Please select your home edition
Edition
Southern Spars - North Technology

Protest chaos at Etchells World Qualifier

by Peter Campbell on 25 Oct 2008
Matt Whitnall’s dot (AUS1134)and Ed McCarthy & Michael Coxon’s North Sydney Station (AUS1273) racing in the Etchells Mini Regatta last Saturday. Photo: Kylie Wilson . .

The Royal Prince Edward Yacht Club protest committee abandoned the second race of last Saturday’s International Etchells Mini Regatta on Sydney Harbour, which was also heat five of the World Qualifying Series - 10 boats had been disqualified after being listed as breaching the Black Flag rule.

In a decision that changed the overall leadership of the Etchells Mini Regatta and also the progressive points for the Worlds Qualifying Series, the protest committee found that the Race Committee could not apply rule 30 after the movement of the starting boat by propulsion, and therefore the start should have been postponed.

The abandonment of heat two brought Fathom (Rupert Henry) and Fifteen (David Clark and Andrew Smith) back to the top of the leaderboard in the Mini Regatta and in progressive points for the Worlds Qualifying Series.

After five of the now scheduled 11 World Qualifying Series heats, an unofficial points score sees Fifteen leading on 13 points, with a gap to Bushfire (Jervis Tilly) on 21 points, followed by Dot (Matt Whitnall) on 27 points, North Sydney Station 29 (Ed McCarthy & Michael Coxon) on 31 points and Fathom on 35 points.

The Protest

The protest committee reached this decision after hearing requests for redress from the skippers of two boats, Bushfire and Fathom, which were among ten boats disqualified after being listed as breaching the BFD (Black Flag) rule.

Facts found included that the Race Officer, for the second starting procedure for the second race of the day, had displayed a black flag for the preparatory signal. Following the display of the preparatory signal for the recalled start, the Race Committee had used propulsion to reposition the starting boat for up to a minute and a half after the preparatory signal was displayed.

There was a second general recall in which 10 boats were identified as being on the course side of the starting line, including Bushfire and Fathom. The Race Officer told the hearing that there were other un-identified boats that were not disqualified under rule 30.3.

In its conclusions, the protest committee found that the Race Committee could not apply rule 30 after the movement of the starting boat by propulsion, and therefore the start should have been postponed.

‘The race could not be considered a fair race with almost half the fleet (of 27) disqualified and now entitled to redress and other boats not being identified as being on the course side of the starting line,’ the protest committee concluded in its report, citing the rules applicable as 27.2, 61.1(a).

The protest committee’s decision was that ‘Race two of the RPEYC Mini Scratch Series, heat 5 of the RSYS Mini Series and Heat 5 of the International Etchells World Qualifying Series be abandoned.’

The Racing

With 27 boats on the line in the freshening 10-15 knot easterly to north-easterly breeze and a fast ebbing tide, the starts were aggressive, to say the least. Royal Prince Edward Yacht Club’s race officer Tony Denham responded with the harshest of start line penalties - the black-flagging three boats in heat one and ten in heat two.

Competition was intense in all three heats as the Etchells battled with the big ebb tide coming out of Rose Bay, a breeze that backed from east to nor’east and freshened during the afternoon, and a huge number of other yachts racing on the Harbour. 'One bad gybe downwind and you could give away vital boat lengths – and a place or two,' commented one Etchells skipper.

Humpback (Stephen Barlow & Peter Gardner) took out the first heat while Fifteen (David Clark & Andrew Smith) won the next two, although the second heat has now been abandoned.

The abandonment of heat two brought Fathom and Fifteen back to the top of the leaderboard in the Mini Regatta and in progressive points for the Worlds Qualifying Series.

Schaefer 2016 Ratchet Block 660x82NaiadInSunSport - NZ

Related Articles

U.S. Junior Women’s Doublehanded Championship winners crowned
The third and final day of the 2012 US Junior Women’s Doublehanded Championship was dominated by light winds. The third and final day of the 2012 US Junior Women’s Doublehanded Championship was dominated by light winds. The race committee attempted to get an early jump on the day to no avail, as the weather refused to cooperate. Yesterday’s leaders Allyson Donahue and Maddie Widmeier were crowned 2012 champs after finishing second last year.
Posted on 30 Jun 2012
Melges 24 Volvo Cup victory for Little Wing
The fifth round of the Melges 24 Volvo Cup 2011 has come to a thrilling conclusion. The fifth round of the Melges 24 Volvo Cup 2011 has come to a thrilling conclusion. Two races were sailed today totaling eight altogether. Apart from the first day, where there was no wind whatsoever, the three following days had identical weather conditions with the first race running under light winds of five to seven m/sec, and the course leaning to the left.
Posted on 11 Jul 2011
Guyader Grand Prix day 1 lead to Wieser
The fleet of the 77 Dragons registered with the Guyader Grand Prix entered the Bay of Douarnenez late this morning. The fleet of the 77 Dragons registered with the Guyader Grand Prix entered the Bay of Douarnenez late this morning for the first day of the Grand Prix Dragon.
Posted on 4 May 2011
ISAF Sailing World Cup Overall Standings after three regattas
After three regattas in the ISAF Sailing World Cup series, the world’s best sailors lead the way in Overall Standings. After three regattas in the ISAF Sailing World Cup series the world’s best sailors are leading the way in the Overall Standings.
Posted on 12 Apr 2011
Melges 24 Worlds momentum builds ahead of May showdown
2011 Melges 24 World Championship will be hosted by Corpus Christi Yacht Club from 16-21 May. 2011 Melges 24 World Championship will be hosted by Corpus Christi Yacht Club from 16-21 May. With two events now completed - Key West in January and the Miami Winter Regatta at Coconut Grove - Italy's Riccardo Simoneschi sailing Audi is leading the series overall.
Posted on 9 Mar 2011
ICAP Leopard leads Rolex Middle Sea after night of attrition
Currently, ICAP Leopard is the breakaway leader sitting pretty in the Rolex Middle Sea Race After a fast passage across to Capo Passero and the southern tip of Sicily yesterday afternoon, so the Rolex Middle Sea Race launched first the sting from its tail as darkness closed last night. Whilst the leaders closed fast on the Strait of Messina, the smaller slower yachts experienced a night of squalls and rain as the front pushed through earlier than expected.
Posted on 18 Oct 2009
Sydney maxi yacht tragedy - Saturday afternoon update from CYCA
This afternoon, Matt Allen, the Commodore of the CYCA held a press conference at the Club in Darling Point This afternoon, Matt Allen, the Commodore of the CYCA held a press conference at the Club in Darling Point, announcing that the owner/skipper of PriceWaterhouseCoopers, Andrew Short and crew member Sally Gordon had perished when the 24.4 metre yacht hit rocks and ran aground at Flinders Islet at approximately 0255 hours this morning.
Posted on 11 Oct 2009
2009 Star World Championship - PRO Under pressure
2009 Star World Championship - PRO under pressure 2009 Star World Championship. H.P. Hylander, the PRO and Regatta Chairman, stood on the Race Committee boat with a Bluetooth phone in his ear, a radio in his hand, binoculars and a hockey puck draped around his neck. He had lots of helpers aboard the RC boat and wind scouts two miles to the south and to the west; the logical directions from which the wind would fill.
Posted on 8 Aug 2009
Elliott 6m debuts on the world stage at Kiel Week
New Olympic boat the Elliott 6m will finally make its debut at Kieler Woche in Germany in June The new Olympic boat the Elliott 6m will finally make its debut on the world stage in a couple of weeks during event six of the ISAF Sailing World Cup at Kieler Woche in Germany, which runs from 20 to 28 June. Twenty-four crews from nine different countries are expected to be fighting for the Kieler Woche trophies
Posted on 3 Jun 2009
Day 1 of the RC 44 Austria Cup fleet regatta
Crazy conditions on day one of the RC 44 Austria Cup fleet regatta The Slovenian team Ceeref, with Igor Lah at the helm and Paul Cayard at the tactics, makes the best of the massive shifts, strong gusts and rain and hailstones showers on day one of the fleet race event of the RC 44 Austria Cup
Posted on 30 May 2009