News Home Video Gallery Photo Gallery : America's Cup: Back in Room 232

America's Cup: Back in Room 232

'Justice Herman Cahn on the New York Supreme Court Bench at the Hearing on 22 October.'    Event Media
Yesterday, in the latest hearing in the America’s Cup case at New York Supreme Court, just a few minutes into the oral arguments, Justice Herman Cahn interrupted Barry Ostrager, the lead lawyer for Societé Nautique de Genéve (SNG), and asked, “Have the two sides had any conversations since our last hearing?”

Ostrager replied, “No, your honor. There are irreconcilable differences.”

That much was obvious to anybody who was there as each side accused the other of misrepresenting the rules and the facts. Whatever Ostrager said for his client (the yacht club for cup defender Alinghi) was contradicted by James Kearney, representing the Golden Gate Yacht Club of San Francisco, which has challenged for Larry Ellison’s Oracle. In November Justice Cahn threw out the Club Náutico Español de Vela as Alinghi’s choice as challenger of record and replaced it with Golden Gate. SNG is now trying to convince Cahn that he made a mistake in naming Golden Gate.

SNG’s main point was that Golden Gate misled it about the boat that will sail in the races, whenever they occur. When Golden Gate challenged last July, it observed a provision in the America’s Cup rules that require a challenger to provide the basic dimensions of its boat, which are the length and the beam. That rule is laid out in the deed of gift written by the cup’s last surviving donor, George L. Schuyler, in 1887. The dimensions provided by Golden Gate include such a wide beam that the boat very likely is a catamaran or trimaran.

Golden Gate also described its boat as a “keel yacht.” Why it did this is not clear because a description of the boat type is not required by the rules, yet Ostrager repeatedly argued that these two words disqualify Golden Gate as a challenger. He gave two reasons. First, only a yacht with one hull (a monohull) can have a keel, a fin under the hull. Second, the defender has a right to know what type of boat is challenging. SNG, he insisted, “needs to determine what type of boat to build,” and what this boat is or will be is a mystery.

While Ostrager did not cite rules to this effect, he did refer to a letter he had recently received from Jerome Pels, Secretary General of the International Sailing Federation, that he said supported his position. In fact, when the letter was released publicly after the hearing it turned out to be far less dramatic than he suggested. “Multihulls usually have no ballasted keels” is one quote. And then there is, “For the purpose of the choice of equipment (boats) for the Olympic Games, ISAF would therefore not consider a multihull to fit in the ‘keelboat’ category. Therefore a ‘multihull’ yacht would not be classified as a ‘keel’ yacht.” After the hearing Tom Ehman of Golden Gate emphasized these qualifications and concluded, with some merit, that the letter offers SNG little support.

Ostrager told the judge that if he did not disqualify Golden Gate as the challenger of record for filing an improper challenge, Justice Cahn should either hold a hearing on the technical questions, with expert witnesses, or hand over jurisdiction to the ISAF. The last point took the judge by surprise. “You’re saying that I should refer these issues to the ISAF?” he asked. “Yes,” replied Ostrager, “A keel yacht is incompatible with a multihull boat.”

Golden Gate energetically disputed SNG’s argument. “Catamarans can have keels and catamarans do have keels,” Kearney said, adding, with his voice rising in frustration, “The very notion that they would tell the court that catamarans do not have keels is a delaying tactic.” He gave the judge photographs of multihulls with keels. Kearney also defended his position with several procedural arguments, one of which was that until recently SNG had accepted Golden Gate’s description of its boat without question and now cannot reverse that judgment, at least in court.

“We have lived through a blizzard of new arguments,” Kearney said. He added that, under the precedent set by the last major America’s Cup dispute, the Mercury Bay-San Diego big boat-catamaran battle of at least my fond memory, jurisdiction over the cup lies in the hands of the New York courts. “Nobody can take from this court responsibility to interpret the deed of gift.”

Acknowledging Kearny’s procedural points, Justice Cahn agreed to hear more on the technical issues from both sides.

After the hearing, standing on the steps of the New York State Supreme Court building at 60 Centre Street, Lucien Masmejan, Alinghi’s chief counsel, said he was obliged to proceed with the case. “As the defender and the trustee of the America’s Cup, we have to be sure to accept only valid challenges. It’s our duty as the trustee of the cup. We are the trustee. We can’t say, ‘we give up.’ We have a vision and we’re not going to give up that vision.”

Ehman was somewhat less philosophical. Asked how he would answer a question about the description of the boat as a keel yacht, he said, “Nobody has asked that question.” The boat, he promised, will have a keel.

This article is adapted from a story filed with the Swiss newspaper Neue Zürcher Zeitung)

by John Rousmaniere


Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

3:37 AM Thu 24 Jan 2008 GMT

Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 America's Cup

Related News Stories:

16 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Expected de Ridder penalty should be reduced
14 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Dean Barker's Blog - A sail with the Duke and Duchess
12 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Coutts claims ISAF Jury on a crusade, backs Kiwi report
10 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Two Kiwis escape hometown action in AC45 rules ruckus
03 Apr 2014  34th America's Cup: A Match of three weeks - Part 3 - Under the Pump
01 Apr 2014  34th America's Cup: A Match of three weeks - Part 1 - Regaining time
08 Mar 2014  Fast foils-a conversation with Paul Bieker, part two
03 Mar 2014  America's Cup- Fast foils-a conversation with Paul Bieker, part I
19 Jan 2014  America's Cup: CNN Mainsail Down Under on the state of the Cup
16 Jan 2014  America's Cup: Jobson goes one on one with Jimmy Spithill (Part 5)

News - USA and the World

America's Cup: Expected de Ridder penalty should be reduced *Feature by Richard Gladwell/, Auckland, NZ

HUD Vision: An interview with Afterguard Marine’s Alex Moret by David Schmidt, Sail-World USA Editor, Seattle

Congressional Cup - Victory for Taylor Canfield and crew by Rich Roberts (As Amended by ISAF),

2014 Halifax – Saint-Pierre Ocean Race by Patricia Nelder, Nova Scotia

Image Gallery: Stratis SL33 flies on the Waitemata by Richard Gladwell,,

Audi Melges 20- Sperry Topsider Charleston Race Week - Light final day by International Audi Melges 20 Class Association,

America's Cup: Gino Morrelli outlines the new AC62 design
Doyle Sails New Zealand signs Andrew Brown as One Design Manager
America's Cup: Dean Barker's Blog - A sail with the Duke and Duchess *Feature
29er World Youth Sailing Week Easter regatta - Day 1 and 2 overall
C Thomas Clagett Jr Memorial Clinic/Regatta - Entries start to roll in
50th Congressional Cup: See the delayed coverage and media conferences
Clipper Race 10 Day 27: Closing stages - Qingdao to San Francisco
Canfield, Williams, Bruni, Swinton in Congressional Cup final four
Sperry Top-Sider Charleston Race Week - Day 2
Audi Melges 20 Charleston Race Week - Perfect conditions in Charleston
Oyster Regatta Antigua - Full on ocean conditions for day 3
PWA World Tour - A taste of things to come at La Torche + Video
Women's International Match Racing Series kicks off in June
Melges 32 Audi Tron Sailing Series - Action shots by Max Ranchi
Clipper Round the World Yacht Race - Frustrating conditions
Man rescued after falling overboard in Pacific taken to hospital
Sperry Top-Sider Charleston Race Week 2014 - Youth leading Melges 20
Congressional Cup - Canfield leads toward Congressional Cup sailoffs
Sperry Top-Sider Charleston Race Week 2014 - Perfection for Day 1
America's Cup: Coutts claims ISAF Jury on a crusade, backs Kiwi report *Feature
Clipper Round the World Yacht Race - Will light winds hamper progress?   
Les Voiles de St. Barth - Preparing to rock Saint Barthélemy waters   
Clipper Round the World Race - OneDLL and Qingdao now in San Francisco   
America's Cup: Emirates Team NZ up against funding hurdle for year *Feature   
Melges 32 Sailing Series Napoli - Day 1 images by Stefano Gattini   
50th Congressional Cup: View the Live racing here   
Melges 32 Sailing Series - Napoli action shots by Max Ranchi   
Volvo Ocean Race - Team Alvimedica launch new boat   
Emirates Team NZ: Royals duke it out on the Waitemata   
2014 Charleston Race Week - Thousands of sailors descend on Charleston   
The Congressional Cup 2014 - Williams hangs on with a classy crowd   
50th Congressional Cup: View the Live racing here   
RORC Transatlantic Race - Notice of Race now available   
Oyster Regatta Antigua - Sunshine and smiles on day 2   
Rolex China Sea Race on the horizon   
What can a boat name tell you about the person behind the helm?   
Clipper Round the World Yacht Race - Race 10 rumbles on   
SAP 5O5 World Championship - Kiel action starts August 13th   
Volvo Ocean Race - It's a family Affair   
Clipper Round the World Race - Great Britain claims line honours   

For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News  

Switch Default Region to:

Social Media





New Zealand

United Kingdom

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World






Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text


Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery


Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery





Privacy Policy



Cookie Policy



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.