Please select your home edition
Edition
SailX 728x90

America's Cup- Protocol changes rung ahead of Entry window opening

by Richard Gladwell Sail-World.com/nz on 9 Jun 2014
Golden Gate Yacht Club - Defender of the 35th America’s Cup © Richard Gladwell http://www.richardgladwell.com
The Defender of the America's Cup, Oracle Team USA has announced a series of changes to the Protocol for the next event.

The changes are said to be issued, as a result, of constructive feedback on the rules from prospective teams, prompting Hamilton Island Yacht Club, the Challenger of Record, and the Defender, Oracle Team USA to issue agreed amendments to the Protocol for the 35th America’s Cup.

The Protocol changes did not have comment from the Defending Club, Golden Gate Yacht Club, but by the skipper of the Defender, Jimmy Spithill, a competitor in the event.

'It’s been great to have positive and constructive contributions from prospective teams,' said Spithill in the official release which accompanied the changes.

'This process has echoed what we did with the Class Rules for the AC62 yacht, where feedback was taken on board and changes were made.

'Our goal is to make this the best America’s Cup ever and we can only do that when everyone is engaged and pulling in the same direction to make improvements.'

The most significant change is to the Protocol is for the responsibility for the appointment of the Regatta Director and his race officials shared by all Competitors, with one vote per Competitor, in line with how the officials are funded. (A Competitor in the America's Cup context means the Defender or a Challenger team.)

The Competitor Forum can also remove or change officials, however 75% of the Competitors must vote for a removal/change, but the new official only needs to receive a simple majority of the votes cast.

The Competitor Forum will appoint the Regatta Director, the Chief Measurer together with all members of the Measurement Committee, the Umpiring team and ant other Regatta officials required.

The effect of the change is to remove the right of the Defender and Challenger of Record to hire and fire key Race Officials, without reference to the other Competitors in the event. The independence of Regatta officials cannot now be questioned.

The point was also not lost that under the initial version of the Protocol, all the Competitors had to share the costs of the Regatta Officials, but had no say as to who was appointed, or their terms of engagement, or indeed the numbers of officials engaged.

The changes will both bring a level of control to the situation, and ensure that the Regatta Officials are seen to be independently appointed and insulated from team pressure/threat of removal.

Arbitration Panel Selection changes:
The Competitor Forum will have some control of the appointment of control of the Arbitration Panel, which has been established in the Protocol contrary to the International Sailing Federation regulations.

While an Arbitration Panel has been used in previous America's Cup, the ISAF changed its Regulations about two years ago to give itself the right to appoint International Jury and other key official for major events.

This was done to remain consistent with ISAF's objective of providing fairness of competition, without insinuation that officials were selected and, therefore, beholden to organisers, or a team (or both in the case of the unique nature of the America's Cup).

The ISAF also felt it necessary to adopt the right to ensure that only properly trained and qualified official were used in major regattas.

With the appointment of a member of the Court of Arbitration for Sport as its Chairman, the Arbitration Panel is set to bypass the ISAF's own adjudication officials used in every other regatta in the sport including Olympics and Volvo Ocean Race.

The first member of the panel will be selected by the Defender and Challenger of Record.

The Competitors Forum will select the second member of the Arbitration Panel and the first two members will select a third.

ISAF has no mention in the selection process, contrary to its own Regulations.

The yet to be appointed Regatta Director is still responsible under the Protocol for trying to come to an accommodation with the ISAF over the part the world body will, or will not play in the next America's Cup regattas.

However Article 12.2 of the Protocol will raise the blood-pressure of the ISAF hierachy: 'The terms of this Protocol shall prevail over the terms of any arrangements with ISAF'.

The first draft of the Protocol for the 34th America's Cup contained 11 references to the world body, including the use of its officials and rules. There are no such references in the 35th Protocol, which has been eight months in gestation.

Part of those discussions will not doubt involve the amount of fees paid to the world body, use of racing rules, and whether the world body will allow the officials it has trained and certified to be used in the America's Cup regatta.

As a federation of Member National Authorities (individual country sailing federations), it is likely that the ISAF will deal initially with the MNA's of the two countries involved in the Protocol. Those expected to be queried initially are US Sailing and Yachting Australia, along with the MNA's of any club whose teams enter the America's Cup, unless there is some accommodation reached with the ISAF.

The situation is not too different from break-out moves that have been made in other sports such as cricket, rugby and rugby league. All were driven by commercial considerations, when event organisers had a differing view of how their professional events should be run than the controlling world body.

Other changes in the Protocol include changes to the complex insurance requirements for competing teams.


Permission requirement altered
The rules requiring the America's Cup teams to have the permission of the AC Commercial Commissioner before competing in non AC35 events has been modified to make it clear that it applies only to America's cup teams.

'There was a similar rule in the last Cup but this time there was some confusion that it might restrict guys from sailing in the Olympics, for example,' Spithill said in the accompanying release. 'That was never the intent and although we don’t think the original rule did that, we’ve worked on the language to make it perfectly clear that this applies to America’s Cup teams – not individual sailors – competing in events in conflict with the Cup.'

Quite how the rule is applied remains to be seen. Certainly it would affect several AC teams competing in the Extreme Sailing Series, and other events. Team New Zealand could have been impacted if they enter the America's Cup, and had elected to enter the Volvo Ocean Race.

However, a workaround is easy - just form a new sailing team and enter to non-AC event under that entity. Or, in the case of New Zealand, just operate under the banner of the already established NZL Sailing Team, which is owned by Yachting New Zealand, with whom Team New Zealand have a good working relationship.

The changes to the Protocol take effect immediately, ahead of the entry period, which is open from June 9 through August 8, 2014.

Barz Optics - FloatersT Clewring One DesignNaiad

Related Articles

Taming the beast-a conversation with Stuart Meurer of Parker Hannifin
While AC72 cats were fast, they difficult to control, so Oracle partnered with Parker Hannifin to innovate a better way. If you watched videos of the AC72s racing in the 34th America’s Cup (2013), you’re familiar with the mind-boggling speeds that are possible when wingsail-powered catamarans switch from displacement sailing to foiling mode. While foiling is fast, there’s no disguising the platform’s inherent instability. Now, Oracle Team USA has teamed up with Parker Hannifin to innovate a better way.
Posted on 18 May
America's Cup - Images from the America's Cup World Series New York
Images from the Practice Day and Day 2 of the America's Cup World Series New York. Images from the Practice Day and Day 2 of the America's Cup World Series New York. Official racing was not possible on the first day, but the confluence of the Hudson River, and wind whistling between the New York skyscrapers created challenging conditions for the six teams.
Posted on 17 May
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ close NASDAQ in New York
Emirates Team New Zealand rang the closing bell of the Nasdaq stock exchange in New Yorks Time Square today Emirates Team New Zealand rang the closing bell of the Nasdaq stock exchange in New Yorks Time Square today, topping off a successful week in the Big Apple both on and off the water. Interest in the Louis Vuitton America’s Cup World Series was huge throughout New York, with hundred of thousands of spectators watching the weekend’s racing and capturing the city’s media with Emirates Team New Zea
Posted on 10 May
America's Cup World Series - Kiwis start historic haka before finish
In the 30 years of its America's Cup history, Emirates Team NZ has never but never done so much as a private High Five In the 30 years of its America's Cup history, Emirates Team New Zealand has never but never done so much as a private High Five before crossing the finish line on their way to a race win. Today in New York at the Louis Vuitton America's Cup World Series that team dictate was broken as the entire crew broke into a haka of victory, complete with war whoops
Posted on 8 May
America's Cup World Series - A flat first day in New York
The first race day of the America's Cup World Series New York did not live up the pre-race hype The first day of scheduled racing in the Louis Vuitton America's Cup World Series New York did not live up to the pre-series hype. None of the scheduled races were completed on the Hudson River course.
Posted on 8 May
America's Cup - The race you have when you don't have a race
The first day of racing on the New York leg of the ACWS was plagued by a strong current and almost no wind. The first day of racing on the New York leg of the America's Cup World Series was plagued by a strong current and almost no wind. The first race of the series got underway with all but Artemis Racing being swept to the wrong side of the start line.
Posted on 7 May
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ have an early look at the Hudson
Emirates Team New Zealand trimmer Blair Tuke and crew took the chase boat out to have a first hand look at the tricky wa Emirates Team New Zealand trimmer Blair Tuke and crew took the chase boat out to have a first hand look at the tricky waters of the Hudson River, race track for this weekends Louis Vuitton America's Cup World Series. Key points of interest in the video are the amount of current in the Hudson River (visible against the channel buoys) and the lack of visible wind signs on the river.
Posted on 5 May
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ on how to build an AC45 - Video
Video from Emirates Team NZ as they take us behind the scenes and show how one of the AC45 One Designs is put together Video from Emirates Team New Zealand as they take us behind the scenes and show how one of the AC45 One Designs is put together ahead of the America's Cup World Series events. The idea with the AC45 is that it can be broken down and fitted into a 40ft container.
Posted on 4 May
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ returns for the Battle of New York
Emirates Team NZ is in battle mode for a return to the Louis Vuitton America’s Cup World Series in New York this weekend Emirates Team New Zealand is in battle mode for a return to the Louis Vuitton America’s Cup World Series in New York this weekend (7th & 8th May). It will be the first time America’s Cup racing has taken place on the New York harbour in 96 years, and will feature plenty of sailing action in the one-design AC45’s against the backdrop of the iconic Manhattan skyline.
Posted on 2 May
America’s Cup Endeavour youth education program extended to USA +Video
America’s Cup Endeavour has been operating in Bermuda, the host venue for the 2017 America’s Cup, since last year. At the Louis Vuitton America’s Cup World Series in May, AC Endeavour is working with three local partners: Rocking the Boat, Hudson River Community Sailing and The New York Harbor School, to bring the program to New York.
Posted on 13 Apr