Please select your home edition
Edition
Wildwind 2016 728x90

Smart Boating PR Sail V Power Comparison

by Deb Jeffreys on 28 Apr 2011
Hanse 32 smart boating group http://www.smartboating.com.au
Can't decide between a sail or power boat share?

Here are some great facts to help you make the decision.


Let's start with cost.

It's hard to believe but... when you compare equity boat share schemes in Australia... the purchase price of a share in a yacht is roughly half the price of an equivalent share in a similar length power boat.

For a yacht you pay around half the monthly maintenance fees, the yacht is more spacious and more comfortable and in many schemes you don't pay extra for fuel.

Or putting it another way...

For around the same price as a twelfth share in a 33ft motor cruiser which sleeps 3 on converted sofas... you can have a tenth share in a 44 foot yacht which sleeps 6 in total luxury.

That's over 10 feet of extra space and more days on the water for less money!

Or course the advantage of a power boat is speed; you can cruise along at 20 knots and reach your destination quickly.

But speed comes at a cost.

Sailing yachts and catamarans are designed to smoothly glide through the water. This means they use very little fuel even when the sails are not up.

Power boats on the other hand plough through the water and are much less fuel efficient.

The fuel for each day out in your power boat can easily cost you a few hundred dollars on top of your monthly maintenance fees - maybe more if carbon tax is introduced.

And depreciation?

Power boats depreciate much more than yachts. After the common three year term many of yacht syndicate owners are pleasantly surprised how much they get back.

Here's a common question...

Are Yachts or Power Boats Easier to Manage?

Despite what you might think, yachts are much easier to manoeuvre and handle in tight spaces than power boats. A motor boat has no keel and tends to skid across the water. Whereas the large rudder and deep keel on a yacht give you much more control.

This is great news when you're parking in the marina.

And if you don't know how to sail?

To be honest, if you have enough skills to manage a motor boat it would take very little to gain the extra knowledge you need to manage a yacht. A learn to sail yachts course would quickly get you up to speed and most boat share companies are happy to arrange private lessons for you.

And talking of sailing it's worth considering how relaxing sailing is.

Here's a fact most boaties realise after a while. Eventually the noise of your power boat's engine begins to annoy you.

Your day becomes about getting to your destination and relaxing once you get there.

On a sailing yacht or catamaran, as soon as the engine goes off and you're being blown along by the wind you can visibly see everyone chill out in front of you.

The journey to the secluded bay is as relaxing as the time you spend there. In fact it is often said Sailing is about the journey and Power Boating is about the destination.

And talking of relaxing...

Because yachts have a deep keel they are stable and more comfortable to sleep on. Catamarans are even better. Power boats tend to roll in the slightest swell - not great if you want a good night's sleep.

And of course if you want to cross oceans or head down the coast for a few days... your yacht is more than capable of taking you where you want to go.

For details of what’s launching this year in Australia's largest yacht share fleet go to www.boatshareaustralia.com

Smart Boating is home to Australia's largest catamaran and yacht share fleet.

SmartBoating, 1714 Pittwater Road, Bayview, NSW 2104. Phone 02 9997 5344



SmartBoating website

Protector - 660 x 82Wildwind 2016 660x82Barz Optics - Floaters

Related Articles

New Xperformance - Optimising the cruiser/racer range from X-Yachts
X-Yachts have built a wide range of 'Cruiser/Racers' as well as dedicated racing yachts which have won many Intl titles Since the company was founded back in 1979, X-Yachts have built a wide range of 'Cruiser/Racers' as well as dedicated racing yachts which have won many famous International titles, and of course One Design Class yachts such as X-79 and X-99
Posted on 14 Feb
World Sailing unites Kiteboarding governing bodies
World Sailing has today signed a landmark agreement with the IKA and the GKA to unite the kiteboarding community World Sailing has today signed a landmark agreement with the International Kiteboarding Association (IKA) and the Global Kitesports Association (GKA) to unite the kiteboarding community and provide clarity of kiteboarding's governance structure.
Posted on 13 Feb
On board interview with Lisa Blair - solo Antartica circumnavigation
So far, Lisa is tracking very well in her attempt to become the first woman to sail solo around Antartica. So far, Lisa is tracking very well in her attempt to become the first woman to sail solo around Antartica. After the setbacks of a delayed departure due to gremlins in the electronics, we are delighted to have these answers from her on board. She is well and enjoying her time. Climate Action Now, her Hick 50, left Albany in Western Australia on January 22, 2017.
Posted on 8 Feb
The price of legacy
Malcolm Page OAM, two-time Olympic Gold Medallist, became the Chief of Olympic Sailing for the USA on January 1 Malcolm Page OAM, two-time Olympic Gold Medallist (470) with Nathan Wilmot in 2008 and Mat Belcher in 2012, became the Chief of Olympic Sailing for the USA on January 1 this year. In and of itself it is hardly the freshest news, and well and truly yesterday’s fish wrapper. It was also a wise choice on behalf of Team USA, for he has succeeded in both the physical and commercial arms of our sport.
Posted on 5 Feb
Zhik becomes Official Clothing Partner to the Extreme Sailing Series
Extreme Sailing Series™ has established an exciting new partnership with the high-performance clothing brand, Zhik. As it enters the 2017 season, the Extreme Sailing Series™ has established an exciting new partnership with the high-performance clothing brand, Zhik.
Posted on 2 Feb
World Sailing headquarters to relocate to London
World Sailing's headquarters will relocate from Southampton to central London, UK in late summer 2017. World Sailing's headquarters will relocate from Southampton to central London, UK in late summer 2017. The selection of London as the new home for the International Federation comes after an extensive evaluation process of possible locations undertaken since the election of a new President and Board of Directors in November 2016.
Posted on 1 Feb
Henri Lloyd join forces with FAST40+ Class
Henri Lloyd is delighted to announce their three year partnership with the FAST40+ Class. Premium British marine and lifestyle clothing brand, Henri Lloyd is delighted to announce their three year partnership with the FAST40+ Class.
Posted on 1 Feb
Tawera takes the NZ Millennium Cup 2017
The Ron Holland designed and impeccably sailed, Tawera, again dominated a lengthier 27nm course on Day 3 of racing The Ron Holland designed and impeccably sailed, Tawera, again dominated a lengthier 27nm course on Day 3 of racing, taking line honours for a third consecutive day, bringing home the NZ Millennium Cup 2017. Coming into the final day of racing, Pacific Division competitors, Antaeus and Steinlager 2, were tied on points. Rumours of an extensive tactical defence strategy to retain the Pacific
Posted on 1 Feb
Rolex China Sea Race launches new official website
RHKYC today unveiled its new official website and logo for its flagship event, the biennial Rolex China Sea Race Royal Hong Kong Yacht Club today unveiled its new official website and logo for its flagship event, the biennial Rolex China Sea Race - Asia’s principal blue-water classic.
Posted on 28 Jan
Bavaria C57 - Something big has arrived
At the boot 2017 in Düsseldorf, Bavaria Yachts presented the new flagship of their sailing yachts' fleet. At the boot 2017 in Düsseldorf, Bavaria Yachts presented the new flagship of their sailing yachts' fleet. The Bavaria C57 does not only convince with a new modern design but also with many new innovative details.
Posted on 24 Jan