Please select your home edition
Edition
Rooster 2025

Gladwell's Line- Justice Shirley's America's Cup Jury may be flawed

by Richard Gladwell on 1 Nov 2009
New York State Supreme Court, 60 Centre St, New York, venue for the next round of America’s Cup Legal on Wednesday. Event Media
The move to appoint a panel of technical experts by Justice Shirley Kornreich, to help her resolve five technical questions relating to the 33rd America's Cup might not be the great idea it seems on first blush.

The simple reason being that finding the technical experts, who fit her criteria may be a little more difficult, let alone get briefed and into her Court Room on 60 Centre Street, by next Wednesday.

The members of the international Jury for the 2007 America's Cup comprised five members, three of who were International Judges certified by the International Sailing Federation. The other two were appointed for their legal expertise, rather than their adjudication experience at major international regattas.

In the 31st America's Cup, in Auckland, there was a split function with an Arbitration Panel taking over many of the adjudication functions, and the International Jury being confined to issues regarding the actual racing rules.

In this theater, the Arbitration Panel were more notable for their impressive legal experience, than the frequency of their attendance on Jury's on the professional sailing circuits, essential to maintain currency.

For the America's Cups, while there is no perfect solution to adjudication, both systems worked well enough. The major issue being the duration of the event and the need to have a working Jury to deal with day to day decisions, but also to have a more detached level above that to deal with wider considerations, issues involving law rather than application of sailing rules, and to avoid the perception issues when Juries start hearing complaints about their own decisions.

So picking three 'independent experts, not affiliated with either party and who has sat on an America's Cup jury in the past' might not be that easy a task.

Overlay the fact that several experts have provided affidavits to one of the parties (GGYC) might tend to rule them out because they cannot not be said to be 'not affiliated with the parties'

Given too, that people have not been considered for a role in the upcoming America's Cup key race management roles if they are of Swiss or US nationality (ie could be partial to the Defender or Challenger) could further thin the available field of candidates.

And finally, it may not be that easy to find people outside USA who are prepared to drop everything and race off to New York to assist in a dispute, which could have been resolved long ago if the parties had picked up a phone and started reasonable communication and negotiation in good faith to reach an acceptable conclusion.

That begs the question of payment by way of compensation for loss of income for around a week, and as all know he who pays the piper gets to call the tune. So a party is hardly likely to pay for an expert to fly to New York to give evidence that will not line up with their desired outcomes on the five questions that Justice Shirley has proposed.

Maybe the good Justice Shirley is on a hiding to nowhere on this novel idea, which frankly could have been more easily resolved by ISAF announcing the 33rd America's Cup Jury, empaneling it, and requiring the Jury to produce the written answers to the five questions, as a Jury, in the normal way.

It will be interesting to see who is put forward, and whether this novel idea does fly. The Jury is out, if you'll excuse the pun.

On the vexed issue of the weather off Valencia in February, it would seem that that rather than too much wind there is a greater prospect of too little, as we saw in the opening days of the Louis Vuitton Cup in April 2007.

Sailing Scuttlebutt commissioned meteorologist Chris Bedford to give his prognosis for the weather in February 2010. Bedford was the team meteorologist for BMW Oracle Racing for the last Cup, and then worked for the Ericsson Racing Team in the Volvo Ocean Race.

He commented, in part: 'An America’s Cup held off Valencia during the month of February will take place in conditions much more variable generally lighter than those experienced during the Challenger Series (which began Apr. 16) and the America’s Cup match (held June 24-July 3) in 2007. Additionally, rather than sailing just a few miles from the shore, the Deed of Gift courses are longer and may require sailing some considerable distance away from the shore, bringing some new weather and tactical challenges to the event.

'Sometimes, strong low pressure will form over the Western Mediterranean east or southeast of the Gulf of Valencia. These systems are sometimes responsible for fresh or even strong Northeast winds that can last a couple days or more. These weather patterns often bring unsettled weather to the region with rain and squalls likely. In addition, these weather systems bring the roughest seas to Valencia. Thanks to a relatively long fetch from the NE, rough swells of 2m, 3m and sometimes more can develop.'

The full prognosis can be read at http://www.sailingscuttlebutt.com/news/09/0518b/!Sailing_Scuttlebutt

It would seem that the major issue with sailing in Valencia is not so much strong winds, but rather a lack of wind - which would disrupt training and buildup to the match in about 100 days time.

In terms of safety, the issue raised by Societe Nautique de Geneve against Valencia as a venue in February 2010. Both teams, as well as race management would have available very sophisticated wind prediction systems, and of course if winds were strong or unsafe for racing they would not do so, as happens in all other yachting regattas.

From a weather perspective, Ras al-Khaimah is the best option, affording training and racing in light to moderate breezes on a daily basis, and because of the near landlocked nature of the venue, near flat seas. However as Justice Kornreich ruled on Wednesday a Northern Hemisphere venue in February is not in compliance with the Deed of Gift.

Vaikobi 2024 DecemberC-Tech 2020 Battens 2 728x90 BOTTOMHenri-Lloyd Dynamic Range

Related Articles

Transat Paprec Day 13
Cap Saint Barth has lit the fire! Competitors in the Transat Paprec - a race organized by OC Sport Pen Duick - and those familiar with the charts have become accustomed to it: Cap St Barth has been at the forefront since the start.
Posted today at 4:56 pm
National Family Island Regatta of the Bahamas
Observations from the outside of the 69th running of the event I have much experience racing sailboats of many sizes in many settings, and much experience as a race organizer for national and international sailing events. This year I attended a Bahamian Wooden Sloop Regatta for the first time.
Posted today at 2:38 pm
Team Race World Championship returns
In a month's time when the New York Yacht Club Harbour Court The past decade for team racing has featured the emergence of a new, spectator-friendly format and the continued spread of the discipline around the globe.
Posted today at 1:38 pm
MS Amlin re-signs with Kiwi race team
Leading European insurer MS Amlin have renewed their sponorship of Aotearoa Ocean Racing, Leading European insurer MS Amlin have renewed their sponorship of Aotearoa Ocean Racing, enabling the newly formed team to take part in a series of races in Europe later this year. The team is still seeking sponsorship for The Ocean Race 2027.
Posted today at 12:53 pm
60th Anniversary Congressional Day 2
Monnin in the hunt for semi-final spot Switzerland's Eric Monnin and his Capvis Swiss Match Racing Team delivered a faultless performance today, the second day of the 60th Long Beach Yacht Club Congressional Cup.
Posted today at 4:26 am
Antigua Race Week Day 4
One-third of the classes started the penultimate day with boats tied on points at the top Racing at this year's Antigua Sailing Week is so close that one-third of the classes started the penultimate day with boats tied on points at the top of their respective leaderboards.
Posted today at 3:04 am
5.5m Alpen Cup at Fraglia Vela Riva Day 1
The Jean Genie makes strong start to title defence The Jean Genie (GBR 43, Peter Morton, Andrew Palfrey, Ruaridh Scott) took a commanding lead on a very tricky opening day of the 2025 5.5 Metre Alpen Cup at Fraglia Vela Riva, on Lake Garda, Italy.
Posted on 1 May
21st Sandberg PalmaVela Day 1
Magic Carpet E wins two from two on her debut The Maxi class officially opened racing today at the 21st Sandberg PalmaVela, completing two W/L races in which the newest elite 100-footer, Magic Carpet E, dominated with two clear victories in what was its first-ever races.
Posted on 1 May
52 SUPER SERIES Saint-Tropez Cup Day 2
Gladiator back on winning form Disappointed to miss out on winning the 2024 circuit title after coming into the last event of the season with a solid points lead, Tony Langley's world champions Gladiator crew started their assault on the 2025 title on the best possible footing.
Posted on 1 May
Touching base with Erden Eruç
Erden Eruç on his 2026 Golden Globe Race campaign Adventures come in all sizes, scales, speeds, and price tags. My longtime friend and sometimes shipmate Erden Eruç was the first person to complete a human-powered solo circumnavigation. He's now turning his attention to the 2026 Golden Globe Race.
Posted on 1 May