Watch the video to see how we can help you with your next project.
Posted today at 4:00 pm
A Day at the Allen Factory!
New and innovative products, cutting-edge manufacturing techniques The Allen factory, based in Southminster, Essex in the UK, makes many of the deck hardware and fittings that we use in our sailing, be that on dinghies or keelboats.
Posted today at 11:00 am
2025 Aloha Classic Grand Final day 2
The battle intensifies as the world's best close in on the crown Perfect trade-wind conditions returned to Ho'okipa today for Day 2 of the 2025 Aloha Classic Grand Final, delivering a full day of 5 Star competition as both the men's and women's draws charged toward Finals Day.
Posted today at 10:12 am
Fireball World Champion interview
Yves Mermod and Maja Siegenthaler talk about their Olympic journey too After their close fought win at the Fireball Worlds in Garda we caught up with the Champions Yves Mermod and Maja Siegenthaler to find out a bit more about their Olympic journey and why and how they ended up competing for a Fireball Worlds in 2025.
Posted today at 9:05 am
Sam Haynes eyes third Rolex Sydney Hobart win
The CYCA Commodore and defending champion will return for the race's 80th edition Sam Haynes, Commodore of the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia (CYCA) and defending Overall champion of the Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race, will return for the race's 80th edition.
Posted today at 6:27 am
The International Masters Regatta renamed
To honor late founder, Don Trask The 2025 International Masters Regatta, which as of October 14, 2025 has been officially renamed the Don Trask International Masters Regatta, is set to return to San Diego Yacht Club October 17-19.
Posted today at 5:57 am
Sydney to Auckland Ocean Race Day 6
Counting down the miles The Sydney to Auckland Ocean Race (S2A) is now into its fifth day and the crews of two boats are counting down the miles to the finish line as they look forward to arriving into Auckland, thoughts turn to what they will do on arrival.
Posted today at 12:12 am
America's Cup: ACP's Brave New World
A look at the still secret Brave New World now in place for the America's Cup It is often said that you read a new set of rules twice. The first time to see what they say, and a second much longer read, to see what isn't said. This is our analysis from the second read of the media statement issued Wednesday.
Posted on 15 Oct
Yachting Malta Coastal Race
A perfect prelude to the 46th Rolex Middle Sea Race The Yachting Malta Coastal Race, organised by the Royal Malta Yacht Club, provided a thrilling variety of conditions for an international fleet — a fitting appetizer ahead of the 46th Rolex Middle Sea Race.
Posted on 15 Oct