Please select your home edition
Edition
Sail World NZ Lone Wolf

Rio 2016 - Murdoch confirms that he won't Appeal tight selection call

by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com NZL on 12 May 2016
Andrew Murdoch pictured ahead of the 2016 Finn Europeans . ..
Double Olympian Andrew Murdoch has confirmed that he will not Appeal the decision of the Yachting New Zealand selectors who gave the nod for Rio 2016 to Josh Junior, who will be on his first Olympic regatta.

Back in November, Murdoch tied on points for the Bronze medal in the 2015 Finn Gold Cup, while Josh Junior placed 14th. The pair were one place apart in the 2014 event. However, Junior placed fourth in the 2016 Europeans in Barcelona, while Murdoch was 19th. Junior's run of form has continued throughout 2016, and his selection was not unexpected.

'I don't think I would get a result in my favour out of the back end of it,' Murdoch told Radio Sport. ït would also hinder Josh's preparation as well.'

'We are under 90 days to when Rio starts. I don't think an Appeal would do anyone any good.'

The Finn and Laser selections while both close are quite different from the Womens Singlehander and Windsurfer decisions where the call was not to send any competitors at all, despite New Zealand having made the cut in the first round of Olympic Qualification back in September 2014.


This is the second time that Murdoch has run a very close second in an Olympic selection. He missed out in 2004, taking the decision to Appeal. He then represented New Zealand in the 2008 and 2012 Olympics in the Men's Singlehander (Laser), finishing a very creditable fifth in each, before switching to the Finn this Olympic cycle, where he has been very successful.

In 2004, three crews appealed selection decisions of Yachting New Zealand to the newly established Sports Tribunal.

Murdoch appealed his nonselection in the Men's Singlehander (Laser), Jan Shearer and Melinda Henshaw appealed their non-selection in the Womens Doublehander (470), and 2002 World Champion in the Mens Doublehander, Simon Cooke and crew Alistair Gair appealed their non-selection in the Mens Doublehander (470).

The Sports Tribunal, containing two QC's, upheld Murdoch and Cooke/Gair's Appeals, overturning the decision of the Yachting New Zealand Olympic Selectors.

Yachting New Zealand then appealed the Sports Disputes Tribunal decisions to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, which found that the Sports Disputes Tribunal had 'trespassed into the forbidden field of reviewing the decisions of the Panel on the merits...'


In other words, the Sports Disputes Tribunal could not stand in the shoes of the selectors and review the merits or otherwise of the Olympic aspirants, but must confine itself as to whether the selection process had followed the prescribed selection criteria.

The Hearings came at a cost. Yachting New Zealand replaced its lawyers in the SDT Hearing, hiring one of NZ's top barristers, the late Richard Craddock QC, to argue its casein masterful fashion before a very distinguished CAS Panel. The costs that Yachting New Zealand claimed amounted to just over $62,000, including Senior Counsel's fee of $40,000. The Court awarded YNZ a total $10,000 costs against the two crews, the burden to be split equally.

However after several months Yachting New Zealand dropped this claim completely. At the Annual Meeting following the Hearings a remit moved by Andrew Murdoch's club was passed by the Meeting, saying that in future the parties should carry their own costs.

For its part, Yachting New Zealand changed the selection criteria for successive Olympiads to be more subjective than objective.

The two sailors who have indicated they will Appeal will be the first since 2004. However, the current appeals are about the non-selection of any competitor in the two Olympic-qualified classes rather than the selector's preference of one competitor over another, as was the case in 2004.


Sail World NZ Lone WolfInsun - AC ProgramSouthern Spars - 100

Related Articles

America's Cup - Russell Coutts takes charge at Manly Sailing Club
Sir Russell Coutts has gone from running the America's Cup to running a small yacht club on Auckland's Hibiscus Coast, 'He can be commodore as long as he wants the job,' Bennett said. 'We don't have set terms here. 'He's said he's done with the America's Cup so has time and he's also said he needs something else to get his teeth into. All of a sudden, he's like a big dog with a bone.'
Posted on 25 Jul
Twice Whitbread Round the World Race skipper Digby Taylor dies
Digby Taylor who master-minded, built and skippered two Whitbread Round the World Racers has died of a heart attack. Digby Taylor who master-minded, built and skippered two Whitbread Round the World Race campaigns, has died of a heart attack. He was in his early 70's. Taylor was the leading force behind two Whitbread Round the World race campaigns.
Posted on 20 Apr
Gold Medalists Burling and Tuke named NZ Team of the Year
Peter Burling and Blair Tuke have won the Team of the Year Award at the 54th Halberg Awards Peter Burling and Blair Tuke have won the Team of the Year Award at the 54th Halberg Awards, held at Vector Arena in Auckland last night. Named after Olympic champion Sir Murray Halberg (ONZ) the Halberg Awards is the country's pre-eminent event to honour and celebrate New Zealand sporting excellence.
Posted on 10 Feb
470 class - Double Olympic medalist announces retirement
Polly Powrie, half of one of the most successful teams in New Zealand sailing history, has retired from Olympic yachting Polly Powrie, half of one of the most successful teams in New Zealand sailing history, has retired from Olympic yachting. Powrie and Jo Aleh, colloquially known as Team Jolly, first teamed up in the women’s 470 in 2009 and established an impressive record in their time together, winning gold at the 2012 London Olympics and backing that up with silver at last year's Rio Games.
Posted on 6 Jan
Sydney supermaxi sets monohull record in White Island Race
The Sydney based supermaxi CQS has set a new record for monohulls in the 320nm White Island Race. The Sydney based supermaxi CQS has set a new record for monohulls, but missed the allcomers record by less than an hour, in the 320nm White Island Race. After the race start just after 10.00am on Friday, CQS reported she was about to round White Island around 6.30pm having taken 8hrs 30 minutes for the 160nm leg or an average speed of around 19kts.
Posted on 26 Nov 2016
Images of radical supermaxi CQS sailing on the Waitemata
Ludde Ingvall’s revamped supermaxi, CQS, was trialling on the Waitemata Harbour today Ludde Ingvall’s revamped supermaxi, CQS, was trialling on the Waitemata Harbour today in a moderate south westerly breeze and sunshine - a welcome break from the strong winds that have plagued Auckland for the past few days. The supermaxi which started life as the 90ft Nicorette has been stretched to 98ft in a design project led by Bakewell-White Yacht Design
Posted on 18 Nov 2016
Gladwell's Line - Oh, and by the way we won a million dollars
Sailing history has been made by a New Zealand crew in winning the richest prize ever offered in sailing July 11, 2016 - Sailing history has been made by the New Zealand crew of Phil Robertson, Stu Dodson, Will Tiller and James Wierzbowski in winning the richest prize ever offered in sailing - $US1million (NZD $1.37m), with their nail-biting win in the World Match Racing Championships in Sweden.
Posted on 14 Jul 2016
Rio 2016 - Yachting New Zealand defends Olympic selection practices
Yachting New Zealand has responded to wide-spread international criticism of its selection practices Yachting New Zealand has responded to wide-spread international criticism of its selection practices and criticism by the Chairman of the NZ Sports Disputes Tribunal, Sir Bruce Robertson of the way it treated two Olympic sailors after they had qualified New Zealand for the 2016 Olympic sailing regatta at the ISAF World Sailing Championships in santander in September 2014.
Posted on 9 Jun 2016
Gladwell's Line - Olympic Appeal over in NZ but hotting up in Oz
The 2016 New Zealand Olympic selection process came to an end on Monday night in Auckland The 2016 New Zealand Olympic selection process came to an end on Monday night in Auckland with the announcement at the end of a Mediation Hearing by the Chairman of the Sports Disputes Tribunal, Sir Bruce Robertson, that he would not overturn the two non-selection decisions by Yachting New Zealand.
Posted on 2 Jun 2016
Olympic board sailor lashes out as Spanish hope for Olympic windfall
2012 Olympian JP Tobin has hit out at Yachting New Zealand's selection policy for Rio 2012 Olympian JP Tobin has hit out at Yachting New Zealand's selection policy for Rio that has left the boardsailing classes vacant for August's Games, according to a story published on the stuff.co.nz website. The online news arm of Fairfax media has picked up comments from Tobin's Facebook page.
Posted on 12 May 2016