Please select your home edition
Edition
Barz Optics - Melanin Lenses

With no awards, it's the year of living dangerously

by Mark Rothfield on 17 Aug 2012
Jeanneau's Prestige 500 found favour with European judges last year Jeanneau Australia
Around this time of year, a lifetime ago, I was in the salubrious Modern Boating canteen perched on ink-stained seats and sipping the fifth watery cappuccino of the morning, while pages listing 70-odd boat names lay spread across the table.

With me were David Toyer, Warren Steptoe, Barry Tranter and David Lockwood, all legends of their boat-testing craft. Our task, a thankless one, was to pick the annual Boat of the Year winners.

Thoughts were deep and the mood argumentative, but the debate was nothing if not fascinating. Considering there’d be five delighted divisional winners and dozens of potentially peeved advertisers, not to mention disgruntled readers if we got it wrong, everyone was taking it seriously.

First came the challenge of dividing the contenders into the rightful categories, which isn't always easy with, say, a hybrid family/fishing trailerboat. Then the respective design merits were tossed back and forth across the table, like Federer and Murray slugging it out at Wimbledon.

We whittled the list down by process of elimination until only the victors were left standing.

Meanwhile, over at the Boating Industry Association offices, they were poring over rigid score sheets trying to determine their own winners. Their judges had flown the length and breadth of the country in a desperate attempt to be transparent and all-inclusive, and armed guards kept the results under lock and key until boatshow time.

But the system didn’t stack up. Icebox too small – lose 10 points. Hull dangerously unstable – lose 10 points.

We, on the other hand, were judging by head and heart, not that these are bad barometers. Your gut often has better instincts than a clinical comparison of facts. Your gut puts things in perspective and detects the mystical X Factor that separates the strong from the weak.

It’s impossible not to impose personal taste and preferences. To this day, whenever I review a boat I close my eyes and try to picture myself as the end user, in the bay of my dreams far from the maddening salesman. In this euphoric state I then try to decide whether I’d fork out my hard-earned to own it.

So the magazine awards weren’t perfect but they gave builders something to strive for and helped raise standards.

A survey at the time showed that 22% of potential buyers felt a Boat of the Year award was a significant factor in their decision-making process. Price remained the number one priority, though, with more than half of survey respondents saying it had the greatest impact.

Sadly, the Australian awards are no more, at least not in a meaningful and truly national sense. If someone can resurrect them at some stage I'd put my hand up again, but for now it means we have to wade through a myriad of international gongs.

An increasing number of people will have to make their own hand-on-heart decision, which perhaps is a good thing. Buyers are, and always have been, the best judges as well.
Ancasta Ker 33 660x82Mackay BoatsProtector - 660 x 82

Related Articles

America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ hooks up in Bermuda with Brits +Video
Emirates Team New Zealand were training again on the Great Sound in Bermuda, in fresh winds of over 25kts from the ESE. Emirates Team New Zealand were training again on the Great Sound in Bermuda, in fresh winds of over 25kts from the ESE. MyislandhomeBDA caught the America's Cup Challenger as they had their first real hook-up with another team - lining up against Britain's Land Rover BAR.
Posted on 25 Apr
America's Cup - Tom Slingsby explains optimal ride height
Ever wondered whether there is a difference between riding high or low in a foiling AC50? Ever wondered whether there is a difference between riding high or low in a foiling AC50? Does the old maxim with catamarans apply - that you are at your most efficient with the hull just clear of the water? At what point to AC50's start sliding sideways - like a Laser dinghy with its centreboard raised too high?
Posted on 25 Apr
America's Cup - Artemis Racing shifts into dog-fighting mode
The third round of America's Cup ACC practice racing got underway in Bermuda on Monday, April 24. The third round of America's Cup ACC practice racing got underway in Bermuda on Monday, April 24. Skipper Nathan Outteridge says Match Racing skills have always been a big part of a successful campaign and the team at Artemis Racing is now working hard at improving its “dog fighting” tactics.
Posted on 25 Apr
New addition to North Sail for Volvo Ocean 65 racing machines
Their sails have powered eight out of nine Volvo Ocean Race winners since 1989-90, with Steinlager 2. Instead of assembling cloth panels into a particular sail shape, the Volvo Ocean Race sails are composites. This means that 3Di material 'tapes' are laid in a specific arrangement, offering stable structure to the sail where it is needed most.
Posted on 24 Apr
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ first practise in Great Sound - Video
Emirates Team New Zealand had their first solid day of training on Bermuda's Great Sound on April 23, 2017 Emirates Team NZ had their first solid day of training on Bermuda's Great Sound on April 23, 2017. Winds during the session were averaging 10kts gusting 15kts. As with the other video it is impossible to gauge boat speed, or form an accurate impression of relative speed. However the infrequency of splash down is apparent, as is the very slick gybing and tacking while remaining foil borne.
Posted on 24 Apr
America's Cup - Tech Tuesday - Why AC50's sail bow down - Video
OTUSA tactician Tom Slingsby (AUS) explains why the AC50's sail with bow down trim Why do the America's Cup Class catamarans sail with bow down trim? It's a common question. Helmsman and Tactician Tom Slingsby? provides a detailed answer in this #TechTuesday feature.
Posted on 23 Apr
America's Cup - Touchdown and take-off for Emirates Team NZ in Bermuda
Today the team's America’s Cup Class race boat was out sailing on Bermuda's Great Sound for the first time It is just over three weeks since Emirates Team New Zealand was sailing in New Zealand, and today the teams America’s Cup Class race boat was out sailing on Bermuda's Great Sound for the first time under inquisitive gaze of an armada of competitors' chase boats getting a first hand glimpse of the kiwi boat
Posted on 23 Apr
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ has first sail in Bermuda + Video
Emirates Team NZ has just completed for their first sail in Bermuda, in preparation for the racing phase of AC35 Emirates Team New Zealand has just completed for their first sail in Bermuda, in preparation for the racing phase of the 2017 America's Cup campaign. The team, the last to arrive in Bermuda, returned to their base in the Royal Dockyard around 7.15pm local time (1015am NZT).
Posted on 22 Apr
America's Cup - Images from Practice Race Session 2 in Bermuda.
Images have just been posted by America's Cup organisers of the second Practice Session conducted between April 6-7. Images have just been posted by America's Cup organisers of the second Practice Session conducted in Bermuda between April 6-7. Images are not available from the third session which finished on April 12. The next Practice Session is a five day one beginning on April 24 to April 28.
Posted on 22 Apr
35 days to go until the start of the 35th America's Cup
Friday 21st April is another milestone in the countdown to the start of the 35th America’s Cup Friday 21st April is another milestone in the countdown to the start of the 35th America’s Cup as it marks exactly 35 days to go until the greatest race on water begins in Bermuda.
Posted on 22 Apr