sail-world.com
 
 
News Home Cruising Photo Gallery Video Gallery
Sail-World.com : Gladwell's Line: Is a Trojan Horse being used in the America's Cup?
Gladwell's Line: Is a Trojan Horse being used in the America's Cup?


'Oracle Team USA sailing off San Francisco. The winglets on the rudder are clearly visible. The windward daggerboard is lowered in preparation for a gybe.'    Guilain Grenier/Oracle Racing©    Click Here to view large photo

Following the conclusion of a four day Mediation by two members of the International Jury for the 34th America's Cup, it was confirmed by various sources, that while the main sticking point for the teams is the adoption of rules regarding Rudder Elevators, there are still serious issues remaining.

'There is a lot of water to go under the bridge', one high-placed source told Sail-World.

The comment comes in contrast to the bland media release issued at the conclusion of the Mediation session, which did not identify the outstanding issues.

Quite what happens from here is yet to be revealed.

It is expected that regatta organizers working under the auspices of the America's Cup Trustee and Defender, Golden Gate Yacht Club will try to get sign-off from the US Coast Guard for the Recommendations which originally came from the Review Committee, appointed to investigate all aspects of the America's Cup Regatta after the fatal capsize of Artemis Racing's AC72.

After those Recommendations were initially published, on May 24, Golden Gate Yacht Club Vice Commodore, Tom Ehman, was adamant that they would be pushed through using the safety provisions of the Protocol, and specifically Article 16 which states that 'Competitors shall comply with all applicable laws and regulations of any city, state, national or other governmental authority having jurisdiction over the Event or part thereof.'

Given that as yet there is no agreement from the teams on all the Recommendations, it appears that the event organizers may be using the US Coast Guard as a Trojan Horse to get new rules imposed on the regatta as part of the Permit to be issued by the USCG.

Clearly if the Teams don't accept the USCG imposed conditions, then there can be no event.

Emirates Team NZ sailing in Auckland with two rudders immersed (both providing some degree of level flight) and flying on a single foil -  Richard Gladwell_©   Click Here to view large photo


While there seems to be little disagreement on the changes introduced under the guise of Safety, the changes to the AC72 Class Rule for Rudder Elevators are a completely different category, and it would be argued that the USCG had no basis for making the rule change as two of the three teams currently sailing in San Francisco are not using the devices, and have been sailing for almost 12 months without them.

Normally if an organiser did not comply with the Protocol a team's first recourse would be to the full International Jury, but it is not clear whether the International Jury has any jurisdiction to direct the US Coast Guard, as the government agency is not a party to the Protocol.

That situation has created speculation that the aggrieved Challengers might have recourse to the New York Supreme Court, to obtain the equivalent of an injunction under English law, until the Rudder Elevator issue has been resolved by the International Jury.

Larry Ellison visits Team / SFO March Testing Session / Oracle Team USA -  Guilain Grenier-Oracle Racing©   Click Here to view large photo

Turning to the vexed issue of Rudder Elevators - which first emerged as one of the 37 Review Committee Recommendations, following the fatal Artemis Racing capsize/breakup on May 9, 2013.

The AC72 class rule 8.6 is clear: Rudders shall not have components such as trim tabs or moveable winglets, that can be adjusted while racing.

In other words you can have winglets, but they cannot be adjusted while racing.

The Measurement Committee received a request for a Measurement Interpretation , in mid-2012 which seemed to query as to whether the whole winglet could rotate (presumably during a race).

(Interpretations are issued by the Measurement Committee in response to a question from one of the teams, and are a way of avoiding lengthy protest hearings during the regatta, when one or more boats turns up with a design 'innovation' which is immediately protested and ruled in or out by the International Jury.)

In an Interpretation issued on August 12, 2012, the Measurement Committee said that: Adjusting the angle of one surface of an appendage relative to another surface of that appendage constitutes a change to the shape of the appendage surfaces, and invalidates the yacht's measurement certificate in accordance with AC72 Class Rule 27.2 (c)

US Coast Guard visits Emirates Team NZ, earlier this weelk - Russell Green - Rules Advisor Capt. Greg Stump - Sector Commander San Francisco, USCG Nick Halroyd - Technical Director -  Ellen Hoke   Click Here to view large photo


In other words if the winglet moved then that yacht was out of class, until she was re-measured with the winglet in the new position.

Regatta Director, Iain Murray effectively reversed that Interpretation with Recommendation 1.3e from the Chairman of the Review Committee allowed Rudder Elevators to be 'permitted to be adjusted until warning signal', or five minutes before the start of a race.

The AC72 Class Rules are even more specific with Rule 8.6 saying 'Rudders shall not have components such as trim tabs or moveable winglets that can be adjusted while racing'

Taking this rule a stage further a team using such devices would normally have to be able to demonstrate that the winglets could not be adjusted while racing. Scout's Honor isn't good enough. The only winglets which are legal are those which cannot be adjusted adjusted while racing.

In this discussion we have used the term 'racing' in the sense it is used in the the Racing Rules of Sailing - America's Cup version. There is no definition in the class rule of the term 'racing'. Further in 27.2a of the class rule lists several items which may be adjusted when not racing which will not invalidate an AC72's measurement certificate.

The inference being that anything which is adjusted, even when the yacht is not racing, will make the AC72's measurement certificate invalid.

The bottom line is that the adjustable rudder winglets used by any AC72 are probably illegal, certainly for racing, and she cannot have a valid measurement certificate while they are in their current state - unless they are completely non-adjustable and fixed in angle at the time of measurement.

Caught on camera
Oracle Team USA was photographed with such a device in mid-March. Again that is not illegal but it must not be adjusted while racing ie two minutes before the starting signal for a race. They are of course allowed to sail out of class, outside an America’s Cup Regatta race, and while training or in development.

The Measurement Committee Interpretation effectively said that it couldn’t be adjusted at all, after the boat had been measured – which is only done while the boat is hauled out, and put into a measurement condition ashore.

That Interpretation was not immediately challenged by the teams in public, and indeed if such a challenge were made, the decision was not overturned.

Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa would be expected to argue that it is not Neutral Management for a team to see an Interpretation, fit a device that could be used in a way contrary to that Interpretation, and then for that team’s club to effectively push through a rule change on the basis of safety, after a fatal accident in winds of just 11-17kts.

The other issues with having an adjustable rudder elevator, means that unless it is sealed after measurement in some way, there is no real way of checking whether a crew has adjusted the elevator angle during a race.

US Coast Guard visits Luna Rossa US Coast Guard visits Emirates Team NZ, earlier this weelk - Francesco Cattani - External Relations Director Luis Saenz - General Counsel Capt. Greg Stump - Sector Commander San Francisco, USCG Max Sirena - Skipper -  Ellen Hoke   Click Here to view large photo


The advantage to a boat using an adjustable rudder elevator (by moving the rudder stock) is that it gives her two means of controlling her foiling – through the adjustable daggerboard case, which only Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa initially fitted, and with a second adjustment on her rudder elevator.

As the situation stands, the two sailing Challengers have little scope to fit Rudder Elevators, as they are due to start racing in 10 days, while the Defender still has two months to continue and refine development.

Further the Challengers are entitled to rely on the Class Rules as they are published, and in particular any Interpretations that explain the Measurement Committee’s view.

If the Class Rules are to be changed they can only be done by the agreement of all Teams, and not unilaterally by a single party.

It would be difficult to argue that the rudder elevators are a safety device, as two of the Challengers at least have been sailing for up to a year without them and in winds of well over 30 knots.

However the ongoing saga could rebound on teams who fit and use the devices. Those with even modest America’s Cup memories will recall the shenanigans that occurred in 1992 over the bowsprit used by then Team New Zealand in the Louis Vuitton Cup. With regular protests the team was not clear on its use, and at one stage had a race result reversed.

The issue with the rudder elevators, that unless properly processed through the Class Rules in the manner prescribed by the Protocol, then the rules battle will continue, and may well rebound in the same way as happened over 20 years ago, in San Diego.


by Richard Gladwell

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.sail-world.com/index.cfm?nid=111207

11:39 AM Mon 24 Jun 2013GMT


Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 America's Cup

Related News Stories:

04 Jul 2013  Americas Cup: High Noon at the America's Cup Corral
03 Jul 2013  America´s Cup 2013 Team New Zealand prepares for Louis Vuitton
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Oracle and Emirates hit their straps - AmCam Video
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Louis Vuitton's Images of the Day - July 2, 2013
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Wet 'n Wild on San Francisco Bay - AmCam Video
03 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Luna Rossa takes tough line against Race Director
03 Jul 2013  Americas Cup: Italian skipper fires broadside on Luna Rossa base tour
02 Jul 2013  America's Cup: NZ Rigging drops the Big Boat's mast into cafe alley
01 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Ted Hood dies at 86
01 Jul 2013  America's Cup: Review Committee member - will commonsense prevail?
MORE STORIES ...






News - USA and the World

Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014 - Images of new arrivals by Rolex/Carlo Borlenghi. ... [more]  

Shannon Wells, Managing Director, Airlines of Tasmania Pty Ltd advises .'At around 6:15 pm, we received notification from the Australian Maritime Safety Authority that a light aircraft had been ditched in to the water near Port Arthur.' ... [more]  

After arriving in St. Maarten on March 2nd the sailing team will start with a two full days of safety and sail training aboard the Volvo 60 in preparation for the Gill Commodore’s Cup. The first day of racing is separate from the Heineken regatta results, allowing sailors to practice and perfect their racing without influencing the main event results. ... [more]  

Constitution Dock, Hobart is buzzing with activity after a stream of boats crossed the finish line throughout Day four of the 2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race. By 17:00 AEDT, 39 yachts had completed the 628-nm race, as the docks filled with tales from another dramatic contest. Of the 117 starters, 65 yachts are still sailing and a further 13 officially retired. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart: Hats Off Tasmania For The Huge Crowds *Feature by Crosbie Lorimer, Hobart, Tasmania
Ken Read, skipper of Jim Clark's super maxi Comanche, has been amazed at the level of interest shown by Australians in sailing and particularly in this race. When he first arrived in Sydney with Comanche, Read was clearly very envious of the crowds that turn up for this race every year ... [more]  

Wild Oats XI crossed the finish line 49 minutes ahead of Comanche in the most anticipated battle of the supermaxis. Crosbie Lorimer spoke to some of the crew from both boats to get their take on the race and the duel between the two front runners. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - It was the space of just six nautical miles that made the difference when it came to Bob Oatley’s supermaxi, Wild Oats XI, claiming a historic eighth line honours in the 628 nautical mile Rolex Sydney Hobart race. ... [more]  

Three very long-standing Australian members of the OK Dinghy class were inducted into the OKDIA Hall of Fame during the opening ceremony of the 2014 World Championship at Black Rock Yacht Club, Melbourne, Australia, on Sunday 28 December. Bill Bell, Roger Blasse and Andre Blasse were all presented with engraved crystal mementoes to mark the occasion. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Have a look at the IRC standings, the list of boats leading the Rolex Sydney Hobart overall on handicap; it’s a long time since such venerable names have graced the top of the list en masse as they do today. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Ever wondered about the cost of breaking and damaging gear – and the repercussions of it in a long race such as the Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race? Well wonder no longer. Three boat owners confidentially whispered this morning 'Don’t tell the wife, but….' ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - the boats dock in Hobart so do the stories. Everyone has a tale to tell, some funny, some of outright terror, some apocryphal to tell about the Rolex Sydney Hobart. This morning Daryl Hodgkinson jumped off his Cookson 50 Victoire with a yarn about crabs, pots and British pluck under fire. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart: Tough Stuff Down the Tassie Coast *Feature by Crosbie Lorimer, Hobart, Tasmania
By nine a.m. this morning (Monday) ten boats were finished, amongst them several of the 50 footers arriving in a group just before 8am. The consistent theme amongst all those we interviewed was the strength of wind late yesterday on the run down the Tasmanian coast. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Comanche was finally defeated by Wild Oats in Hobart. But the new record breaker has shown great potential in the medium and strong wind. It still remains to work on its performance in the low wind. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - It is going to be a busy day in Hobart, with more than two thirds of the Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race fleet expected to arrive into Hobart today. ... [more]  

The overnight and morning finishes have been marked by some very close racing in the Rolex Sydney Hobart race. The battle for third place was won by Ragamuffin (Syd Fischer), after the canting keel supermaxi dropped back significantly yesterday afternoon, and then powered through in the fresh northerly ... [more]  

Before the start of the Rolex Sydney Hobart Race, Ken Read, skipper of the US supermaxi Comanche gave this tour above and below decks of Jim and Kristy Clark's new 100ft flyer. ... [more]  

Sail-World is now running live in the changed website format. If you are running on a Mac with iOS please scroll to the bottom of the site and check that your region is set for your region and not some other. It can be correctly set up using the drop down boxes. Then go to the top, click refresh, and you should be away. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart: Wild Oats XI and Comanche Finish Images *Feature by Crosbie Lorimer, Hobart, Tasmania
The Comanche and Wild Oats XI teams were equally gracious in victory and defeat on the dockside in Hobart today. It had been a close fought battle and while Comanche had reeled Wild Oats XI back in overnight to within 9nm , there simply wasn't enough air to power up the American boat in the run across Storm Bay and up the Derwent River. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014: In what skipper Mark Richards described as the crew’s most hard-fought line honours triumph, Wild Oats XI held off the impressive challenge posed by Comanche, the newly-launched entry from the United States. Completing the race in 2 days, 2 hours, 3 minutes and 26 seconds, Wild Oats XI finished eight hours shy of the race record she set in 2012. ... [more]  

After being dismasted a short time ago in the Rolex Sydney Hobart, Giacomo is motoring to the lee of Maria Island. In other race news, a very disappointed Bill Wild has retired his Reichel/Pugh 55, Wedgetail, from the race after suffering mast damage in the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia’s 628 nautical mile race at approximately 7.40pm off Schouten Island. All are safe and well on board. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014: Spithill was one of six helmsmen on Comanche. 'We can’t leave it at that,' he declared after finishing in Hobart. He says that on his watch this morning the boat reached a top speed of 32 knots and knows what she is capable of. 'Everybody got to see the true potential of this boat at the start. ... [more]  

Top international yachting photographer, Carlo Borlenghi was in the air above the Rolex Sydney Hobart Race fleet and provided these images of the third day of racing in the classic ocean race, as the leaders closed in on the finish, and the dock celebrations by Wild Oats XI. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - 'This is the sweetest victory by far,' Wild Oats XI skipper Mark Richards declared today after steering the silver-grey thoroughbred to a record eighth line honours victory in the Rolex Sydney Hobart. 'To rewrite a bit of sailing history doesn’t come along every day. To win a Hobart is a great honour but to win an eighth; I can’t believe I am here,' Richards said. ... [more]  

Photographer Andrea Francolini was on the water at 2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race line honours finish and provided this gallery of images. ... [more]  

Wild Oats XI entered the Derwent River some forty minutes ahead of Comanche at the Iron Pot and gybed her way up river in 5-10 knot southeaster, bright sunshine and crystal clear light to take a record breaking eighth line honours win in this race at 3.03pm The size of spectator fleet that accompanied Wild Oats XI and the crowds on the dock were much the largest ever sen for this race. ... [more]  

The Volvo 70 Giacomo lost her rig in the vicinity of Maria Island about 5.30pm local time yesterday evening. A second yacht Wedgetail (an RP55) lost the top off her mast in the same area at the same time. Giacomo is a Volvo 70 owned and skippered by Jim Delegat (NZL) and has a full New Zealand crew aboard ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart Wild Oats XI takes number eight by Rob Kothe and the Sail-World Team
Wild Oats XI finished at 303pm, with her big A2 flying. Her elapsed time was two days two hours three minutes and twenty six seconds 02:02:03:26 That was some eight hours outside the race record she set in 2012 of 1 day, 18 hours, 23 minutes and 12 seconds. ... [more]  

At the 2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race photographer Daniel Forster was on the water and provided this gallery of images from Day 2. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart: Wild Oats XI scores comfortable 8th win by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com/nz
Wild Oats XI (Oatley family) has crossed the finish line for the Rolex Sydney Hobart race to take her eighth win in the offshore classic. She crossed the finish line in the Derwent River sailing on port tack with a big asymmetrical headsail flying, and accompanied by a bevy of spectator craft as she crossed the finish line at 3.00pm local time. ... [more]  

In Alamitos Bay Yacht Club's annual Boxing Day race the hometown Gibbs brothers, Riley, 18, and Sawyer, 16, started last in their 49er skiff but passed all of the other boats of various types to finish first in brilliant sun but cool light air Sunday. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Wild Oats XI is still leading the 2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart, some 38-nm from Hobart, and hoping to close in on a record eighth line honours win. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - The crew on the American super maxi Comanche have not thrown in the towel. They do not believe the race for line honours in the Rolex Sydney Hobart is over despite Wild Oats XI’s commanding lead. ... [more]  

2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Bob Oatley’s 10 year-old super maxi Wild Oats XI is racing towards an historic eighth line honours victory in the Rolex Sydney Hobart this morning. ... [more]  

Rolex Sydney Hobart: Wild Oats rounds Tasman Island
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Back markers in for a pummeling as front hits
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Sunday afternoon finish expected for Wild Oats XI
Sydney to Hobart - Another 40 foot white-wash?
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Your Turn, Then My Turn, Then Your Turn! *Feature
Sydney-Hobart: First, Second and Third! *Feature
Rolex Sydney Hobart 2014; Handicap Honours Predictions VIDEO *Feature
Sydney Hobart 2014: A ridge too far for Comanche
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Images by Daniel Forster
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Honing in on halfway
Sydney Hobart Race: 'The Old Girl' proves she's still got great legs
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Drama among the supermaxis
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race images by Howard Wright
2014 -15 Barcelona World Race - Food, food, some not so glorious!!
2015 Fireball World Championship - Notice of Race released
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Supermaxi Race Start VIDEO *Feature
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Perpetual Loyal forced to retire with hull damage *Feature
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart: Clouds backs the small boats for overall win
Rolex Sydney to Hobart: Replay video coverage on Sail-World *Feature
Sydney Hobart - Comanche leads but Oats XI keeps the rubber band on
Will Comanche take a scalp?   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014- Southerly takes its toll   
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Comanche leads in softening morning breeze *Feature   
Rolex Sydney Hobart - Comanche take a gun to the knife fight + Video   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014 - Supermaxi contest + Video   
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Images from the flying start on Sydney harbour   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014: Start photos by Andrea Francolini   
Sydney Hobart 2014 The Cutting edge Formula 1 yacht still leads   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014 – Grand dame heads back to Sydney   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Day 1 start images by Carlo Borlenghi   
Rolex Sydney Hobart: Race Start Images by Crosbie Lorimer *Feature   
Clipper Ventures 10 starts Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Another year another record   
Rolex Sydney Hobart 2014 – Comanche on the warpath   
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart - Spithill to grind on Comanche   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race – Spinnaker start forecast   
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Wild Oats XI ready to go   
Adventures of a Sailor Girl: Hobart coverage - December 26 - Live   
Rolex Sydney Hobart - The Peyron Perspective -Old People On New Boats *Feature   
2014 Rolex Sydney Hobart - Spithill to grind on Comanche   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL NEW US
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT