Please select your home edition
Edition
Naiad

Dinghy Danger - could it happen to you?

by Nancy Knudsen on 27 May 2011
Dinghy danger - what is the worst thing that could happen SW
It’s night, there’s a high wind blowing off the land. You are on the beach, your sailing boat is in the anchorage, but one of the boats far from shore. Beyond the anchorage, there is nothing but hundreds of miles of ocean. On the way to the yacht in your dinghy the outboard engine fails. You try to row, but the wind is too strong, and keeps blowing you sideways out to sea. You call out, but no one hears you...

Here are three true stories that demonstrate how a simple dinghy trip can turn dangerous, even lethal.

Story No. 1:
Several years ago Dominique Courteille, Belgian-born Australian mother-of-four was rescued after three days on a dinghy belted with wild weather and having no food or water.

Dominique said she lost her way while trying to take her dinghy from a beach in southern Thailand to her anchored yacht, a distance of only 150 metres. 'It's very simple. I wanted to join my boat and it was extremely windy. I missed my boat and went into the ocean in my dinghy.'

She was lost at sea for three nights and three days before an Indonesian fishing boat plucked her from sea, hundreds of kilometres south of where she went missing. She had passed her time writing notes to her relatives on the side of the rubber dinghy.

'The fishermen were extremely nice. Very nice. They immediately gave me water and a change of clothes because I was wet and biscuits and a bed. It was the first food and the first drink.'

Dominique said on one night the conditions were very rough and she was forced to use her clothes to pump water out of the dinghy. On arrival back in Phuket she was kept several days in the Phuket Hospital, where she was treated for sunburn and the effects of dehydration.

While Dominique was missing and an international search was underway, her two crew, who had helped sail her yacht back from Lankawi Island in Malaysia, a journey of about 140 miles, were 'given a tough grilling' by police who thought they had been involved in the woman's disappearance.

Crewman Manfred 'Richie' Neustifter, 24, originally from Australia but now also living at the time Phuket, said he and Swiss colleague Conrad Ohlier, 43, 'just hugged each other' when they learned of their skipper's rescue.

Story No. 2:
This happened this month on Trinity Bay near Houston in Texas, USA. It happened to a fisherman, not a sailor, but the dinghy-danger issue is identical.

The man had been fishing with two others on the small island at the mouth of Double Bayou. When the trio left at sunrise, the wind and waters were calm. About 10:00 am, they ran out of bait and one of the fishermen decided to return to a landing point for more bait.

However, the wind had now risen, and strong winds pushed against his small aluminum hull boat, too strong for the small engine on the boat, preventing him from reaching shore. As the wind pushed against the bow, the fisherman was forced back out into Trinity Bay. Waves washed over the stern and began to fill the boat. Realising he had suddenly become in an alarming situation, the fisherman, thinking quickly, moved to the bow. With his weight forcing the bow down he started paddling toward shore. Between his paddling and the small engine, he finally made the shore about two miles north of his intended landing.

He was dehydrated and exhausted after the long paddle. He was picked up there by passersby, and later a friend in a larger and stronger boat retrieved the other two now-stranded fishermen from the island.

Story No. 3:
The final story happened to - me. My fellow crew/husband and I were sailing in far north Queensland, in those muddy sandy regions that crocodiles love to inhabit. We embarked on an oh-so-simple journey from our anchored yacht to the nearby beach in our trusty inflatable dinghy, a perfectly ordinary journey we had undertaken hundreds of times before. The wind was high, the shore was to windward, but the engine was a strong 15hp and we weren't worried.

Not long after we had disconnected the painter and headed for the shore the dinghy motor faltered, sputtered and died and the wind drove us quickly away from our boat and the shore. We quickly grabbed the oars and started to row, but even with both of us rowing with all our strength, we couldn’t get back to our boat. We were headed, not to sea, but to an uninhabited island where crocodiles could be clearly seen sleeping lazily along the shore.

We had to think quickly. What had started as an ordinary morning had now become suddenly life threatening. By veering our course and rowing like we had never rowed before we made it to another sailing boat in the anchorage, puffing and panicked. A few minutes of alarm, and then we were laughing with a cup of coffee on our new friend's boat – but what if it had been at night? What if the neighbouring boat had not been there?

Neither is there any need for it to happen on some far off shore – it could happen so easily, with the right combination of circumstances, in an anchorage near you. In sailing, as in the rest of life, tragedies are caused, never by one event, but by piled-up events.

So what should the cruising sailor do to avoid this kind of occurrence?

It's not difficult to think of some sensible ideas:

1. Always always keep oars and a baler in the dinghy, even if you’re only in it to clean the topsides.
2. Check your motor for fuel before each trip.
3. Never leave your sailing boat in an anchorage without a light (get a LED automatic light and leave it in the dinghy permanently, to save power and save remembering)
4. When there’s a wind, specially if it’s blowing off the shore, have someone aware of your dinghy journey, or, if possible, leave the journey until the wind has abated.
5. Carry a hand-held VHF(Thanks Jamie Gifford for this reminder), charged mobile phone or a satphone as a worthwhile general safety precaution.

As with many other situations sailing, the best question you can always ask is: What is the very worst thing that could happen?
.......................
Letter from Reader:

Sender: john gray

Message: In a similar true story a yachtee mate of mine in Gladstone ( I will not mention his name) anchored off a coral island resort and went ashore for a dinner. He decided to return to the yacht during the evening for some reason leaving the others at dinner.

On the way back his small outboard failed, had no oars or anchor or radio with him and he was rapidly blowing off the reef shallows into the coral sea at night, with the wind strengthening.

He had the presence of mind to remove the outboard tie it to a long painter rope he had and throw it overboard where it caught on the reef before he had blown beyond it. Was found in the morning still 'anchored' to the reef. I never did find out what happened to that motor afterwards!!
Zhik AkzoNobelb 660x82Mackay BoatsInsun - AC Program

Related Articles

America's Cup - Predictwind pitches breeze to Emirates Team NZ's forte
The latest forecast from Predictwind.com for the Great Sound, Bermuda is for light winds The latest forecast from Predictwind.com for the Great Sound, Bermuda is for light winds just above the minimum allowed for racing on Saturday and slightly more on Sunday. That is the same band as for the first two days of racing, when Emirates Team New Zealand showed Oracle Team USA their transoms, to lead around every mark of the course in the first four races.
Posted today at 8:05 pm
America's Cup - New Zealand gripped in America's Cup fever
New Zealand has once again caught the America's Cup fever with this dose reported to be worse than previous years. New Zealand has once again caught the America's Cup fever with this dose reported to be worse than previous years. Various supporters and supporters groups have sent in video clips of how they are celebrating the America's Cup and supporting Emirates Team New Zealand - the clips have been edited together into this compilation, narrated by Martin Tasker
Posted today at 5:08 am
America's Cup - More images of J-Class racing off Bermuda
Second gallery of images featuring the seven J-Class yachts racing in the largest fleet of the 120ft yachts to date Second gallery of images featuring the seven J-Class yachts racing in the largest fleet of the 120ft yachts yet assembled, which raced earlier this week off Bermuda. Although most of the fleet are replicas constructed to one of the original J-Class designs, Valsheda is restored from the original which was laid up in southern England for many years.
Posted today at 4:25 am
America's Cup - Largest ever J class fleet races off Bermuda
The largest ever fleet of J-class to race together assembled off Bermuda for two series of races. The largest ever fleet of J-class to race together assembled off Bermuda for two series of races. Seven of the 120ft sloops that contested the America's Cup from 1930 to 1937 sailed off Bermuda. Here is the first gallery of images from the second day of racing
Posted today at 4:13 am
Americas Cup - Five times Cup winner says Kiwis can win four races
Five times America's Cup winner, Murray Jones thinks Oracle Team USA will resume the America's Cup Final better Five times America's Cup winner, Murray Jones thinks Oracle Team USA will resume the America's Cup Final better, but not drastically different. Jones is now a coach with Emirates Team New Zealand. The American defender had three sessions on Bermuda's Great Sound today while Team New Zealand had just one, ahead of Sunday morning's resumption, where the challenger leads 3-0.
Posted today at 2:59 am
America's Cup - Checking out the superyachts in Bermuda
Over 70 superyachts have registered for the 35th America's Cup Regatta in Bermuda. Over 70 superyachts have registered for the 35th America's Cup Regatta in Bermuda. They make a very spectacular backdrop on one section of the America's Cup course area. And when there is no wind and no racing they make a fascinating diversion to see classic yachts alongside contemporary. Here's a look at some that were on the water for the start of the Semi-Finals, when the wind showed up too
Posted on 22 Jun
Interviews from final day of the Red Bull Youth America's Cup
Pretty incredible racing, with the final results decided in the final race, on the final leg to the finish! Pretty incredible racing, with the final results decided in the final race, on the final leg to the finish!
Posted on 22 Jun
Red Bull Youth America´s Cup – Wrap-up
No one could have scripted a more exciting ending, as New Zealand was toppled from certain triumph in the last seconds No one could have scripted a more exciting ending, as New Zealand was toppled from almost certain triumph in the last seconds of the last race by a determined British team, and Bermuda emerged as the new darlings of sailing.
Posted on 22 Jun
America's Cup - New Zealand developed YachtBot does AC seating plan
A small New Zealand firm is making a significant contribution to the America’s Cup, with an online 'seating' application A small New Zealand firm is making a significant contribution to the America’s Cup, with an online application which effectively 'seats' all participants in the 35th America's Cup each day - and then re-works the plan if there is a major course change.
Posted on 22 Jun
Red Bull Youth America's Cup – More action shots by Studio Borlenghi
Britain grabs the title in the last-minute upset. Studio Borlenghi provided a gallery of images Britain grabs the title in the last-minute upset. Studio Borlenghi provided a gallery of images
Posted on 22 Jun