Please select your home edition
Edition
Sail World NZ Lone Wolf

Whatever happened to Sandy Island?

by Nancy Knudsen on 29 Nov 2012
Sandy Island on an old chart SW
Where did Sandy Island go? Captain James Cook is a revered seaman with an unparalleled record of surveying the countries and islands that he visited. He surveyed Sandy Island as between Australia and New Caledonia in the Coral Sea back in 1772. It was also mapped by a British whaler, the Velocity, in 1876. It's been on world charts ever since. But last week, another vessel went to the location and found only deep water.

The island appears on many world maps spanning several hundred years and was supposedly located at 19° 13' 12? S, 159° 55' 48? E. Even Google Maps displayed the island until 26 November 2012, when it was removed.

It was removed because of the reports by some Australian scientists aboard the RV Southern Surveyor who were studying plate tectonics in the area. During the voyage, they noticed a discrepancy between different maps and decided to sail to the supposed location to investigate. The crew found no island and stated their nautical charts showed depths of 1,400 metres (4,600 ft). They found that 'The ocean floor actually didn't ever get shallower than 1,300 meters below the wave base…'

So how could this island, which has been on official charts, not only British, but also German, French, Italian, Japanese, US and Russion charts, have simply disappeared? The short answer, is, of course, that it couldn't.

While no explanation as to why Captain James Cook surveyed an island that is not, and never could have been there, many other islands have also been charted in the past, from such clues as 'a long cloud' or 'breaking waves' indicating the existence of an island. Such islands have been charted, as a precautionary measure, but later found to be non-existent.

What is amazing is that, while the island persisted on charts until this month, this is not the first time that Sandy Island was proclaimed not to exist.

In 2000 a group of radio amateurs headed to the Chesterfield Islands on a so-called DXpedition, hoping to find the remotest dry land possible from which to send a ham radio message.

In order for the Chesterfields to qualify, they scoured its surroundings for land, found Sandy Island on the map, but not where it should be in the ocean. Nobody took much notice of them.

The original report of their expedition does mention that Sandy Island is marked on some maps, but not on others, and quotes a Senior Editor of National Geographic Maps as saying that their cartography is 'hopelessly outdated for this area', and would be updated ‘soon’.

Just in case there are any adventurous cruising sailors out there who would like to test the existence or otherwise of Sandy Island for themselves, be warned. The Chesterfield Islands are an uninhabited archipelago in French territorial waters, west of Sandy Island’s supposed location.

They are a collection of about a dozen islets, some still shifting, and numerous reefs, spread out over an area 75 by 45 miles, but totalling less than 6 sq miles in dry land, and thought to be charted vicariously. These are significant hazards for the cruising sailor, and very likely to be inaccurately charted.

C-Tech Emirates TNZNaiadProtector - 660 x 82

Related Articles

Tall ship loses power, hits multiple boats before grounding
Coast Guard Station Castle Hill is providing a safety zone in Newport Harbor, Rhode Island, Sunday night Coast Guard Station Castle Hill is providing a safety zone in Newport Harbor, Rhode Island, Sunday night after a tall ship lost power and hit multiple other boats before grounding near Perrotti Park. The SSV Oliver Hazard Perry, an educational tall ship homeported in Newport, was leaving Bowen's Wharf Seafood Festival with 12 crewmembers aboard when it lost power and began to drift.
Posted on 16 Oct
BoatUS “CAT” Team still hard at work
A month after Hurricane Irma struck Florida, the BoatUS Catastrophe (“CAT”) Field Team is still hard at work. A month after Hurricane Irma struck Florida, the BoatUS Catastrophe (“CAT”) Field Team is still hard at work. Here, in Marathon’s Boot Key Harbor, salvage crews from TowBoatUS Marathon raise a sunken sailboat and navigation hazard off the harbor bottom.
Posted on 12 Oct
Newport International Boat Show helping to aid the Caribbean Islands
Newport Int'l Boat Show announced that it committed $15,000 to organizations helping those affected by Hurricanes Irma Newport International Boat Show, announced today that it has committed $15,000 to various organizations helping to assist those in the Caribbean islands affected by Hurricanes Irma and Maria.
Posted on 12 Oct
Coast Guard Foundation salutes members of Coast Guard at annual dinner
US Coast Guard Band and the Coast Guard Academy Glee Club from New London, Connecticut will perform during the event. At the event, the Coast Guard Foundation will honor United States Coast Guard heroism and mission excellence with two awards, and acknowledge the response and rescue efforts of the service during the last three weeks of hurricane activity in Texas, Florida, Puerto Rico and the Caribbean.
Posted on 30 Sep
Auckland on the Water Boat Show gets underway in summer warmth
The Auckland On the Water Boat Show opened to more summery climes. After being lashed by a succession of gales and horizontal rain for the past few months, the Auckland On the Water Boat Show opened to more summery climes. The gates opened at 10.00am with the usual queue waiting to see three floors of exhibits in the Viaduct Events Centre before moving through the pavilion area
Posted on 28 Sep
Relief for Dominica
Our friends in Dominica were hit by Hurricane Maria on Monday evening, a category 5 storm on the Saffir-Simpson scale The Marine community through the Antigua and Barbuda Marine Association is working with Ondeck who is preparing its Farr 65 Spirit of Juno to head to Dominica late on Thursday evening to deliver much needed aid. They will then return a number of times over the coming weeks.
Posted on 20 Sep
Coast Guard Foundation activates Disaster Relief and Response Fund
The Coast Guard Foundation has been working tirelessly to help those affected by Hurricane Irma and Harvey The Coast Guard Foundation, a non-profit organization committed to the education and welfare of all Coast Guard members and their families, announced today the activation of its Disaster Relief and Response Fund to assist Coast Guard Members impacted by Hurricane Harvey.
Posted on 19 Sep
Tropical storm warning in effect
A Tropical Storm Warning means that tropical storm conditions are expected somewhere within warning area within 36 hours A Tropical Storm Warning is currently in effect for the area from Watch Hill, Rhode Island, to Hull, Massachusetts, including Block Island, Martha`s Vineyard, and Nantucket.
Posted on 19 Sep
Coast Guard readies for Jose, cautions mariners
Coast Guard units across the Northeast are accelerating preparations Monday ahead of forecasted tropical storm condition Coast Guard Air Station Cape Cod crews are flying storm tracks and using marine radios to warn offshore boaters of the approaching heavy weather and recommending they seek safe haven.
Posted on 19 Sep
Oceanis – 2018 set to be a prolific year
Alongside the new Oceanis51.1, Beneteau announced four new Oceanises to satisfy a broad range of aspirations this autumn 30 years on, the best known range in the world continues to show its vitality. Alongside the new Oceanis 51.1, which won over the experts at its first sea trials, Beneteau has announced four new Oceanises to satisfy a broad range of aspirations this autumn.
Posted on 15 Sep