sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Cruising Photo Gallery Video Gallery
Sail-World.com : Laser designer takes builder, Class association and ISAF to court
Laser designer takes builder, Class association and ISAF to court


'Exhibit 16 - Laser plaque'       Click Here to view large photo
The most successful sailing boat in history is the single handed Laser, designed in 1969 by Bruce Kirby, launched in 1970 and more than 210,000 Lasers later, it is THE dinghy success story.

But there has been a long running dispute between the designer of the Laser dinghy Bruce Kirby and one of the Laser builders LaserPerformance, the builder and supplier of Lasers into UK, Europe and North America, because of non-payment of design royalties.

On March 4, 2013, Bruce Kirby, Inc., filed a complaint in the U.S. Federal Court District of Connecticut, alleging unlawful counterfeiting of the Kirby dinghy by LaserPerformance principal Farzad Rastegar acting with and through Laser Performance and its associated entities.


This case also names the International Laser Class Association (ILCA) and ISAF alleging they assisted LaserPerformance by continuing to supply ISAF plaques to the builder, after Kirby had given them formal notice to stop.




Here is the introduction from the Complaints document presented by Kirby’s team..

‘This case concerns the production, sale, and racing of sailboats designed and sold by Bruce Kirby since about 1970.
‘In order to establish the Kirby sailboat design as a standard class for international racing, Kirby reached agreements with the various sailboat builders who held rights to the Laser name as well as the international governing bodies that regulate competitive sailing.

‘Under the terms of these agreements, the builders paid a royalty to Kirby and received the right to manufacture boats according to the Kirby sailboat design and uniform Construction Manual and to affix a plaque on the hull of each boat featuring Bruce Kirby’s name and trademark, and a unique hull/sail number.

‘The plaque confirms that the boat was built according to the Kirby sailboat design and is authorized by Bruce Kirby. Only those boats manufactured under the various builder agreements and bearing the appropriate plaque were entitled to race in events sanctioned by the international governing bodies.

‘This system worked to the mutual benefit of the builders, the governing bodies, Kirby, and sailors worldwide for over 20 years until certain builders decided to breach their agreements by, among other things, ceasing royalty payments and transferring their rights without notice or consent of Kirby. Notwithstanding their breach, these builders continue using both the Kirby sailboat design and the Bruce Kirby name and trademark.

‘The governing bodies named in this complaint compound this breach by continuing to issue hull plaques featuring the Bruce Kirby name and trademark, as well as a unique hull/sail number even though the boats were no longer made under Kirby’s authorization.

‘As a result, boats currently distributed in interstate commerce and in Connecticut are counterfeit, and violate Kirby’s trademark and publicity rights. Kirby sues for default of contract as well as counterfeiting, trademark infringement, unfair competition, false designation of origin, inducement to default on contract, and right of publicity under federal and state law.’

While the 23 page Complaints document has been widely circulated, the full detail of the issue have only now begun to leak out with some 17 exhibits, being trademark registrations, contractual documents and correspondence between Bruce Kirby, Bruce Kirby Inc. and LaserPerformance, ISAF (and its precursor IYRU) and ILCA. gradually trickling into the public domain.

What has blindsided most observers who have been focusing on Laser trademarks, which over the years, the rights to which have been bought and sold, Kirby`s case brings into play the use of trademark Bruce Kirby, used on the ISAF plaques attached to every Laser.

An initial search through all the publically available documents and statements reveals that neither LaserPerformance nor any of its associated entities, ISAF or ILCA have ever claimed to have rights over the Bruce Kirby trademark.

The exhibits seems to provide evidence that Kirby formally requested ISAF and ILCA to stop issuing Kirby plaques because LaserPerformance´s agreements with Kirby Inc. had been terminated. Both ISAF and ILCA chose to ignore that request, citing the need to keep a flow of boats reaching the market.

The named parties have been given 21 days to respond to a Summons.

ISAF´s Secretary General Jerome Pels have advised Sail-World that 'ISAF has not previously seen all the exhibits. They were sent to us on 5 March. ISAF has sought and been granted extra time to respond (to the summons) and ISAF does not intend to make a statement until we have responded.

In contrast, ILCA, who had previously said that it had not been privy to all the 'Kirby agreements' released an immediate statement.

ILCA said 'In addition to naming LaserPerformance, the complaint also names both the International Sailing Federation (ISAF) and the International Laser Class Association (ILCA.) Both have been included in the complaint because ISAF plaque sales to LaserPerformance were continued after Kirby, Inc. informed the ILCA and the ISAF of its termination of agreements with LaserPerformance.

‘The decision to continue ISAF plaque sales (and continue to report them to Kirby, Inc.), taken only after consultation with ILCA's legal advisor and close discussion with ISAF, is seen to be in the best interest of the sailors as it maintains the flow of boats and equipment until such time as a resolution to the dispute is reached.

‘It has always been ILCA's opinion that the dispute between Kirby, Inc., and LaserPerformance is between those two parties and should be resolved between them without the need for involvement of either the ILCA or the ISAF. As has always been the case, the ILCA remains ready to fully abide by the outcome of the resolution. Further, the ILCA is optimistic that the filing of this complaint will finally bring resolution to this long standing issue.

‘It is interesting to look back in time, last year the then ILCA President Heini Wellman said – ‘a builder also needs a building agreement from Bruce Kirby or Bruce Kirby Inc. This provision is mostly historical. The rule was instituted at a time when Bruce Kirby held certain design rights. The ILCA is not a party to any of these 'Kirby' agreements.

‘We also took legal advice. The lawyers also informed us that the Kirby design patents had in fact expired.’

The response from Bruce Kirby, at the time was forthright. ‘Wellmann has stated erroneously that the Kirby Inc rights have expired in Europe. ‘These rights are based on Designer / Builder contracts, not on copyright, and they are valid with all Laser builders - Performance Sailcraft Europe, Laser Performance in the U.S.A., Performance Sailcraft Japan and Performance Sailcraft Australia.

The exhibits presented to the US Federal Court certainly seem, in this scribes opinion, to support Kirby`s position and many observers are wondering just how ILCA´s lawyers were able to advise their client without access to all these documents, none of which appear to be ´design patents'.

It seems there might be some difficult decision making ahead. It’s noteworthy that the ILCA Executive Secretary Jeff Martin, is also the Classes Committee Chair within ISAF. His initials JM appear on many of the documents in the list of Exhibits presented to the court.

LaserPerformance themselves made a statement this week via their US office

'Bruce Kirby and Bruce Kirby Inc. have filed a legal complaint against LaserPerformance entities, the International Sailing Federation Limited ('ISAF') and International Laser Class Association ('ILCA'). A number of false accusations and claims have been made in the document.

'LaserPerformance vehemently deny the allegations made by Mr. Kirby and maintain that these legal proceedings are vexatious in nature at best. LaserPerformance will take all necessary action to contest and defend these ill-conceived and meritless claims.

Bruce Kirby is not available for comment at the moment, but he previously indicated to Sail-World his desire not to involve ISAF and the ILCA in the ongoing dispute and he had hoped this matter could be resolved by Laser Performance paying its long overdue debts to him.

But he said some time ago that by their (ISAF and ILCA) continuing to supply plaques to LP they were assisting LP´s activities, in spite of his formal request to them not to so do.

This meant that their actions would become subject to examination though the courts, unless they reversed their positions.

So there are interesting times ahead, an examination of the exhibits show that Kirby has been communicating with the LaserPerformance group, ILCA and ISAF, over the last year, seeking resolution, now it’s the turn of those groups to respond.

Of just two thing we can be sure, the lights will be burning at night and the legal bills will be rising.


Attached is a copy of the Complaint, which has already been widely circulated and a list of the key exhibits, now in the public domain, which can be purchased via an online court reporting service.

Some of these exhibits have already been posted on the Laser forum site and it would not be a surprise if more were posted there.

Complaint - Bruce Kirby, Inc. et al v. LaserPerformance (Europe) Limited et al. 51:1114 Trademark Infringement

Exhibit 1 – Kirby Dinghy specification
Exhibit 2 – Trademark Principle Register dated November 11th 2008
Exhibit 3 - Agreement relating to the International Laser Class Boat between:
The International Yacht Racing Union International Laser Class Association IYRU Holdings Limited
Bruce Kirby, Inc. Bruce Kirby and Laser International Holdings (1983) Limited
Dated 30th November 1983
Exhibit 4 - Licence Agreement between Bruce Kirby and Brook Shaw Motor Services dated 11th July 1983
Exhibit 5 – Agreement amending License between Bruce Kirby Inc and Performance Sailcraft Europe dated 30th August 1995
Exhibit 6 – Signed agreement dated 3rd May 2005 to amend section 10.6 of Exhibit 4
Exhibit 7 – Third Amendatory Agreement dated 16th June 2005 to replace section 10.6 of Exhibit 4
Exhibit 8 - Licence Agreement between Bruce Kirby and PY Small Boats dated 31st March 1989
Exhibit 9 - Amendment to Licence between Kirby and Sunfish/Laser dated 25th March 1997
Exhibit 10 - Trademark Principle Registration for Laser for PY Small Boats dated June 11th 2011
Exhibit 11 - Notification to declare default against Quarter Moon Inc dated 17th July 2012
Exhibit 12 - Letter to Quarter Moon Inc terminating rights to build dated 11th October 2012
Exhibit 13 - Letter to Laser Performance re default to pay royalties dated 11th October 2012
Exhibit 14 - Notice of termination and copy past letters to Laser Performance dated 1st March 2013
Exhibit 15 - Letter to ILCA requesting termination of issue of plaques by Quarter Moon dated 11th October 2012
Exhibit 16 – Image of the Laser plaque
Exhibit 17 - Memo from ILCA detailing Laser plaque despatches to Quarter Moon – Laser Performance North America, dated 28th August 2012


by Rob Kothe and the Sail-World team

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=107549

10:30 AM Sat 16 Mar 2013GMT


Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.







News - USA and the World

Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15, Leg 2. Team Alvimedica’s OBR Amory Ross reports on the Leg 2 start and progress. Well, now we know what it feels like to be shot from of a cannon! That was utter insanity. When the gun went I think there was almost no wind at all—two knots or something—but as we slowly crept out from under the shadow of Table Mountain it changed drastically. ... [more]  

Amidst a 10% growth report on having issued over 9000 certificates worldwide in 2014, the recent Annual General Meeting of the Offshore Racing Congress is pleased to announces numerous improvements approved for use in the ORC Rules and policies for 2015. ... [more]  

The start of Leg 2 offered all the wind conditions you could want. I will not lie: I was pretty nervous to begin leg 2 of the Volvo Ocean Race (Mom called it ‘Stage Fright’); I think the whole team was pretty nervous. Here we are, having confidently completed the first leg of the Volvo Ocean Race—after 27 days at sea! ... [more]  

The ISAF Sailing World Cup Final in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates is set to be 'an experience of a lifetime' according to American Women's 470 sailor Briana Provancha. Some of the world’s top Men’s and Women’s 470 teams will make up the individual fleets with some excellent racing on the cards. ... [more]  

After finishing third in the annual RC44 match race championships, Team Nika seem to have got a taste for the podium. It was a tough day on the water for the start of fleet racing at the RC44 Oman Cup, with many teams struggling for consistency. ... [more]  

St Barth Cata Cup 2014 - Game on! by Dominique Ladouceur
The boats are ready and the sailors have all had a chance to test their catamarans in a very rigorous St-John Bay. The conditions will be windy at the start of this seventh edition of the St-Barth Cata Cup. Sailors will be facing winds from the west at 18 knots with gusts at 22 knots on the first race day. ... [more]  

While more modifications are being mooted for the champion supermaxi yacht Wild Oats XI as part of her preparation for next month’s Rolex Sydney Hobart yacht race, a high-profile new member of the team was revealed on Sydney Harbour today. ... [more]  

Wild Oats XI and Audi are ready to give the 2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart a shot! Photos by Andrea Francolini. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Meek's tips pay dividend in Leg 2 squalls and calms *Feature by Bob Fisher, Cape Town, South Africa
The seven competing boats in the Volvo Ocean Race 2014-2015 roughly gathered at 6pm local time (1600 Zulu) in a south-easterly wind that peaked at 30-40 knots, which had the local habit of dying away to nothing in places along the shoreline in the lee of Table Mountain. The clever skippers has sought advice from Geoff Meek, a local with a mass of experience ... [more]  

Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing (ADOR), the Emirate’s entry into the Volvo Ocean Race 2014–15, cast off on the next leg of the epic, round-the-world race on Wednesday evening hoping to complete a hat-trick of victories in the best place possible – the team’s home port of Abu Dhabi. ... [more]  

Over 600 scientists gathered in Barcelona for the second International Ocean Research Conference have this evening named the skippers in the Barcelona World Race, the first and only double-handed, round the world regatta with no stops, as scientific agents during their upcoming circumnavigation of the globe, departing from the Catalan capital on December 31st. ... [more]  

Team Alvimedica set out on the 6,125 nautical mile race to Abu Dhabi today, as they sailed out of Cape Town at the start of Leg 2 of the Volvo Ocean Race. After a brief lap of Table Bay, with the Turkish/American boat close to the lead, it was straight into battle. ... [more]  

Skippers of the seven boats in the Volvo Ocean Race fleet, which set out for the 6,125 nautical mile (nm) Leg 2 from Cape From the very start on Wednesday (1800 local/1600 UTC), the sailors were given a taste of things to come with gusts of up to 35 knots kicking up a procession of white-capped waves. It was a question of 'don't break your boat' as most opted for conservative sail choices, whil ... [more]  

An invigorated, rested and relatively relaxed crew on Team SCA led the Volvo Ocean Race fleet from Cape Town late this afternoon at the start Leg Two of the Volvo Ocean Race to Abu Dhabi. The 6,125-mile leg will provide a large variety of conditions and will require good seamanship and good navigational choices. ... [more]  

A whole host of Olympic heroes and World Champions will fight it out in the Nacra 17 at the inaugural ISAF Sailing World Cup Final in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates from 26-30 November 2014. The 17-boat Nacra 17 fleet features an abundance of Olympians with no less than 18 appearances stemming from Atlanta 1996 within the 17-boat fleet of 34 sailors. ... [more]  

The ISAF Sailing World Cup Final Finn fleet is made up of some exceptional talent with Great Britain's Ed Wright and Pieter Jan Postma (NED) coming in to Abu Dhabi, UAE with good form. Wright has been a permanent fixture on World Championship and ISAF Sailing World Cup podiums in recent years. ... [more]  

The RC44 Oman Cup opened with the season’s final day of match racing. Defending champions Team Aqua held a slim one-point lead over Synergy Russian Sailing Team who were fighting for the trophy they last won in 2012. Vladimir Prosikhin’s Team Nika started the day in third, with Hugues Lepic just two-points adrift in fourth and keen to get the French flag onto the podium. ... [more]  

Leg 2 of the Volvo Ocean Race is underway. Catch ther replay here, if you missed the 90 minutes of racing action in Cape Town. The sailing is spectacular! ... [more]  

Visiting Cape Town was more than just a stopover in the Volvo Ocean Race for Team Alvimedica, but was an opportunity to really get to know the people and the culture of the 'mother city.' Take a look at how the team get involved while in Cape Town from meeting Archbishop Desmond Tutu to visiting heart surgery patients at the Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital. ... [more]  

15th Ambassadors Cup - Brazil claims victory by May Ling Teo, Changi Sailing Club
Light winds didn’t dampen the enthusiasm of the 20 ambassadors who competed in the 15th annual Changi Sailing Club’s Ambassadors’ Cup, nor did the gentle breezes take the edge off the competitive spirit of the skippers and the crew who competed for the prestigious prize. ... [more]  

Spanish solo skipper Alex Pella wrote himself into the history books of the Route du Rhum solo Transatlantic race and Spanish ocean racing when he crossed the finish line of the 3,542 miles La Route du Rhum-Destination Guadeloupe race first in Classe40 at 06:47:08 hrs TU/07:47:08hrs CET/02:47:08 Local Guadeloupe. ... [more]  

Star Sailors League Finals 2014, Nassau (Bahamas) - Robert Stanjek will be attempting to bring a stunning 2014 season to a fittingly impressive conclusion in the big upcoming Finals in Nassau in two weeks’ time. The second half of the year has proved particularly rewarding for the German sailor. ... [more]  

Two English born Finn sailors, once coach and student, will draw swords at the ISAF Sailing World Cup in December on Port Phillip. Both are gunning for national team selection and a chance to represent their country at the 2016 Rio Olympic Games, Ed Wright sailing for Great Britain and Oli Tweddell representing Australia, where he’s lived for the past decade. ... [more]  

Yachting Australia has announced the appointment of experienced and respected sports administrator Matt Carroll to the role of Chief Executive Officer. Matt commences with Yachting Australia on Monday 24 November 2014, replacing Phil Jones who is leaving the organisation after 17 years at the helm. He comes from a background of roles in Australian and Japanese Rugby and Rugby World Cup. ... [more]  

The Alpari World Match Racing Tour (AWMRT) has announced the addition of the Congressional Cup to the 2015 World Championship Tour schedule. The announcement follows this year’s 50th anniversary of the historic Congressional Cup event, organised by Long Beach Yacht Club, in Long Beach, California. ... [more]  

18ft Skiffs: Smeg's second Red-Line run down Sydney harbour in 40kts *Feature by Michael Chittenden, Sydney harbour
In a sport which generally lacks characters, the 18ft skiffs have an over-supply. David Witt is one of those, underlined by taking his boat and crew out last Sunday daring the rest of the Sydney fleet to race in a breeze of 30-40kts, on an otherwise ideal day on Sydney Harbour. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race sailors set out again for the open seas on Wednesday with no piracy activity on their radar, but the threat of cyclones ahead on Leg 2 from Cape Town to Abu Dhabi. Sailing conditions in Cape Town look challenging for the 1800 start (local time)/1600 UTC, with plenty of wind, but flat seas forecast. ... [more]  

On the opening day of the Airwaves Noumea PWA Dream Cup, which is the final event on the 2014 PWA World Tour, the competitors registered for the upcoming six days of contest, which will see fifty-seven men and twelve women battling it out over Noumea’s pristine waters. ... [more]  

There are 11 days to go until a highly competitive fleet competes in the inaugural RORC Transatlantic Race from Lanzarote to Grenada. The race across the Atlantic will be a very different experience for the crews from 12 different nations taking part. ... [more]  

The Volvo Ocean Race restarts from Cape Town on Wednesday local time. Here is the full replay of the Media Conference with all seven skippers on stage, talking of the prospect of a tropical cyclone, the nuances of this Leg - which won't see the boats hopping on a ship to avoid pirates, and the other challenges facing the crews and their teams. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race - Team Vestas Wind ready to race by Brian Carlin, Team Vestas Wind
It’s the day before departure for Leg 2 of the Volvo Ocean Race and we are much better prepared than the Leg 1 start in Alicante. We all have our small list of jobs to complete today but all being well; we will be out of the team base mid afternoon to take some personal time. ... [more]  

Young sailors in Abu Dhabi made sure to practice their ‘Go Azzam!’ cheers this week as Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing (ADOR) – the emirate’s entrant in the Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15 - prepared for the next leg of the round-the-world yacht challenge – the race from South Africa to the UAE capital. ... [more]  

Photographer Michael Chittenden was on hand to capture the remarkable ride of David Witt and friends after racing was cancelled on Sydney harbour on Sunday when winds gusted 35-40kts. Witt did two runs down Sydney Harbour. See the crew go from make the transition from upwind to downwind and survive the tremendous acceleration of an 18ft skiff in these conditions. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Sam Davies speaks openly about the first leg *Feature
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final: Exciting 49er and 49erFX action expected
America's Cup: Significant changes made to Protocol, but issues remain *Feature
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - the 70th
Stoke Beer 18ft Skiff Auckland Champs: Knight Frank lead after 5 races
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final - RS:X elite Abu Dhabi bound
120 boat start line for Tasar Worlds in Busselton
Melges 24 U.S. Nationals - Full Throttle team grabs their sixth title
RC44 Oman Cup - Grand final showdown on the horizon
Visit Doyle Sails New Zealand at METS 2014
Top Kiwi Finn sailor debuts in the 2014 Star Sailors League Finals
2014 Butler Cup - Shane Young wins match race regatta
Adventures of a Sailor Girl: News and interviews from Nov 16 show *Feature
2014 Melges 24 U.S. National Championship - Moon wind
Australian 18ft Skiffs: 40kt winds cancel race but Witt sails + Video
2014 Melges 24 US National Championship - Day 2 images by Joy Dunigan
Volvo Ocean Race: Abu Dhabi are the Kings of Cape Town
Volvo Ocean Race: In Port races do count *Feature
Volvo Ocean Race: Abu Dhabi rules in Cape Town In Port Race
Volvo Ocean Race - Tricky In-Port Race for Team Alvimedica
Volvo Ocean Race - Team SCA third in Cape Town In-Port Race   
A Sailor's Dream Home in the beautiful Bay of Islands - Auction 22 Nov   
Volvo Ocean Race: Cape Town In Port Race video and Media Conference *Feature   
2014 Brazilian Championship - Day 2   
2014 U.S. Melges 24 National Championship - Long haul   
2014 - 15 Volvo Ocean Race - The thinking trio   
US Sailing Team to celebrate Clearwater Training Center   
Moth Worlds 2015: Sliced bread, sheep stations, awe and reverence *Feature   
Volvo Ocean race: Images from the Practice racing in Cape Town *Feature   
Volvo Ocean Race - Lindsay Dibowitz sails on board Team Alvimedica   
Volvo Ocean Race: Big breeze for Practice Racing in Cape Town *Feature   
Volvo Ocean Race - All-clear from piracy threat   
Volvo Ocean Race - Team SCA confirms Leg 2 crew   
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final - Laser and Laser Radial sailors all set   
Star Sailors League Finals - France to be represented   
67th Turkey Day Regatta - ABYC dishes up another special regatta   
Dual Olympian Krystal Weir announces retirement from Olympic Sailing   
Volvo Ocean Race: Sibling rivalry, Greenhalghs prepare to race   
Star Sailors League Finals - Kljakovic Gaspic and Sitic to race   
Live Coverage of the 13th International Sailing Summit   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL VIR US
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT