Please select your home edition
Edition
Wildwind 2016 728x90

Editorial- America's Cup date and ISAF Credibility

by nzeditor@sail-world.com on 12 May 2008
In around 100 days the funding grants for Tornado sailors will stop. Is a new professional Multihull circuit the replacement answer? © Richard Gladwell www.photosport.co.nz

From the Monday edition of Sail-World.Com/NZ's newsletter

The ISAF Mid year Meeting has concluded in Qingdao, with a lot of fences to be repaired.

As reported in this issue the ISAF Council choose not to revisit the Mens' Events for the 2012 Olympics, and as matters stand there will be no Multihull Event in the 2012 Olympics in Weymouth.

The decision was not made by a majority, but by a minority using ISAF Regulations to prevent further debate and shut the issue down.

The first vote to reaffirm the decision on the Events was carried by a majority of three. One would have thought that those in the minority might have given way to allow the required two thirds majority to be reached and for the necessary debate to take place. However with many on instruction from their national authorities, this did not take place.

The ordering of the voting to take place in secret prevented the disclosure of whether Councilors had followed these strictures, or if they had fallen prey to the lobbyists.

At the core of the matter was whether ISAF was better able to maintain its credibility by refusing to revisit a decision that had been legitimately made, even if it was not the best one that could have been. Or, if it was better for ISAF to put its hand up, admit that a wrong had been done in November, and fix it.

In the end the whole process was doomed before it started. Attaining a 66% majority was always going to be a high bar for ISAF. Getting over the first mark of a simple majority was quite achievable.

That put ISAF in a no-win situation. By being seen to be run by a minority, the body rather than preserving credibility, lost it big time. By not allowing the athletes to address the Council, the credibility fallout was compounded.

Getting out of this mess, will be a big challenge for the ISAF leadership. Now the organisation appears to it membership (the sailors) to be inflexible, long on process and without a real strategy in terms of Olympic Events.

To date the approach of ISAF has been to embrace new disciplines within the sport, and make a place for them at the Olympic table. We have seen this done with the new sports of windsurfing, skiff sailing and with multihulls. The decision on 2012 Events is the first time that ISAF has practised the exclusion of a discipline over a class. And many in the sport, are very uncomfortable with that development.


Quite where this leaves the Multihull sailors is very unclear. There are a large number of professional teams operating within catamaran sailing - but a significant component of their income/defraying of costs comes from national sports funders. As of August 2008 - 100 days time - those lines will be cut.

Normally when a class is dropped, as was the case with the Soling and Flying Dutchman, sailors gravitate to the next nearest boat and rebuild for the next Games. However for the Tornado sailors there is no similar boat - 49er maybe - but the indications from the top crews are that this is not an option.

In this issue we feature the reaction of the multihull sailors who were at the Council Meeting, who make a number of good points.

The following day, ISAF created a Multihull Council, the intentions for this body are unclear. Maybe it will give the the multihulls a better voice within ISAF. Maybe it will head off a breakout movement from the multihulls. That ball is now very much in ISAF's court - and they must answer the fundamental question 'what's in it for the multihull?'

One of the frustrating and rather unique things about the administration of yachting is that it does not own a major event - like FIFA owns the World Cup for football/soccer; or the IRB's Rugby World Cup and so on. The premier single focus event for yachting is the America's Cup - which is run without the level of ISAF control (and financial gain) enjoyed by other sports for their shop window event.

The risk to ISAF is that the Multihull group take a leaf out of the America's Cupper's book, set up their own World Cup, in a single venue which is bid, and sponsored. Certainly the Multihulls have the numbers to be able to do this in terms of the sailors involved, they have it in the spectacle of the sailing festival that they can create, and they have the range of boats in which to do it from America's Cuppers, to ORMA 60's, to Int C-class to Hobie 16's and 14's. It is just a matter of whether they have the inclination to get organised, and start a full-on professional circuit.


America's Cup dates Ordered

On the topic of the America's Cup, Justice Herman Cahn has just issued a Decision in the New York Supreme Court on the dates for the 33rd America's Cup. Cahn has come down on the side of Alinghi, ordering that the America's Cup be sailed in 10 months time from the date of the Order, which by our calculations puts the date at 12th March 2009.

making his Order, Cahn also specified that the venue for the Defence be Valencia, or some other place named by the Defender. This raises the issue that the Deed of Gift specifies that the earliest a Match may be held in a Northern Hemisphere venue is 2 May (2009).

This is an issue that can either be resolved by Mutual Consent (with Alinghi probably looking for a date in July 2009) or Golden Gate YC insisting that 12 March 2009 be the operative date in which case a southern hemisphere venue must be used.

In this issue we have featured the text from the decision and Order issued this morning, New Zealand time.

Stayed tuned to www.sail-world.com/nz!Sail-World for the latest developments in this story, and reaction from the parties

Good sailling!

Richard Gladwell
NZ Editor

Wildwind 2016 660x82Bakewell-White Yacht DesignHelm Events 660x82

Related Articles

Brawn v Brain? The Bar or The Room?
Interesting questions and can they possibly be linked in any way. Interesting questions and can they possibly be linked in any way. Is it just the one connection, or could there indeed be several ways to address this conundrum? Well the route of the answer could be SailX, the online inshore racing game.
Posted on 7 Jul
Practice makes perfect?
There are a lot of us who try to get out on the water whenever we can. There are a lot of us who try to get out on the water whenever we can - be it a club race, a weekend open or a championship. The general feeling is that the more we sail, the better we get, but is that actually the case?
Posted on 27 May
America's Cup- The End of the Beginning
We are now in the Year of Cup - in fact, in just over five months, the first racing will be under way in the Louis Vuitt We are now in the Year of Cup - in fact, in just over five months, the first racing will be under way in the Louis Vuitton Cup. The end of January also marks the end of the first limited sailing period - where test sailing and racing by the AC72's is limited to just 30 days.
Posted on 30 Jan 2013
Melges 24 World Championship victory to Uka Uka Racing
Melges 24 World Championship’s final day in Corpus Christi, Texas saw the regatta saw a close with some thrilling racing Melges 24 World Championship’s final day in Corpus Christi, Texas, saw the regatta saw a close with some thrilling racing action out on the water.
Posted on 22 May 2011
Melges 24 World Championship - Showdown for the podium
Melges 24 World Championship’s international fleet is currently competing on day five of the event in Corpus Christi. Melges 24 World Championship’s international fleet is currently competing at the 2011 event in Corpus Christi, Texas and enjoying two more breezy races on day five of the regatta.
Posted on 21 May 2011
Melges 24 World Championship battle for second
Melges 24 World Championship 2011 in Corpus Christi, Texas day four. Melges 24 World Championship 2011 in Corpus Christi, Texas day four. Brian Porter on USA 749 Full Throttle turned in a 6,4, scoreline today, which was good enough to move him into second place overall.
Posted on 20 May 2011
Melges 24 World Championship 2011 day three - Leader extends
Melges 24 World Championship 2011 in Corpus Christi, Texas reached its midpoint today. Melges 24 World Championship 2011 in Corpus Christi, Texas reached its midpoint today. Race 5 started bang on time on in a solid 15 knots of breeze. The fleet got away to a clean start at the first time of asking, with the boats quickly splitting into two distinct groups on either side of the first beat.
Posted on 19 May 2011
Melges 24 World Championship day 2 and a new leader
2011 Melges 24 World Championship is underway in Corpus Christi, Texas. The event continues until Saturday May 21st Day two of the 2011 Melges 24 Worlds in Corpus Christi, Texas delivered two spectacular races sailed in near perfect conditions, under crystal clear skies and in a solid breeze which built from 15 up to around 19 knots throughout the day.
Posted on 18 May 2011
Melges 24 World Championship 2011 day one + Rick Tomlinson images
Melges 24 World Championship 2011 day one in Corpus Christi, Texas, saw two closely fought races completed Melges 24 World Championship 2011 day one in Corpus Christi, Texas, saw two closely fought races completed in sparkling conditions. The expectation was always for light to medium conditions to prevail on the first day and race one was started in an unstable eight - ten knots of breeze, with direction swings of up to twenty degrees.
Posted on 17 May 2011
Melges 24 Pre-Worlds win to Melleby on Full Medal Jacket + images
The Melges 24 World Championship will take place at the Corpus Christi Yacht Club from May 11 to 21. The Melges 24 World Championship will take place at the Corpus Christi Yacht Club from May 11 to 21. Soling Olympian and America's Cup sailor Espen Stokkeland, tactician aboard Full Medal Jacket, said that the Norwegian team were looking forward to the coming week.
Posted on 16 May 2011