Please select your home edition
Edition
T Clew Ring New Generic

Volvo Ocean Race- Double Olympic medallist slams vital Umpire Call

by Sail-World on 10 Jun 2012
1- Telefonica (blue sails) establishes an overlaop to leeward of Puma soon after theb start of the Oeiras In-Port Race in Lisbon, during the Volvo Ocean Race 2011-12. Ian Roman/Volvo Ocean Race© http://www.volvooceanrace.com

The tension in the Volvo Ocean Race boiled over today, after the InPort race in Lisbon, Portugal, after a controversial penalty soon after the start, relegated former overall race leader, Telefonica back to sixth place in the race.

The incident came seconds after the start, when Telefonica, sailed by Iker Martinez, an Olympic Gold and Silver medalist in the 49er skiff class, sailed through to leeward of Puma Ocean Racing (Ken Read).

Puma was to windward and became overlapped as the result of Telefonica's actions. As such Puma became the windward boat and must keep clear. However because she created the overlap by sailing to leeward, Telefonica is not allowed to sail above her proper course. (A technical term generally meaning a course a yacht would sail to reach the next mark as quickly as possible. There can be several 'proper courses'.)

From the video of the incident Telefonica appeared to luff a little, or Puma bore away (it was difficult to tell precisely as the video cameras had pulled away from the incident at the time of the action, so all that could be seen was how the overlap was established and the incident itself, where the boats appeared to be on a collision course, but no contact occurred.)

But in a replay available on http://www.volvooceanrace.com/en/3d-race-viewer.html!Volvo_Ocean_Race_3D_Viewer, it is clear that Puma was in the 'clear ahead' as she cleared the start line. Telefonica sailed through to leeward, luffed above a proper course, and Puma responded but not by a similar amount of luffing action. On that basis it would seem that Telefonica infringed RRS 17 and was correctly penalised. The skipper of Puma, Ken Read, is a former America's Cup helmsman, and the move by Telefonica was a basic match racing move.

In statement posted on the Telefonica team website skipper Iker Martinez was outraged by the decision which cost five vital points, and increased the margin between Telefonica, and new overall leader of the Volvo Ocean Race, Groupama (Franck Cammas).

Martinez was backed up by the team's rules expert Luis Sáenz: 'My conclusion is that the umpires have made a serious error here and confused a leeward tack by 'Puma' to hoist the spinaker with a luff by 'Telefónica'' (sic)


The report posted on the team website continued: 19 knots of breeze were blowing in the River Tajo today as the tide began to come in, at the predicted time of 12:00 UTC. That's when the eighth inshore race so far of the Volvo Ocean Race kicked off. It took place in Lisbon with a course marked out originally along 18.6 miles, split into four legs, but after 40 minutes of racing, the regatta was cut down to 11.6 nautical miles.

The race began with the spinakers hoisted, a downwind course and that was good for 'Telefónica'. However, an early penalty which skipper Iker Martínez has qualified as 'totally incorrect', forced the Spanish boat to make a turn of 360º that wiped out any possibilities they may have had in the race, despite some good sailing. 'A penalty with these winds, a few seconds after the start totally blows you out of the water', said Martínez.

'We had to make a penalty turn at the start which obviously pushed us right to the back of the race', explains the Basque skipper, back on shore. 'The level at which we're sailing the inshores now is much higher than it was previously and for that we were fairly happy, but today what threw out our chances in the race was quite simply a decision by the International Jury'.

The person in charge of rules and regulations on Team Telefónica is Luis Sáenz Mariscal. He explained what happened in the following terms: 'What the umpire is saying is that we infringed Rule 17 which says that if an overlap occurs from clear astern you mustn't sail above your proper course. My conclusion is that the umpires have made a serious error here and confused a leeward tack by 'Puma' to hoist the spinaker with a luff by 'Telefónica'.

In the Spaniard's opinion: 'They said what they saw on the water and they say that out on the water they saw a luff by 'Telefónica' which meant that they weren't able to keep clear of 'Puma', but the reality is that in cases like these, the rules are structured in a very simple fashion.


There is a basic rule, which is the Windward-Leeward rule. Leeward has the right of way over windward. We were leeward and 'Puma' was windward. 'Puma' had to keep clear and they did absolutely nothing to keep clear. Then there are a series of limitations which state that we can't luff too forcefully, that we can't sail above our proper course... but these are exceptions applied in case of doubt and in this case 'Puma' did nothing to keep clear and there was a moment where they did not halt the hoisting of the spinaker and it touched our shrouds'.

In any case, as the lawyer points out: 'The umpire's decision is final and the matter is closed out on the water. There is nothing to be done and there is no channel for a redress or an appeal'.

'Groupama' won the race, about which Iker Martínez said that they sailed a great race. 'I congratulate them, and they've also boosted their lead by five points, which is an important advantage for them'. American team 'Puma' finished second and is now six points from Martínez and co in the overall rankings. The podium was finished off by 'Camper with Emirates Team New Zealand'.



The penultimate leg kicks off tomorrow

The eighth and penultimate leg in this edition of the round the world race starts tomorrow at 12:00 UTC and 13:00 local time in Lisbon.

It will take the boats across 1, 940 miles from Lisbon to Lorient, home of 'Groupama', and the crew on 'Telefónica' are now completely focussed on it.

'We'll start a new leg tomorrow and we have to give it all we've got, as always. Out on the water there are things that come up and different possibilities which open up, but here on shore, until we take the start we have to prepare as best we can, rest up and make good sail choices etc. to then go on to compete at one hundred per cent on the leg. That is what we are going to do, as angry and disappointed as we might feel today. We feel that this is completely unjust but all we can do now is focus on tomorrow and prepare as best we can', said Martínez.

More Quotes
Iker Martínez, skipper


I think that it's very unfair that this happens, because the inshore races can decide the round the world regatta, although it's the same for us all. The juries need to take the correct decisions and I'm one hundred per cent sure that today's was a totally incorrect decision. I hope there'll be no complaining later that the regatta rested on these points, which is something that could happen.



Xabi Fernández, trimmer.

It was a difficult start, and downwind starts are always tricky and you don't have as much control over the situation. It was a very tight start, especially with 'Puma', and everyone was lined up. Before the start 'Puma' had won the position over us, so they made a better start. Just after the start there was an incident in which they came up very close to us as they were hoisting their spinaker and as we were leeward we protested, thinking that they would be penalised for it. Of course we didn't agree with this at all, but we had to take the penalty and that's when we trailed behind in the race and it was very difficult.

Tomorrow the eighth and penultimate leg begins with a lot to play for. It's a fairly short leg where we are likely to get a mix of conditions. We'll set off with breeze and then we head for the Azores where there won't be any and then as we exit it's likely to pick up again. It's an incredibly important leg and today we dropped some important points on 'Groupama', but I hope we'll have a good leg. Everything slipped away today because of a decision by an International Jury and I don't think we sailed badly, so we're positive about tomorrow.

T Clewring AC72Bakewell-White Yacht DesignInSunSport - NZ

Related Articles

Rio 2016 - The Qualification Games - Part 2
Yachting NZ's refusal to nominate in three classes won in the first round of 2016 Olympic Qualification is unprecedented Yachting New Zealand's refusal to nominate in three classes won in the first round of 2016 Olympic Qualification is without precedent. Subject to Appeal, the Kiwis have signaled that they will reject 30% of the positions gained in the ISAF World Sailing Championships in Santander in 2014.
Posted on 22 May
Gladwell's Line - World Sailing changes tack after IOC windshift
Over the past year, we've given the International Sailing Federation (now re-badged as World Sailing) a bit of stick Over the past year, we've given the International Sailing Federation (now re-badged as World Sailing) a bit of stick. Every blow well earned over issues such as the pollution at Rio, the Israeli exclusion abomination plus a few more. But now World Sailing is getting it right.
Posted on 21 May
Rio 2016 - The Qualification Games - Part 1
Antipodean selection shenanigans aside, the Qualification system for the Rio Olympics appears to be achieving its goals Antipodean selection shenanigans aside, the Qualification system for the Rio Olympics appears to be achieving goals set in the Olympic Commission report of 2010. Around 64 countries are expected to be represented in Rio de Janeiro in August. That is a slight increase on Qingdao and Weymouth, but more importantly a full regional qualification system is now in place
Posted on 19 May
Taming the beast-a conversation with Stuart Meurer of Parker Hannifin
While AC72 cats were fast, they difficult to control, so Oracle partnered with Parker Hannifin to innovate a better way. If you watched videos of the AC72s racing in the 34th America’s Cup (2013), you’re familiar with the mind-boggling speeds that are possible when wingsail-powered catamarans switch from displacement sailing to foiling mode. While foiling is fast, there’s no disguising the platform’s inherent instability. Now, Oracle Team USA has teamed up with Parker Hannifin to innovate a better way.
Posted on 18 May
From foiling Moths to Olympic starting lines-a Q&A with Bora Gulari
Bora Gulari’s is representing the USA at the Rio 2016 Olympics in the Nacra 17 class, along with teammate Louisa Chafee. Bora Gulari (USA) has made a strong name for himself within high-performance sailing circles, with wins at the 2009 and 2013 Moth Worlds. In between, he broke the 30-knort barrier and was the 2009 US SAILING Rolex Yachtsman of the Year. His latest challenge is representing the USA at the Rio 2016 Olympics in the Nacra 17 class as skipper, along with his teammate Louisa Chafee.
Posted on 12 May
Concern for Zika at Rio Olympics is now deadly serious
Alphabet soup is one description that has thus far not been used for either Guanabara Bay, Alphabet soup is one description that has thus far not been used for either Guanabara Bay, or the Rio Olympics. Many others have, and they were apt, but things have changed. So here now we have a situation where one man, Associate Professor Amir Attaran, who does have a more than decent string of letters after his name, is bringing nearly as many facts to bear as references at the article's end
Posted on 12 May
Zhik - The brand born of a notion, not its history
here is probably every reason that ocean rhymes with notion. Zhik’s tagline is officially marketed as Made For Water There is probably every reason that ocean rhymes with notion. Zhik’s tagline has been officially marketed as Made For Water, and this is precisely what the company has done for the last eight years before the succinct and apt strapline came from out of R&D and into mainstream visibility.
Posted on 8 May
Shape of next Volvo Ocean Race revealed at Southern Spars - Part 1
Southern Spars has been confirmed as the supplier of spars for the 2017-18 Volvo Ocean Race. In mid-April, Race Director, Jack Lloyd and Stopover Manager Richard Mason outlined the changes expected for the 40,000nm Race during a tour of Southern Spars 10,000sq metre specialist spar construction facility. A total of up to seven boats is expected to enter, but time is running out for the construction of any new boats.
Posted on 3 May
Sailing in the Olympics beyond 2016 - A double Olympic medalist's view
Bruce Kendall takes a look at what he believes Sailing needs to do to survive beyond the 2016 Olympics. Gold and Bronze medalist and multiple world boardsailing/windsurfer champion, Bruce Kendall takes a look at what he believes Sailing needs to do to survive beyond the 2016 Olympics. A key driver is the signalled intention by the International Olympic Committee to select a basket of events that will be contested.
Posted on 29 Apr
From Olympic flag to Olympic Gold and maybe another
The Sydney Olympics was a Sailing double 470 Gold event for Australia. Having won the 420 World Championship in 2000, the feeder class to the 470, while still at school in Australia young Matt Belcher was given the honour of carrying the Olympic flag during the closing ceremony of the Sydney 2000 Olympics.
Posted on 28 Apr