sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Cruising Photo Gallery Video Gallery

 

Sail-World.com : ISAF - what will it take to turn??

ISAF - what will it take to turn??

'5700 sailors have signed, supporting the inclusion of a Multihull Event at the 2012 Olympics'    © Richard Gladwell    Click Here to view large photo

'My old friend John Fisk, who was the Chairman of the IYRU's Multihull Committee, toiled for years to get the Tornado into the Olympics. Johnny will be turning in his grave right now, at the Disgrace that happened in Cascais, last November'.

Fighting words from the doyen of yachting journalists, Bob Fisher at the opening of the 2008 World Championships in Takapuna two weeks ago.

'Johnny's not with us any more,' added Fisher. 'He was a General. I'm only a foot-soldier, but I'm going to work at it. We're going to have the Tornado back in the Olympics!'

Elsewhere Sail-World.com has reported the large 5700 signature petition to the International Olympic Committee asking for the Multihull Event to be included in the 2012 Olympics.

The publication of the Minutes of the ISAF Executive Committee Meeting held in Geneva in February showed just how flexible the sport's administrators can be - if the occasion suits.

In one paragraph the decisions made last November on the subject of the Olympic Events are declared to be made properly and are closed.

Then comes the closing shot:

(vii) The Executive Committee considered the importance to the Sport, the Athletes, and the Administrators, of the reliability and timeliness of decision making by Council.

What about the need to get a decision right? And if a mistake has been made, how about revisiting the issues and giving proper reconsideration?

Then several items later, the Executive Committee looked at the Equipment for the 2012 Olympics and found that the same Regulations which had been quite adequate to shut down the debate on the Olympic Events issue were somewhat lacking, and that Urgent Change was required to give the organisation some sea-room.

Decision
- The Executive Committee will submit urgent submissions to the 2008 Mid-Year meeting to deal with the specifics of the equipment selection for the Women’s Match Racing Event for the 2012 Olympic Sailing Committee. The first submission is to change Regulation 16.1 to state: ‘With the exception of the Women’s Keelboat (Match) Event, only International Classes shall sail in the Olympic Sailing Competition. The second submission is to change regulation 16.1.2 to state: ‘With the exception of the Women’s Keelboat (Match) Event submissions for Equipment for the Olympic Sailing Competition shall be made in accordance with Regulation 1 etc.

- The issue around the selection of equipment, format and qualification for the Women’s Match Racing Event is to be determined by Council based on submissions and recommendations of the relevant ISAF Committees.


To recap on the November Council meeting, the Council ignored the recommendations of its Events Committee, selected a Womens match racing Event without knowing the format of the competition or how qualification would work.

Now they find they are too constrained by the regulations which restrict Equipment to certain specified international classes, and want to throw the door wide open.

Running the Executive Committee decisions together it should evident to most that a serious error was made in November, which can't be fixed with a series of regulatory band-aids.

But maybe the realisation that soon after having exited the Council meeting in November, the Councillors will be up for re-appointment by their National Authorities and Regions. Maybe the desire to live for another day will have a salutary effect.

The Tornado faces some turbulent times over the next few months -  © Richard Gladwell?nid=42475   Click Here to view large photo


Andy Rice of SailJuice.com gives his view of the ISAF Executive Committee's deliberations:

Last week’s ISAF Word of the Week was URGENT. Didn’t we have fun with that one! This week’s ISAF Word of the Week is CLOSING. Early signs suggest this week’s word will be even more popular with the SailJuice readership.

Below is an excerpt from Item 7 of the Minutes from ISAF Executive’s meeting in Geneva last month. You can download the full Minutes by clicking this link?nid=42475

(iii) The Executive Committee noted:
• Only urgent submissions may be considered at a mid-year meeting
• It is for the Executive Committee alone to decide if a submission is
urgent

(iv) The selection of events for the 2012 Olympic Games had been made by
Council in accordance with the Regulations, closing the matter and
forwarding the decision to the Committees and Secretariat for
implementation.


Published two days ago, this clause has not gone unnoticed by SailJuice readers, with some of you having already posted your response to this. I’m just back from a trip to Lanzarote to see the Ericsson Racing Team’s preparations for the Volvo Ocean Race, hence the lack of posts here recently, but thanks to those of you who have kept the fires burning at SailJuice in the Comments section these past days.

The published Minutes from ISAF Executive’s February meeting in Geneva suggests ISAF Executive is not prepared to entertain any further discussion about the 10 Events decided for the Olympic Regatta in Weymouth 2012. Item 7 suggests a few people are burying their heads in the sand and hoping the problem will go away. In the current climate of unrest, this seems like rather wishful thinking.

What Nick Dewhirst said…

Nick Dewhirst of the UK Catamaran Racing Association sent an email to SailJuice on the subject:

Item 7 (c): ISAF Executive now appears to have boxed itself into the following corner. Having unambiguously declared this is not urgent (7 (c) (v), and gratuitously confirmed that the matter would have been urgent had it not already been decided (7 (c) (vi)), it concluded that the matter was now closed (7 (c) (iv)), implying that it is off the agenda both for the Mid-Year Meeting (as not urgent) and November Meeting (as closed). There is no misunderstanding this as the minute continues “and forwarding the decision to the Committees and Secretariat for implementation”.

However a matter is not closed until the deadline for appeals has passed and if there are any valid appeals, then it is not closed until these have been resolved. Most organisations have appeal processes and indeed so does ISAF. For example the deadline is 21 days for its Anti-Doping Regulation. Indeed there is a specific appeal process for this issue, in Regulation 16.1.3 (b). Importantly no deadline exists. It refers to another vote by Council and the next meeting is the Mid-Year Meeting, barring an Extraordinary Meeting, for which there is no requirement in 16.1.1 (b) relating to Events selection.

Now I am not a lawyer, but my experiences of dealing with UK law tends to confirm common sense plain-English interpretations of what words mean. Imagine holding a prizegiving, knowing that a formal Protest has been lodged but not yet heard, let alone decided!

It seems the Executive is intent on denying members their constitutional right of appeal.

Strong stuff from Nick, but then as an unabashed multihull fanatic, to borrow that saying of Mandy Rice-Davies [no relation, I hasten to add]: “Well, he would, wouldn’t he!”


What Rod Carr said…

So I got in touch with Rod Carr who, by the very nature of his job as RYA Chief Executive, is required to be circumspect about these delicate issues. What did he have to say?

“It doesn’t seem to take account of the submissions that have already been made, nor have they [ISAF Executive] seen what other submissions there might be. You can’t be clairvoyant. It seems a pretty extraordinary thing to say. They could have said, ‘I’d be very surprised if anything stood the test of being urgent,’ but just to say that matter is now closed, that seems odd to me.”

Did Rod think this was how a democratic organisation should deal with these issues?

“I don’t, I don’t, and the other thing is that we know match racing is not closed. We know there are technical issues about the match racing. Everyone knows there are issues about how you qualify, what sort of boats are going to




by Sail Juice.com and Sail-World

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=42475

8:54 AM Sat 8 Mar 2008 GMT






Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.


Related News Stories:

24 Jul 2014  NZL Sailing Team arrive in Rio for Olympic Test Event
23 Jul 2014  Kiwi SKUD Sailing: Paralympic Campaign - your chance to support
22 Jul 2014  Red Bull 49erFX: First look at the Olympic sailing venue at Rio
21 Jul 2014  2014 RPNYC Moore Wilson’s Winter Series – Groundhog Day(s)!
20 Jul 2014  NZL Yachting Trust Youth Team: Bronze Medal for NZL in the 29er
18 Jul 2014  Top Kiwi Laser sailor just avoids being on downed airliner
18 Jul 2014  French 420s: Waste timber, lifejackets, Glad wrap and Dumpster diving
17 Jul 2014  420 Nationals - France: Day 3 - A view from the Orange Roughy
17 Jul 2014  NZL Yachting Trust Youth Worlds team: Kiwi 29ers back into 3rd
16 Jul 2014  NZL Yachting Trust Youth Team: Long, tough Day 2 at ISAF Youth Worlds
MORE STORIES ...

News - USA and the World



































































Six Metre European Championship - High temps and little wind on day 3
Women’s Match Race Golfe du Morbihan - Light wind opener in Vannes
International Moth Worlds: Rashley ahead as Aussies close in
ISAF Youth Match Racing Worlds - American unbeatable on day 1
RS Feva World Championships - All set at Yacht Club de Carnac
ISAF Rolex World Sailor of the Year Awards - Nominations now open
BIC Techno 293 Worlds - Steady winds on day 2 + Video
29er North American Open Championship - Qualifying series wraps up
Opening ceremony O'pen Bic World Cup, Travemunde Week, Germany
Six Metre Europeans - Wind fails to make an appearance on day 2
Edgartown Race Weekend - Let the sailing (and good times) begin
ISAF Youth Match Racing World Championship - Action commences July 23
International Moth Worlds - Mothballed on day 4 + Video
Spirits high as Team Alvimedica completes Transatlantic crossing
Gladwell's Line: A change of direction needed in the America's Cup *Feature
29er North American Championship - Day 1 in Kingston
Red Bull 49erFX: First look at the Olympic sailing venue at Rio
Fuerteventura Kiteboarding Grand Slam - Classic conditions on day 3
NYYC Race Week Part II images by Rolex/Daniel Forster
Drowning or electric shock? What you need to know to help save a life
BIC Techno 293 Worlds 2014 - Day 1   
Six Metre European Championship - Blazing sunshine on opening day   
National Sailing Hall of Fame to present Lifetime Achievement Award   
International Moth Worlds: Greenhalgh and Rashley tied at the top   
PWA Pozo World Cup - Fantastic finale determines winners   
Six Metre Class British Open Championship - Llanoria and Valhalla win   
Anna Tunnicliffe set to compete at the CrossFit Games   
America's Cup: Oracle Team USA holds foiling camp at Wangi SC   
Volvo Ocean Race: Abu Dhabi OR completes double Atlantic crossing   
Volvo Ocean Race: Team SCA has a 'pull through day' off the Canaries   
No tiller sailing - how to steer using just the sails + Video   
International Moth Worlds: Three bullets in a row for Greenhalgh   
U.S. Junior Women’s Singlehanded Championship - Sophia Reineke wins   
BIC Techno 293 Worlds 2014 - Day 0 Opening   
Fuerteventura World Cup - Slalom action highlights day 2   
2014 Governor's Cup - Sam Gilmour of RFBYC victorious again   
Farr 40 West Coast Champ - Skipper Alberto Rossi leads Enfant Terrible   
Flying Dutchman World Championships - Magyars are the Masters   
Final day shakes up standings at Cape Panwa Hotel Phuket Raceweek   
2014 -15 Volvo Ocean Race: Team Alvimedica pushing towards Southampton   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL WAS US
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT