Please select your home edition
Edition
Barton Marine 2019 728x90

Olympic Sailing- New multihull analysis asks hard questions of ISAF

by Richard Gladwell and UKCRA on 4 Nov 2010
There will be no Multihull event at the 2012 Olympic regatta in Weymouth Richard Gladwell www.photosport.co.nz

Just over a week before the start of the International Sailing Federation's Annual Meeting in Athens, Greece the vociferous UK Catamaran Racing Association has issued an analysis, which not surprisingly makes a strong case for the inclusion of a Multihull Event in the 2016 Olympic Sailing Regatta.

Three years ago, at the same conference in Estoril, Portugal, the various Olympic class politicians lobbied for a retention of their nearest and dearest. The multihulls were caught unawares, and the outcome was that the Multihull Event, and the spectacular Tornado catamaran, were bumped off the Olympic bus.

That decision has proved to be a major embarrassment for the world's governing body, particularly when the rest of the sailing world moved towards multihull sailing - including the 33rd America's Cup, and now the 34th America's Cup. The 2010 America's Cup was sailed in massive 120ft multihulls, and the 2013 event will use the AC45 class for preliminary competition and the AC72 class for the America's Cup itself.

While the decision to exclude the Multihull Event for the 2012 Olympic regatta in Weymouth, has been to the continual embarrassment of the ISAF, to its credit the world body established a review group, the Olympic Commission to look at a number of issues with the Olympic sailing regatta.

The OC has reported back twice to the ISAF and its first report essentially told the sailing world that the prognosis for its Olympic regatta was terminal, unless radical change was made.

Again to its credit the Executive Committee of the ISAF backed the findings of the Olympic Commission and the first round of voting for the shape of the 2016 Olympic Regatta and beyond will take place next week in Greece.


The lead-up to the 2007 decisions on Olympic events and its aftermath was a period of bitter acrimony as the disparate multihull class associations got organised and lobbied furiously, producing some very good analysis of the situation as they saw it.

The key to the multihull argument was that as an event, and major discliple of sailing they had been excluded in favour of retaining three snglehanded events and retaining three doublehanded events.

That led a number of countries to propose that in future the Olympics should reflect the major disciplines of the sport and that there should be some gender balance towards maybe five events each for Men and Women covering the five major disciplines of sailing - singlehanded, doublehanded, windsurfer, keelboat and multihull.

The Olympic Commission while not fully endorsing the concepts, went well down the path and its recommendations have been picked up by the ISAF's Executive Committee in two key submissions to the Annual Meeting on the Events for 2016 and beyond.


The first of those submissions recommends the establishment of an initial group of six Core Events which can be changed only at 10 years notice and before then with a 66% majority vote from the ISAF Council. Up to eight Core Events may be established. The other Events will be for one Olympic cycle only (but may be rolled over of course). All Events must be established six years before the Olympic Regatta.

'With its ration of only 10 Olympic medal events ISAF faces extremely difficult decisions as to which events to choose', notes the report from the UKCRA. 'Making the wrong decisions could even jeopardise the position of Sailing as a sport within the Games in the new era of competition between sports.

'The decision to take multi-hulls out of the 2012 Games produced a furore the like of which has not been seen before in sailing – and with up to 25% of the sailing public involved in multi-hulls this was hardly surprising.


'Much anger was also garnered concerning the clear demonstration by certain ISAF council members of the vested interests of their nations rather than keeping to their remit of making sure that their decisions were in the interest of sailing as a whole.

'Over the past four years much debate and discussion has thus rightly been held on the correct choices for the future – choices that need to include what appear as conflicting elements, viz. representation, TV and media appeal rather than tradition – which sad choice last time around led to the Games continuing to keep a nearly 100 year old design sailed by a tiny portion of the sailing world and exclude the fastest and most exciting craft on the water today.


'We acknowledge that it is an extremely difficult task to achieve the right balance. With five specific skills, (1 Person Dinghy, 2 Person Dinghy, Keelboat, Multi-hull and Windsurfer), two sexes and two weight categories, it would need 20 Events.

'If it eliminated duplication and weight categories, the problem would be solved with one Event each for men and one for women in five distinct disciplines, namely One Person Dinghy, Two Person Dinghy, Keelboat, Multi-hull and Windsurfer. This in our view is the correct apportioning of the events.

'There is however an alternative suggestion that would permit another permutation that includes 2 mixed sex events, and UKCRA can also support this approach - as we suggested it in our original Report - albeit with less enthusiasm than expressed for the 5:5.'

To read the full text www.sail-world.com/files/ISAF_Report_Oct2010.pdf!click_here

Selden 2020 - FOOTERExposure MarineTrofeo Princesa Sofía Mallorca 2025

Related Articles

McIntyre Mini Globe Race fleet battles Pacific
In historic 4,300-mile test of endurance Solo Sailors Face Doldrums, Equipment Failures and Avian Invaders in Unprecedented Small Boat Challenge - week five of leg 2
Posted on 30 Apr
Don't Risk Your Keys on the Water!
Keep them safe and dry in a Vaikobi Car Key Lock Box Don't risk taking your keys on the water... keep them safe and dry in a Vaikobi Car Key Lock Box.
Posted on 30 Apr
21st Sandberg PalmaVela kicks off tomorrow
With the spectacle of the Maxis in Palma Over one hundred teams representing 19 nationalities will gather in the Bay of Palma for the first major multi-class event of the season: the 21st Sandberg PalmaVela. The impressive Maxis will be the first to take the stage.
Posted on 30 Apr
52 SUPER SERIES Saint-Tropez Cup Day 1
Light winds prove insufficient to start racing Although the 11 boat fleet went afloat until mid-afternoon, crews filled with hope and anticipation, the wind refused to build enough for racing to take place on the first day of the new 52 SUPER SERIES season at the 52 SUPER SERIES Saint-Tropez Cup.
Posted on 30 Apr
Transat Paprec Day 11
The Battle of the Leaders Now past the halfway point and sailing through the heart of the Atlantic, the competitors in the Transat Paprec are still locked in an intense battle. A windless zone expected later this week is drawing everyone's attention and forcing tough decisions.
Posted on 30 Apr
International 5o5 Euro Cup Leg 1 at Saint Raphael
Sailors from seven countries descended on the South of France 505's from seven countries descended on St Raphael in the South of France for event 1 of the 505 2025 Euro Cup circuit. Many boats arrived early to knock off the winter rust and enjoy the warmer weather and good food the area has to offer.
Posted on 30 Apr
Pip Hare joins Canada Ocean Racing
Sailing alongside Canadian skipper Scott Shawyer for The Ocean Race Europe Canada Ocean Racing is excited to announce that British offshore sailor Pip Hare will join their Be Water Positive campaign for the 2025 edition of The Ocean Race Europe.
Posted on 30 Apr
Antigua Race Week Day 3
Superb racing delivered Sailors ranging from newcomers to veterans of multiple America's Cup campaigns enjoyed Caribbean sailing at its best in today's racing at Antigua Sailing Week, with lots of sun and moderate tradewinds of 10-12 knots.
Posted on 30 Apr
Saint-Tropez set 52 SUPER SERIES season opener
Crioula and Vayu won today's short, sharp warm-up practice races In a light breeze which reached 10kts at the most - a foretaste of what is forecast for the coming days on the Gulf of Saint-Tropez - Crioula and Vayu won today's short, sharp warm-up practice races.
Posted on 29 Apr
La Larga comes to a close
With the prize-giving ceremony at the RCNP The Real Club Náutico de Palma (RCNP) held the prize-giving ceremony for La Larga this Tuesday, 29 April, at 19h00.
Posted on 29 Apr