Please select your home edition
Edition
sMRT AIS Man Overboard Beacons AUS / NZ

Changes to Volvo leaderboard as Int Jury issues penalties in Lisbon

by Richard Gladwell & Rob Kothe Sail-World.com on 3 Jun 2015
Mapfre and Dongfeng penalised by the Jury over Traffic Zone infringements after the start of the race at Newport. Maria Muina / Mapfre http://www.volvooceanrace.com
The ISAF-appointed independent international jury has heard four cases during the Lisbon stopover after alleged breaches of sailing rules during Leg 7 of the Volvo Ocean Race.

Team SCA had to answer two cases: that they sailed against the traffic flow in a Traffic Separation Scheme (TSS), and, additionally, into a Rhode Island Sound exclusion zone. The jury penalised them a point for each infringement.

Dongfeng Race Team and Mapfre are also faced protests that they sailed against the traffic flow in a TSS. The jury penalised them each a point for their respective infringement.

The Race Committee had brought all the cases to the jury, If a penalty was to be given, the jury had discretion on what it will be. These rulings were similar to those in past cases where the penalty for a breach of an Exclusion Zone has been the deduction of a point for the Leg (ie a place).

All three teams admitted their infringements in the hearing, but said in mitigation that there had been confusion over how clearly the TSS zones had been marked and the angle the boats were allowed to sail within them.

“This gave us no advantage, it was an honest mistake,” Team SCA skipper, Sam Davies, told the jury.

“There was no shipping in the vicinity at the time, so no safety issue.”

The jury was earlier given evidence from Race Director, Jack Lloyd, who said that the offences took place early in the 2,800-nautical mile (nm) leg from Newport, Rhode Island, to Lisbon, which started on May 17.

The infringements were spotted by Race Control staff and corroborated by diagrams of sailing movements sent from the crews themselves.

Both MAPFRE and Dongfeng Race Team witnesses said that recently introduced guidelines of sailing in TSS zones had confused sailors and that improvements needed to be made in the future to assist crews from inadvertently breaking sailing rules.

This changes the overall leaderboard, Abu Dhabi has 16 points leads, Brunel with 22 points has a better inshore record than Dongfeng who has now fallen back to 22 points and third place.

Then Alvimedica is now fourth on 27 point, overtaking MAPFRE also on 27 points with a worse inshore result.


The live race siituationwas been graphically described online.

Abu Dhabi not happy

The report from the Abu Dhabi's OBR reads as follows:

“I wanted to be in front of Dongfeng so we could control them”, Ian said in frustration as he sat on the bow in the light wind. “Now because of all this Exclusion Zone business, they’ve managed to slip away from us.”

Just minutes earlier, we had gybed several times around an invisible mark in the ocean. The spectators on the last few power boats shadowing us would never have guessed it was there – there was no blinking buoy or square floating mark – it’s marked by GPS coordinates.

This specific mark was the corner of a larger box that forms a Traffic Safety Separation Exclusion Zone. Consisting of two lanes for incoming and outgoing ships with a figurative barrier between, oceangoing vessels use these TSS areas for safety in high traffic areas. Before the leg, race management decided that teams needed to either respect the correct flow of traffic in the lanes or not enter the zone at all.

Dongfeng, Mapfre, and SCA entered the zone.

We watched as their courses on the nav computer sailed deeper and deeper into the red colored box against the traffic flow. Their routes didn’t just cut the corner on a piece of open water with little significance – no, they were the equivalent of riding a bike across an eight-lane highway and then turning left into oncoming traffic.

They had raced several miles down the course while we had to perform several tacks to get around the zone. Ian, SiFi, and the rest of the guys – still buzzing on deck from the magnificent send-off in Newport – were furious at the loss.'

Will there be a penalty? There was, it was one point or one place on the overall standings.



Specifics of the Hearings are:

Case nº 11
Protest Race Committee vs TEAM SCA: Sailing against traffic flow in TSS
- Rules alleged to be broken: RRS 48.2; COLREG rule 10.b(i)

Case nº 12
Protest Race Committee vs TEAM SCA: Sailing into the Rhode Island Sound Exclusion Zone 2
- Rules alleged to be broken: RRS 28.1; Leg 7 Addendum 5 - SI 5

Case nº 13
Protest Race Committee vs DONG FENG RACING TEAM: Sailing against traffic flow in TSS
- Rules alleged to be broken: RRS 48.2; COLREG rule 10.b(i)

Case nº 14
Protest Race Committee vs TEAM MAPFRE: Sailing against traffic flow in TSS
- Rules alleged to be broken: RRS 48.2; COLREG rule 10.b(i)
Sydney Boat Show 2025 - Apply to ExhibitHyde Sails 2024 - One DesignExcess Catamarans

Related Articles

Yoann Richomme returns to Fastnet
Says Elodie Bonafous' is the boat to beat This weekend's biennial Rolex Fastnet Race - one of the oldest classics in sailing - sees the IMOCA Class return to the racetrack, with eight boats on the startline on Saturday for what is the second round of this year's IMOCA Globe Series Championship.
Posted today at 3:12 pm
Fuerteventura PWA Grand Slam Day 6
Arguably the best female Freestyle final of all time Sarah-Quita Offringa pushed all the way by Maaike Huvermann in arguably the best female Freestyle final of all time, while Yentel Caers wins ‘Battle of Belgium' against Steven Van Broeckhoven to hold respective event leads.
Posted today at 11:48 am
Admiral's Cup 2025 | D2 Inshore Racing Videos
One race and then it was all done. Very light and even a bit of liquid sunshine. One race and then it was all done. Very light and even a bit of liquid sunshine.
Posted today at 10:57 am
How to follow RORC Centenary Rolex Fastnet Race
At present 451 yachts are entered, which, if all start on Saturday, will break the previous record. This year's centennial edition of the Rolex Fastnet Race will set sail this Saturday, 26 July from the Royal Yacht Squadron line off Cowes, Isle of Wight, bound for Cherbourg-en-Cotentin, France.
Posted today at 10:30 am
WASZP Games 2025 Day 3
When racing got under way, it was a game of patience, persistence, and pressure-hunting Day 3 of the WASZP Games dawned with cautious optimism as the early risers in the boat park were greeted by a light but promising northerly breeze. However, an approaching front caused the race committee to call a three-hour postponement.
Posted today at 8:23 am
Masters Games in Canberra early bird entries
More than 200 sailors are expected to hit the waters of Lake Burley Griffin More than 200 sailors are expected to hit the waters of Lake Burley Griffin in Canberra this October as part of the 2025 Australian Masters Games
Posted today at 6:52 am
Admiral's Cup Paul Wyeth Wednesday Photo Gallery
The wind was lighter, the conditions were overcast, but Paul still makes the action come alive The wind was lighter, the conditions were overcast, but Paul Wyeth still makes the action come alive with his photos. Here's his gallery from the racing on Wednesday in the 2025 Admiral's Cup.
Posted today at 5:26 am
Admiral's Cup PKC Media Wednesday Photo Gallery
Out on the water on Wednesday to capture the lighter wind action Patrick Condy of PKC Media was out on the water on Wednesday to capture the lighter wind action in the 2025 Admiral's Cup. Here are his selection of photos from the racing!
Posted today at 5:06 am
Admiral's Cup Ingrid Abery Wednesday Gallery
Up close and personal with the teams on a lighter wind day Thanks to her long lens and skill, Ingrid Abery got up close and personal with the Admiral's Cup teams on a lighter wind day in the Solent. Enjoy these crew photos, and many more in the gallery above!
Posted today at 4:46 am
Admiral's Cup 2025 | Day One Inshore Racing Pics
An excellent day's racing with good breeze. Day One of Inshore Racing at the 2025 Admiral's Cup was highlighted by good breeze.
Posted today at 1:09 am