Please select your home edition
Edition
RS Sailing 728x90

US marine scientist states fishing no worse than farming

by Media Services on 13 Feb 2012
Prof Ray Hilborn in NZ to deliver his comparative report ..
American fisheries scientist and marine biologist, Professor Ray Hilborn is in New Zealand presenting at seminars titled 'The Environmental Cost of New Zealand Food Production', where he compares the cost, economic and environmental, of consuming seafood, meat, dairy and other foods.

Prof Hilborn, who teaches resource management and conservation at the University of Washington, says he became interested in the wider environmental cost of food production two years ago.

'A friend in Africa who's the head of conservation programmes for the Frankfurt zoo asked me ‘should I stop eating fish?’, and I’d never really thought about the tradeoffs before. Almost everybody focuses on rainforest or marine and doesn’t look at the connections.'

Hilborn’s report assembles information on various factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, water pollution, erosion, loss of biodiversity and eutrophication – the amount of nutrients released into the air, water or soil.

The conclusions come in several categories. Per serving, for example, the species of wild fish caught most fuel-efficiently are barracouta and southern blue whiting, but both take more energy than a serving of beef or dairy protein. Dairying produces fewer greenhouse gas emissions than beef farming, but more than most fisheries.
On biodiversity, says Hilborn, the contrasts become extreme.

Since New Zealand dairy and meat production uses mostly non-native forage, the reduction in plant biodiversity is almost total in land converted to pasture. Wild fisheries, meanwhile, rely on a naturally functioning ecosystem.
This fact is often lost on marine conservationists concerned about bycatch, for example, says Hilborn.

'The species that attract the most attention in New Zealand – dolphins, sealions – you've always got to go back to the comparison with agriculture. Those species are still there in marine ecosystems, but in agriculture we essentially plough the place down and turn it into something else.'

Hilborn is critical of a report published this month in New Zealand by Forest & Bird called the 'Best Fish Guide', which aims to advise on which fish are the most sustainably caught.

Of 74 species rated, it recommended consumers avoid 50 and had concerns about the other 24. None were rated sustainable.

'They basically look at the abundance of the stock and they then look at bycatch and things like that. It’s pretty clear how they do it, but to some extent those guys are just clueless. The idea that hoki were in danger because they were going down in abundance ... they just obviously don't understand population dynamics.

'If you look at their list and take the species in their green section, they constitute a couple of per cent of New Zealand's fisheries landings. And this is pretty typical – if you take these marine conservation agendas by themselves and say ‘what should you eat?’ they essentially say you should not eat almost all the fish in the world.

'So my question to them is ‘OK, are we better off if people then go out and eat beef, chicken and pork?’ and I think the answer is pretty clearly no! Yes, there are environmental costs in fishing, but the alternatives are also costly. Even the greenest of farms destroys the ecosystem that existed before.'
KZRaceFurlersMackay BoatsProtector - 660 x 82

Related Articles

Marine Resources sponsor IBI Boat Builder Award for 2nd year running
Marine Resources will once again sponsor the Apprenticeship and Training Scheme Award. Following the tremendous success of the 2016 IBI Boat Builder Awards, leading leisure marine and luxury yacht recruitment specialists Marine Resources will once again sponsor the Apprenticeship and Training Scheme Award. The winners will be announced on 15th November at the prestigious Awards Gala Dinner during the METSTRADE Show 2017 in the National Maritime Museum, Amsterdam.
Posted on 22 Aug
Keep the water out with Zhik’s new Superthermal Hydrobase
The lower arm and leg of the new Superthermal Hydrobase is made from a water-repellent, stretch woven fabric We’ve all done it - and fished a rope out of the water, pushed the rudder down or stepped down the slipway one foot too far and gained that unwanted wet sleeve or leg.
Posted on 9 Aug
North Sails releases new 3Di Headsail for the J/105 Class
North Sails released its latest headsail design for competitive J/105 class. The Li-5 3Di jib replaces the L-4 3DL jib North Sails released its latest headsail design for the competitive J/105 class. The Li-5 3Di jib replaces the L-4 3DL jib bringing the ultimate consistency and performance of North’s exclusive 3Di technology to this light-air optimized headsail. The Li-5 is the perfect complement for the Mi-4 3Di jib which is an all-purpose sail.
Posted on 4 Aug
Hands up - Who is wearing the Zhik Boot 460 at the Moth Worlds?
The Zhik Boot 460 are known as the active dinghy sailors ‘best friend’. The Zhik Boot 460 are known as the active dinghy sailors ‘best friend’. Last week Peter Burling rang the Zhik product development team in Sydney, for assistance to get hold of a pair of the Boot 460s in time for the Moth Worlds in Lake Garda. And looking around the fleet it seems he’s not alone, and the 230 strong fleet of Moth sailors are voting with their feet too.
Posted on 29 Jul
Yacht Racing Forum extends partnership with Zhik for two more years
Top sailors choose Zhik gear to win world championships, and demand it for their OIympic campaigns. The company sells its products into an international network covering more than 40 countries, in Europe, the Americas and the Asia Pacific.
Posted on 25 Jul
Moth Worlds – Moth speed uncovered
C-Tech’s Tim Willetts takes time to reflect on changes in Moth class rig design and development over the past six years With the 2017 Moth world championship starting Tuesday, C-Tech’s Tim Willetts takes time to reflect on changes in Moth class rig design and development over the past six years. A lot has happened behind the scenes that is giving the top sailors the edge by staying ahead.
Posted on 25 Jul
Int Moth Worlds - Zhik returns to its spiritual home at 2017 Worlds
Zhik is returning to its roots as the official clothing sponsor of the 2017 McDougall McConaghy Moth World Championships Zhik, the innovative sailing apparel specialist, is returning to its roots as the official clothing sponsor of the 2017 McDougall McConaghy Moth World Championships. And, ten years on, the Moths are returning to their spiritual home on Lake Garda. Zhik and the International Moth class are virtually synonymous with each other.
Posted on 20 Jul
World Sailing confirms strong presence at Yacht Racing Forum 2017
The tenth edition of the Yacht Racing Forum, in Aarhus, Denmark will reassemble the sport’s key personalities and actors The tenth edition of the Yacht Racing Forum, in Aarhus, Denmark (November 27-28) will once again reassemble the sport’s key personalities and actors, including a strong delegation of World Sailing representatives.
Posted on 19 Jul
Watch Change in Crosshaven - UK Sailmakers under new command
'Our strength has always been service, quality and people. Right now, they are Graham, Claire and Barry.' The famous Crosshaven loft that is part of the UK Sailmakers organisation will shortly have a new crew on deck. Barry Hayes, Claire Morgan and Graham Curran are taking over from Des McWilliam who is stepping down after 39 years in the business and 25 years at the helm of McWilliam Sailmakers.
Posted on 3 Jul
A Few Rays – What to know about your skin?
Skin has evolved over the millions of years to keep water outside of the body out Skin has evolved over the millions of years to keep water outside of the body out, while keeping the moisture we have in our body in. That’s a good thing right? – So we don’t blow up every time we take a swim or go out in the rain. Likewise so we don’t dry up in the sun.
Posted on 25 Jun