Please select your home edition
Edition
Henri-Lloyd Dynamic Range

Cahn rules in favour of BMW Oracle Racing

by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World on 19 Mar 2008
BMW Oracle Racing have prevailed in the latest America’s Cup ruling. MCC McCamp

Sail-World is receiving reports, that have been confirmed, that Justice Herman Cahn has ruled in favour of BMW Oracle Racing, by denying the motions bought by Societe Nautique de Geneve.

After determining that Club Nautico Espanol de Vela was not a legitimate Challenger for the America's Cup Cahn ruled on 27 November 2007 that Golden Gate yacht Club was the legitimate challenger and the SNG, as Defender would have to accept their challenge for a 90ft x 90ft 'keel yacht'.

SNG/Alinghi hired a new legal team and challenged these ruling on the basis that GGYC was not necessarily a legitimate challenger, because one of the requirements that CNEV had not met - staging an annual regatta on the sea - had now been met. This was ruled not to be new information that had not bee previously considered by the Court, and this Motion was denied.

The secon Motion related to the claim that there was an error in the Notice of Challenge in that GGYC had named their vessel as a 'keel yacht' which SNG claimed was confusing even though it was not a required term under the Deed of Gift. This count was also dismissed on the basis that this was known to SNG/Alinghi at the time of the first hearing, and was not raised at that point. In fact one Alinghi spokesman, Hamish Ross gace evidence that the GGYC Challenger could only be a multihull. Cahn also picked up on the point that GGYC had supplied all the required data relating to their Challenger and 'there is no need for a hearing to determine the effect of the use of the word 'keel'.'

Similar arguments of a technical nature such as that relating to the meaning of 'week day' were also dismissed.

Sail-World is not certain of the dates at this stage, however it is understood that these will be negotiated between the parties.

If SNG/Alinghi wish to appeal further then the ruling is worded in such a way that they can only Appeal after the Match has been sailed.

This measure is consistent with the rule made in the Big Boat vs The Cat case where Justice Carmen Ciparick ruled that the parties would have to sail for the Cup and then argue about the fairness of the match or otherwise, after the event.

The current ruling will speed up the Cup process as the 33rd Match, when sailed, will determine a Defender and that Club will be able to get on with organising the 34th America's Cup. While an Appeal process may go on for a further couple of years this would not detract from the organisation of a new America's Cup, which would now seem to be likely for 2011.

We will have further updates on the 11 page ruling when it comes to hand.

Alinghi have indicated that they will not Appeal this latest decision from the New York Supreme Court, however in 1988 there were two further Appeals after the disputed Match had been sailed.


For the full Decision http://www.kiwispy.com/AmericasCup/CahnJ-180308.pdf!click_here

Henri-Lloyd Dynamic RangeNorth Sails Loft 57 PodcastPantaenius Sail 2025 AUS Footer

Related Articles

The Big Bash
Every summer the tournament rolls into town. A short format of the game. Fun and excitement abound. Every summer the tournament rolls into town. Local and international players. A short format of the game, run over a relatively compact six-week season.
Posted on 15 Jun
Finn World Masters opens in Medemblik
A bumper entry of 307 helms in The Netherlands The 2025 Finn World Masters has been opened in Medemblik, The Netherlands, on Sunday evening. It is the third time the Dutch Finn class has endeavoured to run the Finn World Masters, with two previous attempts cancelled by the pandemic.
Posted on 15 Jun
The Ultimate Guide to Load Pins
Types, applications and uses for cruising and racing The use of load pins onboard yachts dates back to grand prix racing in the 1980s. And, while there are many different load sensing devices available today, for standing rigging on yachts 50ft+, the load pin remains king.
Posted on 15 Jun
The oldest video footage of Kiel Week
A look back into our video archive at the Kieler Woche of the 60s and early 70s In our series of articles looking back in time through our video archive, we visit Germany. Kiel Week is been a crucial event on the world circuit, and here we look back at the Kieler Woche of the 60s and early 70s.
Posted on 15 Jun
18th Puig Vela Clàssica Barcelona preview
Event returns to its traditional dates, at the Barcelona Royal YC From July 9 to 12, the waters off Barcelona will once again set the stage for the latest edition of the Puig Vela Clàssica Regatta - one of the Mediterranean's premier events for classic boats.
Posted on 15 Jun
A-Class Cat Europeans at Riccione, Italy overall
The final day was not as traumatic as the previous day wind-wise The final day had promised to be rinse and repeat yet again. Friday the 13th remember? But the race officers were determined not to be beaten and get as near a full series in as possible and at least get to that sailing holy grail of the second discard.
Posted on 15 Jun
IRC UK National Championships day 2
Caro leads in IRC Zero after three races by a single point In Race 1, Karl Kwok's TP52 Beau Geste scored a dramatic victory, overlapped through the finish line with Stefan Jentzch's Botin 56 Black Pearl. Beau Geste took the gun and the race win after IRC time correction.
Posted on 15 Jun
WingFoil Racing World Cup Switzerland overall
New faces shine, but champions prevail After four days of adrenalin-filled racing, the event's top riders arrived at Silvaplana lake hungry for glory in the Medal Series. The wind, however, had different ideas.
Posted on 14 Jun
Loro Piana Giraglia 2025 Winners Announced
The 72nd edition was marked by high pressure and light winds, yet remained full of charm On Saturday at 9:00 AM, as the time limit expired, the long offshore race of the Loro Piana Giraglia 2025 officially came to an end.
Posted on 14 Jun
A-Class Cat Europeans at Riccione, Italy Day 4
Who killed that Albatross? 'The wind's not usually like this here' Thursday, the A-Cat Euros is entering its crucial phase. With enough races sailed to declare it a Championship, but too few to allow a crucial second discard. And believe me, there were many sailors who dearly need that second discard!
Posted on 14 Jun