Please select your home edition
Edition
MySail 2025

Charter boat finance made simple

by Jardine Media on 18 May 2009
Maritimo C60 Sports Cabriolet 2008 Maritimo . http://www.maritimo.com.au
Chartering your boat can be a great option, provided you get proper financial and legal advice about what to expect in terms of likely income and tax obligations. We spoke to Mark O’Donoghue from specialist boat finance company Finlease about some common charter vessel scenarios and discuss recent changes to tax law that could impact on your decision to charter. Finlease will have an office on site at both the Sanctuary Cove (Thursday 21st May-Sunday 24th May) and Sydney International Boat Show (Thursday 30th July-Monday 3rd August).

Please note that individual circumstances vary widely so it’s important to obtain proper legal, financial and tax advice from your lawyer, financial advisor and the ATO; this article is intended as a brief introduction to the topic and is not to be read in lieu of professional advice.

The first thing to understand about chartering your boat is that the tax law is not designed to subsidise the private use of a pleasure vessel. The law allows you to claim certain deductions if you can prove that your vessel is a business; it won’t allow you to claim the costs of keeping your boat if it’s being used purely for recreation.

Generally speaking to prove that your boat is a business you need to show that the boat is at the ‘heart of the enterprise’ or at the centre of business activities. There’s a good summary of the tests the ATO applies to determine whether boat hire arrangements amount to the carrying out of a business at the following link:

http://www.ato.gov.au/businesses/content.asp?doc=/content/34224.htm

Most lay people would say that defining a business is a relatively straightforward affair. If an enterprise is designed to make you money, and it’s likely to do so either now or at some time in the not too distance future, then there’s a good chance that you’ve got a commercial operation on your hands.

(A 30% Investment Allowance is available as an incentive where a boat can be demonstrated to be for business purposes. This Investment Allowance is currently before the Senate for final sign off and will be applicable to new boats ordered prior to 30 June 2009 and delivered prior to 30 June 2010, please see the following link:-)

http://www.treasury.gov.au/documents/1505/PDF/Small%20Business%20FAQ%202.pdf

However the definition of a business, for the purposes of taxation law, becomes more complex in the grey area between a hobby that generates income and a fully fledged commercial enterprise.

Tax law gets interesting in the situation where someone owns a boat, they derive charter income from it, but for some reason they can’t satisfy the ATO’s definition of a business. For example: their vessel may only be chartered for a few days a year, it may earn little income, or there may be a significant disproportion between income and running costs.

Up until recently, if a boat owner derived income from their boat, but couldn’t prove that they were engaged in a bona fide business, then the law said that they couldn’t offset deductions against this income. This meant that the owner wasn’t able to reduce their tax liability by claiming deductions for the costs of running the boat. (Note: not all the costs of keeping, operating and maintaining a charter vessel are allowable deductions- please seek advice from the ATO and/or your tax advisor).

In July of 2007 this situation changed following an amendment to taxation legislation: see Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 – section 26.47: Non-business boating activities. The change to the law followed an intense period of lobbying by industry action group CBISC (Charter Boat Industry Survival Campaign.)

The CBISC campaign was established in 2002 and spearheaded by Finlease’s Mark O’Donoghue who, recognising the substantial threat to the charter industry that the ATO’s interpretation of existing tax law represented, effectively disengaged from his business for 18 months while changes to the law were being debated. He emerged from the process an acknowledged expert in charter boat finance, with an extremely detailed understanding of the needs and obligations of the industry:

‘We’ve lived and breathed this thing for nearly ten years, and really more expertly for the last seven or so… We can’t advise our clients, that’s not our role. But what we can do is make it very simple for them to understand what is available on the market, what they need to think about when it comes to buying a charter boat, and what outcomes they should expect.’

The law now says that if you can’t prove that you are engaged in a charter business which passes all of the tests of a business as prescribed by the ATO, you can still claim some deductions to offset against this income. However if your deductions are higher than your income, you can’t claim them all in one financial year; allowable deductions in excess of your boat income are ‘quarantined’ and in some circumstances may be claimed in later financial years.

Here’s an example from the legislation:

‘Carrying forward and deducting a quarantined amount:

Ian owns a boat which he leases to a charter operator. In Year 1, Ian has available $100,000 in deductions relating to his income-earning boating activities, including interest, depreciation, running costs and management fees. He earns only $40,000 income from leasing the boat. Therefore he can only deduct $40,000. The remaining $60,000 is carried forward to Year 2 (the quarantined amount).

In Year 2, Ian has $95,000 of boating deductions and no income from the boat. Provided the deductions are otherwise allowable, the quarantined amount will accumulate to $155,000 and be carried forward to Year 3. Ian cannot claim any of the $95,000 of boating deductions in Year 2.

In Year 3, Ian has $60,000 of boating deductions and $150,000 of income from the boat. The deductions from Year 3 plus the quarantined amount from Year 2 adds up to $215,000. Therefore, Ian can claim a deduction of $150,000 and carry forward $65,000 to Year 4.’


(Note: there are certain exceptions with regard to quarantined deductions. We again recommend the advisability of obtaining professional advice and contacting the ATO).

O’Donoghue commented that the change to the law introduced greater certainty for people involved in charter operations and he believes that a properly financed charter boat can be an extremely attractive option. Here are two real life examples he uses to illustrate the range of charter opportunities.

In the first example a client buys a new boat and puts it into an established Whitsunday charter fleet.

‘The boat’s going to work 25-28 weeks per year, it’s going to gross income in excess of $120,000 and it’s going to provide a net income to the owner of maybe $35,000. If the boat is geared sensibly- in other words not 100% financed, maybe 70% financed- then there’s a very good prospect that they are going to have a business in its proper sense with all of the benefits of deductabilities and depreciations. They can look at it very much like an investment in property with similar negative gearing implications…’

In the second example, a client offers an older model boat for charter in a regional waterway within driving distance of their Sydney home.

‘It’s really only going to be doing 80 days a year maximum. It might only gross $60,000 per year and it might only net to the owner $15,000 per year. In that instance, trying to 100% gear a brand new boat is never going to pass muster from a fully blown business point of view. But it may produce a wonderful hobby based business.’

‘Instead of getting all your negative gearing implications, what you are going to get is a boat which is going to have all the costs of insurance, marina berths and maintenance covered as a part of the bus

X-Yachts X4.3Vaikobi 2024 DecemberZhik 2024 December

Related Articles

Hyde Sails Flying Fifteen Video Tuning Guide
Ben McGrane explains how to get the most out of your B1 mainsail with B1 or 2H jibs Hyde Sails release new detailed video guide for tuning the Flying 15 for use with the B1 mainsail with B1 or 2H jibs.
Posted on 22 May
Gladwell's Line: - May 22 - A big month
Kiwi's loss is Italy's gain - our thoughts on the hosting debacle. Kiwi's loss is Italy's gain - our thoughts on the hosting debacle. Paul Whiting's tribute - 45yrs on. Surprise winner of biggest ever two-handed nationals. Chalkie Bland remembered.
Posted on 22 May
Puget Sound sailing, Etchells, J/70s, Cup news
Seeking Goldilocks conditions on Puget Sound, Etchells NAs, J/70 U.S. Nationals, AC38 news As the saying goes, 'you don't know unless you go'. While I've mostly heard this phrase applied to climbing, skiing, and mountaineering, four late-winter and springtime races on Puget Sound this year exemplified the fact that this line.
Posted on 20 May
The appeal of offshore
Is there still appeal? Have we made it too onerous? Why would someone take it up now? I had been pondering. Yes. Marquee events have no issue attracting entrants. Middle Sea, Transpac, Cape to Rio, Fastnet, and Hobart all spring to mind instantly, but what of the ‘lesser' races? Lots of boats in pens (slips) a lot of the time
Posted on 18 May
Banger Racing, Back Racing and No Racing
Racing on the cheap, a return to racing for young Aussies, and ILCA struggles We start with racing on the cheap at the Colander Cup, then focus on a return to racing for the Aussies at the Youth Worlds, moving on to a complete lack of racing at the ILCA Worlds, and then looking at how SailGP should be back out on the water.
Posted on 14 May
Night sailing, Transat Paprec, Congressional Cup
Night sailing, encountering light airs in the Transat Paprec, Congressional Cup We bundled up as the last of the rays sunlight dipped below the Olympic Mountains and night quietly fell on Puget Sound. We'd been racing for about twelve hours in the Seattle Yacht Club's Protection Island Race (April 26), and we were getting tired.
Posted on 6 May
For the love of slightly larger, even faster boats
Bring it on. No chicken chutes allowed. Celestial, the newest Cape 31 in Oz is up and racing Thank you. You have let For the love of small, fast boats run before the breeze like a superlight planning hull under way too big a kite, with immense sheep in the paddock, and the Sailing Master grasping the flare gun in his pocket... No chicken chutes.
Posted on 4 May
The Allure of Timber
The longevity, and sheer beauty, of boats made of wood In these days of exotic materials, high modulus carbon and ultra lightweight construction, it's possible to overlook the longevity, and sheer beauty, of boats made of wood.
Posted on 29 Apr
A look inside the Spirit Yachts yard
A close look at what makes their yachts unique Traditional skills in boatbuilding could be regarded as a lost art from a bygone era. In the world of fibreglass and carbon, the joinery and laminating techniques of wood ribs and cedar strips are a thing of the past.
Posted on 28 Apr
Transat Paprec, Classics, US Sailing, Cup news
Some parts of North America are experiencing a faster approach of spring's warm tidings than others While some parts of North America are experiencing a faster approach of spring's warm tidings than others, the offshore racing action is plenty hot in the Transat Paprec.
Posted on 22 Apr