Please select your home edition
Edition
Southern Spars

Laser Lawsuit - Challenge to Laser trademark ownership

by Marine Business-World on 8 May 2013
Rolex Miami OCR 2010 © Rolex / Dan Nerney
Another new development in the widening legal dispute between Bruce Kirby, the designer of the world´s best known sailing boat, the Laser dinghy and one of the Laser builders LaserPerformance (LPE) the builder and supplier of Lasers into UK, Europe and North America, because of non-payment of design royalties.

In March 2013, Bruce Kirby, Inc. filed a complaint in the U.S. Federal Court District of Connecticut, alleging unlawful counterfeiting of the Kirby dinghy by LaserPerformance principal Farzad Rastegar acting with and through LaserPerformance and its associated entities. The case also named the International Sailing Federation (ISAF) and the International Laser Class Association (ILCA) alleging they assisted LaserPerformance by continuing to supply ISAF plaques to the builder, after Kirby had given them formal notice to stop.

ISAF and ILCA defended their position, explaining that they have been acting to protect European and US supply of the boats, as LPE, the notional owner of the Laser trademark in Europe and the USA, had threatened legal action if another company began selling Laser branded boats in those markets. The situation has become very messy with Performance Sailcraft Australia saying that ISAF and ILCA´s decision to provide new plaques removing Bruce Kirby from the plaques left them unable to supply Lasers across Australia, New Zealand and the South Pacific.

This subject is certain to be a hot topic at this weekend’s ISAF mid-year conference in Copenhagen.

Ahead of this meeting, there has been movement on the Laser trademark front, with a posting today on the Kirby operated website www.kirbytorch.com revealing details of a petition to the United States Patent and Trademark office challenging the Laser trademark ownership.

The Connecticut Intellectual Property Rights law firm St. Onge, Steward, Johnston and Reens acting for Bruce Kirby Inc is claiming that the notional owner of the Laser trademark in the USA, a Swiss owned company Velum Ltd. allegedly controlled by Farzad Rastegar, the owner of LaserPerformance has committed fraud in its recent applications for US trademark renewal.

To hold a United States trademark, the owner is required to show proof of active use of the trademark and the grounds for the petition for cancellation is that publically available renewal applications by Velum states that it organizes Laser sailing events, providing Laser event NOR´s as proof.

Serious doubt is being cast on that statement, with Kirby´s attorney Wes Whitmyer, a former North American Optimist Class President and active Melges 20 owner saying today he can find no one in the North American sailing community who has ever heard of Velum organising any sailing events anywhere in the world.

This legal challenge no doubt explains why Kirby had recently filed for US ownership of the Laser trademark, a move which had puzzled close observers of the unfolding drama.

(the full copies of this material has been published on the Improper Course blog
http://www.impropercourse.com/2013/04/laser-trademark-for-running-regattas.html?showComment=1367974742538#c6522235950632464300

Below is the copy of the Petition to cancel the Laser trademark ownership in the U.S.


IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
IN THE MATTER OF U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524

LASER

Bruce Kirby, Inc., :
:
Petitioner, :
: Cancellation No.
v. : [not yet assigned]
:
Velum Limited, :
:
Registrant. :

PETITION TO CANCEL

Bruce Kirby, Inc. ('Petitioner') hereby petitions to cancel U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 for the mark LASER on the following grounds:

1. Bruce Kirby, Inc. is a Connecticut corporation having a place of business at 213 Rowayton Avenue, Rowayton, CT 06853.

2. According to the records of the USPTO, the current owner of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 is Velum Limited, a corporation organized under the laws of Antigua and Barbuda, with an address P.O. Box 1699 17, rue du Cendrier Geneva 1 SWITZERLAND 1211.

USPTO records do not disclose an assignment of the registration. USPTO records indicate that the domestic representative for the service of process is Ilan Nordmann, with an address c/o Dory Ventures, 25 Van Zant Street, Norwalk, CT 06855.

3. Petitioner is actively engaged in the field of sailing and the design, manufacture, production, and licensing of boat designs for use in international sailing competitions including the Olympics, and has an interest in maintaining the integrity of those competitions, including without limitation, the trademarks used in connection with those competitions.

4. On information and belief, Registrant has ceased use of the trademark LASER in connection with the services recited in U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 and intends not to resume such use.

5. On information and belief, Registrant has allowed numerous third parties to use the trademark LASER in connection with the services identified in U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 without authorization or license for a period of greater than three (3) years.

6. Records of the USPTO indicate that the Statement of Use that Registrant filed in order to obtain issuance of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 consisted of specimens used by a third party without authorization or license of Registrant.

7. Registrant knew at the time that it filed the Statement of Use in the prosecution of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 that the specimens of use were not being used by Registrant or by an authorized user or licensee. Registrant submitted the unauthorized and unlicensed trademark specimens of use in the prosecution of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 for the purpose of obtaining issuance of a trademark registration to which it was not entitled under the Lanham Act and USPTO regulations.

The USPTO would not have issued U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524 absent the submissions of the unauthorized and unlicensed specimens of use submitted with Registrant’s Statement of Use.

8. As a result of its non-use of the LASER trademark in connection with the services identified in U.S. Trademark Registration 3459524 with an intention not to resume use, Registrant has abandoned the trademark LASER with respect to those services within the meaning of 15 U.S.C. § 1127.

9. As a result of its allowing third parties to use the LASER trademark in connection with the services identified in U.S Trademark Registration No. 3459524, Registrant has abandoned the trademark LASER with respect to those services within the meaning of 15 U.S.C. § 1127.

10. As a result of its knowing submission of a third party use of its trademark as purposed use in support of registration, Registration committed fraud in the prosecution of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524.

WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays that the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board grant its petition and cancel U.S. Trademark Registration No. 3459524.
Respectfully submitted,
May 7, 2013 /s/ Wesley W. Whitmyer, Jr.
Date Wesley W. Whitmyer, Jr.
Andy I. Corea
Brian L. Repper
ST.ONGE STEWARD JOHNSTON & REENS,LLC
Barz Optics - Kids rangeNaiad/Oracle SupplierT Clewring - Generic

Related Articles

Laser Lawsuit - Kirby´s dramatic move
Kirby Inc. increases pressure on LP, ISAF and the ILCA when they asked Court to issue a prejudgment remedy against LP. Kirby Inc. yesterday dramatically increased the pressure on LP, ISAF and the ILCA when they asked the US Federal Court in Connecticut to issue a prejudgment remedy against LP. If this was to be granted as requested LP and its associates would be unable to build Lasers or have anyone else build them for them, while the Courts then could take their time hearing the case.
Posted on 18 May 2013
Kirby files to cancel Laser Trademark and Sunburst Logo for Boats
Bruce Kirby Inc. today filed the below petition to cancel US trademark registrations Bruce Kirby Inc. today filed the below petition to cancel US trademark registrations directed to both the word LASER and the Sunburst logo for boats. According to US Trademark Office records, these US registrations are owned by Karaya (Jersey) Limited based in St. Helier, Jersey, Channel Islands.
Posted on 11 May 2013
US Laser trademarks up for grabs?
The following opinion piece has been provided by Improper Course: The following opinion piece has been provided by Improper Course, a blog which is a collection of the sailing education and adventures of two sailors on opposite ends of the experience and success spectrum. It ranges from the Laser Master Worlds to the local Laser sailing as well as a couple of other dinghies and the occasional keelboat.
Posted on 8 May 2013
ISAF and ILCA on thin ice? Intellectual Property Rights and Copyright
Commentary on lawsuit between Laser designer Bruce Kirby, builder Laser Performance and its associates and ISAF and ILCA Extracts from an article written for Scuttlebutt USA by IPR lawyer John Harwood-Bee on the lawsuit between Laser designer Bruce Kirby, builder LPE and associated companies and ISAF and ILCA.
Posted on 6 May 2013
ISAF Laser intervention - Supply problems looming?
The long running dispute now it appears that its likely to threaten supplies of Lasers. The long running dispute between the designer of the Laser dinghy Bruce Kirby and one of the Laser builders LaserPerformance, the builder and supplier of Lasers into UK, Europe and North America, because of non-payment of design royalties is now much wider than ever before and now it appears that its likely to threaten supplies of Lasers.
Posted on 1 May 2013
Laser ISAF ILCA action brings expanded Bruce Kirby law suit
Bruce Kirby Inc. today filed a First Amended Complaint adding claims related to the ILCA Rule Change, the ISAF Reversal In a widely anticipated move Bruce Kirby Inc. today filed a First Amended Complaint adding claims related to the ILCA Rule Change, the ISAF Reversal on the Fundamental Rule change, the apparent new ISAF Plaques and other matters, and adding as a party the owner of the Laser trademarks in Europe: Velum Limited ITM SA (Antigua and Barbuda).
Posted on 30 Apr 2013
It's the boat that matters, not the name
We have had calls and e-mails from around the world asking if there is anything that can be done to save the Laser. In an attempt to rescue the Laser Class from its downhill course of the past few years I have reluctantly decided that a name change, or re-branding is necessary. During the past three or four years dealers have had difficulty getting timely delivery of boats, and in particular, of parts.
Posted on 24 Apr 2013
Laser Legal tangles continue
Major developments with ISAF changing tack, now in conjunction with ILCA moving boldly to remove Kirby´s design rights. Previously ISAF had recognised that LPE were no longer licensed Laser builders and had stopped the issuance of plaques by ILCA. Major developments in the last few days with ISAF changing tack and now in conjunction with ILCA moving boldly to remove Bruce Kirby´s design rights
Posted on 24 Apr 2013
Statement from the International Laser Class Association
Newly designed ISAF plaques available to all the current ISAF and ILCA approved manufacturers of the Laser dinghy in acc ISAF and ILCA have taken steps to assure the uninterrupted supply of class legal Laser brand sailboats around the world. This includes making newly designed ISAF plaques available to all the current ISAF and ILCA approved manufacturers of the Laser dinghy in accordance with the ILCA class rules.
Posted on 24 Apr 2013
ISAF Statement On International Laser Class
ISAF has been named a co-defendant in the legal proceedings filed in the US District Court. ISAF Statement - On 22 March the International Sailing Federation (ISAF) published a statement concerning the Laser Class dispute and proceedings filed by attorneys acting for Bruce Kirby. The legal situation is on-going but ISAF can confirm that: ISAF has been named a co-defendant in the legal proceedings filed in the US District Court.
Posted on 24 Apr 2013