sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Cruising Photo Gallery Video Gallery

 

Sail-World.com : America's Cup - 'Guilty as charged on both counts'

America's Cup - 'Guilty as charged on both counts'

'New York State Supreme Court, 60 Centre St, New York, by John Rousmaniere'    Event Media

Justice Herman Cahn has ruled in favour of the Golden Gate Yacht Club in their challenge to the legitimacy of the Challenger of Record, Club Nautico Espanol de Vela.

The judgment comes as no surprise and is in line with comment posted in Sail-World.com since the Protocol was announced on 5th July 2007.

The New York Supreme Court was asked to rule on the legitimacy of Club Nautico Espanol de Vela (CNEV) in terms of the Deed of Gift for the America's Cup, a document lodged with the Court in 1887.

There has been only one previous case relating to the Deed of Gift - being the Big Boat vs the Cat Challenge from Mercury Bay BC in 1988. that case two two years, two hearings and was decided on Appeal. The decision from the Appeal Court weighed heavily in the current case and is reflected in Justice Cahn's decision.

The two key points that the Court was asked to rule related to whether, at the time its challenge was accepted by the Defender Societe Nautique de Geneve, CNEV was an organised yacht club in terms of the Deed of Gift. And, secondly whether it complied with the requirement of 'having for its annual regatta' on the ocean or arm of the sea.


Putting faces to some familiar names, as the lawyers plead their respective cases in front of Justice Herman Cahn in the New York Supreme Court. (Latham & Watkins represented GGYC, White & Case represented SNG) -  Event Media  
On the first point, Cahn spent some time and concluded that being 'organised' meant more than just being an incorporated body and had to function as a yacht club. Here amongst other references Cahn looked at the New York Yacht Club itself which he noted was organised (ie functioning as a yacht club) in 1844, but was not incorporated as a body for another 21 years in 1865.

CNEV was the other way around - incorporated first, in June, and then did not function as a yacht club until November 2007.

The club itself admitted after the hearing on 22 October, that it was formed as a 'legal adjustment', and was clearly not in compliance with this test under the Deed of Gift.

On the second point, that of the timing of its annual regatta, CNEV was again held to be guilty as charged, by Cahn. SNG argued that the words 'having its annual regatta' meant that the club could be incorporated and then then hold a regatta at some future time. In other words that the meaning of 'having' could be satisfied by a future action or intention.

This did not wash with Justice Herman Cahn who held that the plain and natural meaning of the word 'having' should be applied - in that it is 'on-going activity; the activity has taken place and is continuing'. He added 'it implies that the organisation has had one or more regattas in the past and will continue to have them in the future.

Given that CNEV had two attempts at organising sailing events after it had challenged, and really only had a successful event earlier in November, it had clearly not complied, and was out on this count as well.

The claims by Golden Gate YC that SNG had breeched its fiduciary duties as the Trustee of the America's Cup, were dismissed by Justice Cahn after GGYC offered no opposition to the defence proffered by the Defender, SNG.

Justice Cahn also dismissed the defence raised by Societe Nautique de Geneve , that Golden gate YC did not have 'clean hands' in the matter, and found against the Defender, SNG on all three matters raised in this regard.


Justice Herman Cahn on the New York Supreme Court Bench at the Hearing on 22 October. -  Event Media  
At first blush, there would seem to be little ground for Appeal. Justice Cahn has stayed well inside the decision handed down in the Mercury Bay case, and particularly the requirement to stay within the 'four corners of the Deed' where the intention of the donor is clear.

Given too that the facts in this case were largely agreed between the parties, and that all was required was an interpretation of the Deed of Gift in relation to these facts, then the decision would appear to be a relatively simple one to have reached.


The Decision

After reciting the history and key arguments of the Parties, Justice Herman Cahn began his decision which ran for over 17 pages.

The full decision reads:

CNEV’s Challenge:

To qualify as the Challenger of Record under the Deed, the would-be challenger must be an 'organized Yacht Club of a foreign country, incorporated, patented, or licensed by the legislature, admiralty, or other executive department, having for its annual regatta an ocean water course on the sea, or on an arm of the sea, or one which combines both . . . .' GGYC’s contention — that CNEV does not meet these requirements, in that it neither is an organized Yacht Club nor has an annual regatta on the sea or arm of the sea — is persuasive as to the latter requirement and, thus, dispositive.

To qualify under these requirements, the club must be incorporated. It is inconsequential that RFEV may have incorporated CNEV to formalize the challenge because of the likelihood that RFEV’s own challenge would be disputed. That, by itself, does not disqualify CNEV from qualifying as Challenger of Record.
However, being incorporated is not, by itself, sufficient; it must have additional attributes that make it an 'organized Yacht Club.' Although the term 'organized' often refers to the nature of an entity’s legal existence or formation, here the donors contemplated additional indicia of a yachting club, This is evident from the corporate seal of the New York Yacht Club itself, the Cup’s original donee, which states that the club was organized in 1844 and incorporated in 1865

(Ehman Aff, Exh FE). SNG’s dictionary reference (A Dictionary of Law 739 [William C. Anderson ed. 1889] [attached to SNG’s Reply Br]) docs not prove otherwise. It states that '[o]rganizing an incorporation refers to the choice and qualification of offices necessary for the transaction of business,' thereby implying that organizing a yacht club is not synonymous with incorporating a yacht club. Thus, SNG’s argument — that incorporating, adopting by-laws and assigning roles and responsibilities for its officers and directors (SNG Reply Br at 7) is sufficient to constitute an organized yacht club under the Deed — is unconvincing.

Nevertheless, CNEV arguably complies with the requirement that the club be a legally recognized entity of its jurisdiction with certain additional attributes. CNEV is a private Spanish sports club with unlimited duration, registered with the Registry of Sports Organizations of the Valencian Community. According to Bonet, chairman of CNEV and vice-chairman of RFEV, CNEV’s purpose is to promote sailing practices through the organization of national as well as international regattas within the national territory and to organize at least one regatta per year in the open sea, as reflected in Chapter 1 of CNEV’s articles of incorporation. The club is negotiating a collaboration agreement with the Center of Sailing Training in Santander - where the Spanish Sailing Olympic Team is trained — with the Optimist race as its first event and denoting the promotion of sailing among young people as among of its priorities. Bonet also states that CNEV expects to be listed in due course on the website of the Valencian Community Sailing Federation.

Whether these attributes are sufficient — in the absence of vessels, members, and a telephone number, etc. — to constitute a 'Yacht Club' under the Deed would require an analysis of custom and practice in the sport, as well as a hearing. Such is not necessary, however.

Although the meaning of the term 'organized' in the context of a sporting club is unclear as to the club’s required attributes, the Deed expressly requires one specific attribute, namely, that the club have an annual regatta. CNEV’s failure to comply with this requirement nullifies its purported role as Challenger of Record of the 33rd America’s Cup.

GGYC argues that the phrase 'having for its annual regatta' means that the club has held a regatta in the past, and will continue to do so in the future. According to SNG and CNEV, the intention to hold a regatta in the f




by Richard Gladwell

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=39447

10:39 PM Tue 27 Nov 2007 GMT






Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 America's Cup

Related News Stories:

29 Sep 2014  America's Cup: Oracle Team USA's AC72 takes to the streets
27 Sep 2014  America's Cup: Then and now - Coutts on why Oracle won, and the Venue
09 Aug 2014  America's Cup: Former Artemis crew member says danger is being ignored
27 May 2014  America's Cup: Oracle Team USA under stress
23 May 2014  America's Cup: Oracle and Team NZ designers reveal AC72 secrets
22 May 2014  America's Cup: Artemis death verdict 'result of an human act'
10 May 2014  A year after the Artemis incident, the sailors tell of the pain
01 May 2014  America's Cup: Oracle and Team NZ tech insights - Free lecture tonight
16 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Expected de Ridder penalty should be reduced
14 Apr 2014  America's Cup: Dean Barker's Blog - A sail with the Duke and Duchess
MORE STORIES ...

News - USA and the World

Volvo Ocean Race: Fleet charges the door of the Doldrums Casino *Feature by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.com/nz
The Volvo Ocean Race has lifted intensity again on Day 9 with the fleet spread across 100nm of ocean and charging in a line for the turning point of Fernando de Noronha, 220nm off the Brazilian coast. ... [more]  

The first eight days of the 2014-15 Volvo Ocean Race have been filled with more excitement and tighter racing than anyone could have anticipated. Up until Saturday morning, Leg One has left the fleet with few tactical options and therefore has kept everyone tightly packed as one unit of seven boats. ... [more]  

As expected the third day of the 2014 La Torche PWA Grand Slam proved to be a quiet affair with very light winds throughout the day. After a chilly and overcast start, the sun eventually broke through to produce another beautiful afternoon in La Torche. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15. The sun’s out. It’s warm – not too hot, but warm enough for just a tee shirt. Ian Walker is stood at the helm of his Emirati boat, generous Atlantic trade winds whistling past his ears. 'We’re going straight through,' he claims, confidently. 'What Doldrums? - they’re going to say. Azzam isn’t even going to slow down.' ... [more]  

At 1700 CET in the Rolex Middle Sea Race, 113 yachts had rounded Stromboli, the active volcano that marks the most northerly point of the course. Race leader on the water, Esimit Europa 2, was less than 20 miles from Favignana and preparing to turn south with 289 miles to go and is expected to finish the race in the early hours of Wednesday 22 October, which would be well outside the course record ... [more]  

It is with great pleasure that the Star Sailors League announces that two more top Brazilian sailors will be joining the fleet of 20 super-champions taking part in the Star Sailors League Finals 2014 being held for the second consecutive year at Nassau Yacht Club in the Bahamas between December 1st and 7th. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15, Day Nine onboard Team Alvimedica. It’s hard to explain the complexity of the weather in this part of the world. No computer model or forecaster can accurately predict the winds because the air here is dry and warm, 23c now, and the typical barometric pressure gradients that generate them become very weak. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15, Day Nine onboard Team SCA. We’re a boat on a mission: catch the fleet. And they’re getting closer by the mile. The first time I sailed past Cape Verde islands was in 2010 when I was helping deliver a catamaran from Gibraltar to Antigua, W.I. ... [more]  

Thailand bids for 2016 IODA ‘Optimist’ World Championships by Jordan Rumsby, Royal Varuna Yacht Club
Pattaya's Royal Varuna Yacht Club has submitted a bid to host the 2016 International Optimist Dinghy Association World Championships, offering the world's most talented junior sailing teams a chance to experience the steady wind, sunshine, smiles, great food, and family-friendly attractions of Thailand's top dinghy sailing destination ... [more]  

Photographer Ellen Hoke was on the water at the Farr 40 Worlds sailed from the St Francis Yacht Club, San Francisco, and provided this second gallery of images from the Final Day - Day 4 Prizegiving ... [more]  

Bill Green - builder and sailor passes on by Malcolm McKeag, Scuttlebutt Europe, Lymington, England:
Bill Green, San Francisco-born sailor, Navy jet jockey (not a lot of people know that); US Coastguard; shrimp-boat hand (not a lot of people know that either); One Ton Cup winner and most latterly proprietor of Green Marine slipped quietly away from this life ... [more]  

Tom Burton (AUS) retained World #1 in the Laser after a tremendous fight back at ISAF Sailing World Cup Qingdao where he picked up bronze. The Australia had a tough opening day, finishing down the pack in both races but as the week progressed he worked his way up and sealed bronze on the final day to keep hold of World #1. ... [more]  

Photographer Ellen Hoke was on the water at the Farr 40 Worlds sailed from the St Francis Yacht Club, San Francisco, and provided this gallery of images from the Final Day - Day 4 ... [more]  

Photographer Ellen Hoke was on the water at the Farr 40 Worlds sailed from the St Francis Yacht Club, San Francisco, and provided this gallery of images from Day 2 ... [more]  

Rolex Middle Sea Race 2014 - A hard day's night by Media Royal Malta Yacht Club
Rolex Middle Sea Race - As high pressure moved in from the north, the area around Stromboli had virtually no gradient wind and for those yachts yet to reach Stromboli, a south flowing current has slowed proceedings even further. For the competitive offshore yacht racer, performing well in light wind is more difficult than blasting through a storm at top speed. ... [more]  

34th Student Yachting World Cup - France knew today its best day since the beginning of the competition. They spent the two races at the very first positions, even rivaling with the ultra-dominant English team. They showed today an astounding panache, and can now hope to improve their ranking before the end of the SYWoC. ... [more]  

The Chinese entry Donfeng Race Team, has lost her lead on Day 9 of the Volvo Ocean Race, with boats on the east and western side of the course threatening. Two hours before the most recent sked at 0640hrs UTC, Dongfeng was still being listed by Volvo Ocean Race as the leader. But Team Brunel is now listed as the leader, but on a time taken projection basis, Team Brunel is fifth. ... [more]  

Flying Dreams is a movie directed by the talented Elsa Blayau is an ode to ocean, water sports and femininity. Based on an original idea from Alex Udin, Elsa Blayau transformed the project to a complete story and brought it to reality with this realization. ... [more]  

The 70th running of the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia’s annual Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race is living up to expectation with 98 high-calibre entries received so far, from Sean Langman’s 1932 built Maluka of Kermandie, the oldest and smallest boat at nine metres, to the super maxis. The most talked about boat though, is the Verdier Yacht Design and Vplp 100 footer, Comanche. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Blogs from the Boats - Leg 1, Day 8 plus Videos *Feature by Richard Gladwell/Sail-World.nz/com
Several of the On Board Reporters aboard, provide their unique views of Leg 1, Day 8 of the Volvo Ocean Race - in text, images and video. Catch a birthday at sea on board Team Brunel, and unravel the fishing net with Team SCA Hear and see how the crews coped with the front that came through in the nigh ... [more]  

Shala Youngerman and her team from Southwestern Yacht Club won the 23rd annual Linda Elias Memorial Women’s One-Design Challenge Sunday in this two-day fleet race regatta organized and sponsored by the Long Beach/Los Angeles Women’s Sailing Association and hosted by Long Beach Yacht Club. ... [more]  

After three days of racing in the Valparaíso bay, the Santander team was crowned champion of the Off Valparaíso Race, first stage of the Soto 40 South American Tour that was held in the Yacht Club de Chile with the participation of eight boats. ... [more]  

Day two of the La Torche PWA Grand Slam saw the glorious golden sunshine continue together with the waves, but unfortunately the wind remained absent again. To keep the crowds entertained Jules Denel (JP / NeilPryde) and birthday boy - Antoine Martin (JP / NeilPryde) - attempted a bit of wave tow-in with varying degrees of success, as Antoine Albeau (RRD / NeilPryde) took control of the jet ski. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Dongfeng consolidates lead on Day 8 *Feature by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com/nz
After cutting between the Cape Verde islands, separating from the rest of the Volvo Ocean Race fleet, Chinese entry, Dongfeng gained an initial significant lead, which they are in the process of consolidating. One routing option for the then race leader Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing, gave the team the option of cutting inside the island group, they are close to the optimum course for Fernando off Brazil ... [more]  

RS:X Youth World Championships - All set for Clearwater action by RS:X Olympic Windsurfing Class Association
Mild, breezy weather, temperate Gulf of Mexico waters and wide bands of sugar white sand - this is the place where 2014 RS:X Youth World Windsurfing Championship racing is about to start. 'Clearwater Beach is the perfect spot to play host to the young windsurfers gathering here from around the world for international competition', says Frank Chivas. ... [more]  

The first 24 hours of the Rolex Middle Sea Race has seen the fleet progress slowly up the eastern seaboard of Sicily towards the Strait of Messina. By 16.00 on day two, a mere ten per cent of the competition had passed through the Strait and started the leg to Stromboli, where they will turn west towards the Egadi Islands. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15 - If only it were that easy. Amazingly we did manage to replace the rudder and regain first position amongst the fleet however just hours afterwards, navigator Pascal Bidégorry was faced with an important strategic decision. ... [more]  

Ian Moore, navigator on Cookson 50, Mascalzone Latino, is no stranger to the Rolex Middle Sea Race, this is his fourth and Ian was part of the winning crew on Bryon Ehrhart's TP52, Lucky in 2010. Ian describes the tactical nuances of the first night at sea. ... [more]  

Top videographer and photographer, John Navas, was on the water for the final day of the Farr 40 Worlds being sailed on San Francisco. ... [more]  

The brilliant conditions of last week’s opening race of the season were duplicated today when the Australian 18 Footers League’s Major A. Frizelle Trophy race was sailed in a 20–knot North East wind on Sydney Harbour. Current JJ Giltinan champion Gotta Love It 7 team of Seve Jarvin, Sam Newton and Scott Babbage showed why they are the world’s best team. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race - The fleet has finally left the West African Coast. They are now in the trade winds, making the westerly course across the Atlantic Ocean to FernandoThey will find the Cape Verde Islands in the way and that will cause some issues of navigation. ... [more]  

2014 ISAF Sailing World Cup Qingdao - It was a light wind, big wave finish at ISAF Sailing World Cup Qingdao as the medallists were decided across the six fleets competing on the waters of the Beijing 2008 Olympic Sailing Competition. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Farr 40 World Championship - In life, timing is everything. And, after seven years in the Farr 40 class, the timing was right for New York financier Alex Roepers to achieve a long-held goal of winning the Rolex Farr 40 World Championship. ... [more]  

Coast Guard rescues two near Wachapreague
2014 Off Valparaíso Race - Day 2
La Torche PWA Grand Slam - Massive swell on day 1
Volvo Ocean Race: Welcome to Al's Ocean Cafe
Argo Group Gold Cup survives Hurricane Gonzalo
Volvo Ocean Race: Dongfeng regains lead after incident packed Day 7 *Feature
Volvo Ocean Race: Dramatic video of Dongfeng rudder replacement
Volvo Ocean Race - Team Alvimedica bounces back
Volvo Ocean Race - Team SCA expecting the expected + Video
Rolex Middle Sea Race - New record for Mediterranean classic
ISAF Sailing World Cup Qingdao - Medallists decided across six fleets
Volvo Ocean Race - Impressive turnaround for Dongfeng Race Team +Video
Volvo Ocean Race: Race closer than leaderboard suggests - Leg 1, Day 6
Volvo Ocean Race: Dongfeng Race Team break rudder after collision
2014 Rolex Farr 40 World Championship - Famous breeze frustrates
2014 Off Valparaíso Race - Day 1
Sunfish World Championship - Victory for Argentina's Francisco Renna
Volvo Ocean Race - Feeling the pressure six days in
Volvo Ocean Race - Alvimedica cautiously cruising down coast of Africa
Volvo Ocean Race - Team Brunel still within striking distance
Volvo Ocean Race - Testing times for Team SCA + Video   
Beijing 2008 Olympic legacy lives on in Qingdao + Video   
La Torche PWA Grand Slam - A return nearly 20 years in the making   
ISAF Sailing World Cup Qingdao - Game on for remaining fleets   
Farr 40 Worlds: Day 2 Image and Video gallery *Feature   
Day 5 of the Chris Benz Lüderitz Speed Challenge: 4 more records!   
Volvo Ocean Race: Coastal racing at its best - Leg 1, Day 5   
Chris Poole new number one Open Match Racer in U.S.   
Rolex Farr 40 World Champs - Plenty leads as Struntje Light impresses   
2014 Soto 40 South American Tour - Back in action   
Volvo Ocean Race - Mail arrival brings excitement for Team SCA + Video   
Volvo Ocean Race - Jens Dolmer getting restless onboard Team Brunel   
Volvo Ocean Race - Too close for comfort as fleet pushes on + Video   
Foils or not? Explanations from IMOCA Class President Jean Kerhoas   
Ben Ainslie's Olympic Finn sails are up for auction   
Volvo Ocean Race - Team Alvimedica goes to school   
Volvo Ocean Race - Intensity level rises for Dongfeng Race Team   
China Cup Regatta - Olympic medallists and offshore legends to race   
St. Barth Cata Cup - Friendly US rivalry on the Island   
ISAF Sailing World Cup Qingdao - Tight and tactical racing + Video   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL NEW US
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT