Please select your home edition
Edition
Cyclops Marine 2023 November - LEADERBOARD

Commentary- Blame the NY court system for Cup's legal malaise

by Damian Christie on 30 Sep 2009
The current legal impasse would have be obviated had Ciparick’s Decision in 1988 been upheld by the New York Court of Appeal BMW Oracle Racing Photo Gilles Martin-Raget http://www.bmworacleracing.com

The America’s Cup is in a legal deadlock now not just because of the intransigence of its Swiss masters and the American challenger, but also because of the erroneous rulings that the New York court system made two decades ago on the outcome of the 1988 catamaran/big boat mismatch.

It has always been my opinion that Judge Ciparick got it absolutely right in her March 1989 ruling that proposed disqualifying the San Diego Yacht Club for its use of a catamaran against New Zealand’s monohull challenger in the Cup match. On that occasion she ruled that a broad reading of the notice of challenge provision in the Deed of Gift strongly indicated that the Cup donor had intended that the defending yacht would relate in some way to the challenger’s specifications, and therefore the boats would be similar and, as she put it, 'somewhat evenly matched'. Notwithstanding the fact that the Deed uses no express language to promulgate that the competing boats must be alike, it is ridiculous to assume that this would not have been George Schuyler’s intention.

Mr Schuyler himself confirmed as much when he spoke about the third drafting of the Deed in the interview he gave to the New York Times in May 1890: 'The main reason we ask for the load waterline length, draught of water, beam at the waterline and extreme beam is to know what kind of a vessel we have to meet. I believe the challenged party has a right to know what the yacht challenging is like, so it can meet her with a yacht of its own type if it is so desired.'
The fact that the Deed explicitly specifies that the challenger’s 'dimensions shall not be exceeded' is consistent with Mr Schuyler’s comments – it was always his intention that the defender would build a comparable yacht to the challenger (ie of similar size and dimensions, such as the prominent sailing boats of the time such as cutters and schooners), thereby securing a fair contest.

It would also give the defender recourse to disqualify the challenger for exceeding the specified dimensions because it could argue it had built a boat to the notice of challenge specifications in good faith, eg if a challenger had nominated a LWL of 60 feet in its notice of challenge, the defender had built a yacht of 60 feet LWL but the challenger had turned up with a boat that was 90 feet LWL, then surely the New York Yacht Club would have had reasonable grounds to disqualify the challenger.

Even allowing for Mr Schuyler’s statements that 'we would be content to meet the challenger [whose LWL is 90 feet] with a boat four feet shorter' and that the defender would meet the challenger with a comparable yacht 'if it is so desired' (an unfortunate turn of phrase in my opinion that does not in any way imply his endorsement of a future catamaran defence!), it is both ridiculous and illogical for both the courts and Golden Gate Yacht Club and Société Nautique de Genève to conclude that it was his intention that the Cup could be contested by such radically different vessels, whether that be a catamaran vs a monohull or a catamaran vs a trimaran.

As Judge Ciparick concluded in her 1989 ruling, the notice of challenge provisions would be 'rendered meaningless' if the defender could respond with any yacht or vessel whose measurements did not relate to those of the challenger.
By that logic, for example, would it have mattered if in 1988 the KZ1 big boat had been ruled to be 92 feet LWL when the US catamaran was only 60 feet? How could that have been such a massive disadvantage for the defender when they were not even sailing (by choice) an identical, or inferior, boat?

Similarly, it is ludicrous for SNG to be arguing in its latest court submission that GGYC’s yacht must 'match' the dimensions in its notice of challenge – ie 90 feet LWL by 90 feet beam on load waterline- when its own yacht, also designed to the maximum LWL and BLW, is so radically different again. Even the way SNG is deviously proposing to measure the yachts (including rudders and other appendages in the LWL) is inconsistent with Mr Schuyler’s vision – it is likely another reason the challenging yacht’s dimensions were requested in advance was so there could be no confusion or illusion about the way in which the contesting yachts would be measured. Yet SNG is expecting GGYC’s yacht – a trimaran - to comply with a measurement system that is blatantly biased towards its catamaran.

The simple fact is that the New York court system got it wrong two decades ago when it upheld the outcome of the 1988 Cup defence – and both the America’s Cup and sailing in general are paying the price for it today. The New York court today is required to abide by an erroneous precedent that has merely opened up a legal can of worms for SNG and GGYC’s lawyers to exploit. The language in the Deed of Gift is quite simple and logical in a broad reading (especially when you consider the historical factors behind some of the clauses), yet the New York courts’ insistence on a literal interpretation of the Deed has meant that the lawyers of both parties have sought to stretch some of its more ambiguous statements (eg 'having', 'exceeded') beyond credulity.

Damian Christie, Melbourne, Australia
Rooster 2025North Sails Loft 57 PodcastAllen Sailing

Related Articles

29er Class open for championship bids
Inviting venues to submit proposals for the events The 29er Class Association is delighted to announce that bids are now open to host our upcoming major championships.
Posted today at 8:32 am
Switch UK Championship at the WPNSA Day 1
Finn Dickinson leads Sam Whaley by a single point Imagine stepping in to the Dolorian and arriving at the first ever National Championship of your class. Would those present be aware that they were in the throws of making history and how long in to the future will this journey take us?
Posted today at 5:51 am
2025 J/70 Corinthian Worlds at Massachusetts day 3
Light winds lead to leaderboard shake-up Mild breeze combined with a strong tide equaled a shake-up in the standings at the J/70 Corinthian World Championship in Marblehead, Massachusetts USA.
Posted on 26 Sep
2025 Formula Wing Worlds Sardinia day 3
Women's battle heats up in the big waves A change of wind and wave conditions on day three of the Formula Wing World Championships in Cagliari brought a change of fortune for some key players.
Posted on 26 Sep
52 Super Series 2025 Porto Cervo day 4
Sled look to close out regatta win, American Magic Quantum Racing on the cusp of swansong 7th title The penultimate day of racing proved to be a sharp contrast to the two previous days of strong Mistral winds presenting the 13 teams from ten different nations with a different challenge as the conclusion of the 2025 season approaches.
Posted on 26 Sep
Melges 24 Worlds 2025 at Trieste, Italy Day 4
No wind again today, everything will be decided tomorrow The high-pressure system over the Northern Adriatic, and particularly the Gulf of Trieste, left no chance for the 2025 Melges 24 World Championship today, as Day 4 ended without racing.
Posted on 26 Sep
Multihull Cup 2025 Day 1
Allegra takes win in calm but enthusiastic start On what proved a mellow if challenging introduction to the delights of the Multihull Cup for the trio of first timers taking part, it was the Mallorcan event veteran Allegra which showed the fleet the way to go.
Posted on 26 Sep
Offshore Double Handed Worlds Qualifying Race 2
Worlds Apart, Side by Side The second qualification race of the 2025 Offshore Double Handed Worlds started from Cowes, Isle of Wight in a crisp northeasterly, 10 knots under clear skies. But what began as a gentle gradient breeze soon turned into a punishing test of endurance.
Posted on 26 Sep
Les Voiles de Saint-Tropez starts tomorrow
245 competitors vying for 19 trophies Saturday 27 September heralds the start of the 27th edition of Les Voiles de Saint-Tropez. A great many of the Société Nautique de Saint-Tropez's 245 guests have already made the famous port in France's Var department.
Posted on 26 Sep
Sailors shift focus to The Ocean Race Atlantic
The new transatlantic race connects two iconic cities - New York and Barcelona As The Ocean Race Europe came to a close in Montenegro, sailors and teams started to turn their attention to the next event in The Ocean Race calendar - The Ocean Race Atlantic: New York to Barcelona.
Posted on 26 Sep