Please select your home edition
Edition
InSunSport - International - Tough

US marine scientist states fishing no worse than farming

by Media Services on 13 Feb 2012
Prof Ray Hilborn in NZ to deliver his comparative report .. ©
American fisheries scientist and marine biologist, Professor Ray Hilborn is in New Zealand presenting at seminars titled 'The Environmental Cost of New Zealand Food Production', where he compares the cost, economic and environmental, of consuming seafood, meat, dairy and other foods.

Prof Hilborn, who teaches resource management and conservation at the University of Washington, says he became interested in the wider environmental cost of food production two years ago.

'A friend in Africa who's the head of conservation programmes for the Frankfurt zoo asked me ‘should I stop eating fish?’, and I’d never really thought about the tradeoffs before. Almost everybody focuses on rainforest or marine and doesn’t look at the connections.'

Hilborn’s report assembles information on various factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, water pollution, erosion, loss of biodiversity and eutrophication – the amount of nutrients released into the air, water or soil.

The conclusions come in several categories. Per serving, for example, the species of wild fish caught most fuel-efficiently are barracouta and southern blue whiting, but both take more energy than a serving of beef or dairy protein. Dairying produces fewer greenhouse gas emissions than beef farming, but more than most fisheries.
On biodiversity, says Hilborn, the contrasts become extreme.

Since New Zealand dairy and meat production uses mostly non-native forage, the reduction in plant biodiversity is almost total in land converted to pasture. Wild fisheries, meanwhile, rely on a naturally functioning ecosystem.
This fact is often lost on marine conservationists concerned about bycatch, for example, says Hilborn.

'The species that attract the most attention in New Zealand – dolphins, sealions – you've always got to go back to the comparison with agriculture. Those species are still there in marine ecosystems, but in agriculture we essentially plough the place down and turn it into something else.'

Hilborn is critical of a report published this month in New Zealand by Forest & Bird called the 'Best Fish Guide', which aims to advise on which fish are the most sustainably caught.

Of 74 species rated, it recommended consumers avoid 50 and had concerns about the other 24. None were rated sustainable.

'They basically look at the abundance of the stock and they then look at bycatch and things like that. It’s pretty clear how they do it, but to some extent those guys are just clueless. The idea that hoki were in danger because they were going down in abundance ... they just obviously don't understand population dynamics.

'If you look at their list and take the species in their green section, they constitute a couple of per cent of New Zealand's fisheries landings. And this is pretty typical – if you take these marine conservation agendas by themselves and say ‘what should you eat?’ they essentially say you should not eat almost all the fish in the world.

'So my question to them is ‘OK, are we better off if people then go out and eat beef, chicken and pork?’ and I think the answer is pretty clearly no! Yes, there are environmental costs in fishing, but the alternatives are also costly. Even the greenest of farms destroys the ecosystem that existed before.'
Schaefer 2016 Ratchet Block 660x82Barz Optics - Kids rangeupffront 660x82

Related Articles

Olympic Gold medalist and Volvo Ocean Race winner up for WS Board
Torben Grael (BRA) is amongst the 15 nominations for one of seven places on the Board of Directors of World Sailing Torben Grael (BRA) is amongst the 15 nominations for one of seven places on the Board of Directors of World Sailing in November. The five times Olympic medalist, Volvo Ocean Race winner and several times America's Cup competitor will bring a much needed sailing edge to the Board of World Sailing if he can navigate the politics of the controlling body of the sport.
Posted today at 6:03 pm
Southern Spars en route to Monaco – Stand QSE2
It’s been another big year for the NZ based company, there's lots of exciting things to talk about the Monaco Yacht Show It’s been another big year for the New Zealand based company, giving us lots of exciting things to talk about at the 2016 Monaco Yacht Show like our two big projects Adix and Aquijo. Adix, the three-masted 65-metre Dykstra schooner, has been transformed by a rig refit by Southern Spars and Future Fibres.
Posted on 22 Sep
Tony Parker - Basketball player and ambassador of the Bridge
Tony Parker, basketball player with an exemplary sporting career, took advantage of visiting France to launch 100 Club This important meeting took place last Saturday morning on 17th September in Nantes, between Tony Parker, godfather to the Bridge, and the companies which support this Franco American initiative, which will celebrate 100 years of fraternal exchanges between two countries. Tony Parker, the basketball player with an exemplary sporting career, took advantage of visiting France to launch the 100 Club
Posted on 22 Sep
Terry Kohler, driving force of North Technology dies at 82
Terry Kohler who purchased North Sails was the driving force behind the North Technology Group, has died aged 82 Terry Kohler who purchased North Sails from Lowell North over 30 years ago and was the driving force behind the North Technology Group, has died aged 82. With the combined company of North sails and Southern Spars, Kohler created the 'Engine above the Deck' concept which married the technology used to build the sails and spars to be designed and work as an integral unit.
Posted on 21 Sep
Terry Kohler, driving force of North Technology dies at 82
Terry Kohler who purchased North Sails was the driving force behind the North Technology Group, has died aged 82 Terry Kohler who purchased North Sails from Lowell North over 30 years ago and was the driving force behind the North Technology Group, has died aged 82. With the combined company of North sails and Southern Spars, Kohler created the 'Engine above the Deck' concept which married the technology used to build the sails and spars to be designed and work as an integral unit.
Posted on 21 Sep
'Grate Art' in Hong Kong
Hong Kong charity pioneers environmental awareness through innovative storm grate installations In an effort to help Hong Kongers play their part in protecting the world’s ocean, Ocean Recovery Alliance is raising awareness through a unique public art installation called ‘Grate Art’. Hong Kong’s drainage system is one of the main sources for debris outflow into the ocean, and Ocean Recovery Alliance is tackling this problem upstream through an initiative that uses “art for awareness”.
Posted on 14 Sep
The Newport International Boat Show is opening next week!
Newport Exhibition Group has secured a record number of exhibitors, and organized more educational activities Newport Exhibition Group, owners and producers of the Newport International Boat Show, announced today that it has secured a record number of exhibitors, and organized more educational activities and attractions for showgoers than ever before.
Posted on 9 Sep
Brookes and Gatehouse Videos with Knut Frostad
Navico, the parent company for Brookes and Gatehouse (B&G), Simrad and Lowrance have prepared some terrific videos Navico, the parent company for Brookes and Gatehouse (B&G), Simrad and Lowrance have prepared some terrific videos with Knut Frostad, the legendary Volvo Ocean Race sailor and former CEO. See him talk about sailing in general, the B&G product choices and placement he made for his own boat, and then why he loves his Outremer 5X.
Posted on 8 Sep
Bavaria C57 – Something big is coming
Bavaria Yachts presents a new revolutionary sailing yacht, in the form of the new Bavaria C57, at the Yachting Festival Bavaria Yachts presents a new revolutionary sailing yacht, in the form of the new Bavaria C57, at the Yachting Festival in Cannes. The innovative design, the smart layout, the high-quality equipment and build quality, and the impressive performance set new standards - and not only for Bavaria Yachts. …..Something big is coming.
Posted on 8 Sep
Zhik sailors win 17 sailing medals at 2016 Olympic Regatta
The 2016 Olympic games are over and what a Games they have been - Zhik sailors dominated Zhik sailors won almost 60% of the medals contested at Rio de Janeiro. It was a regatta which tested sailors and gear - with one day being the most severe conditions ever experienced at an Olympic regatta. For the Zhik team riders on the waters of Rio, four years and more of hard work and dedication have paid off for many.
Posted on 29 Aug