Please select your home edition
Edition
Selden 2020 - LEADERBOARD

Canting Keel failures

by Don Jones on 19 Jan 2006
Skandia in Bass Strait - 2004 Rolex Sydney to Hobart Rolex/Daniel Forster http://www.regattanews.com
Given the spate of recent problems experienced by yachts taking part in the Volvo Ocean Race which has sparked off a very public debate on the causes of the problems, and what should be done about them (particularly as it relates to the safety of crews and the good of yachting). Unfortunately thus far, much of the comment is ill informed and as a result there seems to be more heat than light being produced. I felt it would be helpful to put pen to paper.

I divide the main problems being experienced as, firstly, structural and, secondly, hydraulic. They are separate but to a considerable extent related.

While the structural detail of the boats may vary considerably and I am not privy to the detailed design of boats other than ING Real Estate Brunel, they were all designed and built to the requirements of the one Rule. While the Rule is short on in specific requirements, it clearly did not anticipate the dynamic loads which can and are applied to the hulls at the speeds they have been found to be capable of. That is, they are too fast for their strength. In particular high dynamic loading while running is a fairly new experience. This suggests the question; why were they not designed stronger?

The answer to this is in two parts, firstly I doubt that the designers realised the full potential speeds of the boats and even if they did the maximum weight imposed by the Rule prevented added structural weight if a bulb of adequate weight to meet the Rule stability requirements was fitted. We in our team realised the danger of the maximum weight rule which we branded 'the suicide rule.' I do not doubt that other teams shared similar concerns.

It may be that some local strengthening of the boats is possible at stops between legs however if design standards for sending crews to sea in these boats require a safety factor of at least 2:1 (say) then clearly some or probably all of the present hulls are hopelessly inadequate.

Turning to the failure of hydraulic components of the keel systems I draw on experience with the three different keels and hydraulic systems which have been fitted to Skandia Wild Thing and the keel and its associated system on ING Real Estate Brunel.



The failure of the cylinder rods on Skandia in the 2004 Rolex Sydney to Hobart race has been well documented previously and I will not repeat this here. Since then the systems on the two boats have been well instrumented and load measurements have been taken in widely varying weather conditions and many hours of sailing.

These measurements have indicated that loading in bad weather and high speeds has produced no surprises on the high side and we cannot subscribe to the theory that it is the higher than expected speeds of the Volvo 70’s which are overloading components and causing the spate of cylinder rods failures.

In designing Skandia we contemplated using trunnion mounted cylinders with the trunnion axes parallel to the keel pivot and the accuracy of mounting determined by accurate machining, an arrangement most commonly used in canting keel boats. However a strain analysis quickly showed that if the mounting accuracy was even slightly impaired or if the accuracy varied with hull distortion due to dynamic or rig loads, then distortion of the cylinder rods would occur associated with high bending stresses which may be cyclical in a seaway.

While I believe it is possible to design such an arrangement to produce a safe set up it would be difficult and probably heavy. On both boats we adopted a system where the cylinder mounting and the rod clevises were free to rotate in two planes at right angles and therefore self aligning, making the flexibility of the hull of no consequence in determining cylinder loading. On the down side there is a significant weight penalty. We have not experienced any surprises to date.

Therefore, assuming I am correct in my analysis, my opening comment holds true, and the structural issues being experienced out there on the high seas impact on the hydraulic problems to the extent that they cause distortion of the hull and hence cylinder misalignment.

Vaikobi 2024 DecemberRooster 2025X-Yachts X4.0

Related Articles

Summer Youth Olympic Games equipment confirmed
Dakar 2026 will feature 2 sailing events in the Techno293 World Sailing is pleased to announce the selection of Techno293 as the equipment used in competition at the upcoming Summer Youth Olympic Games Dakar 2026, being held from 31 October to 13 November 2026.
Posted today at 6:08 am
America's Cup entries open on Sunday
A Cup in turmoil - has Grant Dalton dodged a bullet with the new Cup organisation? Updated story: America's Cup got underway in Rome on Monday, with Round 2 of the official welcoming ceremonies on Wednesday in Naples. Emirates Team NZ CEO Grant Dalton appears to have dodged a bullet with the formation of of new AC organising body.
Posted today at 4:18 am
Giorgio Armani Superyacht Regatta day 1
Ideal conditions for starting the Southern Wind RendezVous and Trophy The 2025 edition of the Giorgio Armani Superyacht Regatta, organised by the YCCS with the support of title sponsor Giorgio Armani, got under way right on time today, 28 May 2025 at 11.30 a.m. on the waters off Porto Cervo.
Posted on 28 May
America's Cup Power Plays
And Growing Sailing Through Learning There's always so much speculation and intrigue in-between each edition of the America's Cup. Everyone wants to know what is happening behind closed doors, inside the teams, and when the Challengers meet with the Defender.
Posted on 28 May
2025 is going to be a huge season for IMOCA
Antoine Mermod talks about the season ahead Over the next four years the most exciting monohull class in world offshore ocean racing will take on no less than 17 races, covering tens of thousands of miles of the world's oceans.
Posted on 28 May
America's Cup enthusiastically received in Naples
The Castel dell'Ovo, was the venue for the arrival of the America's Cup in Napes The Castel dell'Ovo, set on the tuft peninsula of Megaride was the outstanding setting for the Official Host Venue Presentation of the Louis Vuitton 38th America's Cup.
Posted on 28 May
Increased Crowds and Unrivalled Showcase
At 2025 Sanctuary Cove International Boat Show The 36th annual Sanctuary Cove International Boat Show (SCIBS) has once again cemented its status as the Southern Hemisphere's premier marine event, drawing an impressive 45,865 visitors over four spectacular days from 22-25 May 2025.
Posted on 28 May
CYCA team to take best shot at the Admiral's Cup
The Australian flag will fly proud on Zen and Back 2 Black The Australian flag will fly proud on Zen and Back 2 Black during the Admiral's Cup to be held in Cowes from the Isle of Wight from 17 July - 1 August.
Posted on 28 May
Doyle Sails: Ragtime blends retro and modern
Launched in 1966, Infidel now Ragtime Sailing, has celebrated her 60th year with a refit Tina Roberts has beautifully restored Ragtime Sailing in honour of her late partner's wishes, choosing Doyle Sails not only for the world-class sails but for the depth of experience, personal commitment, and collaborative support that define the team.
Posted on 28 May
The Ocean's Logbook amplifies global voices
A digital survey that looks beyond cold statistics to capture real stories A powerful new campaign designed to capture the world's emotional connection to the ocean is being launched today ahead of the third United Nations Ocean Conference (UNOC3) in Nice, France in June.
Posted on 27 May