Please select your home edition
Edition
Switch One Design

Gladwell's Line- America's Cup - the Riddle of the Rudders

by Richard Gladwell on 26 Nov 2009
BMW Oracle Racing Photo Gilles Martin-Raget http://www.bmworacleracing.com

After today's Hearing in the Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court, the Challenger for the America's Cup stated that the inclusion of rudders in the crucial Load Waterline length measurement would disqualify GGYC's yacht.

Calculations by Sail-World from photos show that the length of BOR90, as the Challenger has been known to date, would extend to around 98ft, if the rudder on the outer float, or ama, were included in the length measurement, as argued by Societe Nautique de Geneve.

In one of 14 points that the New York Supreme Court has been asked to rule in the two year legal tragi-comedy that has been the lot of the America's Cup, Justice Shirley Kornreich ruled in late October that rudders would not be included in the vexed Load Waterline Length measurement, which is peculiar to the America's Cup. That ruling was not accepted by the Defender who Appealed in early November.


The 19th century Deed of Gift for the America's Cup prescribes that if of one mast the competing yachts shall not be less than 44ft nor more than 90ft on the load waterline. The Deed does not specify how Load Waterline Length should be measured. It is over to the organising club/Defender to specify how that should be done, when the match is being conducted without Mutual Consent - as was done in 1988 for the Big Boat Challenge (or MisMatch) between the catamaran of San Diego yacht club and the 130ft monohull of Mercury Bay Boating Club (New Zealand).

On 6 August 2009, Societe Nautique de Geneve issued rules for the measurement of the yachts which included the rudder in the length measurement.


The first of the seven rules covering measurement, issued by SNG, stated:

'For the purposes of measurement, the 'length on load water line' is the distance between a line perpendicular to the yacht’s centre line and passing through the furthest forward point of intersection of the yacht with its water-line plane, and a line perpendicular to the yacht’s centre line and passing through the aftermost point of intersection of the yacht with its water line plane.'


While the rule's language is complex, the measurement practice is simple.

With the yacht, floating in still water, and with all the required gear on board, the measurer marks the point where the yacht's hull meets the water at its forward point. He/she then moves to the yachts stern and puts a second mark at the point where the hull exits the water.

Standing on deck, maybe with the use of a plumbline or similar device the measurer will extend the waterline up to deck level, as a measuring convenience, and will measure between the forward and aftermost points.

That distance, between the two points, must not exceed 90ft.


Because she is a trimaran, BMW Oracle Racing have been able to 'cheat' the measurement length rule by having a main hull which measures less the the 90ft Load Waterline Length. However her design team ave cleverly designed her two outer hulls/floats/amas so that they sit just clear of the water when in measurement mode. They 'kiss' the water at their centrepoint - enough to comply with the maximum waterline beam measurement, but no more - and most of the length the ama does not touch the water.

('Cheat' is measurement and maybe design slang, for a way in which the designers have developed a design feature to meet a measurement point. But clearly if measured while a sailing a much longer measurement would come into play. Overhangs are a good example of 'cheats', as are knuckle bows, and bumping the hull in the International Offshore Rule days. There is nothing illegal about the 'cheats' and they are usually recognised as innovative design, and give speed advantage. With the passing of time, history generally treats such yachts kindly, terming them 'rule-beaters'.)

BOR90's amas are estimated to be around 110ft long or more, and increase the sailing length and potentially the speed of the trimaran when immersed.

At face value the rule announced by SNG includes rudders, the effect of this measurement dictate is that the measurer would still take the same forward measurement point (where the bow of BOR90 entered the water), but the aft measurement point would move from the main hull exit/intersection point, to the point where the back edge of the rudder on the ama of BOR90 left/intersected with the water - increasing the measured length by some eight feet, and putting the Challenger out of the America's Cup.

The SNG measurement system looks at the multihull yacht as a platform, not three separate hulls of which the centre one is used for LWL measurement. With this platform approach, a catamaran and trimaran can be consistently measured.


Of course, Alinghi 5, is subject to the same platform measurement rules. Because she is a catamaran her two hulls are of equal length. Her designers have been able to use the same 'cheat' as BOR90 in that a substantial part of her hull(s) forward sections overhang the water when in measurement mode, and such are not 'seen' for measurement purposes. Of course, in sailing mode the overhanging length soon becomes immersed and becomes effective sailing length. It is believed the two yachts are of similar sailing length.


Alinghi 5 has her rudders positioned just forward of the transom of her two 'main' hulls, and aftermost hull measurement point would be close to the intersection of her transom with the water, and not her rudder, as they are immersed.

What's the point?

Simply that if SNG can enforce their interpretation, then BOR90 will be measured out of the Match, as she exceeds the length permitted by the Deed of Gift, and this excess length would appear to be a margin of 8ft.

It would not be possible to move the rudders forward to fall within the length measurement, and Alinghi 5 would win the Match by default.

The Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court reserved their judgment in the matter.

For a previous Sail-World commentary on this Waterline length issue, published two months ago, http://www.sail-world.com/NZ/index.cfm?SEID=2&Nid=61713&SRCID=0&ntid=0&tickeruid=0&tickerCID=0!click_here




Mackay Boats 728x90 BOTTOMCyclops Marine 2023 November - FOOTERDoyle_SailWorld_728X90px_SY BOTTOM

Related Articles

An emotional evening in Les Sables d'Olonne
Les Sables d'Olonne lit up to celebrate the heroes of the Vendée Globe 2024-2025 On Saturday 10 May, Les Sables d'Olonne lit up to celebrate the heroes of the Vendée Globe 2024-2025. An exceptional evening brought together tens of thousands of people, with strong emotions and unforgettable memories, despite the driving rain.
Posted today at 6:34 am
The Swan Bonifacio Challenge concludes in style
The opening event of The Nations League 2025 wraps up with tight racing After four days of spirited competition and a vibrant week both on and off the water, the curtain closes on the Swan Bonifacio Challenge, the inaugural event of the 2025 Nations League by ClubSwan Racing.
Posted on 10 May
iQFOiL Youth & Junior International Games overall
Valentino Blewett and Medea Falcioni win in the U19 fleets; Brüll and Ugurlu top the U17 categories The iQFOiL Youth & Junior International Games concluded in Torbole, Lake Garda, with the debut of the eight-rider experimental Medal Series format—featuring only semifinals and finals—after five days of intense and exciting racing.
Posted on 10 May
Pyewacket 70 & Kialoa III: Comparing two legends
Today Pyewacket 70, a modified Volvo 70, is one of the fastest 70 footers around Antigua Sailing Week 2025 was attended by two top-end offshore racing yachts from very different times.
Posted on 10 May
IMOCA and 11th Hour Racing to continue partnership
Advancing Sustainability and Leadership Initiatives The International Monohull Open Class Association (IMOCA) has renewed its partnership with 11th Hour Racing for the 2025 season.
Posted on 10 May
New Loft 57 Podcast Episode Live Now
Featuring Vendée Globe winner Charlie Dalin, Ken Read, and Guillaume Verdier Loft 57, the North Sails Podcast, offers exclusive access to the biggest names in sailing. Our newest episode features Vendée Globe winner Charlie Dalin, North Sails President Ken Read, and naval architect Guillaume Verdier.
Posted on 9 May
iQFOiL Youth & Junior International Games day 4
Sprint Slalom takes center stage in Torbole The penultimate day was all about Sprint Slalom. Despite a light southerly breeze, the wind remained steady throughout the afternoon, allowing all fleets to efficiently complete a full round of Sprint Racing heats.
Posted on 9 May
Join August's celebration of Flying Fifteens
Enter now for the Flying Fifteen World, International and National Championships The Weymouth & Portland National Sailing Academy 'WPSNA' will be hosting three championships in one with the UK Nationals and Pre-Worlds and the World and International Championships between 10th-21st August.
Posted on 9 May
XR 41 Dominates at MaiOR Regatta
Racing Renaissance in Kiel The all-new XR 41 "Formula X" secured a resounding debut victory, reviving X-Yachts' competitive legacy and energising a vibrant international racing fleet.
Posted on 9 May
World Sailing Annual Conference & Awards preview
This will be the second time the town has hosted a World Sailing Annual Conference. The coastal destination of Dún Laoghaire has been chosen to host the 2025 World Sailing Annual Conference and World Sailing Awards from 3-8 November 2025, bringing together over 400 international delegates.
Posted on 9 May