sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Emirates Team NZ NZ Boating-World Cruising Video Gallery FishingBoating Photo Gallery Features
Newsletter Subscribe MarineBusiness-World

 

Sail-World.com : America's Cup document says RNZYS against Protocol

America's Cup document says RNZYS against Protocol

'Emirates Team NZ are claimed to have signed a letter condemning the 33rd Protocol for the America’s Cup'    MCC McCamp    Click Here to view large photo

Documents filed with the New York State Supreme Court claim that Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron's racing team, Emirates Team New Zealand, was one of six signatories, who had strong objections to the Protocol for the 33rd America's Cup.

Their opposition has, to date, been kept out of the public spotlight but excerpts from the document signed by the racing teams associated with RNZYS and Deutscher Challenger Yacht Club (Team Germany) are mentioned in a Memorandum of Law filed by New York legal firm, Latham & Watkins, acting for BMW Oracle Racing, the team of Golden Gate Yacht Club.

The letter signed by the Challengers says, in part, 'In our collective role as past Challengers and prospective Challengers, our opinion is that this Protocol is the worst text in the history of the America’s Cup and more fundamentally, it lacks precisely the mutual consent items which are required..'

Two new documents have been filed. The first by Tom Ehman of BMW Oracle Racing which sets out a list of the Challengers of Record since the inception of the America’s Cup. The purpose of this document is to offset claims by the Defender, Societe Nautique de Geneve, that there is precedent for the 'paper club' accepted as Challenger of Record for the 2009 America’s up. It was this action and the Protocol agreed between the two, that triggered the current brouhaha.

Two New Zealand yacht clubs are at the centre of these claims. First the RNZYS, which SNG claim was not incorporated until 2003, after it lost the America’s Cup. The second is Mercury Bay BC, which in spite of having a car for a clubhouse, had been organised as a yacht club for almost forty years - rather than the matter of days for the current CoR, Club Nautico Espanol de Vela.

One of the arguments advanced by SNG has been the fact that because five challengers have entered the 2009 America’s Cup, that they have, by definition, supported the Protocol for that event, and are in agreement with it.

The Memorandum of Law filed by Golden Gate YC’s addresses on this point:

'In a transparent effort to show support for its violation of the Deed, SNG argues that four 'accomplished and experienced sailing teams' have 'signed on to join SNG and CNEV to race' under the Protocol.. SNG falls to advise this Court that three of those challengers have publicly objected to the Protocol and CNEV’s challenge, either directly or through their racing representatives. On July 16, 2007, the racing representatives of Deutscher Challenger Yacht Club and the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron ('RNZYS'), were among the six signatories (all of which were distinguished yacht clubs and racing representatives that participated in the 32d America’s Cup) to a letter setting out the reasons why the Protocol is entirely unacceptable..

The letter provides:

'In our collective role as past Challengers and prospective Challengers, our opinion is that this Protocol is the worst text in the history of the America’s Cup and more fundamentally, it lacks precisely the mutual consent items which are required....

'You are well aware that serious questions have been raised about the legitimacy of the newly created and purely instrumental entity called 'Club Nautico Espanol' to advance a Challenge under the provisions of the Deed of Gift. In the sincerest hope that the America’s Cup competition will not have to endure the turmoil associated with litigating that issue, but will rather move forward with balanced and fair procedures and protocols that have historically characterized this competition, we ask you to dissolve 'Club Nautico Espanol' and withdraw your Challenge within the month of July 2007.

'When recently asked '[w]hat don’t you like about the protocol?' the Commodore of the Royal New Zealand Yacht Squadron ('RNZYS') said 'Everything!'

'Similarly, the Captain of South Africa’s team Shosholoza, which has also challenged under SNG’s Protocol, stated that 'CNEV does not have the required qualifications to be CoR [Challenger of Record] in my opinion.'.

'Indeed, even the Commodore of RNZYS, one of the current challengers for.the 33rd America’s Cup, after becoming a challenger, conceded that CNEV is illegitimate. When asked 'Does it matter that Desaflo isn’t represented by an established yacht club, since it wasn’t last time?' responded that 'It shouldn’t have been allowed last time.'. '


The Memorandum of Law traverses many points raised by SNG, and runs to 23 pages and it seems that the decision of the New York Supreme Court will come down to interpreting the meaning of words in the Deed of Gift to determine whether or not Club Nautico de Vela is in compliance.

Two key words are 'fulfilling' and 'having' which SNG argue have an acceptable meaning of intention to comply at some time in the future. Where Golden Gate YC argue that the words have a past tense meaning only, meaning that there is a 'tick-box' exercise to be conducted and that the challenging Club must already have met the criteria set out in the Deed of Gift.

One of the ways of testing the interpretation by SNG is to logically extend the word’s implied meaning into other areas, and to give these a 'sanity check'.

Back to the Memorandum of Law, looking at the meaning and implications of the word 'fulfilling':

'CNEV’s notice of challenge cannot preempt a subsequent challenge from a yacht club that has met the conditions of the Deed, such as GGYC. The Deed of Gift is explicit: 'when a challenge from a Club fulfilling all the conditions required by this instrument has been received' no subsequent challenge can be considered. (emphasis added).

''Fulfilling all the conditions required' means what it says. For example, the term 'fulfilling is used in the New York education law that empowers the Board of Regents to 'endorse a license upon the applicant fulfilling the following requirements: . . . Age: be at least 21'. The age requirement in this statutory example would be rendered meaningless if 'fulfilling' meant qualifying sometime in the future. 'Fulfilling' here means possessing the 21 year old minimum age. Otherwise, an 18-year old could qualify because he was in the process of becoming a 21-year old.

'This entirely obliterates SNG’s fanciful interpretation of the Deed that would permit an unqualified challenger to become qualified at some indefinite time in the future. It renders irrelevant CNEV’s Chairman’s statements that CNEV intends to become 'a normal club' and that he undertakes to have a CNEV regatta.

'It is undisputed that GGYC, the Challenger of Record for the 32nd America’s Cup is a 'Club fulfilling all the conditions required by this instrument.' As of July 11, 2007, the date on which GGYC noticed its challenge, CNEV was not an organized yacht club
'

The other word in question is 'having', and the believed requirement by GGYC that in order to qualify as Challenger of Record a club must already have staged an annual regatta on an ocean course. SNG argued that the intention to hold such a regatta was sufficient to comply with this requirement.

The Memorandum of Law has a long hard look at this one, too:

'Any fair reading of the plain language of the Deed’s requirement, '[a]ny organized Yacht Club. . .having for its annual regatta an ocean course,' would conclude it means that to be eligible the yacht club must have an annual regatta.. SNG contends that the Deed means only that the club must undertake to have an annual regatta at some undefined time in the future —just so it can meet this requirement. SNG’s only support for this is the assertion that 'the Deed uses the word ‘having’ which, fairly read, includes past, present or future regattas.'. SNG cites no authority whatsoever for this outlandish distortion of the text. SNG’s reading defies logic and contradicts standard usage.

'First, by SNG’s logic, a 'person having a law degree' could practice law wit




by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World NZL

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=38068

8:06 AM Mon 8 Oct 2007 GMT






Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 America's Cup

Related News Stories:

29 Sep 2014  America's Cup: Oracle Team USA's AC72 takes to the streets
27 Sep 2014  America's Cup: Then and now - Coutts on why Oracle won, and the Venue
09 Aug 2014  America's Cup: Former Artemis crew member says danger is being ignored
27 May 2014  America's Cup: Oracle Team USA under stress
23 May 2014  America's Cup: Oracle and Team NZ designers reveal AC72 secrets
22 May 2014  America's Cup: Artemis death verdict 'result of an human act'
10 May 2014  A year after the Artemis incident, the sailors tell of the pain
01 May 2014  America's Cup: Oracle and Team NZ tech insights - Free lecture tonight
16 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Expected de Ridder penalty should be reduced
14 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Dean Barker's Blog - A sail with the Duke and Duchess
MORE STORIES ...

News - New Zealand & the World

November 27, 2014: The NZD has been impacted by weaker commodities (mainly dairy) but not to the extent of its ANZAC partner. The KIWI trades back towards 0.7900 while the cross has spiked north. China remains crucial to commodity demand and all signs point to a slowing in demand. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: The Traemeister's onboard gym session *Feature by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz
On Board Reporter, Brian Carlin, claimed he did not know what a Gym before he set foot aboard Team Vestas Wind. And then compounded his issues by saying that he thought 'Gym' was pronounced 'Gime'. Fitness freak Trae has taken on the invidious task of getting the Irish OBM up to a passable fitness level, believed to be 100 push-ups. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Thanksgiving at Sea *Feature by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz
Although they may be far from home, old traditions aren't forgotten as the US crew aboard Team Alvimedica celebrate one of the great traditions. And the non-US crew partake of their first Thanksgiving, off the coast of Madagascar. There's some of the traditional fare, adapted for the Volvo Ocean Race, and some messages and mementos from home. ... [more]  

Overall race leader, Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing Has slipped in the Volvo Ocean Race having led for most of Leg 2, and won Leg 1. But as has been done before Abu Dhabi has caught up, and now playing storm-watch. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - The official launch of Syd Fischer’s super maxi, Ragamuffin 100, will take place next Tuesday, 2 December 2014, at Sydney City Marine Complex, Rozelle. ... [more]  

Oceanair has launched two new producst at METS, the worlds largest international boatshow, held in The Netherlands. Oceanair’s innovative SKYSOL Mini pleated blind has been designed specifically for portlights with cost and quality in mind. The second new product released is SKYSOL Precision, a cost-effective, compact pleated blind for yacht windows ... [more]  

The new application from PredictWind for Mac and PC is revolutionary for accessing weather data when offshore. Accessing GRIB files, Weather Routing, GMDSS forecasts and Satellite Imagery is now a simple task with the unique and user friendly interface. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Mapfre takes lead in Leg 2 as break point looms *Feature by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz
The latest position report from Volvo Ocean Race Control has given the lead in leg 2 of the Volvo Ocean Race to Mapfre (Iker Martinez). She takes over the lead from Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing (Ian Walker), who has led from soon after the start of Leg 2, a week ago. ... [more]  

Over 270 sailors from 38 nations have enjoyed a mixed range of conditions since their arrival early on in the week. The athletes have used the time to acclimatise to their surroundings, different sea states and a variety of wind strengths. But now, the practice time is over with racing across the ten Olympic and open kiteboarding fleets to kick start the inaugural ISAF Sailing World Cup Final. ... [more]  

VOR 2014-15: Some of them also wake up in the middle of the night to check the latest position reports of Team Brunel. The crew is aware of that, including our skipper Bouwe Bekking. 'We are not the only ones looking out for the position reports. We know that the home front is eyeballing every move of us. Our wives, children, girlfriends, friends and supporters live this race as extreme as we.' ... [more]  

ISAF Sailing World Cup Final 2014: Among the ten Olympic series represented, Franck Cammas will be participating in the event for the first time aboard a Nacra 17, this time teaming up with the young, light Alizée Desbordes. Having remained in France to satisfy her professional obligations, Sophie de Turckheim will be following the performance of her favourite helm closely. ... [more]  

November 26, 2014: The AUD has dropped back to four year lows, falling below 0.8600, a more than 50% retracement from technical highs. The AUD is under siege and the KIWI has been infected, now testing 0.7800, on the downside. ... [more]  

ISAF Sailing World Cup Final: Bjorn Allansson (SWE), Briana Provancha (USA), Sofia Bekatorou (GRE), Lara Vadlau (AUT) and Anton Paz (ESP) have fully embraced the Abu Dhabi and Emirati life, grasping the opportunities available with both hands. 'There are so many welcoming and friendly people here,' explained Provancha at the opening press conference. ... [more]  

Leading sailing marine electronics manufacturer B&G has been appointed an Official Race Supplier for the Volvo Ocean Race 2014/15. B&G will also be providing full electronic navigation systems, tactical software and race support to the organisers of the 2014 Volvo Ocean Race, which began on the October 4th in Alicante, Spain. ... [more]  

The first animated trim app 'sailtrim upwind one' is available for Android at the Google Play Store and also in the App Store for iPhone and iPad. The application makes it fun and easy for users to learn what happens when you operate different trim elements on a sailing boat. ... [more]  

If you missed this week's edition of Adventures of a Sailor Girl, then hear the replay below. Adventures of a Sailor Girl #31 - Pathways and passion! ... [more]  

Star Sailors League Finals: This Bahaman event is about much more than just sailing, however: it promises a blistering week of high emotion, passion and dazzlingly action that will deliver a unique display of sporting prowess from a slew of champions. All in an easy-to-grasp and see format that even non-sailing folk will understand perfectly. ... [more]  

America's Cup: Sweden to host World Series regatta in 2015 by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz
Artemis Racing and the City of Gothenburg are set to host an America’s Cup World Series event during the last weekend of August (28th - 30th) 2015. Racing will take place either on the Gota River close to the city centre, or at Långedrag, and the race village will be located in Frihamnen. ... [more]  

2014 Extreme Sailing Series - Act 8 - Tom Slingsby, Australian Olympic Laser Gold medalist, and member of Oracle Team USA, has signed up as skipper of Oman Air, one of two Oman Sail Extreme Sailing teams, for the final act of the Extreme Sailing Series in Sydney, Australia (11-14 December). ... [more]  

Top Volvo Ocean Race correspondent, navigator and sailing analyst, Mark Chisnell writes a regular report for B&G on the current race and trends he sees developing. This week he reviews the first week of action in Leg 2 as the teams leave Cape Town for Abu Dhabi: ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Big spread in fleet as Abu Dhabi leads *Feature by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com/nz
Abu Dhabi (Ian Walker) continues to lead the Volvo Ocean Race. She is the most westerly of the fleet as they approach the coast of Madagascar. In a video, Abu Dhabi skipper Ian Walker explains the weather hazards of the second leg of the Volvo Ocean Race. ... [more]  

November 25, 2014: The single currency bounced to 1.2430 while the GBP jumped to 1.5700. These are likely dead-cat bounces as the EUR drifts towards 1.2000! Commodity currencies gave up some of last weeks gains, with the KIWI falling back to 0.7850, while the AUD was the big loser. The AUDUSD fell to 0.8615 impaired by the reality of the Chinese interest rate cut. ... [more]  

ISAF Sailing World Cup Final 2014: With a packed crowd of local dignitaries, VIPS and competitors, the ISAF President welcomed the world’s finest Olympic sailors and kiteboarders who will be battling it out on Abu Dhabi's waters. 'It’s a great honour for me to be here today because we have a very important regatta which will be the future of our sport,' explained Croce. ... [more]  

Sir Keith Mills GBE announced that America’s Cup Racing is to return to British waters when the America’s Cup World Series (ACWS) takes place in Portsmouth 23-26 July 2015 and 21–24 July 2016. The second European location is expected to be Cagliari in Italy, where Luna Rossa Challenge have their base. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Welcome to Brian's Gime *Feature by Brian Carlin, Team Vestas Wind, At sea
The irrepressible Brian Carlin, the On Board Reporter for Team Vestas Wind is on fitness program on board, under the watchful eye of race veteran Tony Rae. Today as my personal trainer, friend and fellow shipmate we accomplished a goal, 70 press-ups. I’m sure to some it maybe easy but I ask anyone of you right now sitting at your desk, hit the floor and give me 70 on the spot. ... [more]  

Two of the crew from Overall race leader, Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing look at leg 2 and the race overall. Here are the latest blogs (unedited) from On Board Reporter Matt Knighton, along with an onboard video with Simon Fisher (navigator) musing on what is required to win the race, and skipper Ian Walker on how Leg 2 has panned out for them so far. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014 - A new deal for corinthians by Bruce Montgomery – Rolex Sydney Hobart media
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014: Since 1945 starters in the Sydney-Hobart have raced the equivalent of two circumnavigations of the world, almost 45,000 nautical miles. They have been drawn from the seven seas; they come from all corners of the world; they board boats that range from 100-feet supermaxis to boats littler larger than the Owl and the Pussycat’s. ... [more]  

2016 Hansa Class Combined World and International Championships - The International Hansa Class Association has announced that the 2016 Hansa Class Combined World and International Championships will be held in the Netherlands. ... [more]  

More than forty five years since his historical circumnavigation, legendary Clipper Race founder Sir Robin Knox-Johnston, 75, continues to prove inspirational to adventurers around the globe. Sir Robin, the oldest entrant in the 3,542 mile Route du Rhum, finished third in his Rhum class into La Pointe À Pitre, Guadeloupe. ... [more]  

With Olympic heroes and World Champions in their numbers at the ISAF Sailing World Cup Final in Abu Dhabi, UAE, local children are being inspired to take up the sport. By utilising the star names on show at the ISAF Sailing World Cup Final, the Abu Dhabi Sailing and Yacht Club, hosts of the regatta, are using the event to promote the sport in the Emirati capital. ... [more]  

The last day of the Airwaves Noumea PWA Dream Cup saw a grandstand finale to the 2014 PWA World Tour as the morning showers finally cleared to allow the wind to fill in and the respective titles to be decided. With the racing beginning later than scheduled the title race came down to one final race, which would ultimately decide the title. ... [more]  

Olympic medal-winning skipper Ian Walker, from Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing (ADOR) – the emirate’s Volvo Ocean Race contesting squad – recently took time out of his hectic schedule while he was in Cape Town, as the team prepared for Leg 2 of the race to catch-up with students at The British School Al Khubairat via a video call. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15 – Corinna Halloran reports on day five of leg 2 for Team SCA. Team SCA has a super fan. She’s seven and, at home, she has posters of Team SCA on her wall. As a member of the team, and as a woman in 2014, this is extremely cool. ... [more]  

2014 Oceania Marine Technician Grand Prix
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final: Abu Dhabi Sailing Instructions published
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final - Italian 49erFX duo ready for action
Volvo Ocean Race: Racing between a Rock and a Hard Place
Volvo Ocean Race - Position report at: 24 Nov 0700 UTC
2014 RC44 Championship Tour trophy – Video highlights
Volvo Ocean Race - Position report at: 23 Nov 1930 UTC
Volvo Ocean Race - Position report at: 23 Nov 0748 UTC
Gladwell's Line: The America's Cup is now Bermuda's Cup? *Feature
RC44 Oman Cup - Nika wins and Team Aqua clinch their fourth RC44 title
RMSIR 2014 – Last Gasp. A Champion, and 36 winners
Harken International Youth MR Regatta - An exciting final day
18ft Skiffs: Club Championship, Cordukes Clubhouse Trophy - Race three
RMSIR 2014 - first inshore races in Langkawi
Volvo Ocean Race: On board with Abu Dhabi - torn sail and where to go? *Feature
2014 Argo Group Gold Cup - Bermuda shines
Airwaves Noumea PWA Dream Cup - Delphine Cousin officially world champ
Volvo Ocean Race: A man's got to do what a man's got to do
RC44 Championship Tour - A great sailing day on the Gulf of Oman
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final - Open Formula Kiteboarding event preview
2014 Harken Int'l Youth MR Regatta - ANZAC test between four finalists   
Volvo Ocean Race: Fleet heads into the Southern Ocean + Videos *Feature   
ISAF Sailing World Cup Final - Set to be an 'experience of a lifetime'   
America's Cup: Source named in Bermuda venue leak *Feature   
2014 RC44 Oman Cup - Challenging day + Videos   
Volvo Ocean Race: A bumpy, hard driving ride in the Southern Ocean   
Yates Cup: US supermaxi Rio100 wins first offshore race + Video *Feature   
Airwaves Noumea PWA Dream Cup - Men’s title race takes a twist   
RC44 Oman Cup - Consistency hard to come by   
Volvo Ocean Race - Rapid change for Team SCA   
ZK Seaboots from Zhik - Keeping your feet cosy and dry this winter!   
Collinson FX Market Commentary: Nov 21 - NZD moves up   
Yates Cup: Images from the front of the fleet *Feature   
Burling and Tuke named for New Zealand Sailing’s Top Honour for 2014   
2014 Harken International Youth MR Regatta - Anyon surprises on Day 1   
GC32 Racing Tour 2015 - Dates and venues   
RMSIR 2014 – Penang to Langkawi. An espresso race   
Spectacular performance by Bakewell-White maxi early in first race *Feature   
Airwaves Noumea PWA Dream Cup - Big strides for Cousin and Moussilmani   
America's Cup: Team New Zealand responds to Venue rumours *Feature   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL WAS NZ
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT