sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Cruising Photo Gallery Video Gallery
Sail-World.com : Gladwell's Line: Is a Trojan Horse being used in the America's Cup?
Gladwell's Line: Is a Trojan Horse being used in the America's Cup?


'Oracle Team USA sailing off San Francisco. The winglets on the rudder are clearly visible. The windward daggerboard is lowered in preparation for a gybe.'    Guilain Grenier/Oracle Racing©    Click Here to view large photo

Following the conclusion of a four day Mediation by two members of the International Jury for the 34th America's Cup, it was confirmed by various sources, that while the main sticking point for the teams is the adoption of rules regarding Rudder Elevators, there are still serious issues remaining.

'There is a lot of water to go under the bridge', one high-placed source told Sail-World.

The comment comes in contrast to the bland media release issued at the conclusion of the Mediation session, which did not identify the outstanding issues.

Quite what happens from here is yet to be revealed.

It is expected that regatta organizers working under the auspices of the America's Cup Trustee and Defender, Golden Gate Yacht Club will try to get sign-off from the US Coast Guard for the Recommendations which originally came from the Review Committee, appointed to investigate all aspects of the America's Cup Regatta after the fatal capsize of Artemis Racing's AC72.

After those Recommendations were initially published, on May 24, Golden Gate Yacht Club Vice Commodore, Tom Ehman, was adamant that they would be pushed through using the safety provisions of the Protocol, and specifically Article 16 which states that 'Competitors shall comply with all applicable laws and regulations of any city, state, national or other governmental authority having jurisdiction over the Event or part thereof.'

Given that as yet there is no agreement from the teams on all the Recommendations, it appears that the event organizers may be using the US Coast Guard as a Trojan Horse to get new rules imposed on the regatta as part of the Permit to be issued by the USCG.

Clearly if the Teams don't accept the USCG imposed conditions, then there can be no event.

Emirates Team NZ sailing in Auckland with two rudders immersed (both providing some degree of level flight) and flying on a single foil -  Richard Gladwell_©   Click Here to view large photo


While there seems to be little disagreement on the changes introduced under the guise of Safety, the changes to the AC72 Class Rule for Rudder Elevators are a completely different category, and it would be argued that the USCG had no basis for making the rule change as two of the three teams currently sailing in San Francisco are not using the devices, and have been sailing for almost 12 months without them.

Normally if an organiser did not comply with the Protocol a team's first recourse would be to the full International Jury, but it is not clear whether the International Jury has any jurisdiction to direct the US Coast Guard, as the government agency is not a party to the Protocol.

That situation has created speculation that the aggrieved Challengers might have recourse to the New York Supreme Court, to obtain the equivalent of an injunction under English law, until the Rudder Elevator issue has been resolved by the International Jury.

Larry Ellison visits Team / SFO March Testing Session / Oracle Team USA -  Guilain Grenier-Oracle Racing©   Click Here to view large photo

Turning to the vexed issue of Rudder Elevators - which first emerged as one of the 37 Review Committee Recommendations, following the fatal Artemis Racing capsize/breakup on May 9, 2013.

The AC72 class rule 8.6 is clear: Rudders shall not have components such as trim tabs or moveable winglets, that can be adjusted while racing.

In other words you can have winglets, but they cannot be adjusted while racing.

The Measurement Committee received a request for a Measurement Interpretation , in mid-2012 which seemed to query as to whether the whole winglet could rotate (presumably during a race).

(Interpretations are issued by the Measurement Committee in response to a question from one of the teams, and are a way of avoiding lengthy protest hearings during the regatta, when one or more boats turns up with a design 'innovation' which is immediately protested and ruled in or out by the International Jury.)

In an Interpretation issued on August 12, 2012, the Measurement Committee said that: Adjusting the angle of one surface of an appendage relative to another surface of that appendage constitutes a change to the shape of the appendage surfaces, and invalidates the yacht's measurement certificate in accordance with AC72 Class Rule 27.2 (c)

US Coast Guard visits Emirates Team NZ, earlier this weelk - Russell Green - Rules Advisor Capt. Greg Stump - Sector Commander San Francisco, USCG Nick Halroyd - Technical Director -  Ellen Hoke   Click Here to view large photo


In other words if the winglet moved then that yacht was out of class, until she was re-measured with the winglet in the new position.

Regatta Director, Iain Murray effectively reversed that Interpretation with Recommendation 1.3e from the Chairman of the Review Committee allowed Rudder Elevators to be 'permitted to be adjusted until warning signal', or five minutes before the start of a race.

The AC72 Class Rules are even more specific with Rule 8.6 saying 'Rudders shall not have components such as trim tabs or moveable winglets that can be adjusted while racing'

Taking this rule a stage further a team using such devices would normally have to be able to demonstrate that the winglets could not be adjusted while racing. Scout's Honor isn't good enough. The only winglets which are legal are those which cannot be adjusted adjusted while racing.

In this discussion we have used the term 'racing' in the sense it is used in the the Racing Rules of Sailing - America's Cup version. There is no definition in the class rule of the term 'racing'. Further in 27.2a of the class rule lists several items which may be adjusted when not racing which will not invalidate an AC72's measurement certificate.

The inference being that anything which is adjusted, even when the yacht is not racing, will make the AC72's measurement certificate invalid.

The bottom line is that the adjustable rudder winglets used by any AC72 are probably illegal, certainly for racing, and she cannot have a valid measurement certificate while they are in their current state - unless they are completely non-adjustable and fixed in angle at the time of measurement.

Caught on camera
Oracle Team USA was photographed with such a device in mid-March. Again that is not illegal but it must not be adjusted while racing ie two minutes before the starting signal for a race. They are of course allowed to sail out of class, outside an America’s Cup Regatta race, and while training or in development.

The Measurement Committee Interpretation effectively said that it couldn’t be adjusted at all, after the boat had been measured – which is only done while the boat is hauled out, and put into a measurement condition ashore.

That Interpretation was not immediately challenged by the teams in public, and indeed if such a challenge were made, the decision was not overturned.

Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa would be expected to argue that it is not Neutral Management for a team to see an Interpretation, fit a device that could be used in a way contrary to that Interpretation, and then for that team’s club to effectively push through a rule change on the basis of safety, after a fatal accident in winds of just 11-17kts.

The other issues with having an adjustable rudder elevator, means that unless it is sealed after measurement in some way, there is no real way of checking whether a crew has adjusted the elevator angle during a race.

US Coast Guard visits Luna Rossa US Coast Guard visits Emirates Team NZ, earlier this weelk - Francesco Cattani - External Relations Director Luis Saenz - General Counsel Capt. Greg Stump - Sector Commander San Francisco, USCG Max Sirena - Skipper -  Ellen Hoke   Click Here to view large photo


The advantage to a boat using an adjustable rudder elevator (by moving the rudder stock) is that it gives her two means of controlling her foiling – through the adjustable daggerboard case, which only Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa initially fitted, and with a second adjustment on her rudder elevator.

As the situation stands, the two sailing Challengers have little scope to fit Rudder Elevators, as they are due to start racing in 10 days, while the Defender still has two months to continue and refine development.

Further the Challengers are entitled to rely on the Class Rules as they are published, and in particular any Interpretations that explain the Measurement Committee’s view.

If the Class Rules are to be changed they can only be done by the agreement of all Teams, and not unilaterally by a single party.

It would be difficult to argue that the rudder elevators are a safety device, as two of the Challengers at least have been sailing for up to a year without them and in winds of well over 30 knots.

However the ongoing saga could rebound on teams who fit and use the devices. Those with even modest America’s Cup memories will recall the shenanigans that occurred in 1992 over the bowsprit used by then Team New Zealand in the Louis Vuitton Cup. With regular protests the team was not clear on its use, and at one stage had a race result reversed.

The issue with the rudder elevators, that unless properly processed through the Class Rules in the manner prescribed by the Protocol, then the rules battle will continue, and may well rebound in the same way as happened over 20 years ago, in San Diego.


by Richard Gladwell

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=111207

11:39 AM Mon 24 Jun 2013GMT


Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 America's Cup

Related News Stories:

04 Jul 2013  Americas Cup: High Noon at the America's Cup Corral
03 Jul 2013  America´s Cup 2013 Team New Zealand prepares for Louis Vuitton
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Oracle and Emirates hit their straps - AmCam Video
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Louis Vuitton's Images of the Day - July 2, 2013
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Wet 'n Wild on San Francisco Bay - AmCam Video
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Luna Rossa takes tough line against Race Director
03 Jul 2013  Americas Cup: Italian skipper fires broadside on Luna Rossa base tour
02 Jul 2013  America's Cup: NZ Rigging drops the Big Boat's mast into cafe alley
01 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Ted Hood dies at 86
01 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Review Committee member - will commonsense prevail?
MORE STORIES ...






News - USA and the World

Photographer Ingrid Abery was on the water at 2015 ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami and provided this gallery of images. ... [more]  

VX One momentum is growing with ever larger fleets showing the pure fun and easy performance of this true thoroughbred one design. ... [more]  

Touch2Play had the great fortune of participating in what would be the largest yet gathering of J88’s to date. Quantum Key West Race Week would serve as a chance to see how boats lined up against one another in conditions that covered the full range. For this event we had Rob and Sandy Butler, Steve Leibel, Keven Piper, Coleen Walsh and myself, Larry Huibers. ... [more]  

As the Barcelona World Race leaders race to the Crozet Islands, once again their paths have diverged – Neutrogena around 200 miles to the south-west of first-placed Cheminées Poujoulat on the water, and gaining around 40 miles in the past 24 hours. ... [more]  

For the Tokyo 2020 Paralympic Games the International Paralympic Committee (IPC) will announce on Saturday (31 January) at 10:00 CET the final line-up of sports. ... [more]  

On a high octane first day of the ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami on Monday (26 January) Giles Scott, Alison Young and the Paralympian Sonar trio of John Robertson, Hannah Stodel and Steve Thomas saw the best possible start to their 2015 sailing seasons with double race victories. ... [more]  

On the opening day of racing at ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami, presented by Sunbrella, it was sunny and bright. It was storming and raining sideways. It was sunny and bright. ... [more]  

On the opening day of racing at ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami, presented by Sunbrella, it was sunny and bright. It was storming and raining sideways. It was sunny and bright. ... [more]  

RC44 World Championship Leg 1 gets underway on 24th March until 29th March 2015. The RC 44 Class is unlike any 40 foot sailing yacht ever designed, and the reason for that is simple. She is a high performance one design yacht created for top level racing in international regattas. If one was to compare this concept to racing cars, then we would be talking about the F1, NASCAR or similar. ... [more]  

On Day 1 of the ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami, Presented by Sunbrella, America's premier Olympic and Paralympic classes regatta, featured the full range of what sailing in Miami has to offer. Over 850 sailors enjoyed strong breeze for the duration of the day, in addition to a brief but powerful rainstorm. ... [more]  

ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami - Giles Scott (GBR) said last week that he hoped his unbeaten run would continue, and based on Monday’s form at the Sailing World Cup Miami, the 2014 World and European Finn Champion is giving it a pretty good shot ... [more]  

ISAF Olympic classes regatta Miami 2015 images provided by photographer Ingrid Abery. ... [more]  

Team Alvimedica won a Leg 3 podium place in China after some of the closest racing ever seen in the history of the Volvo Ocean Race. The Turkish-American team protected their position in the final stretch to Sanya, carefully navigating a course peppered with fishing boats along the Vietnamese coast and across the South China Sea to cap off a well-sailed leg to clinch third. ... [more]  

The finish of Leg 3 of the Volvo Ocean Race in Sanya, China just before noon on January 27, 2015 marked an unbelievable end to a magnificent leg for Dongfeng Race Team. After leading the fleet virtually all the way from Abu Dhabi to Sanya in China, over more than 5,000 miles of intense ocean racing, Dongfeng finally crossed the finish line in first place ... [more]  

Winner of Leg 3 of the Volvo Ocean Race, Dongfeng, have released footage taken from a drone launched from the Volvo Ocean Race yacht, as she sails in light airs on the last days of Leg 3 of the race. It is believed to be the first time a drone, launched from a competitor, has been used in a major ocean race. ... [more]  

World sailing history was created earlier today when Dongfeng Race Team became the first Chinese yacht to have a win in a premier trans-ocean racing event. Her win was also a first in the 41-year history of the Volvo Ocean Race. At 1131hrs UTC the Chinese flagged entry emphatically won Leg 3 in their home port of Sanya to take the overall leadin the 40,000nm event with six stages to go. ... [more]  

On the morning of the 26th of January, the Maersk Line ship MV Stockholm delivered the Team Vestas Wind's damaged VO65 to the port in Genoa, Italy. From here she will be taken to the Persico building facilty where the rebuild of the wrecked boat will be undertaken. The team's goal is to rejoin the race in Lisbon, Portugal in June, 2015. ... [more]  

Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin Group is considering backing Sir Ben Ainslie’s America’s Cup bid, in a move that would propel the fortunes of the Olympic gold medallist yet further. Sir Ben is believed to have asked the Virgin billionaire to consider backing the venture when he and his new wife, Georgie Thompson, spent time on Sir Richard’s Necker Island in January. ... [more]  

To the 91st 2015 Bell's Beer Bayview Mackinac Race significant changes have been made in order to enhance the race experience, and by the looks of it, sailors are embracing them wholeheartedly. ... [more]  

Alpari World Match Racing Tour - Monsoon Cup preview by Alpari World Match Racing Tour
The final event of the 2014 Alpari World Match Racing Tour, Monsoon Cup Malaysia, is to take place in its new home of Johor, the southernmost state of Malaysia, over 10th-14th February. In addition to being the grand finale of the Tour, the event will also see the 2014 ISAF Match Racing World Champion crowned. ... [more]  

In the Barcelona World Race the two lead boats are preparing for a gruelling 3,500-mile game of chase across the Southern Ocean, until the next natural gateway of the course, Cape Leeuwin in south-west Australia. ... [more]  

Quantum Key West Race Week provided the opportunity for the GC32s to make a spectacular debut in the USA. During the five days of racing held in balmy temperatures off the southernmost tip of Florida, crews experienced a range of conditions. ... [more]  

40 year old Charles Caudrelier the skipper of race leader Dongfeng was a major figure of the winning French team Groupama in 2011-12 . With the Dongfeng team now approaching Sanya, almost unstoppable, its worthwhile hearing from Volvo Ocean Race CEO Knut Frostad who is hugely pleased with the current on water situation. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race. The northerly drag race continues, with the stable light wind forecast to drop slightly. The boats have all remained in position, if anything cementing their places with gaps between them increasing slightly through the night. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race Leg 3 - Sailing in a straight line was never supposed to be as tense as this. We’ve been pointing at Sanya for almost a day now and fortunately, Alvimedica, MAPFRE, and Brunel far enough back to not be in AIS range anymore. The problem is they’re not in AIS range anymore. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race Leg 3 - After what can only be described as a frustrating few days of wind and current conditions in the Malacca Strait, the shipping lanes we had to pass were a bit more entertaining as it was upwind which meant some tacking. ... [more]  

Volvo Ocean Race: Leg 3 Finish - Video - Delayed feed by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com/nz
Tune in here to see the finish of Leg 3 of the Volvo Ocean race in Sanya. Will sailing history be made? Can Dongfeng become the first Chinese flagged yacht to win a Leg in a Round the World Race? ... [more]  

2015 ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami - Bigger than ever in 2015, with an atmosphere crackling with adrenaline, the ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami, Presented by Sunbrella, was ground zero on Sunday as competitors from 63 countries made their final preparations. ... [more]  

The Chinese entry Dong looks set to create sailing sailing history when she finishes first on Leg 3 of the Volvo Ocean Race, Sanya in two days time. Includes video Currently Dongfeng is 250 nm to the finish line in Sanya and the chasing pack with ADOR ahead in second place 55+ nm behind the Chinese team. ... [more]  

The first of the iconic Great Capes has been passed in the Barcelona World Race with Cheminées Poujoulat rounding the Cape of Good Hope earlier this morning. Bernard Stamm and Jean Le Cam passed 20°E around 400 miles south of Cape Agulhas – the southernmost tip of Africa – at 0935am (UTC) today and have begun the Indian Ocean leg of their race around Antarctica. ... [more]  

The Classic 18fters were racing again on Saturday on Sydney harbour. Michael Chittenden caught the action from a shore vantage point. ... [more]  

When race leader Dongfeng rounded Singapore 60+ nautical miles ahead of the chasing pack, it looked like the final 1200 miles of Leg three would be a procession but over the last day, the Volvo Ocean race leg from Abu Dhabi to Sanya China appears to have tightened incredibly. ... [more]  

US Sailing and Rolex USA announced last week that the 2014 Rolex Yachtswoman of the Year is Stephanie Roble. Her accomplishments on the water last year were recognized by the selection panel for her versatility; her accomplishments as a skipper and as a crew; and her competitive successes on a variety of platforms, sailing against both men and women. ... [more]  

Barcelona World Race - Taking advantage
Oakcliff Awarded Joe Prosser Award at US Sailing NSPS 2015
20 Nations head for 2015 St.Maarten Heineken Regatta
Volvo Ocean Race - Less than 500 miles to go
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - Fantastic finish
Barcelona World Race: Weather beacons launched midrace
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - Day 5
Mount Gay Round Barbados Race – Gala prizegiving marks end of event
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - Day 5 images by Ingrid Abery
Volvo Ocean Race Leader - Dongfeng - the right place at the right time
ISAF Youth Match Racing World Championship - Notice Of Race online
Currently doing scheduled maintenance.
Volvo Ocean Race: Changes to Team Vestas Wind crew
McDougall+McConaghy Moth Worlds: Highlight video released
America's Cup: Oracle crew mate lodges complaint against Tienpont
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - Day 4 images by Ingrid Abery
2015 ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami - US Sailing Team preview
Quantum Key West Race Week 2015 - A great day
Volvo Ocean Race: Jump seat and Pro-Am race spots up for auction
Lauderdale Olympic Classes Regatta overall
Volvo Ocean Race - Dongfeng? Race Team suffer? damage   
America's Cup: Italy to host first America's Cup World Series regatta   
Breeze and Sunshine at Quantum Key West Race Week   
Images of the Millennium Cup and Bay of Islands Sailing Week - Day 1:   
2015 Mount Gay Rum Round Barbados Race – Three records broken   
St.Maarten Heineken Regatta - Simplified logistics and fun themes   
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - Day 3 images by Ingrid Abery   
Millennium Cup: Racing in the picturesque Bay of Islands   
Volvo Ocean Race - Up up and away   
Barcelona World Race - 'Haves' and 'Have Nots'   
Volvo Ocean Race Leg 3 update from Jack Bouttell onboard Dongfeng   
ISAF Sailing World Cup Miami - Game time!   
Extreme Sailing Series™ 2015 – Ninth year ready to rock!   
Foiling GC32s Key West Race Week images by Ingrid Abery   
Mount Gay Rum Round Barbados Race - Crews prepare for big race   
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - Day 2   
2015 Quantum Key West Race Week - A challenging day   
America's Cup: Spithill leads Oracle reconnaissance team in Bermuda   
Extreme Sailing Series announces new teams and venues for 2015   
Barcelona World Race - Leaders enter the fastest section of the course   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL NEW US
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT