sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Cruising Australia Cruising USA Cruising Canada Boats for Sale Sail-World Racing Photo Gallery FishingBoating
Newsletters Video Gallery
Sail-World.com : Yachting New Zealand makes stand on Aquaculture intrusion on cruisers
Yachting New Zealand makes stand on Aquaculture intrusion on cruisers

'The pristine waterways of Marlborough Sounds seem destined to be taken over by the expanded aquaculture industry.'    . ©    Click Here to view large photo

Yachting NZ represents 31,000 subscribed club members and over 200 affiliated organisations -  Yachting NZ  
A New Zealand national sports organisation, Yachting New Zealand has issued a statement setting out the organisation's position on legislation and application and licence approvals that will enable the aquaculture industry to achieve its goal of becoming a $1 billion contributor to the New Zealand economy.


Many believe this legislation and the applications which stem from a quadrupling of the output of the industry will have a major detrimental impact on the New Zealand recreational and environment.

Yachting New Zealand represents 31,000 members in 123 yacht clubs from Taipa in the north to Bluff in the south – also affiliated are 50 class associations and 40 maritime associations. Yachting New Zealand says it has taken this this position in support of their affiliated clubs and boaties, sailors and powerboat users alike.

The statement issued by Yachting New Zealand reads:

Yachting New Zealand (YNZ) feels it is timely to reiterate its position on aquaculture development. This is due to the passing of the Aquaculture Legislation Amendment Bill earlier this year and the increasing number of significant new applications for marine farms being made which are causing serious concern.

Mussel farm on the prime cruising ground off the Coromandel coast - a farm in this area is illegal and has been so for 10 years. -  Christine Hansen   Click Here to view large photo


Yachting New Zealand seeks to ensure that:
-Aquaculture development takes place in areas where there will be no adverse effect on the community’s access to the coastal marine area (CMA) for recreational use.
-That government (central, regional and local) place appropriate weight on the importance of recreational boating concerns.
-That any aquaculture structures are illuminated and marked in a way that they are visible in all conditions.
-That all proprietors of farms are required to pay an adequate bond to cover removal of structures once farms outlive their usefulness.
-That government (central, regional and local) consider the impact any new farms will have on local tourism and marine industries.

David Abercrombie, CEO, Yachting New Zealand -  .. .  
David Abercrombie, Yachting New Zealand’s CEO outlines his organisation’s position on this matter, 'Yachting New Zealand is not opposed to aquaculture per se, however aquaculture and much of the activity YNZ promotes and protects is mutually exclusive; the physical nature of aquaculture means that it will take up space in the marine coastal area that then cannot be used by others and/or will pose navigational hazards in some areas'.

'Yachting New Zealand considers that it is important that aquaculture development takes place in areas where there will be no adverse effect on the community’s access to the water for recreational use.'

It is recognised in the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010 that aquaculture should be placed in appropriate areas. The term 'appropriate' needs to be more clearly defined within regional coastal plans and Government policy.

The recent change in legislation has simplified the processes involved in applying for space in CMA and setting up farms, and is accordingly more encouraging of development. The New Zealand Government is also making no secret that it is pushing aquaculture growth and encouraging regional government to facilitate new applications. We can be sure that we will lose coastal area to marine farms over time. It is important that we focus our efforts on protecting areas of importance to recreational boating.

It should be noted that marine farms have an influence over a wider area than their immediate footprint. For example, it is illegal for vessels to empty holding tanks within 1 kilometre of a marine farm.

Tests needed to protect cruising rights
High level chart view of the Marlborough Sounds showing areas designated for aquaculture -     Click Here to view large photo
Yachting New Zealand wants to ensure suitable tests are put into Regional Policy Statements and Regional Coastal Plans to protect against adverse effects of establishing marine farms.

Policies should take into account the effect aquaculture has on:
- Access by boaties to water to valued/used parts of the CMA
- Navigational hazards
- Enjoyment and appreciation of inshore environments

Yachting New Zealand is particularly focussed on:
- Inshore waters for small sailboat racing
- Bays, passages and coastal area used for cruising
- Sheltered anchorages for safe day and overnight stays
- Ports of refuge in foul weather
- Navigational hazards posed by imposed structures
- Common navigational passages used by boaties
- Areas of high use for diving and recreational fishing
- Areas with high natural character and/or high amenity values
- Future tourism

Such a test exists and is written in to legislation for recreational and commercial fishing, known as the UAE test (Undue Adverse Effects test). If a prospective aquaculture development does not pass this test it cannot progress to the resource consent stage. YNZ sought a similar approach to be taken that recognises the effects listed above. YNZ and other submitters put this forward to the Select Committee considering submissions on the now passed Aquaculture Legislation Amendment Bill but were largely ignored. It is important that YNZ and clubs are active in making submissions on reviews and changes to Regional Policy Statements and Coastal Plans to try and ensure that these matters are adequately covered by policy and rules and to try and exclude aquaculture from the most valued areas as non- complying or prohibited activities (or maintain existing restrictions in the face of plan change requests from the industry).

Beatrix Bay in the Marlborough Sounds - most of it has been allocated to aquaculture in its various forms -     Click Here to view large photo
The RMA process remains the only opportunity to oppose an application and we have yet to see whether the consent process under the RMA will adequately provide for submitter concerns given the uneven playing field created by the new legislation and pressure from central government. It is noted that quite apart from the changes to the Aquaculture legislation there other changes have been made to the RMA which will compress the time frames for consent hearing and in some cases remove appeal rights. There has already been one significant application referred to a Board of Inquiry (BOI). The time frame for putting a case before a BOI is very tight indeed and there are no rights of appeal to the Environment Court.

Appeal costs prohibitive for clubs
There is a concern that if the considerations previously outline are not adequately allowed for in the resource consent process that many yacht clubs will be faced with appealing decisions at great cost, and where they cannot afford to appeal or to run a proper case on appeal, they may face losing some of their traditional sailing and cruising grounds. This would see a weakening of our sailing and boating culture in New Zealand and potentially have an adverse affect on New Zealand being a destination for foreign cruising vessels.

Changes in legislation that more easily allow for the establishment of marine farms put our community yacht and boating clubs at risk. These clubs will now have to fight each individual resource consent application that puts their sailing waters in jeopardy. Most New Zealand clubs are very small and have financial resources that pale in comparison to those of the large aquaculture companies’, this can limit the extent to which they can fight applications meaning some may just have to 'roll over'. A current example is of a company having spent up to $6 million on an application to expand salmon fishing in the Marlborough Sounds.

For any successful application there should be minimum requirements placed on the applicants which include marking structures so they are visible in all conditions and a requirement to remove structures once they outlive their usefulness.

Aquaculture structures can become safety hazards for vessels. For any structure it is imperative that it is adequately lit, adequately marked and properly charted. Yachting New Zealand seeks that any new structures are not placed where they will intrude into the path of popular navigation routes. YNZ also seeks that there should be a requirement on farm proprietors to take all reasonable and appropriate steps to publicise the existence of a new farm to reduce the risk of collisions. There is also a suggestion that this should extend to updating existing charts and navigational software

For all successful marine farm applications, Yachting New Zealand seeks to have a bond requirement placed on the applicant. This will ensure that when a farm outlives its usefulness, lease expires, or the company no longer wishes to continue farming that site, that a resource is available to remove all parts of the structure and return the marine coastal area to its natural, pre-farm state. The danger of not doing this is evident in bays such as Beatrix Bay in the Marlborough Sounds where there are a number of disused farms left to rot creating an unsightly wreck on the coastal landscape and prohibiting safe anchorage due to the remaining debris.

Irreversible environmental damage by sea farms
The environmental impact caused by aquaculture must be carefully considered; the effect that the farms have on the sea bed and sea life in the area surrounding farms can be irreversible and requires further research.

The benefit of aquaculture growth needs to be considered against the negative impact it could have on the tourism industry in high value areas where tourism is a major economic contributor such as the Bay of Islands. In Northland alone, tourism brings in approximately $592 million per annum via 5.451 million visitors with 7114 people employed in the industry. In comparison, the aquaculture industry earns $19 million a year in revenue, with 336 people employed in Northland (figures sourced from the Ministry of Economic Development, Northland Regional Council and Envico).

Mussel farm off Waiheke Island, Hauraki Gulf the Government’s objective is to take four times the current area for sea farming -  Christine Hansen   Click Here to view large photo


Reducing the value of the New Zealand’s cruising grounds through the taking up of space with marine farms has potential to impact the Marine Industry. Many overseas super yachts come to New Zealand for its prime cruising waters and will undergo refits and maintenance while here. If New Zealand is a less desirable cruising destination then yacht owners may go elsewhere reducing income in both in the Marine and Tourism industries.

Figures identifying employment opportunities that are regularly published and bandied about by the industry are often misleading. Many of these jobs disappear once a farm is built and operational. The industry needs to separate the short term employment numbers building farming structures, and the long term numbers of those that remain as permanent employees.

Yachting New Zealand feels Government (central, regional and local) need to recognise New Zealand’s maritime culture and history along with the high recreation value of our coastal marine area. Inshore waters are used by over 450,000 recreational craft.

Growth in aquaculture in New Zealand needs a balanced, well considered and well managed approach. Government needs to be wary of overly permissive rules for the aquaculture industry and economic gains at the expense of our environment and natural playground that makes New Zealand such a strong maritime country.

Sea farms are a navigational hazard - an issue that will only increase under Government proposals for a four fold increase. -  Christine Hansen   Click Here to view large photo


To our clubs:
Yachting New Zealand and clubs will need to be vigilant as to new applications for coastal permits for aquaculture, and applications by the industry for plan changes that facilitate that obtaining of consents. Appropriate submissions will need to be lodged by clubs and in some cases YNZ.

We will also need to be vigilant as to Council initiated Policy Statement and Coastal Plan changes or reviews which impact on aquaculture. Councils will be under significant pressure and influence from the industry to make changes favourable to the industry. Sadly, we cannot simply trust Councils to make appropriate decisions and not fall in to the trap of short term gains without consideration of long term consequences.

There will be increasing pressure on volunteer and financial resources as a result. We will need to 'pick our fights' and collaborate with others who have an interest in protecting the coastal environment.












by Sail-World

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=90783

7:48 AM Wed 16 Nov 2011GMT


Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.


Related News Stories:

29 Mar 2012  Windy sailing for Splash Nationals
29 Mar 2012  JP Tobin takes Bronze Medal in RS:X Worlds in Spain
29 Mar 2012  Third time lucky for Team Vodafone in Auckland to Tauranga race?
29 Mar 2012  Strong New Zealand Team head to Maersk Paper Tiger Internationals
26 Mar 2012  BMW Auckland Cup: A boisterous and spectacular final day + Video
24 Mar 2012  2012 Round NZ Race: From start to finish
24 Mar 2012  BMW Auckland Regatta: Champagne racing conditions on Day 2 + Video
23 Mar 2012  BMW Auckland Cup: Light winds test fleet on Day 1 + Video
22 Mar 2012  2012 BMW Auckland Regatta gearing up for big battles
22 Mar 2012  Wetas go Volvo chasing
MORE STORIES ...






Sail-World Cruising News - local and the World

The record-setting North American winter of 2015 has left us with all kinds of remarkable images, most of them of snow and ice. But a photographer on Nantucket found something most of us have never seen – nearly frozen waves. ... [more]  

Coast Guard crews continue the search Monday for Richard Byhre, the 76-year-old sailor who did not return from his sailing trip as expected. ... [more]  

Rio de Janeiro's state environmental agency says it is investigating a fish die-off that has left thousands of carcasses floating in waters where sailing events are to be held when Brazil hosts next year's Olympics. ... [more]  

The Salty Dawg Rally (SDR), a cruising rally that has quickly grown to be the most popular one of its kind on the U.S. East Coast, announces the Spring 2015 rally plans, when members of the SDR once again sail out of their ‘Winter headquarters’ in the Caribbean and head home for the warmer months of the year. ... [more]  

Dutch Chief Mate suspended following tragic yacht incident by Maritime and Coastguard Agency Press
On the 8th June 2014 the 'Shoreway', a 98 metre 5000 tonne dredger, owned by Koninklijke Boskalis Westminster NV, collided with a Moody 31 sailing yacht 'Orca' at the entrance to the River Orwell in Suffolk. At the helm of the Shoreway at the time was Mr Gerardus Chapel who was employed as Chief Mate. ... [more]  

Last year, OceansWatch trialled a Climate Change adaptation program in two communities in the Solomon Islands which have been identified as one of the countries that will be most affected by the rising sea levels and increased storm conditions. The low coral atolls where we work are especially vulnerable. ... [more]  

Sailors for the Sea and Cruising Club of America will work together to encourage sailors to become stewards of the ocean. Sailors for the Sea, a leading conservation organization that engages, educates, inspires and activates the sailing and boating community toward healing the ocean, will partner with the Cruising Club of America (CCA), an international organization of over 1,300 sailors ... [more]  

Safety at Sea seminar is being held on Saturday, March 14 at SSYC. Before you head offshore to cruise or race, join us for the most authoritative daylong seminar on safe seamanship, heavy weather tactics, weather forecasting, communications and boat preparation. ... [more]  

The European Commission considers a Greek cruising tax introduced at the end of 2013 to be lawful following concerns from Britain's Royal Yachting Association (RYA). Although it has yet to be implemented, the new Circulation Tax (TPP) applicable to all boats over 7m sailing in Greek waters, has now been ruled lawful by the European Commission. This report by Yachting World. ... [more]  

Rescued Australian father and son are recovering fast by Sean Flynn | The Newport Daily News
The Australian father and son who were rescued from their 43-foot sailboat Sunday morning in 60-mph winds and 25-foot waves two days after setting out from Jamestown were recovering Monday at the Coast Guard Air Station in Forestdale, Mass., a village in Sandwich. ... [more]  

Airbnb may a popular 'peer-to-peer' lodging site on the web, but if you want to rent a boat in your local area or away, you’ve got options, too. Boatbound.com, Boatsetter.com and Cruzin.com are just a few of the new crop of online websites offering a chance to rent a boat for the day or weekend. ... [more]  

Australian father-son duo delays trip back home by By Matt Sheley | The Newport Daily News
Lousy weather and a wonky autopilot kept the 43-foot sailboat Sedona docked Monday at the Conanicut Marina in downtown Jamestown. Australians Reg and Jason McGlashan rode out the snow in the boat’s cabin, waiting for a marine electrician to show up and fix its electrical system. ... [more]  

Reg and Jason McGlashan spent the weekend getting ready to embark on the journey of a lifetime. In freezing weather, the father-and-son team prepared the 43-foot sailboat 'Sedona' for their 8,600-nautical-mile trip back home to Port Macquarie, Australia. ... [more]  

With shark encounters and bites on the rise, Lindsay Lyon, Shark Advocate and Managing Director of Shark Shield, the world’s only proven shark deterrent technology, provides his tips on preventing a shark attack as the last days of summer roll in. ... [more]  

The National Marine Manufacturers Association (NMMA) and Boating Writers International (BWI) announced today winners of the 2015 Progressive Insurance Miami International Boat Show Innovation Awards, presented during the annual Industry Breakfast at the Miami Beach Convention Center. ... [more]  

The Baja Ha-Ha… The 750-mile cruiser rally from San Diego to Cabo San Lucas beckons with adventure, fun and memories-to-be-made. This year 171 boats and 525 participants answered the call. ... [more]  

Oceans of Hope is a Sailing Sclerosis Foundation project that aims to change perceptions of Multiple Sclerosis (MS), inspiring people with the disease to overcome their own personal challenges by telling the stories of those taking part in the first ever circumnavigation by a yacht crewed by people with MS. ... [more]  

Tropical Cyclone Marcia is moving quickly through the Coral Sea towards the Queensland coast. The recent movement has been to the southwest, and it is expected to maintain this general motion through to landfall on the eastern Queensland coast between St Lawrence and Bundaberg early on Friday. Tropical Cyclone Marcia is expected to slowly intensify, with the possibility of reaching category 2 inte ... [more]  

Between 18th-25th May 2015 I will spend 7 days and nights in a life raft in Portland Marina, Portland Harbour, Dorset. This is a twofold exercise, firstly to raise money for Great Ormond Street Hospital families centre, and secondly to allow Professor Mike Tipton and his team at Plymouth University conduct experiments on me. ... [more]  

Fusion®, a worldwide leader in marine audio, announced today the release of its revolutionary high-performance marine audio systems, the Fusion 750 and 650 True-Marine™ Entertainment Series. Approaching audio engineering from the perspective of the boat enthusiast and incorporating the latest marine technologies and environmental protection ... [more]  

Boat owners cruising in Turkish waters are facing more difficulties because a new law regarding Residence Permits is confusing everyone concerned. ... [more]  

I was ruined...completely and utterly ruined. At the young age of 22, my very first trip to the Caribbean was to Eleuthera, which is, in my opinion, the most beautiful place on earth. It will now be an uphill battle for me to surpass my visit there. ... [more]  

RYA Suzuki Dinghy Show 2015 - Over the weekend of 28 February-01 March everything you ever wanted to know about dinghy sailing plus hundreds of boats, brands and kit can be all be found under one roof at Alexandra Palace, North London. ... [more]  

Don Macpherson developed a passion for sailing in his twenties while cruising with his father, a navigator in the US Navy, on the family Swan 57. ... [more]  

OCA Series - Face the fear with Julie Salisbury as she takes you on a journey at sea, encountering sharks and jellyfish, complete darkness alone 1,000 miles from land, battling malaria, a debilitating back injury, and being jilted in Malaysia and left alone with no money, friends, or home. ... [more]  

Dominica has been on 'the' list for quite some time now and when I actually get to do something on 'the' list, my heart skips a beat! Although Dominica still remains somewhat off-the-beaten track for boaters, it is located right in the middle of the chain of Caribbean islands and can be easily accessed from Antigua and Guadeloupe to the north or Martinique and St. Lucia to the south. ... [more]  

Yachts arriving in the Galapagos are now subject to more stringent checks to prevent introduced species invading the Islands. ... [more]  

Cruising under Power - With more and more members trading in the sails for the power option we thought we’d take a look and see if taking on the Power option really was turning to the Dark Side! ... [more]  

Boat Owners Association of The United States (BoatUS) Chairman and Founder Richard Schwartz, who created and grew the association to become the predominant advocacy and boater services organization for the nation’s recreational boat owners, passed away Wednesday after a short illness. He was 85. ... [more]  

50th Newport Bermuda Race - When I wrote my history of the race, A Berth to Bermuda, in 2006, one theme wove its way through the narrative: Anyone who wishes to win the oldest of all ocean races must be prepared to be bold in choosing strategy and tactics. Jim McCurdy designed Carinas and sailed with the Nyes, as did his daughters, Hope and Sheila. ... [more]  

About five percent of our land-based mess (12.7 million metric tons of plastic) estimated to wind up in the water. Since their invention roughly 75 years ago, plastics have become increasingly prevalent in the consumer marketplace. Today, we use and dispose of plastics on a daily basis, in products like bottled water and grocery bags. Plastics now represent a significant portion of the solid waste ... [more]  

At 20.29 UTC, Captian Piotr Kuzniar, & his 10 man polish crew onboard the 67 foot yacht Selma, reached the edge of the ice in the Ross Sea, at 78,43.S in the Bay of Whales, just over 100 nautical miles farther south then the previous record. ... [more]  

ARC USA Rally - Offshore Passage Opportunities (OPO), the largest crew networking service in North America, has reserved 24 crew berths for amateur crew aboard five boats it is 'delivering north' during the upcoming ARC USA Rally. A Swan 57, Swan 53, two Swan 46s and a Beneteau 50, each with a professional skipper and five crew, will start the ARC USA Rally on May 9 ... [more]  

Setouchi International Yacht Rally preview
Cruising yacht disappears in Bay of Islands
Getting your gear (wheel) on
Caribbean Safety and Security Net 2014 year end report
Boat Docking Secrets - How to Avoid Springline Snap-back
New legislation would fix renewable fuel standard
New legislation would fix renewable fuel standard
Provisioning the aCappella Way
Ilen’s Whiskey Plank Ceremony at Hegarty’s Boatyard
Best Loch Ness Monster evidence may have been destroyed
Tall ship falls over - Could your boat do this?
Two Somali pirates appeal in deaths of four Americans aboard yacht
Producing jet fuel from ocean algae
FUSION® unveils 750 and 650 Series Marine Entertainment Systems
The true story of Donald Crowhurst set for a major film adaptation
Humans drive 500 species of land animals extinct, now marine?
Predicting coral reef futures under climate change
Sailors for the Sea launches ocean conservation movement to heal ocean
Family rescued after catamaran breaks in half
2015 Ocean Cruising Adventures - First to finish without really trying
Winter Storm Juno expected to impact Northeast - Take precautions!   
Sailing Sclerosis Oceans of Hope arrives in Panama City + Video   
Ocean Cruising Adventures Series preview   
Planning an open ocean cruise? Become a Citizen Oceanographer   
Croatia First Regatta - Brand new limited entry one design event   
Boot 2015 – Worlds largest boat show shows optimism   
Doyle Sails offer sail repair and basic rigging service at BOISW   
World Arc Leg 2 - Fleet depart for San Blas   
World Arc - First arrivals to St Helena island   
2014 warmest year since records began + Video   
Volcano creates large new Tongan island   
Summer camps for teens aboard an extraordinary tall ship   
Highland Yacht Club - Lake Ontario’s hidden jewel of a Yacht Club   
Particular Harbour – Gananoque   
SE Asia tanker hijacks rose in 2014 - IMB report reveals   
Rescuing Ben Ainslie from a boat? Stranger things have happened at sea   
Christmas Caribbean Rally - Success, new dates, multihulls offer   
Cruising like a Vendée Racer   
World ARC - Two rally fleets set sail   
Hidden battles on Reefs - How will corals fare in a changing ocean?   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph, contact the photographer directly.
XLXL NEW CRU NH
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT