Sail-World.com : America's Cup: Oracle let off lightly on spying penalty

News Home

Cruising

Photo Gallery

Video Gallery

Sail-World.com : America's Cup: Oracle let off lightly on spying penalty

America's Cup: Oracle let off lightly on spying penalty

'San Francisco (USA,CA), 34th America’s Cup, Oracle Team USA AC72 training' Gilles Martin-Raget: AmericasCup© Click Here to view large photo

Oracle Team USA have been left off lightly by the International Jury, who have announced their penalty for spying within the 200 metre radius permitted in the Protocol governing the 34th America's Cup.

Just before Christmas, the Int Jury, which is completely independent of race and event organisers, upheld a complaint from Italian Challenger, Luna Rossa, that the US Defender had taken photos of their AC72, within the specified 200 metre distance.

Despite some strong words in the Discussion leading to the Penalty, the Int Jury prescribed that Oracle Team USA will be prohibited from sailing either of their boats for a period of five days at the end of the next no-sail period. That period runs from February 1, 2013 to May 1, 2013 - and teams are allowed to sail for 45 days in that three month period.

The restriction on sailing days was bought in ostensibly as a cost reduction measure, the teams are currently in the first restricted period from July 1, 2012 to January 31,2013 in which they are allowed to sail 30 days maximum in the six month period. Only one team looks as if it will use all its allowed 30 days.

Oracle's penalty comes at the very end of the second and last restricted sailing period, and will probably come in handy to catch up on some boat maintenance and enhancements. After the end of the second restricted sailing period, any restrictions on sailing days will be removed completely. The US team still keeps its entire 45 sailing/training days, the only inconvenience is how they spend their allowed 45 days.

Probably more significant is the awarding of costs against the America's Cup Defender of Euro 11,500.

Oracle Team USA returned only 10 photos to Luna Rossa and the Int Jury. It is not known if any video was taken.

Both Luna Rossa and Emirates Team New Zealand sought far more substantial penalties, with each giving several options - none of which was taken on board by the International Jury.

Oracle Team USA claimed that no penalty was required as costs would be sufficient, an issue that OTUSA had conceded should be awarded against them in the Submission phase, before the penalty was announced. The 'no further penalty' view was also rejected by the Int Jury

The full Decision on the Penalty can be read by clicking here

by Richard Gladwell

Tweet

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=105141

10:34 AM Sun 30 Dec 2012GMT

Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 America's Cup

Related News Stories:

28 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Dean Barker reflects on 30 days of sailing the the AC72
27 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Short break and then the Big Push for Emirates Team NZ
27 Dec 2012	America's Cup: A look inside Oracle Team USA's building facility
23 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Merry Christmas from Emirates Team NZ
22 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Oracle found guilty as charged on Italian spy incident
21 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Oracle Team USA's second wingsail starts journey to USA
20 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Latest news - Oracle Team USA - December 19, 2012
20 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Oracle Team USA reveal state of repairs and re-launch
20 Dec 2012	America's Cup: Oracle believed to be on wrong side of spying Decision
19 Dec 2012	America's Cup: One year on for Luna Rossa

MORE STORIES ...

News - USA and the World

Maxi Soh scores double wins in CMRC Summer Doubleheader by Chicago Match Race Center,

A new day today brought wind and skies that looked more promising, starting out sunny with a perfect 8-10 knot breeze from the west-northwest. By Noon the wind had picked up to a consistent 20 knots with gusts pushing to over 30, forcing race managers to impose a no-spinnaker restriction for the day's remaining flights.... [more]

ORC World Championship - Third Course area opens for huge fleet by ORC Media,

Organizers from Kieler Yacht-Club and the Offshore Racing Congress (ORC) are pleased to announce that a third course area will be opened for competition when racing starts for the 2014 ORC World Championship on Monday, August 4th, and continues through Saturday, August 9th.... [more]

Anna Tunnicliffe On the Final two days of the Reebok CrossFit Games by Anna Tunnicliffe, Carson, CA.

Anna Tunnicliffe: We finished up the 2014 CrossFit Games with the final 3 events. I gave it my all, made the final cut and finally finished 22nd overall. The 2008 Olympic Gold Medalist in the Laser Radial class describes the final two days of the competition.... [more]

Joachim Aschenbrenner takes gold at ISAF Youth Match Race Worlds 2014 by ISAF,

Everybody was nervous in the morning as they waited for the wind to fill in. The wind was too light to start racing the important final matches. Only after 1pm the postponement was lowered and the regatta was ready to continue.... [more]

29er World Championship opening ceremonies in Confederation Park by Marianne Davis,

The ceremonies will be held at confederation Basin Park in downtown Kingston (across from Town Hall) and begin at 1815. Kingston’s own world champion Town Crier will lead the parade of 200 athletes form 14 countries. Kingston’s Honorable Mayor Mark Gerretsen and the 29er World Council Vice President Blake Macdiarmid will welcome all participants.... [more]

Land Rover Sydney Gold Coast Yacht Race Start 2014 VIDEO by Dale Lorimer, Sydney

The Land Rover Sydney Gold Coast Yacht Race start saw the fleet of 56 yachts slowly move out of Sydney Harbour under blue skies and a light north westerly breeze that dropped out totally as the boats reached the Heads. The fleet came to a complete standstill as many of the yachts drifted around under South Head lighthouse.... [more]

Laser Radial Men’s World Championship 2014- Final day by Jeff Martin,

After a clean start under a black flag Stelmaszyk held his nerve in the light 11 knot North East wind to lead the fleet round the first mark. He was caught on the downwind by Alexander Finian AUS and they rounded the opposite marks of the gate together just in front of Karolis Janulionis LTU and Rudawski.... [more]

2014 Pacific Cup - Scarlet Runner wins by Vanessa Yates, Hawaii

2014 Pacific Cup - Since crossing the finish line at 02:05:18 HST on Saturday 19 July the crew of Scarlet Runner, have been cautiously celebrating their provisional race results. Although first place in their Latitude 38 division looked likely for Robert Date's Reichel/Pugh 52, it was still possible that pending strong winds could favour the 48 other competitors still to complete their journey... [more]

Gladwell's Line: America's Cup - Joint Statement is a curious note *Feature by Richard Gladwell,

The Joint Statement issued on Friday, by four European America's Cup teams, appears to indicate a change of stance in relations between the Defender and Challengers. Most obvious absence was that of long-standing Challenger, Emirates Team New Zealand, otherwise all would have been sweetness and light.... [more]

ISAF Youth Match Racing World Champ - Top four battle it out for final by NJK,

2014 ISAF Youth Match Racing World Championship - Denmark, France, Australia and USA are fighting for a place in the ISAF Youth Match Race World Championship final.... [more]

BIC Techno 293 Worlds 2014 - Day 6 by Patrik Pollak,

2014 Techno World Championships - Wind, the ultimate master, did not allow us to sail any more races. All had to return to beach and soon they have to travel back home.... [more]

PWA Fuerteventura Grand Slam - Wind teases competitors on day 2 by Chris Yates,

Day two of the Fuerteventura PWA Grand Slam, hosted by René Egli, saw a pause in the action as the wind teased the competitors for much of the day. At 12pm it looked as though we would see another afternoon of racing, but unfortunately a thick layer of cloud soon disrupted the wind, despite the breeze threatening to return in the early evening, suitable conditions never quite materialised.... [more]

Women’s Match Race Golfe du Morbihan - Action-packed day of racing by WIM Series,

An intense day of action packed racing at the Women’s Match Race Golfe du Morbihan in Vannes, France, saw an exciting conclusion to the round robin. Despite tight racing in tough matches, all the quarter finals went through quickly with 2 – 0 scores, opening for the beginning of the semis.... [more]

Herreshoff Marine Museum announces successful fundraising campaign by Graham Humphrey,

Herreshoff Marine Museum is pleased to announce that it has successfully met the previously announced $100,000 Challenge offered by an anonymous donor. The campaign raised $172,000 for the Museum. A principal target was to engage new and re-engage former donor groups.... [more]

Brewin Dolphin Commodores' Cup - The most comprehensive victory yet by James Boyd,

Ireland's three boat team, comprising Anthony O'Leary's Ker 39 Antix, Marc Glimcher's Ker 40 Catapult and Michael Boyd and Niall Dowling's Grand Soleil 43 Quokka 8, today scored the most comprehensive victory in the 22 year history of the Commodores' Cup.... [more]

Anna Tunnicliffe holds fourth at mid-point of Reebok CrossFit Games by Anna Tunnicliffe, Carson, CA.

At the halfway point of the 2014 Reebok CrossFit Games double sailing Olympian, Anna Tunnicliffe (USA)is holding onto 4th place overall... [more]

2014 29er North American Open Championship - Australians win by Peter McIntosh, Kingston

2014 29er North American Open Championship - As the World 29er series kicks off today in Kingston, Canada, there’s no flying under the radar for Kurt Hansen and Harry Morton, who just won the North American Open at the same venue.... [more]

INSA Sabot II Invitational Regatta - Erik Hou claims victory by Rick Roberts,

Erik Hou of Newport Harbor Yacht Club won the 2014 International Naples Sabot Association (INSA) Sabot II Invitational regatta Wednesday against 25 other 6-11 year old junior sailors from Southern California yacht clubs. In the regatta hosted by Long Beach Yacht Club, Hou dominated the races held in Long Beach’s Alamitos Bay Turning Basin winning four of the five scheduled races.... [more]

CMRC Summer Invitational Series - Maxi Soh wins Doubleheader A event by Dobbs Davis,

After an ambitious program of 12 flights in the Round Robin, followed by Quarter Finals, Semi-Finals and Finals in only two days of racing, Singapore's Maxi Soh and his team of Justin Wong, Russell Kan, and Andrew Chan have emerged today as the winners of the 2014 CMRC Summer Invitational Doubleheader A event. This is the first of two ISAF Grade three events.... [more]

PWA Fuerteventura Grand Slam - First blood to Toselli and Angulo by Chris Yates,

The Fuerteventura PWA Grand Slam, hosted by René Egli, got underway in explosive fashion as the racing started promptly this afternoon, allowing the opening two eliminations to be completed. The first blood of the day went to Pascal Toselli, before Josh Angulo claimed his first bullet of the season in the second race.... [more]

Melges 24 Nationals - Record entries for 2014 and 2015 venue revealed by U.S. Melges 24 Class Association,

The 20th running of the Melges 24 U.S. National Championship will take place on November 13-16, hosted by the Davis Island Yacht Club in Tampa, FL. Already, twenty-five of the nations biggest and brightest teams have registered to race. Boats will be arriving from all over the country - Florida, Georgia, Texas, California, Michigan, Ohio, Washington and Wisconsin are on the board.... [more]

Women’s Match Race Golfe du Morbihan - Anna Kjellberg claims the lead by WIM Series,

Another calm and sunny morning at the Women’s Match Race Golfe du Morbihan in Vannes, France, was followed by a day of intense and action-packed match racing, enjoyed by the crowds on the beach. 'We’ve just lost one match so far, and that gives us great confidence approaching the weekend,' Kjellberg smiles, just before going for a cooling and refreshing swim.... [more]

Jessica Uniack Memorial Beach to Bay Race at Long Beach YC by Rick Roberts,

TJ O’Rourke of Dana Point Yacht Club finished first Thursday in the Sabot C3 class winning the perpetual trophy for first place in the largest class in the 27th annual Jessica Uniack Memorial Beach to Bay Race, hosted by Long Beach Yacht Club.... [more]

Laser Radial Men’s World Championship - Poland tops the leaderboard by SailingNet,

Day four of the Laser Radial Men’s World Championships is over. Traditionally the competitors didn’t surprise the race committee, starting with two general OCS. The weather conditions were very good. The races ran very smoothly and the last competitor crossed the finishing line at 14:57.... [more]

America's Cup - Four teams confirm full support regardless of venue by Sarah Alexander,

Joint statement from the teams Luna Rossa Challenge, Artemis Racing, Ben Ainslie Racing and Team France, who will be challenging for the 35th America’s Cup.... [more]

Plastic Classic takes place at Mariposa Hunters Point YC by Erik Simonson,

The small and funky 51 year old Bay View Boat Club, centered in the heart of one of the hottest real estate regions on the planet, is the envy of of every developer on the San Francisco Peninsula. It, and it's even funkier, smaller and older cousin just up the road, The Mariposa Hunters Point Yacht Club exist, in part of a grandfather clause via the Port of San Francisco's leasing agreement.... [more]

Six Metre European Championship - No champion declared for 2014 by Fiona Brown,

Chris Hadden and the Royal Cornwall Yacht Club's Race Committee gave it their all to achieve two races on the final day of the Six Metre European Championship, but the wind once again refused to cooperate and their best efforts were thwarted. As a result no Six Metre European Champion, Modern or Classic, could be declared for 2014.... [more]

J/Teams sail tough Chicago Mackinac Race by J/Boats,

This year’s Chicago Mackinac Race was up to its usual tricks again, offering the fleet the dilemma of starting off with breezes in the NE to SE quadrants, with a hole forming in the middle of the rhumbline on late Saturday evening after the start.... [more]

Anna Tunnicliffe wins first event of Reebok Cross Fit Games + Video by Anna Tunnicliffe, Carson, CA.

The first day at the 2014 Reebok CrossFit Games started with an event win for double sailing Olympian, Anna Tunnicliffe (USA). The second event didn't go quite as planned, but it was what it was, and now we move onto Friday's events and the rest of the competition.... [more]

2014 Pacific Cup - Skill and luck required for victory by Pacific Cup,

Winning an ocean race like the Pacific Cup requires skill, but also some luck. Unlike many previous years where a boat performance was key, this year was more of a chess match, with luck and weather analysis making a big difference. Everyone in the fleet sailed south of the rhumb line for the first third of the race, but those who remained south suffered severely.... [more]

Six Metre European Championship - Action resumes on day 4 by Fiona Brown,

After a two-day hiatus, the fourth day of the Six Metre European Championship in Falmouth finally produced a much-needed third race for the twenty-seven competing teams. The wind failed to cooperate for much of the day and it wasn't until 17.30 that the race finally started in a rainy nine knots from the northeast.... [more]

BIC Techno 293 Worlds 2014 - Day 4 by Patrik Pollak,

2014 Techno World Championships - No problem!!! We had cart world championship with some very, very attractive prizes. Some exercise, lot of fun, lot of smiles.... [more]

PWA Fuerteventura Grand Slam on the horizon by Chris Yates,

From the 25th of July to the 2nd August Fuerteventura will be returning to the forefront of the windsurfing world, as the world’s fastest sailors prepare for their third instalment of warp speed slalom, whilst the freestyle elite prepare for their second battle of the season.... [more]